Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Cutting and Pasting, Without Identifying the Source

who's talking here?

freshhell 4
Unichic 1
JDB2 2
bbjones 7
planemom 1
lulajean 1
gking 3
khshops!! 1
©Hanson♥ 1
sharky 1
WashingtonYankee 1
cowboyswife 1
Ladybug 1
lonesophist 5
accent_ 9
superstar 7
Mabbers 13
Cicero 5
Reality is good 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Cutting and Pasting, Without Identifying the Source

To support our own arguments, many of us frequently cut and paste quotes and blocks of text from various sources. Most of us identify the source. There's nothing wrong with that, at all. It helps us share informaion. Some of us, though, routinely, cut and paste substantial blocks of text and never mention that the text is not our creation, and never identify the source. My thought is that this is intellectually dishonest and lazy. I won't name names and beg that you do not, but one can pick, almost at random, a substantial block of text from one prominent poster, Google it, and find the source for "profundity" that the poster never identified as not his own. I just did it with one of the poster's longer posts, found the unattributed source quickly. I'm interested in your thoughts.

Posters should be expected to identify quotes and give sources. Vote
 
 34.5% (20)
Posters shouldn't be expected to identify quotes and give sources. Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
If other posters catch an unattributed quote, they should call attention to it. Vote
 
 1.7% (1)
They should not call attention to unattributed quotes. Vote
 
 1.7% (1)
Borrowing without attribution makes the poster less credible. Vote
 
 10.3% (6)
Borrowing without attribution doesn't make the poster less credible. Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
It's really unimportant. Vote
 
 15.5% (9)
I don't care. Vote
 
 36.2% (21)
accent_ --- 19 years ago -

To support our own arguments, many of us frequently cut and paste quotes and blocks of text from various sources. Most of us identify the source. There's nothing wrong with that, at all. It helps us share informaion. Some of us, though, routinely, cut and paste substantial blocks of text and never mention that the text is not our creation, and never identify the source. My thought is that this is intellectually dishonest and lazy. I won't name names and beg that you do not, but one can pick, almost at random, a substantial block of text from one prominent poster, Google it, and find the source for "profundity" that the poster never identified as not his own. I just did it with one of the poster's longer posts, found the unattributed source quickly. I'm interested in your thoughts. 

freshhell --- 19 years ago -

I may be old fashioned (in addition to old), but I do think that any time you post words that are not your own, you should admit it , and give credit to the source. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I may be old fashioned (in addition to old), but I do think that any time you post words that are not your own, you should admit it , and give credit to the source. Every word you just posted is not your own. Did you give God the credit for them? 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

Every word you just posted is not your own. Did you give God the credit for them? "Born again?! No, I'm not. Excuse me for getting it right the FIRST time." --Dennis Miller 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

"Except a man be born again, he cannot see the kingdom of God." -- God 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

If you judge people, you have no time to love them. -- Mother Theresa 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

This is why I'd rather post links then cut and paste. That way whoever is reading it can decide the efficacy of not just the article but the website it's coming from. 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Okay I see what you're sayin' and all. But isn't this a casual forum? Why not just say something? Even if we heard somewhere else. If someone claims it to be their own, that's their lie. What I'm not sure I can stand is the shock factor. Those posting photos and lengthy excerpts. Come on. I understand the whole share and pass along thing, but a little restraint could be in order. 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

I agree, JMABS. I think if someone is going to cut and past a NOVEL size quote, why not just post the link and we can surf off and read it for ourselves. 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Yeah lone. Whachu said. 

freshhell --- 19 years ago -

I agree with you lone. I usually skip over the cut and pastes. 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

I had to leave the pc last night after some pictures. Needless to say, I just won't be a part of that kind of sillyness. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

I agree, JMABS. I think if someone is going to cut and past a NOVEL size quote, why not just post the link and we can surf off and read it for ourselves. +1 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

"Do ye not know that the saints shall judge the world? and if the world shall be judged by you, are ye unworthy to judge the smallest matters?" -- God 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Does a bear go in the woods? 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

"My friend has a baby. I'm recording all the noises he makes so later I can ask him what he meant. " - Steven Wright 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

"Professing themselves to be wise, they became fools" -- God 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Always look on the bright side of life. To be or not to be. Live and learn. C'est la vie. Que sera, sera. What goes around comes around. Don't worry be happy. Laughter is the best medicine. Same shit different day. Shit happens. I've got a million. My dad and I used to play this game. The cliche banter! Those are quotes. But I sure don't know where the hell they came from. Guess I'll have to google that too, huh?! 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Always look on the bright side of life. To be or not to be. Live and learn. C'est la vie. Que sera, sera. What goes around comes around. Don't worry be happy. Laughter is the best medicine. Same shit different day. Shit happens. I've got a million. My dad and I used to play this game. The cliche banter! Those are quotes. But I sure don't know where the hell they came from. Guess I'll have to google that too, huh?! 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Always look on the bright side of life. To be or not to be. Live and learn. C'est la vie. Que sera, sera. What goes around comes around. Don't worry be happy. Laughter is the best medicine. Same shit different day. Shit happens. I've got a million. My dad and I used to play this game. The cliche banter! Those are quotes. But I sure don't know where the hell they came from. Guess I'll have to google that too, huh?! 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Always look on the bright side of life. To be or not to be. Live and learn. C'est la vie. Que sera, sera. What goes around comes around. Don't worry be happy. Laughter is the best medicine. Same shit different day. Shit happens. I've got a million. My dad and I used to play this game. The cliche banter! Those are quotes. But I sure don't know where the hell they came from. Guess I'll have to google that too, huh?! 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Always look on the bright side of life. To be or not to be. Live and learn. C'est la vie. Que sera, sera. What goes around comes around. Don't worry be happy. Laughter is the best medicine. Same shit different day. Shit happens. I've got a million. My dad and I used to play this game. The cliche banter! Those are quotes. But I sure don't know where the hell they came from. Guess I'll have to google that too, huh?! 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

I really don't care..... 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

"To B, or to C ... that is the question." - Me 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

What the hell happened? Just looked back at this thread and my stuff is on like 5 times?!!!!! I didn't do that on purpose...swear! 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

I know, the baby was hitting keys when I was putting something in the dishwasher...yeah....that's it!? 

Reality is good --- 19 years ago -

JMABS, I think the original point of this thread is for the people that post very long articles and they claim that the cutting and pasting is their own. They either claim that by a) not citing their source and/or b) they come right out and say on another post 'Can you not read what I just wrote?' 

Ladybug --- 19 years ago -

I vote that this poll is unimportant 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

I'm sorry reality. I vear off track a lot. Yes I read it. Yes I understood it. Sorry if I stepped on your little piggys. 

Reality is good --- 19 years ago -

Nope, my piggies are all tucked into their little sock cocoon's. We are square. Sorry to misinterpret your veering as non-understanding. Please, veer away. 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Consider me veered. 

Reality is good --- 19 years ago -

Veery interesting. 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

This is so funny. I just did what accent did (typed in part of what someone wrote) on another post on here and found the entire thing online, word for word. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

This is so funny. I just did what accent did (typed in part of what someone wrote) on another post on here and found the entire thing online, word for word. I was actually surprised. With one poster, it is the rule rather than the exception. It goes to credibility. If a poster cannot be intellectually honest, isn't he risking discrediting not only his point, but his cause? Another poster occasionally responds to this by responding with the source, but, considering the volume of the plagiarism, that approach is impractical, I think. 

superstar --- 19 years ago -

doesn't matter to me because people repeat jokes, or sayings all day long that they heard from somewhere and they don't state where they get it all from...why would it matter here? 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

I think it's ok to quote if you agree with whatever it is. Posting these long passages is annoying though. Just post the original link instead. 

superstar --- 19 years ago -

JMABS, I think the original point of this thread is for the people that post very long articles and they claim that the cutting and pasting is their own. They either claim that by a) not citing their source and/or b) they come right out and say on another post 'Can you not read what I just wrote?' not stating who said it afterwards doesnt' mean they claim it as theirs.. 

sharky --- 19 years ago -

who really cares?? by the way, did you know that sanjaya got kicked off american idol last night??? SmileyCentral.com 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

who really cares?? by the way, did you know that sanjaya got kicked off american idol last night??? Yeah really. Let's discuss stuff that matters .... like American Idol. hehehehe 

Reality is good --- 19 years ago -

superstar, if you are on a message board, using a certain moniker, that you are identified by, and you post something, people are going to assume it is your words if you do not cite a source. Accountability 

page 1 2
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

ku
politics
polls
rant


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground