Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Absolutism vs. Relativism Fallacies

who's talking here?

freshhell 1
JDB2 2
bbjones 19
Neo 1
NoNameNoLastName 1
TruthKing 3
racerfan 1
ChezML 11
accent_ 19

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Absolutism vs. Relativism Fallacies: "I Know I’m Right, But…" March 8, 2000 by Lynn Ridenhour I don’t want to be a relativist but neither am I comfortable with becoming an absolutist. Both camps have their slippery pitfalls and both can lead you into a dead end ditch. Besides, who wants to be a real turn-off? I find it interesting—a recent Gallup poll has shown that 50% of Americans expressed serious concerns about fundamentalism—camp of the Absolutist. Only 36% expressed a similar concern about secular humanism—camp of the Relativist. Could it be, everyone’s getting real nervous with all the religious mudslinging Bush & McCain have been hurling at one another here lately? My Lord, I have never heard so much talk about religion and Jesus and Bob Jones and Pat Robertson and Jerry Falwell during an election year! What is it with these guys? Back to my point. I don’t want to be a relativist and neither do I want to be an absolutist. It’s like wanting to hang out with Lemuel and Laman. Why pick the lesser of two evils? Both choices are bad. Of course, I’m using a bit hyperbole. My point, however, is: relativism and absolutism both have their weaknesses. And as "good Christians," we’re to avoid both. Let’s briefly look at… WEAKNESSES OF THE RELATIVIST: Let me tell you, I. It’s tough these days being a secular humanist, a relativist. Denying God’s existence does have its consequences. Atheist Jean-Paul Sartre said it best, "…no finite point has any meaning without an infinite reference point." And Sartre went on to sum up life’s meaninglessness in the title of his book Nausea. Life without consequences can be one big throw up. Camus, another noted writer, followed Sartre’s conclusions and proposed the only really serious question is whether or not to commit suicide. Dostoevsky, in Brothers Karamazov, nails the dilemma—"…if there is no God, everything is permitted." As I said, it’s tough being a relativist these days. Another weakness… II. Relativists are really absolutists in disguise. Many of their statements are self-refuting. For instance, the Greek philosopher Gorgius made the statement that "…all statements are false." The problem with this is that if all statements are false, then the statement that all statements are false is false. Each of us, at one time or another, has heard someone say, "…but there are no absolutes." That’s like my saying, "…there are absolutely no absolutes!" Or "…I hold to the truth that there are no truths." Another example: many of my colleagues maintain a radical relativism that forbids us to judge another culture. Yet they (rightfully) oppose any form of oppression against women and racism. Dilemma: if we lack a sufficient basis to judge another culture, how do we have a basis to judge our own? Likewise, many in the academic world despise anti-Semitism, yet their philosophy provides no basis for condemning it. Not that it shouldn’t, mind you. The upshot of the matter? Sooner or later all positions of this sort lead to some kind of judgment about what is good for our world, our country, our lodge, our neighbor and our dog. We may not call it "good," but C.S. Lewis says "…their skepticism about values is on the surface…" We may debunk others’ values while unable to realize that our own are not so immune. Here’s another weakness… III. Everyone is right and no one is right. I’ve heard that a lot. Or versions of it. If whatever is true for you is true for you, and whatever is true for me is true for me, then everybody is right and nobody is right. What a strange state of affairs. There is not what one might call "true" truth—objective truth OUTSIDE of one’s own subjective preferences. Here’s a tough statement for the relativist: "God exists." Assertion: that statement must be either true or false. Another assertion: If God exists, then no amount of unbelief will make Him cease existing. Still another assertion: If God does not exist, then no amount of belief will make Him exist. Three tough assertions for any relativist. Here’s another weakness… IV. There is no evil. If there are no absolutes (if truth is relative) then, really, there is no evil. Problem: we know better. Go visit the "killing fields" of Cambodia, the "ethnic cleansing" in Bosnia and Kosovo, tour the ovens at Auschwitz. Can we really say, "…there is no evil?" I don’t think so. Renowned journalist, Arthur Koestler, took a good hard look at the logical conclusion—"there is no evil"—when interviewing a Japanese expert in Buddhism, who denied the existence of good and evil. KOESTLER: You favor tolerance toward all religions and political systems. What about Hitler’s gas chambers? BUDDHIST: That was very silly of him. KOESTLER: Just silly, not evil? BUDDHIST: Evil is a Christian concept. Good and evil exist only on a relative scale. Most of us are not willing to go quite so far. But perhaps we are willing to take a good close look at where such assertions lead us. There they are—four weaknesses of relativism: * It’s tough these days being a secular humanist, a relativist. * Relativists are really absolutists in disguise. * Everyone is right and no one is right. And * There is no evil. Now let’s turn our attention briefly to the flipside… Neither should we as believers be quick to embrace absolutism. WEAKNESSES OF ABSOLUTISM The key is—how do we proclaim absolutes in a changing world without falling prey to absolutism? By the way, that’s a balancing act. It takes the Spirit of Christ actively engaged in the human heart to believe in absolutes without becoming an absolutist. Bottom line?… What good is it if we win the argument and lose our soul in the hunt? That’s why perhaps we should preface our assertions with "…I know I’m right, but…" Let’s always leave room for both listener and speaker to exit gracefully. Kindness heals all wounds. I know, there’s a backlash these days toward believers who want to maintain an objective basis for law or for any truth. We’re often pegged as those "Bible thumpers" who conjure up media images of "closed-mindedness," "intolerance," and "rigidity." In other words, the very idea that there are absolutes—something really true and really false—brings to the table--accepting absolutes means becoming an absolutist to some people. I beg to differ. The two are not the same. Having said that, there are, indeed, definitive weaknesses in being an absolutist. I briefly mention four. I. Truth is carried in these earthen vessels. All our revelations come to us with a filter attached. We see through a glass darkly (I Cor.13:12). An absolutist implies he has no filter. Though we indeed have a basis for absolutes in our God who has revealed Himself in scripture, infallible absolutes still exist among fallible people. We kid ourselves, thinking we’re in ultimate control. The truth is--our revelations can quickly turn to mush, our hearts to stone, and our pocket books can be in chapter eleven before we cross the street. Yes, we carry this treasure in earthen vessels, knowing full well who’s the potter and who’s the clay. Humility goes a long ways,especially with one's foes. Our arguments have not always been wrapped in attitudes becoming of the spirit of Christ. Another weakness… II. Right is not righteousness. An old Baptist preacher once told me, "…son, remember, you can be as straight as a gun barrel and just as empty…" Right is not rightly related. Jesus reminded a group of folks of that very thing in Luke 13. Some were telling Jesus a story of an atrocity committed by Pilate, thinking His response would be "…why, that’s awful! We need to do something…" Christ’s response was a shock. He said, "…unless you repent you will all likewise perish…" Right is not rightly related. Ouch. Here’s another weakness of absolutism… III. Confidence not arrogance. There’s a fine line between the two. Should we hesitate to state our case? No. Should we balk at arrogance? Yes. Should we run from pride? At all costs. Someone has said, "…none have more pride than those who think they have none…" The absolutist sets himself up to be ambushed with pride. IV. Might is right. The unstated theme in absolutism is—might is right. The end justifies the means. Secular absolutism, for example, has committed the greatest of all historical atrocities under the philosophy of Nazism and Marxism. Hitler killed six million Jews, Stalin killed some 60 million, Pol Pot in Cambodia, Mao Tse Tung, untold millions. And sadly, believers have the Inquisition to point to. There we have it—four weaknesses of absolutism: Truth is carried in these earthen vessels. Right is not righteousness. Confidence, not arrogance. Might is right. I return to my thesis—as believers, we’re to avoid both camps, the relativist camp and the absolutist camp. Jesus would simply have us to love one another, and let truth cut its own path.  

TruthKing --- 19 years ago -

Here is Truth's path. I'd like to be a real turn-off! (Have you seen my electric bill?) I live for life Accent, not for death. I live for joy, not for pain. I live for my friends, not my enemies. I live for fun, not the dregs of KU. I live, so do you. Live strong. Show up. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Lynn Ridenhour does not undersatnd absolute certainity because he apparently does not know God! 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Lynn Ridenhour does not undersatnd absolute certainity because he apparently does not know God! Again, bbjones, your frequent definition of not knowing God is disagreeing with bbjones' interpretations of God's word. bbjones is human, with a human brain, human experiences, and human biases. bbjones' faith is sincere and strong, but no one would confuse bbjones' word with God's word, and, just because someone does not agree with bbjones' interpretations, that does not mean that he does not have an uncerstanding of God's word as valid as that of bbjones. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

bbjones is human, with a human brain, human experiences, and human biases. bbjones' faith is sincere and strong, but no one would confuse bbjones' word with God's word, and, just because someone does not agree with bbjones' interpretations, that does not mean that he does not have an uncerstanding of God's word as valid as that of bbjones. You apparently do not know what God has said about Christians in earthen vessels. "For who hath known the mind of the Lord, that he may instruct him? But we have the mind of Christ." (1 Corinthians 2:16) Since Christians have the mind of Christ available to them, if they will allow it to guide them, then it IS possible for them KNOW what God tells us with absolute certainity! You are putting more credence in a man's words than you are in God's Word. Now that is mocking God! 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

You are putting more credence in a man's words than you are in God's Word. Now that is mocking God! Again, you keep confusing disagreeing with bbjones with mocking God. bbjones' word is not God's word, but it is bbjones' sincere interpretation of God's word. bbjones' word is not God's word. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Again, you keep confusing disagreeing with bbjones with mocking God. bbjones' word is not God's word, but it is bbjones' sincere interpretation of God's word. bbjones' word is not God's word. You have said that we are only human "with a human brain, human experiences, and human biases." But my quote from the Bible IS NOT my words at all. "... we have the mind of Christ." (1 Corinthians 2:16)" is God's Word and all TRUE Christians will know that! When you treat God's Word with contempt or try to limit it, you ARE mocking God! 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Disagreeing with you, bbjones, is not mocking God. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Disagreeing with you, bbjones, is not mocking God. You are disagreeing with "... we have the mind of Christ." (1 Corinthians 2:16)" Those are GOD'S Words - not mine! 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

You are disagreeing with "... we have the mind of Christ." (1 Corinthians 2:16)" Those are GOD'S Words - not mine! No, I am disagreeing with bbjones. bbjones' word is not to be confused with God's word. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

No, I am disagreeing with bbjones. bbjones' word is not to be confused with God's word. Whose words are "... we have the mind of Christ." (1 Corinthians 2:16)? 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

bbjones' word is not God's word. and is an interpretation, just like everyone elses. Not better; not worse. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

bbjones' word is not to be confused with God's word.  

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

bbjones' word is not to be confused with God's word. Most certainly not! 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

and is an interpretation, just like everyone elses. Not better; not worse. Are you calling "... we have the mind of Christ." (1 Corinthians 2:16) an interpretation? If that is what you think it is, you had better pull out your dictionary and try again! 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

bbjones' word is not to be confused with God's word.  

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

bbjones' word is not to be confused with God's word. I do not think that anyone is. Apparently, you feel the need to hide your mocking of God behind false statements! 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

bbjones, you are no more than a modern version of a pharisee. But your lack of humility prevents you from noticing that. To me, you don't come across as someone who acts as a Christian. I don't think you have the mind of Christ. Far from it. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

I do not think that anyone is. Apparently, you feel the need to hide your mocking of God behind false statements! Disagreeing with bbjones is not mocking God. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Disagreeing with bbjones is not mocking God. Trying to spin a lie will not make it true. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Trying to spin a lie will not make it true. Disagreeing with bbjones is not spinning a lie. It is disagreeing with a fellow human. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

Disagreeing with BBJ is not spinning a lie. Disagreeing with BBJ is not mocking God. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

You believe the words of this Lynn Ridenhour over the words that God gives us in the Bible. I do not have to judge you at all to recognize the way that you are defining yourself. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Chez, how about saying something yourself without copying someone else. At least accent has enough upstairs to do that. How about you? 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

You believe the words of this Lynn Ridenhour over the words that God gives us in the Bible. I do not have to judge you at all to recognize the way that you are defining yourself. Offering views that differ from bbjones is not believing those words over God's. 

TruthKing --- 19 years ago -

can we borrow accent and chez for some fun threads? we will bring them back in an hour. 

freshhell --- 19 years ago -

Anyone who claims to speak the words of god is either quoting themself or quoting someone else. So which is it BB? Either way you are simply CLAIMING!!!! 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

Chez, how about saying something yourself without copying someone else. At least accent has enough upstairs to do that. How about you? Personal attacks on your part BBJ do little to enhance your credibility or stature, nor are they an intelligent strategy for garnering converts to the BBJ Divine Word. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Offering views that differ from bbjones is not believing those words over God's. People only offer views that they agree with. Those views DO differ from God's Words! 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

can we borrow accent and chez for some fun threads? Gee, TK, doesn't this look like fun? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Personal attacks on your part BBJ do little to enhance your credibility or stature, nor are they an intelligent strategy for garnering converts to the BBJ Divine Word. No personal attack there. Just made an observation and asked a question! If you do not know the definition of a personal attack, then that is no one's fault but your own! 

TruthKing --- 19 years ago -

would you really like to know what it looks like?  

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Anyone who claims to speak the words of god is either quoting themself or quoting someone else. So which is it BB? Either way you are simply CLAIMING!!!! Sorry freshhell, but that makes absolutely NO sense at all! 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

I'm going to go cook something Divine and Heavenly for supper. Will be back later ;-) 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

People only offer views that they agree with. Those views DO differ from God's Words! No, bbj, secure people, in the interest of dialog and education, often offer, for consideration, views with which they may not totally agree. bbjones's word and God's word are not the same. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

If you do not know the definition of a personal attack, then that is no one's fault but your own! Limp and lame. So sad; too bad. bbjones' word is not to be confused with God's word. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

People only offer views that they agree with. Those views DO differ from God's Words! I have tremendous respect for C. S. Lewis, share his writings often on KU, but I do not agree with many of his views. I'll still share his thoughts, though. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

would you really like to know what it looks like? Oops! Someone didn't see the ONE WAY sign! 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Just like you enjoy sharing satan's words also! 

page 1 2
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

ku
religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground