Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

MMR vaccine and Autism???

who's talking here?

blessed 2
MAD 3
Paige 13
whatchamacallit 2
angel 1
mand1994 1
MomofTwins 1
Liane 6
Fiona 3
Local Gal 1
smartypants 1
Scottie's Hottie 8
cmi 6
justmy2cents 2
I Love Horses 4
star7827518 1
photomom 1
ajmart 3
Anderson 8

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Anyone else concerned about the MMR vaccine being the 'trigger' to the onset of autism in children?

I was just following up on my friends autistic son in Rochester,NY (...he got to meet the President this week) and saw in one article that autism in America is increasing 10-17% every year!!!!

Anyone else think the MMR is linked? I personally do....I did not allow my 5 yr.old to have the MMR until he was past the onset age of autism. 

Paige --- 20 years ago -

Oh...this is a topic I can get in on. My 3.5 year old was diagnosed with autism at 2 and I have researched just about everything that goes along with it until my eyes have crossed.

I never bought into the MMR thing fully because there were still a ton of kids who had the shot but were fine. However, I recently started reading a lot about it. I do believe that mercury and metals play a big part in the autism rise, but I don't think it is the shot alone. I was reading about large quantities of metals that enter our bodies/ and fetus/infant/childs.
There is metal in rhogam shots (for rh- mom's- which I am,) dental fillings, drinking water, fish, etc... I think it is a combination of all those things and more.

My son is going to see a DAN doctor in July about a lot of different things, but this is one of the things I am interested to pick his brain on. There are techniques to remove the metals, but I am still a little unsure on all of this. 

Paige --- 20 years ago -

By the way... I loved the story of your friend's son. It was so nice to see that. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 20 years ago -

My daughter has a close friend who has a little sister with down syndrome. She goes downtown for therapy a couple of times a week. Her mother claims that there are 5 children that they have met alone that have autism and they all believe it to be linked to the MMR vaccination. My son had a reaction to his first set of shots so he doesn't get more than one shot at a time but we have held off on the MMR shot up to this point. My peditrician and I have discussed this at great lengths. It is her medical opinion that children who have autism will have it with or without a reaction to the MMR shot. She said that the MMR shot can bring out earlier signs of autism. She advised me to wait until my son was 2 until we discussed the MMR shot again. It is my understanding that it is the combination of the drugs. They are supposed to be safe when seperated but you can't get them that way anymore. My son turned 2 in January but I haven't given him the shot yet. I am just afraid to take any chances. When he had the original reaction to the shots they said that it happens to 1 out of 14,000 children! I can't believe he was the 1! 

Scottie's Hottie --- 20 years ago -

Oh and Autism isn't on the rise but is diagnosed more correctly than it has been in the past and also earlier than ever before.

Sorry, I used to read alot and this is one subject I have read extensively on. 

smartypants --- 20 years ago -

i agree with paige and amy.......i think the "rise" in autism may b directly related to enviromental polution and exposure to toxins, and improvements in detection and early diagnosis. the theory that the vaccine may b a trigger in individuals already predisposed to autism is interesting. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 20 years ago -

Thanks, smartypants. You said exactly what I was trying to say but just couldn't seem to spit out! 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

In my former life, I was a school RN (that would be "before kids"). I was at the time pretty "up" on all the vaccine info. It is true that there is a rise in a lot of childhood illnesses, but if every child gets the MMR shot (they are required to get it to enter school, and have been for a long time...of course there are exceptions, but less than 1% don't receive it), how come we are just NOW having the rise. I mean, I got the vaccine when I was a kid 30 years ago. Why do SOME get autism and some don't? I have to agree with the above statement that those who got autism were most likely going to get it anyway. We have tremendously better diagnostic tools these days, and MANY people who are working on diseases that, years ago if people had them, they were just labels "slow" or "weird" or something like that. ADHD is one of those diseases too.....probably many of the "troublemakers" of the past really had what would be diagnosed as ADHD today. We just have a different perspective today as well as more sophisticated diagnostic equipment.

When people would approach me about the subject of not having their children vaccinated and asked for my opinion, I would tell them this....

If NOBODY vaccinated their children on the very slight chance that something (like autism) MIGHT happen to them (not been proven yet), there is a VERY good likelihood that their child would contract something like measles or polio which in the past killed or seriously and permenately injured children. It's a matter of weighing the risks.....and a lot of groups out there use scare tactics to keep people from vaccinating their children and don't tell what could happen to their child if they AREN'T vaccinated.

Of course, there are some required vaccines for illnesses that AREN'T life threatening such as varicella (chicken pox). That one came around to keep people from having to be out of work with there kids for two weeks (seriously) and keep the labor force working. I feel differently about requiring these, but many of the vaccines were created for entirely different reasons (like keeping populations alive). 

mand1994 --- 20 years ago -

Most clinics have switched to thimerisol-free vaccines now to be on the safe side. Not sure how I feel about the whole topic, because I haven't had to face having a child with autism. I just know that all of my children get vaccinated on schedule and it bothers me that other parents don't get their kids vaccinated. Just because the diseases aren't prevelant, doesn't mean they're not still out there and can kill. I met one woman once who told me, "I don't have to get my child vaccinated, because everyone else gets their kids vaccinated". So it's ok for my kids to get all these shots so your child can benefit. How selfish! Ok, off my soapbox now. I have a 9 month old and she will get her MMR at 1 year like my other kiddos did. 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

In Texas, esp being so close to the border and with the extent of immigaration, there are lots of people that have not been vaccinated. That is why we are seeing a rise in some diseases that were almost obsolete a few years ago in our population like polio. Not every one DOES have their child immunized, and that is why it can so very dangerous to NOT immunize your child unless there is a very good medical reason not to. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

I agree with immunizations.....we all need them.

I disagree with the MMR....it is owned and developed by Merck Laboratories....an American company with DEEP pockets!!!

No where in Europe can you get the MMR.....other developed nations are saying the MMR and increase in Autism MAY be linked and therefore just got rid of the MMR.....those countries do it the old fashion way and give the kids 3 seperate shots at different times.

Anyways......our govt. could NEVER acknowledge a problem with the MMR vaccine because of law suits......that is why dentist and the ADA still say "silver" filling are safe......and yet other nations won't give their dogs silver fillings!!! 

cmi --- 20 years ago -

It was recently confirmed that my 3 and a half year old is also in the autism spectrum. I do think that they should continue to study the link between the MMR and Autism. However, I also think they are now better diagnosing children. I know that when I look back, my son showed very early signs before the MMR was ever given. Now, I know this could mean that "it" was there and the MMR triggered it, but I don't think the rise in autism can just be placed on the MMR shot. I agree with you, Anderson, they will never admit it if there is a problem. That's what I hate about litigation in this country. 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

Honestly, I've never studied the actual "MMR" as a combined shot and it's effects on autism. I guess I was just addressing the people and organizations that I ran into as a school nurse that were totally against immunizing their kids at all. Yes...if you gave the vaccines seperately, that would have the same effect as far as I'm concerned :) 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

yes....seperate vaccines are best......BUT because of the strong hold the MMR vaccine has here in the USA....it is VERY hard to get the 3 shots seperately......

I tried with my 5 yr. old and even went to Co.Health Dept. hoping to get 3 seperate shots.....and noone had the vaccines seperately.

I waited until my child was 2.5 yrs. old before I let him get the MMR.....which is past the onset age of autism 

Scottie's Hottie --- 20 years ago -

I don't agree with my parents not getting their children the immunizations. They are necessary to keep many diseases that have been epidemics in the past extinct/ My son is not up to date on his shots by medical standards and his age because of a severe allergic reaction to an immunization. He had a reaction to the DHTP so he will never be vaccinated with that. He will receive a seperate tetnus (sp) shot eventually but my peditrician does not feel comfortable giving him that at this time.

I have made the decision to hold off on the MMR until my son is at least 2 1/2 years old. This is a decision supported by my peditrician and since she is the one with the medical degree I will take her advice and follow my own instincts. 

Local Gal --- 20 years ago -

I have a friend who refuses to get her daughter ANY vaccines, much against the advice of her friends, family and Dr...Her daughter starts Kindergarten this coming year, in Katy. Says she can get by, by stating the shots are not given, because of "religious reasons". NOT TRUE! Just how she will get thru the system. She says all the research is enough to, not give her child the shots. Sorry, I disagree. (As does her family) 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

I also only allowed my son to recieve one immunazation at a time.....no 3 or 4 shots in one visit for us.

It only makes sense to me that more than one immunization per appt. could be too much on his little body to handle.....and that if he ever had an adverse reaction I would know exactly which immunization caused it. 

star7827518 --- 20 years ago -

I have questions about the affects of metals in the body and autism. If the amount of metals in a child's body might be causing the autism, then wouldn't you want to avoid them? Instead of the MMR triggering the autism, could it be making the level of autism in a child worse. Is it all metals that affect autism or just certain ones? And do children with autism have higher amounts of metal than other children or are they just sensitive to them?

And I just want to make sure that I don't sound like I am against vaccines. My little girl has had all of hers and I think they are benefical for stopping deceases but I wish they would give them one vaccine at a time. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

I think the big question "star" is the level of metal a mother has in her blood stream and how those level effect the developing baby.

Most people do not know.....and your dentist won't tell you....that your "silver" fillings should be replaced EVERY 10 years!!! The reason is the metal alloys start breaking down and leaking into your body and blood stream.

So maybe the rise in autism is a combination of factors.....age of mom, fish she eats, level of leaking metals from fillings....and the list goes on. 

Paige --- 20 years ago -

I do believe Anderson is correct about a combination of things that might be a part of autism developing. It is very common to have multiple children with autism. With every child that does have it you have, the percent increases of having another one with it. It is mostly common in boys.

However, I do believe there has to be more to it. My first son, the 3.5 year old has it, but my second, also a boy and 2, does not. I didn't have any fillings replaced, and I was not aware at the point of his conception my first child was autistic. Therefore, I didn't really do anything different.

It would make sense to avoid metals, but it isn't as easy as it sounds. By just starting to avoid them doesn't make the autism go away. Metals can be removed somewhat from a child's body through a process called chelation. It is hard on a child's organs and a lot of prep work has to be done, however some believe it to be very successful. Even then, the child doesn't become "un-autistic" it just reduces some of the symptoms. Alot of times it has been known to help communication boundaries. It is more successful in younger children and it is reported that progress reduces when started at older ages.

Pretty much anything related to autism is not covered by insurance either. School (private), most therapies- occupational, speech, gross motor, and sometimes physical or behavioral(private), supplements, and majority of tests for reasons relating to the spectrum. Chelation or any of the tests relating to would definintly not be covered. It is very easy to spend thousands and thousands of dollars fast!

The public school does offer programs and they have fantastic people working for them. However, early intervention is one of the most important things in attacking this. So, many times you need a lot more then 30 minutes once or twice a week in therapy. I have heard good remarks about the PPCD program also. 

Paige --- 20 years ago -

I just wanted to add- THANKS to all who have read this thread. It is so encouraging to see autism awareness happening in our area.

Until recently, I hadn't met anyone else in our area who had a child like mine. With the numbers on the rise- it surprised me.

Anyways... just wanted to say thanks for the discussion. 

Fiona --- 20 years ago -

Paige, if you don't mind me asking how did you know that your child had autism? My son is due to get his shot and I want to know if there were indications before having the shot. I did a little research and I read that a child can behave and progress as scheduled and then all the sudden not be able to do as he once had. Very scary. I completely understand if you choose not to answer. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 20 years ago -

That is such a good question, Deanna. I actually asked Paige the same question a while back. She has a lot of really good information. I actually spoke to Dr. Chin about it too. Dr. Chin said that children with autism usually miss milestones very early on but it really isn't realized until they are a little older. A big one and I believe Paige's little boy did this too was not talking. They also don't make eye contact and aren't able to socialize in an enviroment that most children his age could.

There are different levels of autism though and if your child didn't have a severe case wouldn't it be hard to tell?

I know lots of people will disagree with me but I am glad that I held off on the MMR and knowing now what I do about vaccines when my new baby is born I will hold off on this until they are at least 2.5 too. 

Fiona --- 20 years ago -

Amy, okay so regression from this point doesn't happen? Since he does make eye contact, talk and socialize. Also, if you wait til 2.5 does the chances of developing austism from the shot go down? 

Paige --- 20 years ago -

No problem. We are very open about it. We absolutely love him exactly as he is (of course!) and there are so many parts of his autism that are truly amazing gifts. I think what is important to remember is that autism is a spectrum disorder. There are truly 1000 shades. One kid may have some signs that another may not. My son is considered high functioning, which means he pretty much would seem normal to you in passing. he can do a lot of what a "typical" child can do, but we do have road blocks.

One of the big signs is regression, however, that was never an issue for us. My son still to this day has never lost anything he has been taught. He always did everything on schedule except talk. Our biggest indicator was language delay. At 18 months he was immitating maybe 2 words and not calling any of us anything specific. I then asked my pediatrician who I adore, but he said I was totally jumping the gun and wait until 2. At 2, he told me give him a few more months because everything else about him is typical. I pretty much disagreed and wanted an evaluation with a dev. pediatrician (which by the way is not covered by ins.) Ended up, mothers do sometimes know stuff :-)

He also has some different behaviors, such as flapping his hands. I know a lot of kids do this when excited, but his was very intense. His whole body and mind were wrapped up in it. This is more of a sensory issue, but is common when dealing with the autism spectrum. He also loved trains madly! The lining them up and wheel turning were his specialty and he could do it for hours. Not playing trains, just lining them up and watching the wheels. At his school, THOMAS is the most loved toy!

He has always made eye contact and loves cuddling and touch. He does sometimes seem deaf, when his mind is in his thoughts, but he can usually be redirected pretty easy. He does like other children, but struggles in appropriate play with them. He can't talk, so he may shove them with a smile. He is just now starting to actually play with Little People as people. He use to just throw them. Pretend play has come kind of late for us, but the important things is that it is coming :-)

We are just now starting to face the hard stuff. Other kids don't understand why he doesn't talk. Lifeguards don't understand why he continues to run. Barbers don't understand why cutting his hair is truly painful for him and he kicks. Playgroups don't go so well and a lot of programs dont let him participate because he doesn't follow the routine or isn't potty trained. The other day it broke my heart when another kid on the street said, "he is the stupid one." We get stared at alot, but I just smile my biggest smile and talk to him like I understand every single thing that comes out of his mouth. If people are giving me looks, we just laugh like what he is doing is so funny. It is kind of easy to disguise now (for his benefit only, not the starers sp?) However, his IQ and receptive language is out of this world, and it won't be long before he gets it all.

We just keep on truckin... and the journey is great :-) 

Scottie's Hottie --- 20 years ago -

I am not sure if regression happens at this point but I would think that he would already be showing some signs. If I remember correctly Paige suspected something wasn't right early on with her son.

From what I have read and been told the MMR shot will only cause a child to become autistic that would have developed autism either way. This is not what K's friends mom believes. She believes the actual shot will cause it but I spoke to the dr. about it and somewhat disagree. I would just rather be more confident that the shot didn't cause this in my children by waiting until the usual onset age of autism to appear which is around 2 years old. Since M did have that reaction to his first shots it has really opened my eyes. I know that vaccinations are necessary but it doesn't make them any less scarey.

I have heard that you can get your child into school by saying that it is your religious beliefs that they not be immunized. In my son's case we will have to have documentation to support his shot records showing that it was medically necessary for him NOT to recieve the immunization he had a reaction too. 

Fiona --- 20 years ago -

Paige, my heart and my prayers are with you and you family. People can be so mean and as a mother myself my heart breaks for you having to deal with them. Keep you head held high and your spirit even higher. It sounds to me that you are a GREAT mom. 

justmy2cents --- 20 years ago -

Just a bit of information: I recently took a child psychology class at UHD and our professor (a child psychologist - Dr.) said there was absolutely NO link between the shots and autism. His main point and case was the fact the Europe's children receive the same shots and have an extemely low rate of autism. Also, in the US 1 in 110 children are born with autism. According to him there are two main reasons that doctors/psychologist believe a child can be born with autism:

1. The number one reason - They belive that if a child has parents whom are both more than average mart in math/science/or computers than the child has a much higher risk to be born with autism. This can be seen with the rate of autism in Silcon Valley is highest in the US.

2. The mother was sick during her pregnancy. The could be anything from the Flu to a hospital stay. I am unsure why this was a cause but if memory serves me correctly - it is something do with the development of the fetus and the sick mother not being able to provide what is needed. 

Paige --- 20 years ago -

First, let me preface this with how much I do appreciate your sharing. However, I would love to pick his brain and have him explain his reasoning. That sounds like the silliest thing in the world to me. However, I am not a doctor- so I would love to hear what he has to say. I am always open to hearing out new theories.

Neither of those apply to me....the math/science/computers has my husband chuckling-LOL! No offense at all to your professor's theory... we just know our skills in those areas are lacking :-) 

Scottie's Hottie --- 20 years ago -

Paige: No need to modest we all know that you and your DH are borderline geniuses! LOL! No really you are pretty intelligent and hubby must be somewhat because he married you! 

MomofTwins --- 20 years ago -

Paige - I applaud you - you have an awesome, positive attitude.

If anyone is interested in reading a novel (fiction) about children's vaccinations, read "Fatal" by Michael Palmer. It has to do with the creation of a 'super-vaccine' (one shot, all diseases covered). It really gets you thinking and got me hooked on reading all of his other books. 

angel --- 20 years ago -

At what age are they supposed to receive their MMR? We have a round of shots coming up next month and if this is included then I will need to check with our Neurologist to see if we need to skip it. We cannot take the DTP vaccine for medical reasons but there may be others that we need to wait on as well. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

justmy2cents, "I recently took a child psychology class at UHD and our professor (a child psychologist - Dr.)"

Not to discredit what you heard ....but for that doc to tell you the MMR is used in Europe is incorrect. Most of Europe (5yrs.ago, don't know if it is still ongoing) was sueing Merck because their own research concluded the MMR did cause the autism. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

As parents we all have to read and educate ourselves.......and that means reading other things besides what the immunization nurse gives you.

I DO NOT trust the pharmacutical companies.....they are not out for your best interest.....they make and sell "products".....when research is done at universities and the university files bad reports-they loose funding!!!

And as far as your doctor being trained....oh, he's trained alright....trained by that same pharmacudical dollar that funds research and educational grants to those same universities. Most doctors are nothing but a puppet---educated to "treat" your symptoms---not find the problem. WHY???

Because treating your symptoms makes the drug company money, you become dependent on daily drugs $$$$......finding the cause of your sicknesses is not money making/ 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

okay....I just got a quick read online about what is new in the whole MMR deal.....it does appear that Europe is once again using the MMR, but they had stopped doing so a few years back.

I just don't understand......if there is this question of safety......why not just go ahead and give 3 seperate vaccines like they use to....??? I would rather my kid be pricked 2 extra times than to play russian rullette (sp?) 

cmi --- 20 years ago -

I wanted to share with you guys the signs my son also showed. Since birth, he has always kept to himself. He had no interest in any toys until he was over 1. He learned how to say there you go and thank you, but lost it. He did not even say mommy and daddy until he was 2 and a half. He did not mimic animal sounds until he was 2. To this day, he will not sit and listen to a story. He did not make eye contact until after 2, when he was in therapy. He will not sleep alone. He is extremely obsessive. For example, when he was in speech, the therapist opened her cabinet for a toy. It didn't close all the way. He started kicking and screaming. She thought he didn't like the toy. I told her to close the cabinet. When she did, all was fine. He did not point until he was over 2. He has sensory issues. For example, he loves slides. Since these brown things started being everywhere outside, he just stands by his slide and says, "eww." I clean it off. He still manages to see one. I clean that off, he scans the slide and manages to find another. He will not go on it anymore. He is oblivious to other kids. One mistake some make is thinking that because they interact with adults, they are fine. Not true. At 3 and a half, he is now starting to combine 2 words, but still has only about 30 words.

I'm sure there are many more signs. We love having him. He is very smart and can draw just about anything he sees. He is lucky to have patient parents. The most frustrating thing about it is judgement of parenting by others. Even his own grandmother thinks we just give him what he wants, and nothing is wrong. Would you let your kid scream for two hours because you wouldn't let him hold a ball, which he is obsessed with doing (just holding it, not throwing)? Would you let them cry for two hours until they told you they were hungary when you knew it to begin with and he can't tell you? I just wish there was more awareness. I was relieved to be confirmed that it was autism, and not bad parenting, because that's the way some people made me feel. We love him very much, and he will have a great life! 

justmy2cents --- 20 years ago -

SO SORRY but I did not have a chance to log back on Monday - I did not mean to cause such a stir.

The opinion was not mine it was the opinion of our text book and his research - I am not saying he is correct - just stating his facts. He has his own practice and teaches at night. A parent with a child whom is Austic does not have to fall into those two theories - they are just what scientist are researching currently as the cause for Autism. The two children that I have met with forms of Autism their parents fell into cataglory #1 - they were both more than average smart - this does not mean they were rocket scientist - just smarter than most folks in certain fields of knowledge. Everyone uses 10% of their brain - each and every person is just as smart as the next person - no one is smarter than anyone else - not even Einstein. How you use your 10% is not up to you - you are born with that gravitation. Most people use their 10% evenly and some peak in certain areas and valley or fall short in others. Take Einstein for example: He was a sheer genious in Science and Math but could not tie his own shoes or even find his way home. It is even a sound theory that he was in fact Austic. His 10% was used soley for science and math and that left his no % to use on social or other skills.

A child with Austism is like any other child - but their gravitation falls on the side of Einstein - they will peak in a certain area and excell beyond what their parents ever imagined. It is a known theory that most genious and savants have a form of Austism - if you take that theory to heart - that means who we are as a society, who we are as a race, the life that we know it all stems from the genious, the savants, the people with Austism. How amazing is that to think that who we are and the lives we have are from people whose 10% helped the lives of each and every human that will ever be born.

Okay off my soap box.

As for my posting, I am terribly sorry to each and everyone of you if I caused offense. 

Paige --- 20 years ago -

Oh my gosh... JUSTMYTWOCENTS... none taken here at all. I love hearing all of the different theories people have. And honestly... to this point that is all they are.

Keep sharing :-) 

Paige --- 20 years ago -

Oh...and to AMY J- well about the genius thing... we just like to play our shy cards so the rest of society feels smart, too :-) HA HA HA- LOL!

However, on the serious side... marrying me is the smartest choice my man ever made! Ha! 

I Love Horses --- 20 years ago -

In response to the having to have vaccinations to have your child in school is wrong, the texas department of health has a form they will mail to you to give to your childs school stating you dont vaccinate for reason of concience or religious reasons, our govenor passed this law stateing that no child or parent should be forced to give their child vaccines due to the fact that so many children are getting sick from them and the vaccine companys are not wanting to be held liable for it so they made it a parents choice! I vaccinated my son at age 5 due to being told i had to to enroll his is school (such liars) and his demenor changed rapidly he was a outgoing child and then he became a recluse and would bang his head on the walls and rock back and forth i stopped his vaccines after a year and he has only gotten a little better even his Dr believes that the vaccines altered his chemical balance. I have been to 3rd world countries where i helped vaccine children only to see them die from the vaccinations i gave them, i will not and have not vaccinated my other 2 kids and i believe its a parents choice it should be up to you if you want to sumit your child to vaccines that can make them sick or kill them. I dont condeme anyone that does vaccinate their children i just tell them to be aware and not just do it because the school says they have to or their Dr says they need to, they have had this stuff driled into there brains so they dont know any better, there are Dr out there that have resurched this and have found it harmful. Anyways enough venting for me, iam just saying only do what you are comfortable with and reserch it dont get bullied ito it because your dr or school lied to you and said you had too. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground