Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Wierd ? to some, but I really need advice!

who's talking here?

blessed 1
Unichic 1
Sandyr911 1
Texasflygirl 1
The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees 1
Denise C 3
MissT 2
Scottie's Hottie 2
cmi 1
RRay 1
Mrs_Mac 1
Little Gypsy 1
Loni 1
duflochy 3
Kingwoodgal 8
Anderson 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

Ok, I know this is going to sound very wierd, or just plain dumb, but I honesty need advice. My family have just started to go to church, and we have never been church goers before.
My question is, when they pass the offering basket around, what is the "norm" amount you give??
I know I will get answers, whatever you can afford, et.... but I honestly have NO idea!
Can some of you out there please give me some insight or an idea of what is the appropriate amount. I know it will differ from family to family and what people feel they can afford et, but I would like a ball park, as it is making feel nervous.
Thanks!!!! 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

kingwoodgal, "offering basket "

If it is an "offering" then that is above and beyond your tithe.

The bible is very clear on how much your tithe is to be....and that is 10% of your income.

An "offering" is something seperate from your tithe....and is whatever you feel God is leading you to give. There is no set amount.....nor is it required weekly or anthing.

Hope this helps. If your a new believer you should look into New Believer Classes at your church....this will explain more clearing your role in the church and what the church believes in. 

Texasflygirl --- 20 years ago -

If you are not a member, and are just visiting, I would say $5-$10.....whatever you're led to give. Give whatever is on your heart to give, and God will be honored. 

Denise C --- 20 years ago -

Don't want to start a religous debate but tithing was applicable under Mose's Law not the new covenant.

If you are visiting, no don't give. If you are a member give what you can afford. 

Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

Anderson,

Thanks for your reply,

Ok, now I am more confused than ever! Having never gone to church before, (at least on a regular basis), this is all new to me.
What is tithe?
I know some churches have the 10% when you belong to a church. What does it take to belong to a church?
I dont mean to sound dumb, but I honestly dont know.
We have just started going, and we are enjoying it, but we have not "joined" as yet, and dont know how to, to be honest!
As newbies to the church we go when we can, which is not always regular as our work schedule doesn't let us. We have gone 4 times so far, and intend to go as often as we can.
I cringe when the offering basket comes, as I have no idea what is appropriate.
If we do join this chuch, are we expected to give 10% of our income? We cant afford that at all. I know churches rely on thier parishiners, but what if you cant afford it?
Thanks for any advice! 

Denise C --- 20 years ago -

Go under google and type in tithing. You will find many articles by religious scholars. Read them and the bible verses and you make the decision.

Tithing will not buy you eternity in heaven.

Tithing for Israel is not the same as the tithe that we hear of today-- in fact tithing was rarely money. There were three tithes in the Old Covenant. More often tithes were the crops, the produce of the soil was to be tithed, grains, the fruit of the trees, every year new wine and oil, the firstborn of their herds and flocks (Leviticus 27:30-33). If the place the nation of Israel were to tithe was too far away to carry their goods (such as Jerusalem) it could be exchanged for money. They were to use their money to buy anything the owner chose: cattle, sheep, wine (Deuteronomy 14:22-26). Every third year the tithe was to be reserved as a festival tithe where they brought out all the tithe, and their produce where the Levite, the stranger, the orphan, the widow, the poor who were in their town, could come and eat and be content (Deuteronomy 14:28-29; 26:12-15). You can expect not to see those who teach tithing as an obligation to practice the third year tithe.

Prosperity teachers who promote tithing like to point out that Jesus commanded tithing. In the New Testament tithe and tithing are found eight times (Matthew 23:23; Luke 11:42; 18:12; Hebrews 7:5-6,8-9). All of these passages refer to the Old Testament usage under the law. Tithing was still practiced under the law when Jesus was on earth, however, the only time Jesus mentioned the tithe was a rebuke to the religious leaders “But woe to you Pharisees! For you tithe mint and rue and all manner of herbs, and pass by justice and the love of God. These you ought to have done, without leaving the others undone. In Matthew 23:23 he explains they “have neglected the weightier matters of the law: justice and mercy and faith.” These you ought to have done” Here Jesus makes it clear that living the life of faith toward God included love toward man and was more necessary than what you give to God; and this was under the law, not grace. Think about what is Jesus addressing? Justice, the Pharisees were unfair in the in dealings with the people, they ripped them off in their sacrifices brought to the temple. Mercy, they had none, everyone had to be as religious (spiritual) as they were. They constantly looked down upon people, remember the story Jesus told of “Two men went up to the temple to pray, one a Pharisee and the other a tax collector.” The Pharisee stood and prayed thus with himself, 'God, I thank You that I am not like other men-- extortioners, unjust, adulterers, or even as this tax collector. 'I fast twice a week; I give tithes of all that I possess. “And the tax collector, standing afar off, would not so much as raise his eyes to heaven, but beat his breast, saying, 'God, be merciful to me a sinner!' “I tell you, this man went down to his house justified rather than the other; for everyone who exalts himself will be humbled, and he who humbles himself will be exalted” (Luke 18:10-14).
So we see giving is not enough to make one justified before God, yet many have been convinced to rely on their obedience in this area to have God's blessings.


The old covenant is the law of Moses. When Jesus brought the new
covenant, the old was no longer in effect.

So on the question of tithing in the New Testament. Nowhere does Paul or any other apostle mention a required amount. On the other hand, Israel was under the law, being a theocratic nation they were obligated to tithe. Jesus had kept the law before He was crucified, for this reason Jesus had Peter pay the temple tax (Matthew 17:24). After Jesus was crucified the New Covenant began and the Old was finished (Heb.8:7,13). New Testament Christians were NEVER under the Old covenant law? One cannot conclude tithing is required under the New Covenant the same as the Lord's Supper and Baptism. Not once does any epistle contain any admonitions or a rebuke for failing to tithe. The necessity of giving is mentioned but only with the right attitude, to help and support others. You do not have to tithe to have God's blessing, in fact, those who are well off are asked to give away their things away when necessary. “Command those who are rich in this present age not to be haughty, nor to trust in uncertain riches but in the living God, who gives us richly all things to enjoy. Let them do good, that they be rich in good works, ready to give, willing to share, storing up for themselves a good foundation for the time to come, that they may lay hold on eternal life” (1 Timothy 6:17-19).

The New Testament when it speaks about giving goes against “tithing as a doctrine. 2 Cor. 9:7 says, “Every man according as he purposed in his heart, so let him give: not grudgingly, or of necessity: for God loves a cheerful giver.” Notice there is no amount mentioned, it what you have settled in your own heart. The Greek word for cheerful is hilaros, it is the English word “hilarious,” meaning give in a joyful, cheery, and exuberant manner. We should be happy and joyful to give to expand God's Kingdom. We are specifically told not to give grudgingly. The Greek word for grudgingly is lupe. It carries the meaning of sorrow, grief, being annoyed. If you are compelled to give, or give out of necessity and you have sorrow and annoyance in your heart don't give. If someone has convinced you or forced you to give by making you feel guilty or promised you a greater return, then you are no longer a cheerful giver.

The Apostle Paul also says in 1 Cor. 16:2, “On the first day of the week let each one of you lay something aside, storing up as he may prosper, that there be no collections when I come. Again, it is not “tithing,” only giving as one has purposed in his heart and as one has prospered, you choose the amount. God does not pressure us, or manipulate us by guilt or hold a bonus out to us to motivate us to give. Have you ever noticed Jesus did not take any offerings!
Love is to be our motivation, not compulsion or legalism (Hosea 6:6; Micah 6:6-8; Mark 12:28-34; 1 Cor . 13:1-7). The more a person loves God the more he will want to give to see his work exp and, and this not always mean money.


http://www.letusreason.org/Wf34.htm 

Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

Thanks texasflygirl !!!!!!!!!!!! I needed a ballpark, and I'm glad I have been within it!
We went once and neither my husband or I had any cash on us at all, and we felt awful!
We made up for it the following week though.
Thanks to everyone, i am learning!
Another ?? How do you give tithe?
Is that once you belong to a church??
How to "join" a church? 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Kingwoodgal....the answer to your questions would be better served asking the pastor of the church you are desiring to become members of.

With you being a new believer.....you want to be careful of the advice you ask. Would you go to your veternarian to discuss your pap-smear? NO...LOL...it would be crazy! =)

When it comes to money and your church it is very personal. As your spiritual walk grows and you become more involved with your church....your hearts desire will be to give. 

Unichic --- 20 years ago -

Dang, if I had to give 10% of our income to the church, we'd be on the street. Is this what the poor church-goers must pay also?

I am sorry, but this sounds crazy. The Bible SAYS you must give 10% to the church? Crap, I need to be a pastor. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Kingwoodgal, "How do you give tithe? "

Tithe means 10th, so you give a tenth of your income. Think of it this way: Imagine giving your 18mo.old a lollipop....he's so cute and adorable drooling it all over himself. Then you say, "Johnny, give mommy a lick" and his reply is, "NO, MY LOLLIPOP!"

It is the same with us when God says, "Hey, can you give 10% of your income to grow and benefit my Kingdom?" ...and we seamingly innocent enough say, "Hey God, I can't. I need it".

We are like the 18mo. toddler....who does not realize that you GAVE him the lolipop and could easily take it away! We don't realize that at our Heavenly Father has provided our income and our ability to earn that income and HE can just as easily take it away and give it to someone else who will use it to prosper His Kingdom. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 20 years ago -

LOL! It does say to tithe 10% but that God's blessings will be double what you have given. Something to that extent. I can't remember exactly what. Honestly I have been a member of 2 local churches but I have not payed my tithes regularly. It is something that eats at me. I do however pay monthly to World Vision. When we go to church I usually drop a check in the offering for $20-$150. It just depends on how much extra I have that month. 

Denise C --- 20 years ago -

Sorry, don't believe in tithing. But like Anderson said, it is everyone's personal belief. 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

Kingwoodgal----Dont worry about offerings or tithes at this point, just go and enjoy it. If u see that u dont enjoy it get out or look for another church. There will be time enough later on to worry about money. GO there to lay your troubles down, not to add to them. there will come a time when u will have money and want to give. do not be embarrased when the offering plate is passed. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 20 years ago -

Great advice, duflochy! 

Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

Thanks to all ! Good advice. Anderson, I have emailed the pastor this morning to seek advice, but not about this.
Here I am asking input and advice for a specific question, not for a spiritual one. 

Loni --- 20 years ago -

I was tought 10% of your income should be given to the church. 

Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

I guess, this tith thing is also a personal choice. I feel if God knows I cant afford it, ok. I am giving tith to benifit the church right? To help spread the word as such? Well, I can do other things to spread the word, if I cant afford 10% ???
Tith, I take it pays for the upkeep of the church et... which I do not deny, takes money, so I guess once you do join try to be as generous as the pocketbook allows. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Kingwoodgal, "Here I am asking input and advice for a specific question, not for a spiritual one."

I'm glad your already seeking wise councel with your pastor. But "how much you give" is also a spiritual one too.

I am so not trying to make you feel guilty about whether you do or do not give. Just trying to answer your questions.

Did you know that you can test God? .....there is only ONE thing you can test Him on....and that is your money! He says "test me" and see if I don't return to you ten-fold. 

Sandyr911 --- 20 years ago -

Thank you information Fairy for pointing out the tithing thing.

I dont believe in tithting either. Never have and I didnt want too start some religious hoo-ha about it. In my church we were taught too give what God led you too give. In the church we went too it was a small country church and NONE of it went too the pastore, his wife or the church. It was all used too help members of the church or others who were in need. My grandmother was BIG into tithting but she was Pentecostal. And ive gone too church where some of my friends went and they gave 10% when there phones were being cut off and they were struggling too buy groceries and the pastor encouraged this. I dont belive in your family doing without for a church too get their part.

Thanks Denise.....Didnt wanna be a leper.....lol 

Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

Anderson, dont worry you haven't made me feel guilty! I didnt mean to come off bad. You have answered my question, thank you. 

Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

Does the tith go towards the salary of the pastor? If not, how does he earn his living? 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Kingwoodgal, "Does the tith go towards the salary of the pastor? "

Not directly no.

Kingwoodgal, "If not, how does he earn his living?" Each church is different. The pastor can be paid a straight salary. Or, he can be paid a % of church revenue. Or a combination of the both.

I think a pastor should be paid a % of church revenue. In this way, the pastor is financially blessed when the church as a whole is financially blessed. But if/when times get tough the pastor would recieve financial cuts just as every other aspect of the church would. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

To hear what God has to say on tithes and offerings to: Malachi 3:6-10

On a personal level....you would not believe what it cost a church to operate! My spouse was on the financial board of a church in Kwd....and the electric alone was 5-7k a month! Then there is the mortgage, lawn service, cleaning personnel.....and toilet paper.....have you an idea how much it cost in hand soap and t-paper?? LOL 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

I guess some church folks are (full of it) 

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees (Mod) --- 20 years ago -

I've been going to Catholic Church for years. (When I was little,) What we always did was, my dad would give each of us kids a dollars to put in the collection basket, and he woud put in 5. So, they would get a total of 8 dollars. I always felt it was sufficiant. It also made us kids feel like we were doing something special. Now, I just give whatever change I have. If I have a few dollars, I give it. If I have 50 cents, then thats what they get. Its the luck of the draw most weeks :-P 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

When you tithe and give offerings.....there is an actual spiritual maturity that comes with it. A humbling of ones self before God.

What your actually saying with your money is, "God I have faith in you....I have faith that you provide for me and my family and that you will continue to provide all our needs."

The hardest thing for anyone to do is give away money.....especially 10%!! That is why God asks....he wants you to grow spiritually....he doesn't really need your money. Your money isn't the real issue to God, but as humans it is sometimes hard to see that...because money to us is very important.

But when you tithe....and do it with a joyful heart....you are showing God that you do rely on Him and his provisions versus your own understanding.

PS.for those of you that know what Prosperity Preaching is...I do not believe in it....to tell someone to give because they will recieve in return is an incorrect reason to give.....does God say he will reward the giver? Yes He does, but we are not to give ONLY so that we can recieve 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

Kingwood gal - I have been reading all of the replies to your question of giving. At this time I thing the whole point is being missed.

If you are new to church the first and foremost important thing is to give yourself to God. Ask him to be in control of your life and to take you and use you for his glory. From that point on he will guide you and you won't feel guilty over what you do or do not have to give.

By all means talk to the pastor of the church you are attending and if he stresses money over a personal relationship with God find a church that does.

The widow gave a penny while the rich man gave in abundance. Jesus said that she gave more than them all because she gave all she had.

There are several referencces in the Bible telling us that the Lord perfers a relationship with us over anything else.

Study, ask questions but rely on yourself in prayer to God for you answers.

Mrs Duflochy 

RRay --- 20 years ago -

Mrs Duflochy

in my opinion has the best answer by far.

"By all means talk to the pastor of the church you are attending and if he stresses money over a personal relationship with God find a church that does. "

I wholeheartidly agree!

THAT is really the point...ANd you don't even NEED a church to do that....

Myself.......Private Catholic schools all my life, Schooled by Ninja Nuns...
They can humble the most hardened Marine with merely a glance.
Don't mess with Nuns. 

Mrs_Mac --- 20 years ago -

I couldn't agree you more Mrs Duflochy! You have made a choice to seek a relationship with God. This is a huge undertaking in itself and requires a lot of love, humility, and dedication.

The fact that you WANT TO give, says a lot. But by no means should you feel any pressure to HAVE TO give.

You should be focusing on building your relationship with God. How can you feel free to hear His word when you're in church if you're worried about whether you're giving enough money or not? Give what you can, if it's only $1 this week, then so be it. God isn't sitting there with a spreadsheet keeping track of your "deposits" like the bank would. He and ONLY He has the right to judge. So don't feel ashamed or embarrassed about how much you give. Be proud that you're there letting God and others know that you want Him in your life.

I grew up Catholic, and was dragged to church every Sunday and first Friday of the month. And I felt so OBLIGATED to be there, that I was always too self conscious to learn God's way. It wasn't until I was an adult, and CHOSE to become a Christian, and found my own path to God that I was truly happy.

Ray is right about those nuns! I went to Catholic School all my life, and for some peace loving people, they sure can be mean!

Good luck along your path and God Bless. 

Little Gypsy --- 20 years ago -

we do 10% of earnings , i was always under the impression that was the correct amount . But I feel that it should not be a financial strain to go to church if you do not have it , it shouldnt be an issue , sometimes we don't and Sometimes we do . But if we gain income tax or a larger amount we usually try to make up then . Just my thooughts. 

Kingwoodgal --- 20 years ago -

Great advice everyone, !!!!!! 

MissT --- 20 years ago -

ok - I know you've probably heard enough of this already, buy I have to share my story. First, let me say that everything Anderson has said is right on. I believe that if you are visiting, you give an offering of what your heart says to give, but if you a member of the church you give your tithe to the church. This was made clear to me when I was a missoinary several years back.

Read Malachi:

http://bibleresources.bible.com/passagesearchresults.php?passage1=Mala chi+3%3A10-12&version1=31

Note the part where is says "TEST ME" and watch and see all the blessing that he will pour down. I will make this long story short, but I took every last peso I had in my purse and put it in the basket and told God I still owed him, but that he could consider himself TESTED. I was testing him. I was thinking about my new car, my new house, my new job, etc - all the blessings he said he would pour down. But he clearly told me - just look for my son and I will give you all the desires of your heart. Within one hour, someone gave me a check, within a week I was given a new house - not just any house, buy a huge hacienda - completely furnished - and I didn't have to pay a thing. I had job offers coming at me left and right and had to turn so many down.

The funny thing now is (God has such a sense of humor) that since he taught me such a good lesson, if I stop tithing, he charges me that amount somewhere else. Example, my car will need repair or someone will need a visit to the doctor - and the bill is ALWAYS the exact same amount of the tithe I missed. If something goes wrong in my family, the first thing my husband asks is if I tithed! :)

So, my two cents.... enjoy getting to know God your new church and your new family. When the time comes, test him and see. 

cmi --- 20 years ago -

So, based on your Biblical values, God wants his people to suffer while the church prospers. If you make minimum wage and support a family with two minimum wage earners, you shoud give 10% of your 20,000 income to the church. That is absolutely absurd to me (maybe not to you). If you believe in an all loving God, that god will be okay with you giving what you can afford. 

MissT --- 20 years ago -

It's a principal, you can't understand it until you live it. 

blessed --- 20 years ago -

It is all based on faith. It is not based upon how much you should give to the "church". It is what you give (with complete faith) to God. It is so hard to explain. This concept truly defined the phrase "leap of faith" to me. However, tithing without complete faith is just putting $ in to the basket. It is not giving your faith and money to the Lord. The Lord wants you to do this in obedience to Him. He does not want your $$ necessairly, but he wants your heart to be in the direction of HIM.

One thing I do love love love about my church is that we do not have an offering basket. We don't pass around anything for people to put their $ in. We have a small box right in the lobby of the church. Our church believes that tithing is between you and the Lord. If you are in obedience with Him, then you will make that effort to tithe.

Small testimony....my husband and I were at a really low point before we had kids. I had no job and my husband just started his own insurance business. The first month we made a whopping $500 for the total month. Our rent alone was $590. We tithed that $50 knowing that it was God's money and that He would provide if we just had the faith of a mustard seed.........and HE DID! EVery bill got paid and $ showed up where we would have never expected it to show! Praise Him! Nobody knew of our $$ problems. I won't write my total story, for it is too long and I love to chat about it! :) 12 years later, we still know 100% that the Lord has provided everything we have. My husband could never provide for all 7 of us without faith and direction from HIM. Every month no matter how big or how small our check is, we tithe that 10%. We do it joyfully. We understand that it is not our $ to begin with. He has never forsaken us.

It is all about faith. It is not about a basket. It is not about not being able to pay bills. It is not about what others say you should or should not offer. It is about faith and what the Lord has lead you to do. Don't bother tithing until you have complete peace about it. God does not want a heart that is lukewarm. He wants all of you. :) Right now, you do what the Lord leads you to give. In the meantime, look up in your bible what He says about tithing. Scripture was already given in this thread. Then pray. That is all the Lord wants from you...is your heart and your time. He will reveal the rest. :) God Bless! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground