Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

What's the better answer to TAKS?

who's talking here?

cockatiel34 1
Lydia Erb 2
cat 1
Sandyr911 6
marthas attic 1
Margo 1
amy groze 1
Scottie's Hottie 2
Cheryl 4
Mrs_Mac 4
Anderson 3
dawgschit 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

cockatiel34 --- 20 years ago -

I made a separate thread for this, other than the TAKS petition....

If we cut TAKS, what do we replace it with? It's one thing to say an idea is bad, but what is the better answer? Maybe we can revolutionize education! 

Lydia Erb --- 20 years ago -

Let's go back to the way things were when I was a kid. There were tests to see if we had learned what was being taught. If we had not learned the subject matter, we did not pass to the next grade. I don't even remember summer school being offered until I was in high school. If you didn't pass, you had to repeat the grade. Of course, there were tests to see what legvel you were actually at on the national average, but that didn't affect your passing or failing a grade. There was no prep for these tests. I think this old fashioned system made for better teachers and better students. 

Sandyr911 --- 20 years ago -

Cockatiel I personally think they need too come up with something too truly test our childrens minds on what they learn.
Most of the tests they have come up with thus far havent been helpful.
TAKS has been the worst and they seem too get harder every year.
Now too update the tests is one thing but my 3rd grader is expected too have multiplication and division mastered by the end of this year along with money and they have already started decimals and fractions. We didnt get in this stuff until the 5th grade.

They need too come up with better testing that can test all children not just some. I dont know what the answer fully is but im open too ideas.

They dont want prayer in schools but as long as this test exists it will be there. 

Cheryl --- 20 years ago -

Cockatiel, I agree with Sandy that their needs to be another way to test our children. I just sent my oldest to College and believe it or not she had to do placement testing to see where she was on the scale.... She was a straight A student, graduated Magna Cum Laude in her high school class. The placement was to help make sure that she had a grasp of certain subjects and was put with her peers.
Unlike the High schools where they stick all children in a pack and say learn or else. My son and me are on pins and needles as to whether he is going to pass or not, he is different from my daughter and learns at different pace. He wants to become a Marine so bad but knows if he doesn't pass the TAKS test he won't graduate and he can't join. He would rather drop out if that be the case. Not all children are going to go to college and become DRS and LAWYERS not that there is anything wrong with that, but these kids are giving up and after going through some of the hardest years of their lives, to be told that you can't graduate because you didn't pass the TAKS test is wrong and defeats the NO CHILD LEFT BEHIND. 

cat --- 20 years ago -

if a child does not pass a grade then they repeat the grade, just like when we were growing up....no taks test should be given in order for a child to go to 4th grade....they have to take exit exams in high school to get out of there...sad very sad..so they start stressing them at age 8 (3rd grade) and continue till they are going to graduate....and then they don't walk if they don't pass.....this is a bunch of bull----shit 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

I still just don't understand where there is a problem with having your children take a test that makes sure they have learned what they are suppose to learn.

Unless I am missing something....what is the big deal? If little Timmy can't pass 3rd grade who's fault is that?

And shouldn't little Timmy stay in 3rd grade until he can test out?

Wouldn't it be worse for little Timmy to move ahead and become even more lost and fall further behind?

To make the educational system require students to move ahead regardless of ability seems to be worse. 

Sandyr911 --- 20 years ago -

Anderson I geuss its seeing your child get sick at the thought f having too take this particular test. I dont disagree with them testing a child too make sure they are learning but the kids in Texas dont learn anymore.

The test isnt friendly too the kids at all, any of them, not just the learning disabled ones. 

marthas attic --- 20 years ago -

The problem with TAKS is thats all they teach..they teach for the test not really anything else. And there is nothing wrong with going back to the way things were. You were taught, several chapters, you took a test..they average everything and boom you either passed or failed. Now they stress these kids out so bad making them think they will be held back it makes me sick. What about kids who are great students but freeze on this test? Way tooo much stress for these kids. And we wonder "what does my kid have to be stessed about?" I know 2nd and 3rd graders who have actullay become physically ill over this stupid test!! 

Margo --- 20 years ago -

I dont have a problem testing a child to see if they are learning. But to focus the whole year around these tests and then put so much pressure on them about failing them is not right.

My son comes home and lets me know that if he fails he wont move on, that his teacher says that if he passes then he will get something special for it. This is what is in disagreement that is why the Forum reads....
What"s the better answer to Taks

We are looking for better ways to get this testing done without all the unnessesary pressure it is putting on these kids. 

Lydia Erb --- 20 years ago -

Anderson, the big problem with the test is that the kids are not learning. They are memorizing what will be on the test so that they can pass it. That isn't learning. Little Timmy gets to move into the 4th grade if he passes the test and he hasn't learned what he should have in 3rd grade. So he is even more lost and he does fall further behind. 

Cheryl --- 20 years ago -

Anserson, I agree that there should be testing, all of us do. But there is a problem when even the teachers are stressing over this test and the students are being moved from one class to another to avoid "cheating". It's clear that this test is affecting some of our teachers as well. I've talked to my sons teachers and they have told me that their number one focus is passing the TAKS test, and if a student is behind or falls behind it is extremely hard for them to catch up and they are the ones left behind because of the pressure on the school to meet the overall standards set by the state to pass the TAKS test. 

amy groze --- 20 years ago -

I agree they need tests but the pressure they put on them the pep rallies and the posters and the time they spend on this is ridiculous.. My son has severe test anxiety like me and he literally stops sleeping before these last night he was jumpy and in a horrible mood.. he is already struggling with other subjects.. now this, they cancelled his track pratice for it yesterday and they have a meet thursday..my childs desire to go to college is so great..he panics that he wont do good.. there was nothing i could do last night to calm him down and this happens every year.. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 20 years ago -

Anderson:

What is so bad about the test is that they are extremely hard. An example of this was when my daughter was in 3rd grade and she was having a hard time on the math practice test of the TAKS. I had a conference with the teacher and I swear to you she had to sit down and work out some of these problems with me. I am by no means stupid and I have even taken college math but this questions were very tricky. This rings true to the test my daughter took last year too. My daughter is an all A and B student. School just comes easy to her. Well last year she failed the math part of the TAKS test! She had made an A in her math class all year long! She told me that there were so many things on that test that she had never been taught. Now this year she is in 7th grade and has to pass the test to move to 8th grade. I guess what I am trying to say is that if my daughter who is even in some accelarated classes and always makes A & B is struggling to pass this test what about the kids who struggle with school everyday? They don't have a chance. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

I definatly understand anxiety....I get that part. I'm not trying to demean anyones children here.

I understand teachers feeling pressure from the school to teach the subject matter that is on the test.

But if kids find the test hard....wouldn't that mean that the school/teachers are not "teaching" what is required at that level grade??
I wouldn't think that the state would require a 3rd grader to take a 5th grade math test.

Isn't the point of the test to see that the kids are recieving a standarized level of education? 

Sandyr911 --- 20 years ago -

Well the only problem is they dont "teach" anymore they preach.
They force our kids too memorize NOTHING but this test from day one.
They are not taught any social skills or any thing BUT this tes.

And no this test isnt standardized at all.

"But if kids find the test hard....wouldn't that mean that the school/teachers are not "teaching" what is required at that level grade?? "

Not anymore it doesnt, that used too be the scenario.
Now it is the fact they didnt have enough time too cram all the test materials into these kids before the test came. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 20 years ago -

Kids..parents! LOL! I wouldn't have passed the 3rd grade one! I agree there has to be some sort of testing but I think this particular needs to be overhauled. Teachers are forced to teach nothing but the TAKS all year long. I just don't think you can base a child's accomplishments on one test. My daughter has told me that in her math class (one of the few on level classes she has) has some very undisiplined children and the teacher spends most of the class period writing kids up and sending them to the office rather than getting to teach. But yet that teacher is going to be penalized when she has students failing the TAKS because she had unruly kids that wouldn't behave long enough for her to teach. I even mentioned this to the counselor and she just looked at me and shook her head. They all know it's true. 

Mrs_Mac --- 20 years ago -

My daughter is a straight A student. But last night she was complaining of a stomach ache and she was up all night with in pain. This morning when we were getting ready for school, she was doubled over in the bathroom crying. She swore up and down that she wasn't nervous about taking her TAKS test today.

I had to keep her home. I called her teacher at 7:45 this morning and she told me she could do the retest in April. She wouldn't have survived running back and forth to the bathroom during testing. But miraculously, her stomach seems to be doing a lot better. I don't know if it's better because she didn't have to take her test today or was she really sick and the Imodium I gave her settle her stomach? I guess we'll have to wait until April to find out.

It just tore me up to see her like that though. She was ice cold, pale, and shaking with pain. I don't know what to do if this was all brought on by a nervous stomach because of TAKS. 

Sandyr911 --- 20 years ago -

Mrs Mac Ive been waiting for you.
I hope your daughter is feeling better.

Yeah see the other thread about the abolish TAKS petition. 

Mrs_Mac --- 20 years ago -

Thanks Sandy.
I'm glad to see you're back! 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Well....it seems that the teachers are putting all the stress on the kids.

If you end up with a neurotic teacher I can see where she would be all freaky with the kids and over emphisize the "importance" of the test.

I would be worried and upset for my child too if he expressed the level of anxiety you guys are telling me about.

Hope I didn't piss anyone off....I was just asking questions. =) 

Sandyr911 --- 20 years ago -

Mrs _Mac....aint no little hole poking gonna keep me down long! :-) 

Sandyr911 --- 20 years ago -

Anderson it is really a big mess you would almost have too have a kid involved sometimes too understand our passion against this particular method of testing. 

Mrs_Mac --- 20 years ago -

I'm glad to hear that Sandy! How's your daughter handling the pressure of this test? 

Cheryl --- 20 years ago -

I am glad to know that I am not the only parent with a child who is having this much trouble with this test. It's like pulling teeth with my son, I have him in after school tutoring and I am in contact with his teachers weekly. Like Amy J one of my sons teachers (math) has a unruly class. I have been on the phone and even in the principals office because he was struggling in this class. I finally went up there and had them change his schedule. This test doesn't test on what they have learned but what the state says they should know. The teachers are underpaid, the class sizes are sometimes to big for one on one help and the teachers jobs sometimes are lost because of this test. I also had a practice test that my son brought home and was dumbfounded over some of these problems. 

Cheryl --- 20 years ago -

Just another thought, What of the students that are home-schooled? How does that work? Are they required to take this same test in order to Graduate? If you know let me know, that may be something I check into. 

Mrs_Mac --- 20 years ago -

We just went to parent teacher conferences and my son's teacher admitted to us that what they're about to be tested on in the mock science TAKS hasn't even been taught yet. They want to see what the kids actually know. That struck us as kinda stupid. Why would you test kids on what they don't know, and then if they don't pass the darn thing, force them into unnecessary tutoring.

I don't remember testing being like this when I was a kid. We didn't spend 3/4 of the school year preparing just for these tests. We actually learned things. I'm appauled by this. My kids were never subjected to this kind of testing pressure at the their schools in CA. I mean, yeah sure they had testing, but it didn't come with "Pass or Don't Promote" threats attached to them. They were just basic aptitude tests to let us know where the kids were at in their understanding of the subject matter. A large portion of the school funding didn't come from these test scores. And teachers definitely didn't get bonuses as a result of them either. I have a g/f who teaches in our old neighborhood back there and she gave us the skinny on all that stuff. But, things are much different here. We love the school and the teachers, but seeing my daughter the way she was this morning really concerns me.

Here we are 12 hours later, and she hasn't had another episode since. So, was it TAKS?

BTW Sandy, my husband and I did sign the petition. 

dawgschit --- 18 years ago -

 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground