Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

AGE 60 discrimination against airline pilots

who's talking here?

momma0204 1
onthelake 1
PilotsWifeMommyof2 4
The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees 1
grandma again 3
randyjet 8
duflochy 2
Anderson 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

randyjet --- 20 years ago -

I just thought that I would let people know that I am looking for a job after having been kicked out of the cockpit when I turned 60. This is a federal regulation which was instituted to help American Airlines get rid of older pilots. Since I flew for a regional airline, that means I get NO retirement, or medical insurance. Now that the major airline pension plans are going away, there is some movement and a bill in the Senate to raise the age limit. The major airline pilots are going to only get a max of $22,000/yr since they are forced to take retirement at 60 and so their retirement is cut in HALF because of that reg.
We need people to write to Sen. Hutchison since she is indicating she will vote against raising the age limit. For all the Vietnam vets, we are the ones who are getting the shaft on this again, since the age limit will eventually be raised. Then the younger guys who did NOTHING of service to our country will get to fly later, and move up faster at OUR expense. THAT is how the war vets get rewarded. 

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees (Mod) --- 20 years ago -

ouch, thats harsh. what airline did you work for? my good friends father is a pilot, and i would sure hate to see him out of a job in the next few years. 

grandma again --- 20 years ago -

Randyjet, I will gladly write a letter Sen Hutchinson and encourage her to vote FOR raising the age limit for pilots. 

randyjet --- 20 years ago -

I worked for Chautauqua Airlines and flew the EMB-170. It looks like the B737 only a little smaller and has 76 pax seats. Thanks for writing because she is against raising the age limit. She is bought by American Airlines and their union. The other airline pilots union is also against raising the age limit because the younger pilots want to move up faster at our expense.
ALL airline pilots now have to "retire" at 60 with NO SS or medical benefits because of the regs. You friends father will be out looking for a job at age 60 unless the laws are changed.
What is worse is that when I go to IAH I can see the Jazz Air Canada pilots who CAN fly in US airspace over 60, while all US pilots cannot. IT is outrageous that all foreign pilots have MORE rights in the US than us veterans and American pilots. ALPA, the pilots union, signed a contract recently allowing Jazz pilots to fly to age 65, yet they refuse to do so for US pilots. 

grandma again --- 20 years ago -

Randyjet, it is a little harsh of you to say "Sen. Hutchinson is bought by American Airlines and their union". I am writing the letter because I think 60 year old pilots deserve to maintain their jobs and benefits just as any other profession can. Just wanted to let you know that. I, in no way, want to get involved in a political rah-rah here. I don't care what profession a person has, they have worked for retirement benefits and I think they deserve them. That is what I am in support of. 

randyjet --- 20 years ago -

I agree that it may be too soon to know for sure if she is bought by American Airlines and the APA. From all indications I have seen, it looks that way, but not proven. You should know the way the age 60 rule was enacted. Back when the FAA was first established, the FAA head, Gen. Pete Quesada, got a letter from his good buddy Smith of American. Smith had just lost a strike that forced him to take back over age 60 pilots who he had simply fired for reaching that age. Since there was NO rule about when pilots had to get out, he asked Pete to enact a rule to make 60 the cut off age. Quesada pushed it through with no studies done to support his rule, and then a few months later Pete quit the FAA and got a job on Americans board at a very nice salary. Now THAT is being bought! Thank you for your efforts. I am very sensitive to the way things are done in Washington since it affects my life so much in this regard. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

randyjet, what year was this 60yr age limit enacted?? And was this rule in effect when you became a pilot?? 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

I found it...it happened in 1980. It does state that younger pilots were all for the forced retirement....getting rid of the over 60 yr.olds opened up room for advancement.

So I just have to ask randyjet.....that would have made you 26 years younger than you are today...making you 34 yrs.old when the ruling went into effect.

At 34 yrs.old did you think this was a great move? Did you think you would never have to worry about it....because 60...well that was a long way away for you?

I'm not saying your to blame for your predicament....No. What I am pointing out is that our ideas sure change alot from 34 to 60.

Do I think it is wrong?? YES of course. As we all know 60 isn't old anymore. And with the inability to collect on SS or medicare...what is a pilot to do?? 

grandma again --- 20 years ago -

Anderson, I agree with you 100%. As I get closer to 60, it does not seem too old. I never want to be "old" as far a my abilites to work, think, react, etc. At 30 or so, 60 WAS old to me. As I became older, I resented computers and the younger group taking my place in the job market. Now I am thankful they did because I love what I am doing and am having fun in life...not having to compete with all that anymore. It just took lots of work and sacrifice to get to that "acceptance" state of mind. ha-ha 

momma0204 --- 20 years ago -

I agree that the Age-60 rule needs to be changed. I've got personal interest in it....my husband is an airline pilot. I would love for him to have the option to work longer than 60....though I think by then he'll probably be ready to call it quits.

That said, my husband knew that's what the rules were when he started his career a few years ago so we plan for the future based on the assumption that his career will have to end at 60. We still have almost 30 years to retirement but we save towards it every month. If we get lucky and he can work longer (if he wants to) then that will be a BONUS.

By the way....I just wanted to clarify that pilots can still fly after 60....just not for airlines. They are also not excluded from SS and Medicare once they reach the appropriate age....just for that gap between 60 and then. 

PilotsWifeMommyof2 --- 20 years ago -

The rule about pilots retiring at 60 really has nothing to do with forcing people to retire so that other people can move up faster.

It is entirely based on several age-related studies.

It also did not happen in 1980...the first rule ever made about this issue was in 1959. The issue was revisited in 1980.

Please check out this site - the ALPA site (Airline Pilots Association) and the info about why they have the rule.

http://www.alpa.org/DesktopModules/ALPA_Documents/ALPA_DocumentsView.a spx?itemid=1309&ModuleId=1532&Tabid=256

It says, "In 1981, the NIH's National Institute on Aging completed the study, finding no particular medical significance for an age 60 limitation, but stating that age-related changes in health and performance could adversely affect aviation safety."

I dont know about you, but I surely want all of my pilots to be on top of their game when they have me at 37,000 feet!

It also says, "The FAA also says that since the regulation does not prohibit pilots over the age of 60 from serving in other capacities with an airline (i.e., flight engineers or flight instructors), mitigating the economic consequences of the rule, the FAA does not consider the Age 60 rule to be a mandatory retirement policy. Additionally, the rule does not apply to Part 135 operations. This provides other employment possibilities for pilots who have reached the age beyond which they can no longer fly for the airlines."

There are many pilots that continue flying after age 60, doing ferry, or maintenance flights. There are options out there to stay in the airline industry.

The site I posted has a LOT of info regarding the issue...and is still being decided on. Studies do not always provide exact results, because each person is different from the next - for some people, 60 is VERY old and they do not need to be flying a plane with hundreds of passengers on board - reflexes get a lot slower and when you are flying at .8 mach, or 550 mph, 30,000+ feet about the ground, there is no time for error, or slow responses.
Also, being 60 and a pilot is a lot different than being 60 and being a teacher, or working in an office....

Randyjet, I feel for you. Maybe try looking into doing maintenance flights or something similar for someone...then you can continue to do what you love. And in no way was this an attack on you...I just wanted to state facts of the reasoning behind the rule.

The government did not come up with this rule to try to get rid of Vietnam Veterans...it is simply to help ensure the safety of the skies. 

PilotsWifeMommyof2 --- 20 years ago -

Randyjet...you said The major airline pilots are going to only get a max of $22,000/yr since they are forced to take retirement at 60 and so their retirement is cut in HALF because of that reg.


But it is not a forced retirement....

the FAA does not consider the Age 60 rule to be a mandatory retirement policy (quoted from the site posted above)

The rule does not apply to Part 135 operations - non-scheduled operations.

For those that don't know a lot about aviation, an example of a Part 135 is a charter flight for a basketball team (conducted by the major airline) - not a previously scheduled flights that tickets were sold for, to the general public.

So there are a few options...charter, maintenance, smaller charter companies.

Even Spirit airlines flies under Part 135 - one of the largest charter operations. 

onthelake --- 20 years ago -

Air traffic controllers are forced out at 56... (and no one past 30 is hired either)... they've recently approved a waiver although not many can qualify for it. My dad flew until 65 for a freight company... there are other options. Good luck. 

randyjet --- 20 years ago -

I am afraid that Kingwood hottie is wrong and disingenuous on a whole lot of points. AS to the study cited, I am glad that it was quoted" that THERE IS NO particular medical significance for age 60." IN short, there is NO reason for it to be age 60. Then it says that age related changes due to aging COULD be some problem. I see that ALPA left out the studies that found the WORST pilots were those who were age 30-40 in their safety record. I would say that in the interest of safety, that NO person should become a captain of an airliner until AFTER they turn 40 years old. ALPA also forgot that THEY signed a contract with JAZZ Air Canada which allows pilots over 60 to fly. So ALPA thinks that Canadian pilots are better over 60, while US pilots are NOT. I suppose that ALPA thinks that Canadian pilots are better preserved because of the cold, while we here in Houston will ROT faster. They also did not publish the FACTS about the 200+ pilots who flew past 60 when the commuter airlines came under part 121. They flew over 16 million hours of safe flying with one of the pilots being 72 when the grandfather clause ran out in 1999. Those pilots were flying in less capable airplanes, with less automation, in More demanding flying short runs, and with less experienced co-pilots. They had ALL the cards stacked against them, yet compiled a better record than the major airline pilots who were younger. In short, what that proved was that flying skills improve with age rather than diminish.

I see that you are not a pilot either since you would know that if you do something sudden at 33,000', the plane will NOT take kindly to it, so having a lightning fast reflex is a liability in such a situation if anything. In fact some airplanes REQUIRE that the autopilot be flyiing the plane above certain altitudes. In modern planes, including the one I flew, HAND flying the plane is DISCOURAGED and in some it is FORBIDDEN! The autopilot is supposed to be on most of the time. A pilot flying is more like an older surgeon doing operations. Experience is the key to success and it does NOT require the fast reflexes of a sport. Though I did fly competition aerobatics, and the 1984 USA champ in the highest category was Henry Haig who was 65 at the time that he won. NOW THAT kind of flying DOES require fast reflexes and stamina since you pull +12 gs and -4gs or more.

AS for opportunities doing 135 flying. I was offered a job flying a Cessna 402 in the Northeast out of BOS and LGA in the most dense and traffic congested area in the US. I would be doing it in an airplane single pilot, with marginal power on short flights. THAT is FAR more demanding and DOES indeed require quick reflexes and responses, yet ALPA thinks that is perfectly safe and less demanding than doing the same thing in an overpowered airplane, with another experienced pilot on board, with all the automation and on longer flights with less noise and fatigue. It truly requires a person who believes in fairy tales to say such a thing. The pay for such demanding flying was $25,000/yr and I would have had to live out of my car to accept the job. In short, ALPA is LYING that it is concerned about safety with their support for the age limit.

You are also wrong about a number of other items such as flying charter on large aircraft. I can only legally fly as a pilot in an airplane having 9 seats or LESS. I cannot even fly a small commuter plane since they are all under part 121 now. SPIRIT Airlines is NOT a part 135 operation! I cannot fly as a pilot for a freight airline that flies any airplane that has a payload more than 7,000 lbs since that would put the airplane into the part 121 regs. I can fly as a flight engineer, though there are not too many planes left that have them.

To say that the FAA does NOT think of the rule as a retirement age again requires an Orwellian twist of mind. You don't have to retire, you just can't fly any more in your present job. You can always get a job as a WalMart greeter,so you are not forced to retire. Only an FAA or government bureaucrat could take that one seriously. In short, it is hard to take ALPA seriously when they say it is because of safety that they take this position. You might ask them why they changed their tune when they opposed the rule for all those years. It is only recently that they have come out in support of the rule. DID they discover some new study when they changed their mind? All they say is that they accepted the rule since it was not changed. NO mention of safety there. It reminds me of what the communists used to do when they changed the party line. They burned all the old documents or ignored what they had previously said when the line was changed. So all the Canadian pilots ARE Safe after age 60, but Americans are NOT. So ALPA was supporting risky flying before they changed their minds. So more difficult flying over 60 is safer than flying an airplane which demands less skills and reflexes. Just where is the LOGIC or FACTS to support the contention that it is about safety? 

randyjet --- 20 years ago -

I just finished reading the ALPA propoganda for the age 60 rule. I see that they mentioned the fact that the ICAO made 60 the limit in 1978. THEY forgot somehow to state the FACT that ICAO is going to RAISE the limit to age 65 in Nov. 06. I think that is a rather SERIOUS ommission. They also forget to mention the FACT that most of Europe now has 65 as the age limit with the exception of France. The other countries that still use age 60 are places like Cuba, Korea, Yemen, Mongolia, and other such paradises. The ALPA propoganda also forgets to mention the FACT that foreign airlines have over 60 pilots flying in US airspace and that US pilots may NOT do what foreign pilots may do in OUR own country! Why is it that I am a second class citizen compared to foreigners in MY COUNTRY?

Given the FACT that ICAO will be raising the age limit this November, it is only a matter of time before the US will eventually be forced to follow. THAT will benefit the younger pilots who now support the age 60 limit. They will have the option to continue flying if they wish. They will also get the benefit of kicking us older Vietnam vets out so that they move up quicker. It is todays older pilots who are vets for the most part who will get screwed. Thanks for supporting the veterans in this way! 

PilotsWifeMommyof2 --- 20 years ago -

Actually randyjet...my husband IS a pilot. He flies the EMB-145 XR LR and ER for Express.

The age 60 rule has been around for a long time, and we are with momma0204....you plan for it. You plan ahead so that you are prepared for retirement. We know when my husband hits 60 that he's going to retire....and we look forward to that! Planning is important no matter what career you choose.

If you would also look at what I first posted, I said every person is different at age 60. Some people are really old when they are in their 60s, some are still young at heart. Unfortunately, there is not an option available within the airlines to somehow distinguish between the age 60 pilots to see who should stay and who should go.

randyjet you said.... You are also wrong about a number of other items such as flying charter on large aircraft. I can only legally fly as a pilot in an airplane having 9 seats or LESS.

My husband flies ferry flghts ALL the time for fun (from IAH to Conroe) and he flies with a Captain who is AT LEAST 65. He can still fly those flights, even though he cannot fly passenger flights.

I posted the ALPA site for info. Not ANYwhere did I say this is the way it is and get over it. I simply stated facts. The airlines are already in bad standings financially, keeping that many pilots around is just going to make it that much more economically/financially unstable.

You are acting like everyone is out to get you.
The age 60 rule affects ANYone who is 60...not just Veterans. So not supporting getting rid of the age 60 rule is in NO WAY not supporting our veterans. 

randyjet --- 20 years ago -

The FAA and the airlines DO have a means of testing for who should stay and who should go. It is called a FIRST CLASS Medical which involves an EKG and other tests which is adminstered every six months. Unless of course you think that older pilots should be MORE fit than younger ones. They also have the six month PC checks and line check as well to see if you are performing to standards. I know of NO other profession such as doctors, lawyers, or others who go through such a process.

I sort of assumed that you would understand that I was refering to REVENUE flights when I said what I could fly or not. There is not a whole lot of demand for pilots to fly airplanes around when they are NOT making any money. I can go abroad and fly the same airplanes for most foreign carriers, but they usually want their citizens to be doing that work.
I fail to see the reason why I am safe flying the same plane abroad and in the USA as long as it is for some carrier that is NOT a US one. It must be that ALPA and the FAA did a study that showed that the color of the paint scheme on a plane determines how pilots perform.

I hardly think what the rule is doing is designed to get me or others in my situation. What I have pointed out is that by keeping the rule for now, the ones who are hurt the most are the pilots who are veterans. It is clear that your husband will benefit in the coming years from the rule change which WILL happen this year or some other years down the road since the rest of the world will have 65 as the standard soon.

As for planning, all of the airlines in bankruptcy now have all terminated the pensions for their pilots. The pensions that they PLANNED on are GONE. How are they supposed to have planned for that when supposedly the pensions were guaranteed? The Akaka Amendment was supposed to give them relief by giving them full benefits at age 60 since the LAW requires them to retire at that age. That relief failed because ALPA wanted the relief, but did NOT want to accept a proviso to raise the age limit so as to lessen the impact on the PBGC. It was more important to them to molify the younger pilots than protect the pensions of the older guys. At United they went even further and took money away from the older pilots and gave it to the younger ones who don't need it now.

My point is that the pilots, who have given FAR more to our country than the current non-veterans, are hurt by events beyond our control or planning. We are asking for relief that will not cost any taxpayer money nor compromise safety. Indeed changing the rule will HELP in reducing the deficit since we will still be earning more money than the juniors who will move up AND we will NOT need to have the PBGC pay out more money if the law is changed. You and your husband will have many years to make up for any slower move to the left seat or to mainline. The pilots who are forced out now, have NO such opportunity to make up for the faults that they did not cause or could plan for. The effect is to hurt those who gave the MOST in terms of going out on strike, and going to war, in favor of those who gave the LEAST to the union and country. THAT is what I mean by screwing the veterans. 

PilotsWifeMommyof2 --- 20 years ago -

Some airlines did terminate pensions. That is exactly why we save into our own 401k account. Money goes in there from every paycheck. No matter what happens to the airline, we have money to fall back on.

And let's say they change the age to 65. So 60 year old pilots now have 5 years more. Is that really enough time to save up and prepare for retirement, again? Let's be realistic. There has to be a cutoff age somewhere - airlines aren't going to have 80 year olds flying airplanes.

I think the age 60 rule probably had the worst affect on the people who were in their late 40s and 50s when it was put into place - they had no warning that their careers would be over in a few short years.

Again, like I said before, I am sorry about your situation. I just dont know if the remedy is increasing the age limit. Maybe making sure there are some benefits put in place for those pilots, yes.

ALPA doesn't sound like it is really trying to help you guys out....from reading what you said about them not wanting to accept the proviso. I think you should start getting on them since that is the union that is supposed to support pilots. Flying for Chautauqua Airlines, did you have to be a member of ALPA? 

randyjet --- 20 years ago -

Actually in my case it will make a BIG difference since I made so little money when I was first hired at Chautauqua. If I can keep flying to age 65 as ICAO is going to allow, I will have a very good sum in the 401k plan. WE have NO retirement plan at Chautauqua. Plus I will have SS to help as well. I knew going into aviation as a second career was a crap shoot, and Hussein shot me down on getting to the majors with the First Gulf War when aviation crashed and burned for a number of years after that.

I always wanted to fly for a career, but I was discriminated against because of my size. AT the time the airlines only took military trained pilots for the most part. Since I am 6'5" tall, I was not allowed to fly military aircraft, so any career was out for the airlines. Most of the pilots who were flying when the rule was enacted had come on board the airlines right after WWII or shortly afterwards. The age of them would have been around 25 to 30 when first hired. Then they would have been around 35 to 45 at the time the rule went into effect, giving them 15 to 25 years to plan for it. ALPA then traded the age limit for the good pensions in compensation. It made NO difference to the pilots then if they had to stop at age 60 since they got near their full pay at age 60 when they retired. THAT is the reason American pilots are not concerned about the rule change and are still in favor of the age 60 rule. THEIR pensions are good for now.

Unfortunately, now that ALL the pensions for the rest of the industry are gone, ALPA still wants to keep the trade permanent when the whole basis for that trade is GONE. Thankfully, I did not have to join ALPA at Chautauqua. We have the TEAMSTERS which is supportive of me and the efforts to change the rules. 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

Well,Randyjet u could fly crop dusters, they are always looking for fresh meat. 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

Well,Randyjet u could fly crop dusters, they are always looking for fresh meat. 

randyjet --- 20 years ago -

I would LOVE to fly as an ag pilot. Unfortunately, I have to spend some big bucks to get that rating. The old days of just hopping in the plane and flying it to the field are LONG GONE. I need the FAA approval, a state license for ag operators, which involves a training course, and then practical ag ops course. I have enough taildragger time, but I still need the training. The same is true of firefighting. You need to go to a rather pricey school for your card. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground