Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Spank or not to spank?

who's talking here?

outermaga 1
GCan 1
love4bdd 9
lindagail 1
buddercup 7
Sandyr9111 1
Anderson 1
sniklefritz 1
Splendor 1
lilmommy 1
mykidsmom 2
Ducatisti 1
cowboyswife 1
caitlin 1
Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen 2
myself 1
TruthKing 2
Military Mom 1
lonesophist 1
*emily 2
Brian 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

buddercup --- 19 years ago -

Ok i am interested to see different peoples views on this topic. 

*emily --- 19 years ago -

I mostly try time outs. I have popped my oldest on the bottom a few times. I don't like to do it because I feel guilty and it doesn't really seem to help anyway. So, I don't like to do it but it has happened before... 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

I believe strongly in spanking. BUT not for every little offense. Most things children do are teachable moments not moments for spanking. My oldest was spanked about 7 or 8 times ever and he is almost 19 yr. old. and a great kid. My 6 year old has been spanked that many times in his short years.....heck, probably that many times in the last 12 months. 

love4bdd --- 19 years ago -

I liked to be spanked personally......... Thanks for asking :) 

*emily --- 19 years ago -

Most things children do are teachable moments not moments for spanking. That is a good way to put it Anderson. Not every offense warrants a little pat on the bottom. 

Ducatisti --- 19 years ago -

I liked to be spanked personally......... Thanks for asking :) tmi! 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

Yep I do...But I try NOT to of course. 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

I spanked mine when he was a toddler but when he got older, he had anger issues and also has ADHD and spanking is not effective. It just causes him to get more aggressive and violent and run his smart mouth. I have tried everything, from punishment to counseling to positive reinforcement, to negative reinforcement, and he finally seems to be growing out of it and I can reason with him. To answer your question, I am not opposed to spanking, but I think it depends on the kid and their temperament. 

buddercup --- 19 years ago -

I liked to be spanked personally......... your silly! 

love4bdd --- 19 years ago -

apparently not many things are tmi anymore on KU ~ lol 

Brian --- 19 years ago -

I liked to be spanked personally......... Thanks for asking :) OK, that's pretty funny! 

love4bdd --- 19 years ago -

well buddercup asked :) Ok i am interested to see different peoples views on this topic. SEE! 

myself --- 19 years ago -

I liked to be spanked personally......... Thanks for asking :) you silly girl! 

TruthKing --- 19 years ago -

The answer is YES but I would like to tell you who I want spanked. 

love4bdd --- 19 years ago -

hey there myself! 

caitlin --- 19 years ago -

I don't like spanking of any kind but I also believe each parent should do what they feel is right for them. 

buddercup --- 19 years ago -

OK THIS HAS TURNED A DIFFERENT DIRECTION. THATS OK! 

love4bdd --- 19 years ago -

who or what TK? I'm sorry........I had to......... :) 

Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen --- 19 years ago -

I personally like to be spanked when I'm doing my best Austin Powers. Yeah baby. Yeah. It's better to be the spankee than the spanker. Unless you're that type of person. SICKO! 

buddercup --- 19 years ago -

What confuses me is that the bible says spare the rod spoil the child but society says it is totally wrong. 

love4bdd --- 19 years ago -

How did the bible come into this??? Now I feel like a sinner,........muhuaaaahhhhh 

love4bdd --- 19 years ago -

Say it isn't so shutterman!!! 

Brian --- 19 years ago -

What confuses me is that the bible says spare the rod spoil the child but society says it is totally wrong. I don't think everybody says that but you sure hear it a lot on the media. If my kid needs a spanking, he gets one. It's certainly effective. If love4bdd deserves one, I'm sure she gets it too! 

love4bdd --- 19 years ago -

:) 

TruthKing --- 19 years ago -

repent quickly love 

buddercup --- 19 years ago -

How did the bible come into this??? Now I feel like a sinner,........muhuaaaahhhhh You sinner you. keep yalls little discussion it is funny. lol! 

love4bdd --- 19 years ago -

Ironically enough ~ I don't spank ~ well, unless it was something dangerous where they could have gotten really hurt! 

buddercup --- 19 years ago -

My 2 year old is out of control and I dont' know how to handle her. 

Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen --- 19 years ago -

Say it isn't so shutterman!!! Which part? :) 

Brian --- 19 years ago -

My 2 year old is out of control and I dont' know how to handle her. I would spank her when she disobeyed and only as a last resort. Better get 'em while they are young! 

buddercup --- 19 years ago -

I KNOW I COULDN'T EVEN IMAGINE HER AS A TEENAGER WITH HER LITTLE TEMPER. Help! 

Brian --- 19 years ago -

I just feel like a young child needs a clear defintion of who is the parent and who is the child. No debating issues. No tantrums to get your way. Not harsh by any means. Just firm. Once the rules are established early and quickly, it sure helps later. But that's only my opinion. 

lindagail --- 19 years ago -

My 2 year old is out of control and I dont' know how to handle her. Be consistant when you say something. Give her a choice to make the right decision...for example, if you want her to sit down, you could say...Annie, you have a choice, you can sit down right now by yourself or mommy will have to put you in time out. You decide." GIve her a minute and then if she does sit down, say "great choice".If she does not, put her in time. And, make her stay there even if it means you have to sit right there with her. Do not give long explainations or hold on a conversation with her while she is in time out. Simple say, "Annie, I am sorry you could not listen to mommy, now you have to sit in time out". Do not talk to her until timeout is over. I take care of 2 yr olds for a living and I can get almost every child in my class to mind me. It takes awhile but I am very consistant and they know I will follow thru with what I say. Never make the mistake of saying something you can not go thru with. 

Military Mom --- 19 years ago -

The Bible does not say 'spare the rod spoil the child', it say's "the rod is for the back of him that is void of understanding", which translates into 'beat some sense into them'. JK I do spank when absolutely necessary, but I don't like it. And thankfully, I rarely have to do it. 

outermaga --- 19 years ago -

I believe in spankings but not for little things. I try to resort to other types of discipline for littler things. 

mykidsmom --- 19 years ago -

I spank and it does not bother me. I don't understand why it should bother me. I am not abusing them and spanking always gets their attention. I am the kind of parent that believes that I should only have to tell my children 1 time to do or to stop doing something... I don't count to 3 and I don't say "please". I am the parent and what I say "goes" the first time I say it... The concequence for not listening or minding me is a good old fashioned spanking on the butt... At 4 and 5, my kids have a pretty good understanding that Mommy means business.. They on occasion will "try" me, but the end result is always the same... We as parents should not feel guilty for disciplining our kids, it should make us feel good to know that we care about how they act and it lets them know that we expect them to mind and be well behaved. 

sniklefritz --- 19 years ago -

Well said mykidsmom. I completely agree. Society's opinions and changes have gotten us where we are in the world today. Look at the disrespect and the crime rates. HERE'S YOUR SIGN! 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

I spank.... I don't have to spank very often, though.... My oldest is 9 and reasoning works better than spankings.... So, I can't remember the last spankings he's gotten. My 5 year old gets the occasional spanking for misbehaving and then there's my 15 month old....... Well let's just say he gets pops on the hands DAILY!! LOL That boy is stubborn. My older two have it pretty rough, though... They believe the school has the right to spank them... I've told them this forever. LOL They are forced to stay on their toes.... But guess what, they aren't bullies... I think I'm doing a fairly good job raising my children... Not perfect, but pretty good. 

GCan --- 19 years ago -

I'm a spanker and I'm not ashamed to admit it. And like Lilmommy...my kid thinks that the principal has my permission to spank him if he gets out of line. As a mom, I'll use whatever tactics necessary (and reasonable) to get the desired result. I do not want my boys to grow up and harm someone else's child because they weren't properly disciplined when they were younger. 

mykidsmom --- 19 years ago -

sniklefritz - Thanks... I agree too that we as a society have done away with "respect". Most of us don't even know what that means anymore. We don't require our children to respect us, therefore not only do they disrespect us as parents, they don't have any respect for their teachers or anyone else... The buck stops here with me.. I will be damned if my kids aren't going to respect me or other adults... It starts with me. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground