Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Adoption: should kids know real parents?

who's talking here?

adam 2
marthas attic 1
Melanie 3
FirePrincess 3
PilotsWifeMommyof2 2
Denise C 2
ms_mm 1
amy groze 1
Lilteapot 2
Mary C 1
Stephanie 1
buzzingo 1
planemom 4
Anderson 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

adam (Wizard) --- 20 years ago -

Our friends have five adopted kids, and we were talking tonight. Should adopted children have the right to know their biological parents? 

Denise C --- 20 years ago -

yes 

planemom --- 20 years ago -

That is such a tough question. This is one of those questions that unless you know all the circumstances its hard to answer. 

adam (Wizard) --- 20 years ago -

yes such a short answer from a large, wise brain....need more details!! :-) 

planemom --- 20 years ago -

By right to know do you mean they could find the bio parent even if they didn't want them to? 

planemom --- 20 years ago -

If the bio. parents want a closed adoption the child shouldn't be able to find them. 

ms_mm --- 20 years ago -

I would say that it would have to be based on the situation. I had a student last semester that had such hatred and contempt for his biological mother that I don't think it would be good for them to meet. 

buzzingo --- 20 years ago -

My cousins are all adopted. Some wanted to meet their real parents, and were encouraged by aunt/uncle to do so once they were older and could deal with it. Others didn't want anything to do with the subject. The oldest chickened out. I guess parents should show support when they're old enough, but not push it. 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 20 years ago -

I'm adopted and I think once the child is of age it is their right. My parents were always open and honest about my adoption, I think the only thing I have interest in and I think should be made available to all adopted children is medical history of the bio family. 

Denise C --- 20 years ago -

My brain is tired..but here goes. I have met many adopted older children as well as younger. One young lady I worked with didn't even know her actual birthday because she was abandoned. She said it was so hard on her growing up. She wouldn't even date american guys because she said it grossed her out to think if she dated american it might be her brother. Another woman I know adopted her son when he was a baby (open) and when he was 12 he started wanting to know his birth mother. She let him go but it was horrible so she regretted it. I think I would want to know simply because I would want family history etc. 

amy groze --- 20 years ago -

i had a friend that was adopted and the parents didnt tell him that he was adopeted until he was in High school come to find out his real mom lived right down the street she always had. he was so angry for them not to share this info with him he moved in with his real mom and as far as I know never forgave his adoptive parents. I also knew someone that was the oldest of three childeren and when her parents got pregnanat they gave her up for adoption at five. she finally met her real mom just to ask WHY? 

Lilteapot --- 20 years ago -

I think you should always tell the children they are adopted. When they are old enough, if they want to, they can choose to look for their birth parents or not. Honesty and an open communication is the way to go with raising any kid! Everyone wants to know where they come from, so be honest from the start. 

planemom --- 20 years ago -

Unless it's an open adoption I don't think the child or bio. parents should communicate until the child is an adult or close to it. Too many problems can arise if earlier communication is allowed. I agree with knowing the medical history. 

Melanie --- 20 years ago -

Adam here it is from someone who knows. I am 1 of 5 adopted children, from different families, different nationalities. We were all told when we were able to understand that we were adopted. We had such great parents that none of us have chosen to seek our bio parents out. I have ALWAYS wondered what it would be like, but no one, no matter who they are could ever replace MY parents. My parents have since passed away & I still wonder about my bio parents, especially for medical reasons, for my daughters & grandkids. I will always be grateful to my parents for "choosing" me & my other brothers & sisters when there are so many kids in this world that need a home. Just my 2 cents! 

Lilteapot --- 20 years ago -

planemom: I meant communication between the adoptive parents and children, NOT the birth parents. 

FirePrincess --- 20 years ago -

My husband is adopted and he seeked out his birth parents when he was 21. It's not that the kids want a relationship or want to replace their adoptive parents. It's just curiosity. He met his birth mother and father once and never had a desire to see them again. 

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

I think you should tell them the truth about being adopted and let them decide one day on their own. I think they will respect their parents much more for that later in life. Although, it may be harder to let little kids adopted from another country know who their real parents are... 

Melanie --- 20 years ago -

Of course you're curious & I still am but they could easily seek me out too & have chosen not to. I have my parents & my brothers & sisters, what else is there? 

PilotsWifeMommyof2 --- 20 years ago -

I am adopted. My parents adopted me when I was 2 months and 1 day old. They are the only parents I know - I am extremely blessed to have been raised by them. I know very little about my birth mom and her family, but I would not have had a very good upbringing - not very educated, no goals in life, etc... But, I do want to know her. I have been looking for several years now. She is looking for me, I found it out through the adoption agency. But the agency wants $700 to make contact with her and that is something we don't have right now. I don't think it is fair for someone to tell me I can't know where I come from. Does it mean I want her in my life as an active member? No way. She would be an acquaintance. I want to know the circumstances, what happened, did she think of me, and MOST important, I need to tell her Thank You! Thank you because she could have had an abortion and not carried me for 9 months and gone through labor. Thank you for thinking more of me than herself, making herself go through heartache to give me a better life that she knew she couldn't provide. I could go on and on. LOL Denise and Jessica know.... 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

It would all depend on why the parents relinquished their parental rights. I have an 8 yr.old cousin visiting me right now...he has been here a week and a half. I would love to KEEP him. He is smart, polite and eager to learn whatever he doesn't know. Both of his parents are in jail. The grandmother is raising him and his 10yr.old sister. Grandmother is getting old and going blind from her diabetes. Anyways....I would love find these kids another home. Mine would be great...but probably need someone else so as to completely remove them from that side of my family. So when the mother and father are released they can't just wander over. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

BTW adam, I was speaking to that family (if it's the same one at a swim meet).... ...I'd like to know what agency they went through---she told me but I forget. 

FirePrincess --- 20 years ago -

Anderson's comment made me realize I wasn't clear. I believe every "child" has the right to seek out their birth parents, but I believe it should not happen until they are adults. I don't think the circumstances are ever "good" when a child is given up for adoption. If it happens before then, it's likely to cause problems. 

PilotsWifeMommyof2 --- 20 years ago -

Typically you can't search until you are an adult. Through Children's Home Society (the adoption agency that was used for me) the child has to be 18 to start searching on their own. If the biological parents want to search for their placed child, they have to wait until the child is 21. That is when my bmom started looking for me. So frustrating! And yes, I agree on the situation. 

FirePrincess --- 20 years ago -

My husband's adoption was different. The birth mother lived with his parents until she gave birth. She had him and he was handed to his adoptive mom. They always knew how to contact them but he didn't ask until he was 21. He went to court to get his records opened but the judge refused. He was hoping to do it without his parents knowing, but he had to tell them anyway since he had no other choice. I wasn't sure if Adam's friend's kids were grown or not. 

Mary C --- 20 years ago -

Children should be told at a young age that they are adopted. I'm not sure it is a "right" to know your birth parents, but some choose to and some choose not to. I met my birth mother and wouldn't give up that experience for anything. I had great adoptive parents and they will always be my parents, but meeting your birth parents has nothing to do with them, it has everything to do with understanding who you are. JMO 

Melanie --- 20 years ago -

It would all depend on why the parents relinquished their parental rights. What happens if you don't know why? I don't. I'm very glad my parents told me & didn't wait until I was an adult. It would be kinda strange when I all of a sudden I got a "new" baby brother or sister & they were already 4 or 5. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

adoption
biological parents


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground