Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

It Could Save Your Child's Life

who's talking here?

Mabel 5
Paige 5
Momoftwo 16
MomofTwins 5
momba 6
Scottie's Hottie 9
cmi 3
I Love Horses 6
buddercup 2
crazyfun2baround 1
ambergris 1
SVloves 3
lilmommy 1
Pixel Giggles 2
SS (SmilingSurvivor) 10
HFD Family 3
cowboyswife 1
BrookleighPhotography 2
Mygirl01 17

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Mabel --- 19 years ago -

My DIL Has been looking for a new carseat for my grandson, and look what she found undefined  

Mabel --- 19 years ago -

link title 

Mabel --- 19 years ago -

undefined 

momba --- 19 years ago -

So, the Britax 5 point harness is unsafe? How? 

cmi --- 19 years ago -

I think it's the other way around. The 5 point harness is safe, boosters are not. 

SS (SmilingSurvivor) --- 19 years ago -

OMG, that was one beautiful little girl, SO SAD THAT SHE IS GONE. "A" is staying in a 5 point harness until he is 18 years old, LOL, j/k ;) 

Mabel --- 19 years ago -

It's not unsafe, but it got you to open and read this thread. People seem to pass up good info. for unknown reasons. Just wanted to make sure everyone child is safe. 

cmi --- 19 years ago -

Yeah, b/c noone would open the thread to save our child's life....just being a smartalec. 

momba --- 19 years ago -

Oh, the title changed. I was confused. It's a tough call. How long do you keep them in a 5 point harness? and when is it safe to use a booster. 

Mabel --- 19 years ago -

no hoping there where not mice all over this thread. 

SS (SmilingSurvivor) --- 19 years ago -

It's a tough call. How long do you keep them in a 5 point harness? and I would go by the weight & height suggestions myself. Which the ones that I have purchased for my ds in the past have 5 point harness capabilities up to 80 lbs. 

cmi --- 19 years ago -

I would use the harness until my kids no longer fit. But, I'm also the one that kept my kids rear-facing until their legs were too long. 

SS (SmilingSurvivor) --- 19 years ago -

I would use the harness until my kids no longer fit. But, I'm also the one that kept my kids rear-facing until their legs were too long. diddo, lol ;) 

momba --- 19 years ago -

Well, the one I had I was hurting (he's a boy) every time I buckled him. He is going to be 5 and is a pretty big boy. I'm just conflicted about the whole thing. 

SS (SmilingSurvivor) --- 19 years ago -

momba, how much does he weigh? 

I Love Horses --- 19 years ago -

I bought this one for our 2 1/2 year old and it holds kids up to 100lbs. 

I Love Horses --- 19 years ago -

Graco 5 point booster seat! 

momba --- 19 years ago -

Not sure maybe close to 50. pretty tall. 

momba --- 19 years ago -

But 100? That is my 10 year old in a car seat? 

I Love Horses --- 19 years ago -

My 2 1/2 year old is over 40lbs and he isnt fat just tall and solid! 

I Love Horses --- 19 years ago -

we had a britax roundabout and had to switch to this one. 

crazyfun2baround --- 19 years ago -

I took my car seat in when my dd was first born to the fire station. They said it was fine. They looked over at my ds who was 6 at the time. They told me that due to his height and weight (skinny), he should still be in some type of restraint. That they saw too many kids his size slide under a regular seatbelt. I think he was in a booster, at least, until he was 8. His friends use to make fun of him. My reply back was "I love my child and don't want any harm done to him. If it means he has to sit in a booster a little longer, it is my choice, not his". That would get them quiet, very quickly. Protect your children, is all I have to say!! 

ambergris --- 19 years ago -

Well, the one I had I was hurting (he's a boy) every time I buckled him. He is going to be 5 and is a pretty big boy. I'm just conflicted about the whole thing. I have a soon to be 5 year old too and he is right at 50lbs. I moved him to a booster recently because he just wasn't fitting in the bigger size carseat. He's a little big for his age while I have an 11 year old that doesn't even weigh 80lbs yet. 

BrookleighPhotography --- 19 years ago -

Heres another one that was posted awhile back on here i cryed for an hour atleast and sent it to everyone i know. This is so extremly sad. I still have it posted on my myspace!! 

momba --- 19 years ago -

I have seen that one. And I cried as well. Very heartbreaking. Didn't the car's seat belt fail in that accident? 

BrookleighPhotography --- 19 years ago -

Yes it did :( 

SS (SmilingSurvivor) --- 19 years ago -

OK, I am screwed, lol. Because I misunderstood when I bought this recent carseat for my ds it said up to 80 lbs. Well that is when used as a booster. And all of this has made me research further. I NEED 5 point harness seat that will hold up to 80-100lbs used AS A 5 POINT HARNESS, not converted into a booster after 40 lbs. Any suggestions?! Thank you so much for this post Harpo, seriously! 

SS (SmilingSurvivor) --- 19 years ago -

Okay I just looked on the NHTSA website and the ONLY 5 point harnest that was listed to hold kids OVER 40 lbs as a 5 POINT HARNESS, not converted to a booster was the SAFETY 1ST APEX 65. Here is the link if you guys are interested. NHTSA LINK 

I Love Horses --- 19 years ago -

I have seen a 5 point harness that you can attach to you seat belt for a child at babies r us. 

SS (SmilingSurvivor) --- 19 years ago -

okay, so I have been doing some research trying to find out what is the best option for my ds to be as safe as possible and now I am even more confused, lol ;) Because I just looked on the TXDPS website and it actually recommends that children over 40lbs be seated in a belt positioning booster. Yet the two videos say 5 point harness. Who is right in your opinion, TXDPS or the videos of those who have experienced loss?! Seriousy?! I mean obviously I am not going to base my decision on the safest option for my son off of KU's opinions, lol (just to clarify, no offense intended) I am just trying to get as much input as possible. This is the link to txdps if interested: txdps car seat recommendations 

SS (SmilingSurvivor) --- 19 years ago -

okay, so I just watched a video from TXDPS, it was quite informative, you all should watch it if you have a minute to do so. Here are some of the statistics, etc, that it stated: 87% of car seats in cars have installation mistakes 8 out of 10 safety seats have installation mistakes motor vehicle crashes leading cause of death in children 1,765 deaths under age 15 272,000 injuries annually replace safety seat if it is older than six years or- involved in a crash Here is the link to the page with the video on it if you are interested: TXDPS car seat safety video 

Momoftwo --- 19 years ago -

I have done alot of researching over the last 5 years and have learned alot, been confused alot :) The reason there are so many errors and accidents involving carseats is b/c of user error. It's difficult to chose a seat and install it correctly. It makes me crazy to be in Walmart, see someone spend 10 minutes looking at a carseat and buy it. I spend hours LITERALLY before I buy a seat. There have been a few threads here b/t Momtotwins and regarding carseats. She has alot of knowledge. With that, I think a 5 pt harness IS the best way to go vs a seat belt positioned booster. My dd is 5, 44 inches and 41 lbs. She is now too big for her Evenflo Comfort Touch 5 pt harness. After much searching, I did order the Britax Regent (NOT b/c of the video...I was on the hunt for a seat before that). I just installed it today. I will more than likely only use it for my dd for another year or so, then pass it to my "large" son. When my dd is mature enough to stay seats completely upright in a booster (no sleeping, bending down to reach for stuff, etc) then I will more her to a seat belt booster. She is in one now when she ride in DH's car and I make sure to keep my eye on her at all times. She is a very mature 5 year old, but she likes to nap occassionaly in her seat and she is constantly pulling on the seat belt and trying to put it behind her. I make sure now to pull the slack and make the belt "lock" in place, so she cannot put the belt in a different position. SS, I remember talking about all of this awhile back when you were searching for a seat. I still think the Britax Marathon or FP version (heck, the name is slipping from me...and I don't have time to look it up) is the best bet for your son right now. He is too young for a seat belt, in my opinion. I don't car what the TXDPS says :) I will keep mine in a harness past 40 lbs, even though they are tall. I just feel safer that way. 

SS (SmilingSurvivor) --- 19 years ago -

I will keep mine in a harness past 40 lbs, even though they are tall. GOD I HOPE I don't offend you by saying this, but, a very good point was made through a pm to me about the 5 point harness past 40lbs, do you think that they may not be strong enough to keep the child secured? I am just wondering why the majority of the carseats say that over 40lbs should be used as a booster. I just had a thought................My son is only 27lbs right now, LOL, I have 13lbs to go until I have to get all the info, so really he is good to go right now.....so I am gonna just chill on the researching that right now ;) And hope you guys have figured it out by the time he is 40lbs!!!!!!!!! ROFL! 

Momoftwo --- 19 years ago -

My 2 1/2 year old is over 40lbs and he isnt fat just tall and solid! Angela1978...the 5 pt harness is only good for up to 40 lbs. If you son is over 40 lbs, he can only use the seat you posted the link to in a seat belt booster position (meaning you have to remove the harness and use the seat belt). That is the info that people miss when buying harness boosters. Most are NOT good for over 40 lbs with a harness. It's hard to find seats taht harness for heavier kids. Trust me, they are out there though if you look hard enoug :) Also, if your son's ears are highter than the seat or his shoulders are above the harness slot...he's too tall. BUT, it sounds like if he is over 40lbs, he's past the weight restriction. Sorry if I sound mean :) Not my intention at all! 

Momoftwo --- 19 years ago -

GOD I HOPE I don't offend you by saying this, but, a very good point was made through a pm to me about the 5 point harness past 40lbs, do you think that they may not be strong enough to keep the child secured? Since carseats are tested, I am sure they are strong enough to hold the weight limit they list. If they say harnessed up to 100 lbs, they have been tested to do so (I assume, anyway. lol). For the seats that say up to 40 lbs, that's the limit. I wouldn't trust the harness higher. 

SVloves --- 19 years ago -

After I saw this video a while back I bought my dd the Britax 5 point harness carseat. It holds up to 100 pounds. I love it and so does she. It was expensive ($269) but well worth it. 

SS (SmilingSurvivor) --- 19 years ago -

If they say harnessed up to 100 lbs, they have been tested to do so (I assume, anyway. lol). I agree, however, like I said, I have only found one so far in all of the research that I have done online that says it is safe used as a 5pt harness up to 65lbs. and that was the SAFETY 1ST APEX. All the others that I have looked at are safe to use w/ the 5pt harness UP TO 40lbs, but ONLY AS A BOOSTER over 40lbs and I misunderstood until today, bc I always assumed that when they said safe up to 80-100lbs, that meant as a 5 point harness, but IT DOES NOT mean that, it means that they are safe as a 5pt UP TO 40lbs AND AS A BOOSTER over 40lbs. And I stated that "God I hope I don't offend you" comment, in response to what I quoted, where it was said: I will keep mine in a harness past 40 lbs, even though they are tall I am just confused, I am sure I am missing something here, lol! I dunno! 

Paige --- 19 years ago -

SVLoves- isn't that seat great! My boys both have them and I wish I could sit in one LOL!~ My husband calls them, "The Recliners." 

Paige --- 19 years ago -

Smiling- The Britax Husky or The Britax Regent are safe as 5 point harnesses up to 80 pounds. They cannot be used as seat belt boosters. Just another to look at :-) 

Momoftwo --- 19 years ago -

And I stated that "God I hope I don't offend you" comment, in response to what I quoted, where it was said: I will keep mine in a harness past 40 lbs, even though they are tall I am just confused, I am sure I am missing something here, lol! I dunno Okay, I am sleep deprived, so I am clueless :) Maybe I am missing something. No offense taken at all. I was just saying that even though my kids are tall and could move to a seatbelt booster, I will keep them harnessed as long as possible b/c I think it's best. Alot of mom's I visit with seem to think since their kids are tall and 40 lbs, they are just as safe in a seatbelt booster. Maybe they are, but for my peace of mind...I like to know my dd is positioned properly in a harness. Too much lead way for error wiht a seatbelt, I think. The belt has to hit a child in the right places to protect them. There are actually a few other seats that harness for heigher weights. A few that come to mind are the Sunshine Kids Radian 65 and 80, The Apex you mentioned and the Safeguard Go. Okay, son that is making me sleep deprived is screaming. He's 2! ugh. And sick :( 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
parenting


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground