Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Is Man's Free Will Limited?

who's talking here?

adam 2
blessed 1
ACwife 20
bbjones 20
planemom 1
Anderson 1
Hardshell 7
sharky 1
JDaddy 1
qpc 1
AuthorMan 1
Tyrus 1
isnthatnice 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

No...but He will "allow" things to happen...and still, His will will prevail. I do not feel that our "free will" is limited. God's ultimate WILL for mankind does prevail, eventhough, His WILL for us individually does not. It is God's Will for ALL to be saved, however, because of man's free will that will not happen. 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

A pastor once said it like this: If God wants something done it'll get done with our without my help. If I exercise my free will by not helping, God will find someone else who is willing to help. 

ACwife --- 19 years ago -

His WILL for us individually does not So then God isn't in control? If it were God's will for us ALL to be saved then we WOULD all be saved. God isn't just a helpless, powerless being sitting up there waiting for us to make all of the decisions. I believe in a Triune God...which includes the Holy Spirit...who DRAWS us to him. Salvation is based on faith alone through grace alone. If there were ONE SINGLE thing that we had to do to EARN our salvation, then it would be based on works not faith...surely you don't believe that your salvation is based on works, do you? Yes, we have to believe; who makes us believe? God. Why do we believe? Because He wills it. Even our FAITH is a gift from God. 

ACwife --- 19 years ago -

God will find someone else who is willing to help. True, but the the facts are... IF God doesn't want someone else to do it...He wants you to...and that's just the way it is...He will prevail in your life...circumstances will happen to make you go on the path he wants you to....you may vere off, but the path still ends up where He wants it to. Moses didn't want to lead the Israelites out of Egypt...BUT HE DID. Noah didn't want to go to Ninevah...BUT HE DID. WHY? Because they were the people He chose and He wouldn't have it any other way. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

So then God isn't in control? If it were God's will for us ALL to be saved then we WOULD all be saved. God is in control, but because He gave us free will, he ALLOWS things to happen. Not only does man possess free will, but he can actually exercise his free will in a way that defies God's will. In other words, although God is Sovereign, He does not always get everything He wants. In 2 Peter 3:9, it is plainly stated that God is "not willing that any should perish but that all should come to repentance." God's Will can be rejected and it is every day. Is it His Will for babies to be aborted, or people murdered, etc.? No, it is not, but they happen. God does not make us believe, however, God does plead with mankind to obey His preceptive will so they can be saved. God reveals to us in 1 Timothy 2:4 that He "desires all men to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth." However, some reject His plea. Salvation is not by works. We do nothing to EARN our salvation, but we must accept His free gift to obtain salvation. 

adam (Wizard) --- 19 years ago -

God does not make us believe That brings up a good question. Can God change our heart if we don't want him to? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

That brings up a good question. Can God change our heart if we don't want him to? He will do thngs that can influence our heart to change. 

adam (Wizard) --- 19 years ago -

things that "can"? or things that "will" ? 

AuthorMan --- 19 years ago -

Things meant to be will always find a way. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

things that "can"? or things that "will" ? Can 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Right on Steve! 

blessed --- 19 years ago -

My biggest issue with Calvinist's are that they get most of their information from other books rather than just seeing what the bible says so clearly. I see it in everyone of my friends who believe these views. It's like they are trained to see the bible differently from outside sources. Just an observation...... Not that I don't read other materials that encourage my walk..... 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

adam, "Can God change our heart if we don't want him to?" WHy not....in scripture many times it mentions that God had hardened someones heart. 

Hardshell --- 19 years ago -

The belief in a totally "free" human will is inconsistent with the existence of God, because a man's free will would undetermine and contradict the very attributes that define God. If a man is free to determine anything, how could God possibly have perfect knowledge? He couldn't, because the future would not be an absolute, but a vast array of possibilities that would not become determined until man exercised his "free will". God would not have Divine Foreknowledge if men were free, for there would be nothing definite to foreknow. But there is a God, and His attributes are perfect, and He has "declared the end from the beginning, and from ancient times the things which are not yet done", thus He has perfect Foreknowledge of all things. Can anyone show me from the scriptures that man is free to will and act contrary to how God knows he will "will" and act? Can anything come to pass contrary to the perfect foreknowledge of God? Let's not jump to the subject of God's government, or Predestination, or anything causative on the part of God......just consider His perfect knowledge. Is man free to will or act contrary to how God knows he will "will" or act? Is man ever going to surprise God? I know that I am taking a very broad scope with this topic, so before stating one scripture after another one, I'll just ask some questions on a very personal level. There are many on here that will defend a person's "free will" inspite of the obvious, so let's even take the Divine perspective out of the equation for a moment. Have you ever "willed" to love a man/woman that you honestly did not love? Has anyone ever "willed" to save a failed marriage, when the spouse' affections are elsewhere? How about parenthood? Take for example the loving, caring, expectant mother who "wills" to have a happy, healthy child. She visits her doctor, and performs all of the prescribed actions as in eating healty, taking supplements, exercises, etc. only to give birth to a mentally retarted child, or worse yet, gives birth to a dead baby? What went with her free will? How about the man that struggles daily to provide support for his family, yet meets with difficulties and roadblocks all along the way. Despite his "will", he is never able to raise his children out of poverty, and eventually dies a pauper. For those who truly believe that they have freewill.......have you ever had a headache, toothache, inflammed hemorroid? Why????? How about those that are genetically predisposed to suffer some terrible health problems. Did they have a free will concerning this situation? What about your own beliefs, religious or otherwise....... Can you exercise your freewill and believe something that you honestly do not believe? My father passed away on December 16th, only weeks after the birth of his youngest and last grandchild. Even though he looked forward to knowing and enjoying this child, his body was just worn out, and no amount of medical treatment helped. Should he have just "willed" that he would live another 5 years? I know that he did have the will and reason to live longer. So am I supposed to believe that his will was free? Obviously not. But let's get back to the meat of the issue. Can man and God both have free will? No,.....one of these "wills" must be subservient. Does God's will ever become subservient to the will of man? What do the scriptures say? "He (God) doeth according to His own will in the army of heaven and among the inhabitants of the earth, and NONE CAN STAY HIS HAND, OR SAY, WHAT DOEST THOU? Daniel 4.35 "He (God) is of one mind, who can turn Him? and what His soul desireth, THAT HE DOETH"....not might doeth if allowed by man! Job 23.13 "He worketh all things after the counsel of His own will," Ephesian 1.11 "He doeth whatsoever He pleaseth," Psalm 115.3 .....and He does not change, "I am God, and I change not", Malachi 3.6, and with Him there is no "variableness nor shadow of turning" James 1.17, therefore "He is the same yesterday, today, and for ever." Hebrews 13.8 But what about a man's belief in Christ? Does any man have the "freedom" of will to approach Christ in a salvific manner, or can man, of his own will, believe in Christ? "No man can come unto me, except it were given unto him of my Father." John 6.65 Wouldn't the freewill choice of believing in Christ be a righteous work? Yet we're told that "There is none righteous, no not one: There is none that understandeth, there is none that seeketh after God. They are all gone out of the way, they are together become unprofitable; there is none that doeth good, no not one," Romans 3.10ff "For all have sinned and come short of the glory of God," Romans 3.23. So is it within the realm of man's freewill to choose to believe in Christ or is his belief determined by a higher WILL? Just how does man believe in Christ? "His arm shall be revealed to make sinners believe the report of Christ crucified" John 12.37ff "He will draw sinners to Christ" John 6.44ff "He will fulfill the good pleasure of His goodness, and the work of faith, with power," II Thess. 1.11 "He (God) worketh in them both to will and to do of his good pleasure". God's "work" here is not an external offer, but an internal work, (i.e. "in them"), an effectual work that effects and affects, man's will. Steve has mentioned here, and in past topics, that men are not automatons....In other words, he does not believe that they are puppets in the hand of God. I think the following passage helps to define my position......."Thy people shall be willing in the day of thy power," Psalms 110.3 But this willingness is of the Lord! Concerning the Will of God, I have mentioned several scriptures that EXPLICITLY state my position that God's will is supreme and absolute over the will of man. Can anyone provide scriptures that EXPLICITLY state that God ever refrains from being God, or that He ever relinquishes His Sovereignty to man? Especially in the area of salvation? 

ACwife --- 19 years ago -

Sorry...just returned...let me try and catch up :) In 2 Peter 3:9, it is plainly stated that God is "not willing that any should perish but that all should come to repentance." You spoke earlier in the other thread about the "context" of the verse...2 Pet 1:1 clearly states who Peter is speaking to...Simon Peter, a bondservant and apostle of Jesus Christ, To those who have obtained like precious faith with us by the righteousness of our God and Savior Jesus Christ: God reveals to us in 1 Timothy 2:4 that He "desires all men to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth This does not mean that God sovereignly wills "every human being" to be saved, but rather "all types of people" ie...Jews and Gentiles, kings and servants, etc. In other words, although God is Sovereign, He does not always get everything He wants. You make God sound powerless. That's scary. Yes, man can and does choose to sin, but God's effectual call in the end will prevail in that person's life if God has chosen them. Please give me one scriptural reference where God failed. but we must accept His free gift to obtain salvation. What makes us accept the gift? Do we just wake up one day and decide to become a Christian? ABSOLUTELY NOT! All throughout history and including myself...God chooses some of the worst sinners...do you really think that in all our sin that we would wake up and choose a Holy God without some sort of "drawing" from the Spirit? Read Romans ch. 9 That brings up a good question. Can God change our heart if we don't want him to? Absolutely and God be thanked for it because we CERTAINLY couldn't change our heart on our own... John 6:44 No one can come to Me unless the Father who sent me draws him. things that "can"? or things that "will" ? will...His call is always effectual to His elect. God ALWAYS accomplishes what he intends to accomplish. After all God IS God! Where is there glory in "Making your children love you" He doesn't drag us kicking and screaming to "make" us love him. His Holy Spirit "draws" us to him through his grace and love. Of course we want our children to choose to love us, but aren't there things that we do as parents to create that love...that bond? OF COURSE! My biggest issue with Calvinist's are that they get most of their information from other books rather than just seeing what the bible says so clearly Then you obviously haven't read where the Bible so CLEARLY talks about God's elect and God's sovereignty. What outside sources are you referring to? Everything we believe is Bible-based...soley on scripture. Not that I don't read other materials that encourage my walk..... So then what are you saying? You can read other materials to gain knowledge of scripture but we can't? It's called educating yourself and learning history...not just reading "feel good" books. The doctrine referred to as "Calvinism" did not begin with John Calvin...it is seen throughout the pages of the Old and New Testaments, clearly affirmed by the Apostolic Fathers, St. Augustine (414 AD), Martin Luther (1517), John Huff...the point is that there is a historical continuity...note that this doctrine was never condemned as heretical by the church...unlike Palageanism, semi-Pelagianism, and Armenianism. Unfortunately the majority of churches today affirm the very Armenianism that was condemned by the church as herecy. There inlies the importance of knowing history...if we don't know it, we're doomed to repeat it. In America we are led to believe and want to believe that we control EVERYTHING. That is why Armenianism is so popular. Now I know that you fear God, because you have not withheld from me your son, your only son." How do you explain that underlined phrase if Abraham did not have a choice in the matter? How could God "not know" what Abraham would choose, IF God willed it to work out that way? Noone said he didn't have a choice..again, God does not choose to control our every action. If you really think that God didn't "KNOW" Abraham was faithful, I feel bad for you. The whole of scripture testifies of God's omniscience. 

ACwife --- 19 years ago -

by the way, I noticed a typo...earlier, I meant Jonah, not Noah :) 

ACwife --- 19 years ago -

I have to go, but will be back to respond to any other questions or comments :) 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Hardshell, your concept of free will is flawed. Free will involves making a choice with YOUR mind, NOT willing your dying body to continue to live, or willing your spouse not to divorce you (that would be taking away her free will), or willing that your baby would not be born mentally retarded. Those are out of YOUR control. What is in YOUR control is YOUR own actions, such as YOUR decision to accept God's free gift of salvation or to reject it. 

isnthatnice --- 19 years ago -

Question.....Is God all knowing? If he is all knowing then how can it be considered freewill? I don't get it. Do we really have a choice? 

Hardshell --- 19 years ago -

Hardshell, your concept of free will is flawed. BB, You are correct in pointing out that my scope encompassed more than the individual's will, but that was the point. My concept is not flawed, as I have used examples to show the human will as being limited in every aspect of our lives versus the unlimited power of the will of God. This is an inevitable problem when we are discussing "will" without regards to the term "action". Even if we restrict our discussions to our own will and action, your critique does not answer any of the items that I've mentioned with relationship to the existence and knowledge of God and the contradiction that a human freewill causes. Even in the area of faith, I have to go back and quote the passage from Psalms "Thy people shall be willing in the day of thy power,". This definitive prophecy could not have been made, if it was contingent on the "freewill" of men who were not yet born. Maybe it was just a shot in the dark??? 

Hardshell --- 19 years ago -

Steve, Isn't the case of Abraham that you've mentioned a perfect picture of "trying" faith? It wasn't done to prove anything to God, but to "try" Abraham and prove the strength of faith. Do not forget that a promise had been made to Abraham prior to this occasion...."In Isaac shall thy seed be called". I would call this a "trying" of faith, because it took faith for Abraham to attempt to slay this child in whom his "seed" was promised. It proved that Abraham had faith that God could bring Isaac back from the dead, which is symbol of the Lord Jesus Christ. Without faith Abraham would not have been willing to attempt to kill Isaac. Where did Abraham's faith come from? From God, so it makes no sense in arguing over whether or not that faith, which was given by God, was sufficient for God's purposes, and that God had to run an experiment to find out, "For the Lord knoweth the way of the righteous:" Ps. 1:6......... As for the language "Now I know", there is at least one Jewish talmudist, Saadiah Gaon, that translates this passage as "I have made known", that is, to others. It's certainly an interesting verse to research, but do I feel that it undermines the perfect knowledge of God? No........ Do I think that Abraham had a will in the matter? Yes, but instead his own will, he was tried by faith to slay Isaac, which is not something that he would have been willing to do. I can't help but repeat, "Thy people shall be willing in the day of thy power." 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Yes, but instead, he was tried by faith to slay Isaac, which is not something that he would have been willing to do. Abraham WAS willing to slay his son because he had faith in God and who God was. But He was willing to do so because he made a "free will" choice to do so. I can't help but repeat "Thy people shall be willing in the day of thy power. Those people are willing because this is a promise concerning Christ and His people - people who have ALREADY used their "free will" to accept the gift of salvation. 

Hardshell --- 19 years ago -

I do not feel that our "free will" is limited Since you believe that there are no limitations to human "freewill", why don't you cease from being a sinner for the remainder of your life? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

why don't you cease from being a sinner for the remainder of your life? Because sin has corrupted my mind, just as it has all of mankind, and my mind sometimes rebels. Everytime I do sin, it is a conscious decision on my part to do so. If I did not have free will, then I would not sin because, if I was always doing God's will, then how could I sin? 

ACwife --- 19 years ago -

If I did not have free will, then I would not sin because, if I was always doing God's will, then how could I sin? I think that people who question the truth in scripture are just ignorant of the doctrine...not being mean...I, too was ignorant of it until someone pointed out the TRUTH to me. The scriptures are clear. To answer your question...no one said that once we are saved we ONLY do God's will...we do have the power to make choices, but our will is secondary to God's...it's that simple...to say that God is powerless or "can't" do something or doesn't "know" something is heretical. 

ACwife --- 19 years ago -

God does not individually create each person, therefore, He does not create ANYBOBY for dishonor. He can only form their responses to Him through actions of His own that will influence them to make the choices necessary to walk the right path - to walk with Him. The vessels that the Bible speaks of are the two vessels that God can form out of the totality of fallen man - vessels of wrath and vessels of mercy. this has nothing to do with their salvation. Not trying to be mean here, but you are basically calling God an ogre by saying that some people have no opportunity to be saved and have eternal life with God. Jesus died for the sins of ALL people so that ALL could be saved copied and pasted from your pm, bb...I figured we could keep it on the thread since you started this one... You say an awful lot that God "cannot"...What? Remember that you are speaking of GOD!!! Please refer to scripture in your arguments...after all, this is not a battle of opinions here...it's a search for the truth, right? The Bible says that He knows us before we are ever in the womb...he knows the number of hairs on our head...you are contradicting scripture to say that he does not make anyone for dishonour... KJV Rom 9:15,17-21 For he saith to Moses, I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I will have compassion. For the scripture saith unto Pharaoh, Even for this same purpose have I raised thee up, that I might shew my power in thee, and that my name might be declared throughout all the earth. Therefore hath he mercy on whom he will have mercy, and whom he will he hardeneth. Thou wilt say then unto me, Why doth he yet find fault? For who hath resisted his will? Nay but, O man, who are thou that repliest against God? Shall the thing formed say to him that formed it, Why hast thou made me thus? Hath not the potter power over the clay, of the same lump to make one vessel unto honour, and another unto dishonour? Romans 9:24 and 10:12 to name a couple are also affirmations of who "all people" are...he is talking about all types of people both Jews and Gentiles...all that HE CALLS. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I think that people who question the truth in scripture are just ignorant of the doctrine...not being mean...I, too was ignorant of it until someone pointed out the TRUTH to me. The scriptures are clear. I am not ignorant of the doctrine. Calvanists have taken snippets of scripture out of context. If the scriptures are clear, post them so that I can see them. to say that God is powerless or "can't" do something or doesn't "know" something is heretical. I never said that God is powerless. If I say that God can not lie, am I being heretical or or telling the truth? Where did I say can not in the quote you used in the post above? I say can not about God because He can not go against His nature, such as God can not lie. The Bible says that He knows us before we are ever in the womb...he knows the number of hairs on our head...you are contradicting scripture to say that he does not make anyone for dishonour...there are several scriptural references to back up what I said...where are yours? Knowing the number of hairs on your head or knowing us in the womb does not mean that he creates each one of us individually. As I said before, creating someone that has no chance for salvation, or even creating someone, blind, deaf, mentally retarded, etc. would make God an ogre. What do you mean, where are my scripture passages? A lot of people get mad at me for always quoting scripture. 

Hardshell --- 19 years ago -

What do you mean, where are my scripture passages? A lot of people get mad at me for always quoting scripture. It's getting late, but I wanted to post one more thing and say that you should always post the scriptural proofs regardless of what the general public thinks.......It's always good to know how those who differ on doctrinal points view specific portions of the word. Nite! 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

KJV Rom 9:15,17-21 Lets look at what that scripture is saying in context with the rest of the Bible. Paul uses the quotation about Moses from Exodus 33:19 to show us the freedom of God's mercy. Individuals can not by virtue of works or parentage insist that He give mercy to them and not to others. God is free to offer such mercy to to whomever He chooses. Verse 17 deals with Pharaoh, the ruler of Egypt who had enslaved Israel at the time of the Exodus, is an example of those who resist God - as an unbelieving Israel was now doing. He was, as Israel now is, an unwilling, unbelieving, and ungrateful witness to the truth and saving power of God. The issue is not the personal fate of Pharaoh, but how God used his opposition. Verse 18: God has mercy on some in that he allows them consciously and voluntarily to serve His purpose. Others He hardens, in the sense that they have a negative role to play, by bringing circumstances upon those people that have already resisted Him. This influence causes their hearts to harden further. In the Old Testament, while it says that God hardened Pharaoh's heart, it also says in Exodus 8:15 that Pharaoh had already hardened his own heart. Notice in Exodus 19 where God says "I will make all my goodness pass before thee". God had given Moses wonderful instances of his goodness in being reconciled to Israel, but now He was going to show him all His goodness. This was God's answer to Moses who said "shew me thy glory". God's goodness is His glory and He wants us to know him by the glory of his mercy rather than by the glory of his majesty. It is never said, "I wiil be angry at whom I will be angry," for his wrath is always just and holy, but He says "I will shew mercy on whom I will shew mercy," for His grace is always free. He NEVER damns by perogative, but by perogative He saves. Verse 19: The question is raised, if God's will can not be resisted, should a person, such as Pharaoh, then be held responsible for what that person, in fact, had no choice but to do? Verses 20-21: In verse 21, the vessels that He is speaking of are the two vessels that God can form out of the totality of fallen man - vessels of wrath and vessels of mercy. God is free to appoint people to variuos tasks for his overall place and purpose. But just as a potter is not unwise (he will make pots that sell) God has a purpose for even people like the stubborn Pharaoh and an unbelieving Isreal as He reveals in verses 22-24. Becoming vessels of wrath does not mean that they will always be so. God's patience, as shown with the Pharaoh, may indeed lead to their repentance. In Ephesians 2:3, the believers are said to have once been "children of wrath". God designs the vessels of mercy to "make known the riches of his glory". That is God's goodness, for it is His greatest glory. Romans 9:24 and 10:12 to name a couple are also affirmations of who "all people" are...he is talking about all types of people both Jews and Gentiles...all that HE CALLS. Refering to Romans 9:24 - Yes God calls EVERYONE to be saved. In verses 24-26, God has CALLED the vessels of mercy not only from among the Jews, but also from among the Gentiles. The presence of the Gentiles in the Church (the body of Christ) is His sign and pledge that the realm of rejection - Ishmael, Esau, Pharaoh and of the unbelieving Jews themselves - is not shut out from the mercy of God. Notice the passage in Romans 10:12 which states "For there is no difference between the Jew and the Greek: for the same Lord over all is rich untoall that call upon him." This verse is speaking to "all that call upon him." If you look at Romans 3:23 which states "For all have sinned, and come short of the glory of God;", the emphasis is negative. In verse 12, the emphasis is positive - all can be saved by faith. "...no difference...same Lord" - the God of the Jews is the God of the Gentiles. 

ACwife --- 19 years ago -

If the scriptures are clear, post them so that I can see them. We already have...Hardshell and I both have asked you for scriptures to back your heretical views up and you've shown none. Where did I say can not in the quote you used in the post above? I say can not about God because He can not go against His nature, such as God can not lie. True...good point, but what you are saying that God cannot do excuse me...does not do..."God does not create ANYONE for dishonour". I think this is the only point that you're having a hard time understanding and NOTHING in the scriptures I refrenced for you are taken out of context...so read and discern my friend. AGAIN, since you asked for scripture... KJV Rom 9:15,17-21 For he saith to Moses, I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I will have compassion. For the scripture saith unto Pharaoh, Even for this same purpose have I raised thee up, that I might shew my power in thee, and that my name might be declared throughout all the earth. Therefore hath he mercy on whom he will have mercy, and whom he will he hardeneth. Thou wilt say then unto me, Why doth he yet find fault? For who hath resisted his will? Nay but, O man, who are thou that repliest against God? Shall the thing formed say to him that formed it, Why hast thou made me thus? Hath not the potter power over the clay, of the same lump to make one vessel unto honour, and another unto dishonour? Romans 9:24 and 10:12 to name a couple are also affirmations of who "all people" are...he is talking about all types of people both Jews and Gentiles...all that HE CALLS. You say... God is free to offer such mercy to to whomever He chooses. EXACTLY THE POINT!!! So what's your question? 

ACwife --- 19 years ago -

those who resist God But WHY did he resist? God hardened his heart! 

ACwife --- 19 years ago -

gotta run...I'll pick up later :) 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

We already have...Hardshell and I both have asked you for scriptures to back your heretical views up and you've shown none. I have given you plenty of scriptures to show you that your views are unbiblical. I explained your scripture choice of KJV Rom 9:15,17-21 in great detail and in context with the corresponding passages in Exodus in my previous post. There is NOTHING in that passage that backs up your belief that some are born to sin and be damned and some are born to be saved. When they come to this verse, Calvinists are so brainwashed with the concept that our lives and salvation are predetermined that they immediately assume that this is just the same rather depressing truth that we are like clay in a potter's hand - just an inanimate, substance that has no will that it can exercise, that lies passively in the potter's hands so that what we become is absolutely and solely due to the Creator's will and has nothing to do with our response to His actions. This, of course, is heretical misunderstanding of the truth stated in this verse. What is the corect understanding? Well, let us look at the scripture where this parable was first used - Jeremiah 18:1-4 which says, “The word which came to Jeremiah from the LORD, saying, Arise, and go down to the potter's house, and there I will cause thee to hear my words. Then I went down to the potter's house, and, behold, he wrought a work on the wheels. And the vessel that he made of clay was marred in the hand of the potter: so he made it again another vessel, as seemed good to the potter to make it.” Since no parable is meant to be applicable in every detail and can normally be used to communicate only one main truth, Jeremiah expressed the explanation that God Himself gave of the vision in verses 5-12,“[5] Then the word of the LORD came to me, saying,[6] O house of Israel, cannot I do with you as this potter? saith the LORD. Behold, as the clay is in the potter's hand, so are ye in mine hand, O house of Israel. [7] At what instant I shall speak concerning a nation, and concerning a kingdom, to pluck up, and to pull down, and to destroy it; [8] If that nation, against whom I have pronounced, turn from their evil, I will repent of the evil that I thought to do unto them. [9] And at what instant I shall speak concerning a nation, and concerning a kingdom, to build and to plant it; [10] If it do evil in my sight, that it obey not my voice, then I will repent of the good, wherewith I said I would benefit them. [11] Now therefore go to, speak to the men of Judah, and to the inhabitants of Jerusalem, saying, Thus saith the LORD; Behold, I frame evil against you, and devise a device against you: return ye now every one from his evil way, and make your ways and your doings good. [12] And they said, There is no hope: but we will walk after our own devices, and we will every one do the imagination of his evil heart.” In other words, just as a potter is limited in what he can make of the clay by its response to his hands, so God is limited in what He can make of Israel, and of you and me, by our response to His molding. A lump of clay may appear to have a perfectly smooth consistency but as the potter works it, some particle or softness spoils the vessel being molded and the potter has to rework it into something else. So, in Jeremiah 18:7,9, God states clearly that any plans that He has for Israel or for your life and mine are totally dependent on our moral response. How does Israel respond to God? We see in verse 12 that they reply "we will walk after our own devices, and we will every one do the imagination of his evil heart.” They used their free will and refused God. You seem to be hung up on the potter reference where he takes the clay to mold vessels. That passage is NOT referring to God creating the vessel (person) in the womb, or from birth, etc. As seen in Jeremiah 18, Israel, the object of God’s parable, is already in existence – had already been born. A potter does not create the lump of clay, he only molds an existing lump of clay; therefore, God molds us by revelation, experience and circumstances into vessels for mercy or vessels for wrath dependant on our moral response to Him. Romans 9:24 and 10:12 to name a couple are also affirmations of who "all people" are...he is talking about all types of people both Jews and Gentiles...all that HE CALLS. I also explained those verses in my previous post. Refering to Romans 9:24 - Yes, God calls EVERYONE to be saved. In verses 24-26, God has CALLED the vessels of mercy not only from among the Jews, but also from among the Gentiles. The presence of the Gentiles in the Church (the body of Christ) is His sign and pledge that the realm of rejection - Ishmael, Esau, Pharaoh and of the unbelieving Jews themselves - is not shut out from the mercy of God. Notice the passage in Romans 10:12 which states "For there is no difference between the Jew and the Greek: for the same Lord over all is rich unto all that call upon him." This verse is speaking to "all that call upon him." NOT as you wrote "all that HE CALLS". If you look at Romans 3:23 which states "For all have sinned, and come short of the glory of God;", the emphasis is negative. In verse 12, the emphasis is positive - all can be saved by faith. "...no difference...same Lord" - the God of the Jews is the God of the Gentiles. You say... God is free to offer such mercy to to whomever He chooses. EXACTLY THE POINT!!! So what's your question? No question about it. God chose to extend mercy to ALL through His Son Jesus Christ. Romans 10:13 states "For whosoever shall call upon the name of the Lord shall be saved." That means ANYBODY can call upon the name of the Lord with the promise that they WILL be saved. The Bible clearly and emphatically denies Calvinism. If God is "not willing that any should perish, but that all should come to repentance," (2 Peter 3:9) then Calvinism simply cannot be true. That one verse exposes the heretical teachings of Calvinism, because God can not lie! 

ACwife --- 19 years ago -

In the Old Testament, while it says that God hardened Pharaoh's heart, it also says in Exodus 8:15 that Pharaoh had already hardened his own heart. Let's go back further to Exodus 4:21. God tells Moses that He will harden Pharoah's heart. Verse 19: The question is raised, if God's will can not be resisted, should a person, such as Pharaoh, then be held responsible for what that person, in fact, had no choice but to do? What is your explanation of verse 19? Why does God find fault? Who are we to reply against God? One other thing... CALLED the vessels of mercy not only from among the Jews, but also from among the Gentiles Who are the "vessels of mercy" you speak of if not the elect. You haven't commented at all about all of the Biblical passages that speak of God's elect. That, after all, is what we are debating here. Does God predestine His elect? No one is taking scripture out of context here...it's obvious...please give me your explanations of the following, bb. John 6:44 No one can come to Me unless the Father who sen Me draws him. Romans 3:10-18 There is none righteous, no, not one; there is none who understands; there is none who seeks after God.......... Point...if we are the ones making all of the choices with no intervention on the part of the Holy Spirit, then we are the sovereign ones...not God. We don't seek Him...He seeks us...He draws us...He elects us...as the scripture says. There is no real argument...I'm done with this. We obviously interpret scripture differently...all I can say is that it seems to me that you are a man of God, so read, pray and discern the scripture for yourself. Blessings... 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

those who resist God But WHY did he resist? God hardened his heart! It does say in the Old Testament that God hardened Pharaoh's heart, however, it also says in Exodus 8:15 that Pharaoh had already hardened his own heart. So God took that already hardened heart, one that had resisted God by not letting God's people go, and just hardened Pharaoh's heart further by revelation, experience and circumstance. 

ACwife --- 19 years ago -

It does say in the Old Testament that God hardened Pharaoh's heart, however, it also says in Exodus 8:15 that Pharaoh had already hardened his own heart. So God took that already hardened heart, one that had resisted God by not letting God's people go, and just hardened Pharaoh's heart further by revelation, experience and circumstance. See above, bb....if you go back further in Exodus 4:21, God tells Moses that HE WILL HARDEN PHAROAH'S HEART...does he not? 

ACwife --- 19 years ago -

gotta go 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

OK...I'm going to interject here with no hard and fast theology lessons or anything. A few years ago, I really looked at this issue and studied and prayed about it. This is the understanding that God led me to: 1) God is God. 2) I am not. (I think that both sides of the debate can agree on these two points, right?) The Scripture does talk about "elect" and "predestined" and ALSO talks numerous times about salvation being for "all". Because we know that Scripture is God's Word and doesn't contradict itself, the two must work together. But how? Through lots of prayer and study, God showed me that I am looking at it from a HUMAN point of view. The human mind cannot truly grasp the concept of omnipotence. It really can't. I cannot truly understand knowing everything in time and how everything will turn out. Humans also cannot truly grasp the concept of being outside of the limits of time, because that's all we know. Everything for us has a beginning and an end, but God does not exist in time where there is a beginning and an end. He created time, but He doesn't live in it. So, this is how I put all those concepts together. God DOES have an elect (because He said so) and He DOES desire that all would be saved (because He said so). There are Scriptures that talk about God hardening hearts, and there are also Scriptures that show man making decisions that go against God. In my finite understanding, I understand it to be that God knows everything that will happen and every decision I will make. He knew before creation that I would accept Christ as Savior, and because of that I am one of the elect. But, if He knew that I wouldn't accept Him, He would still have created me and loved me and desired me for His own, even though He knew I wouldn't end up choosing Him. Because He is sovereigned, He chooses to give us the power to choose Him or reject Him, however He can take that power away at any time (as he hardened Pharoh's heart). Of course, because of foreknowlege, He KNEW that Pharoh's would not accept Him. We only have free will because of God and His sovereignty that can give it to us. There is nothing that we do to "earn" salvation. It is a gift given freely to us when we accept it. I will not claim to have the exact answersto the whole mechanics of was it the Holy Spirit calling (it was) or me responding (it was). I think sometimes we get too caught up in the theology of things, and miss the really important things. I just think that our desire to know God more (which is the greatest of desires) will sometimes lead us to put God into a very human "box" because that is all we know. I truly believe that we can have a very intimate knowledge of and relationship with God, but we can never really "understand" God, and debates such as these come from trying to "understand" God. As long as we have finite minds and limited perspective (which we will always have because we are not God), we will never truly, truly understand all that God does. We can know that God is perfect and everything that He does is perfect, and simply rely on that and trust Him when we don't understand. 

ACwife --- 19 years ago -

He knew before creation that I would accept Christ as Savior, and because of that I am one of the elect. That is what the debate is about, qpc. Our society has led us to believe that WE are the ones who ultimately control everything. I do not believe that God based His elect on what we would choose...that would make US the ones in control. Do you believe that we (the elect - which you believe in) wake up one day and decide to be saved? How could we make that choice without God DRAWING us to him? You bring up very good points and I think that the true debate between Calvinists and non-Calvinists is not to UNDERSTAND God in His infinite wisdom, but it is about God's sovereignty. HE is the one who offers grace to us. He is the one who draws us to him. Imagine sinking, drowning...dead...just like we are "dead" in our sin before salvation, right? If we are dead, and God puts his hand down to save us...can we reach up and grab his hand? NO...because we are dead. It is only by the "quickening" or awakening from death that we are able to be saved from death (sin). Is that by any action of our own? No...how can we act if we are dead? God does the work in us. The point is this; if we are the ones that do the work by reaching up for his hand in our death (which is impossible), then our salvation is based on works. THAT is what the debate is about...make sense? It's not about understanding God, but about understanding how we are saved, which is important...we need to know that we are not saved by ANY form or works of our own. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Verse 19: The question is raised, if God's will can not be resisted, should a person, such as Pharaoh, then be held responsible for what that person, in fact, had no choice but to do? What is your explanation of verse 19? Why does God find fault? Who are we to reply against God? The verse does not say that God finds fault, however, God might well find fault with people who refuse to accept the terms on which salvation is offered. The salvation is great, however the terms are not hard. I answering the objection of verse 19, God reproves the objector in verse 20 "Nay but, O man," where God tells us that this is not an objection fit to be made by the object of the Creation against its Creator. Notice the contempt which which God addresses man, when he comes to argue with God his Maker - "Who art thou," that are so foolish, so incompetent a judge of divine guidance "That repiles against God". God is telling us that it becomes us to submit to Him, not to reply against Him, nor charge Him with folly. Who are the "vessels of mercy" you speak of if not the elect. They are the elect. But who are the elect? The elect are God's chosen people. Who are God's chosen people now? Jesus warned: "Many are called, but few are chosen" (Matthew 22:14; Matthew 20:16). Now that the promised Messiah has come, God's chosen people are they who accept Him as Lord and Savior: "For Moses truly said to the fathers, 'The Lord your God will raise up for you a Prophet like me from your brethren. Him you shall hear in all things, whatever He says to you. And it shall come to pass that every soul who will not hear that Prophet shall be utterly destroyed from among the people'" (Acts 3:22,23). "Even so then, at this present time there is a remnant according to the election of grace. And if by grace, then it is no longer of works; otherwise grace is no longer grace. But if it is of works, it is no longer grace; otherwise work is no longer work. What then? Israel has not obtained what it seeks; but the elect have obtained it, and the rest were hardened" (Romans 11:5-7). The election is no longer based on physical lineage, but on one's relationship with the Messiah: "He is Lord of lords and King of kings; and those who are with Him are called, chosen, and faithful" (Revelation 17:14). John6:44 "No man can come to me, except the Father which hath sent me draw him: and I will raise him up at the last day." God, not man, plays the most active role in salvation. When someone chooses to believe in Jesus Christ as Savior, he does so only in response to the urging of God's Holy Spirit. God does the urging: then we decide whether or not to believe. Therefore, no one can believe in Jesus without God's help. Romans 3:2-20 "[9] What then? are we better than they? No, in no wise: for we have before proved both Jews and Gentiles, that they are all under sin; [10] As it is written, There is none righteous, no, not one: [11] There is none that understandeth, there is none that seeketh after God. [12] They are all gone out of the way, they are together become unprofitable; there is none that doeth good, no, not one. [13] Their throat is an open sepulchre; with their tongues they have used deceit; the poison of asps is under their lips: [14] Whose mouth is full of cursing and bitterness: [15] Their feet are swift to shed blood: [16] Destruction and misery are in their ways: [17] And the way of peace have they not known: [18] There is no fear of God before their eyes. Now we know that what things soever the law saith, it saith to them who are under the law: that every mouth may be stopped, and all the world may become guilty before God. [20] Therefore by the deeds of the law there shall no flesh be justified in his sight: for by the law is the knowledge of sin." To get a better understanding of the Scripture passages, we need to include verses 9, 19, and 20. Pauls opponent has pressed him for an admission that the Jew is superior to the Gentile. Paul responds by turning to the Old Testament to demonstrate the universal fact of sin. There is no exception, no superiority. All are sinners. all are accountable before God. No one will be declared righteous. the charges made in 3:1-8 were serious, but they did not reflect an accurate understanding of God's will, as Paul shows in these verses. In verse 9, the questions of 3:1 are repeated, but now a different answer is given because Paul has a different distinction in mind. In 3:2 he admits that the Jews have an advantage over the gentiles. They have God's words. They know God's plan and God's will. however, Paul says that this does not translate into an absolute guarantee of God's favor. In verses, 10-18 Paul strings together in Rabbonic fashion, a paraphrasing of various Old testament verses drawn mainly from Psalms that put together a disturbing description of human nature. The point of these verses is clear. All people, whether they be Jew or Gentile, are under sin's power. This is seen in the fact that no one seeks God and his ways (verses 10-120; their very words condemn them(verses13-14), as do their violent ways(verses15-18). In verse 19, Paul answers one last objection in that the Jews think that the verses refer only to the Gentiles. Paul tells them no, that which is in the Old Testament is directed to those who have the Old Testament. The Jews' very advantage in verse 2 is the source of their condemnation. In having the "words of god", the Jews, of all people, should know their sin and, therefore, their guilt before God. In verse 20, Paul uses the meaning of Psalms 143:2 to close his case against them. The function of the law, rather than being a shield against god's wrath, is to make people aware of their sin. Once it has done that, its power is gone. It can not hide a person from God's action on the Day of Judgement. Point...if we are the ones making all of the choices with no intervention on the part of the Holy Spirit, then we are the sovereign ones...not God. As we make choices the Holy Spirit is giving us guidance and urging to take the right path, however, we can choose to ignore and reject. Let me ask this question. When you sin, why didn't the Holy Spirit intervene and stop you from committing that sin? Now before you answer that, think about this. If you say it was God's will for you to sin, then explain to me how god could be involved with sin? Why would He make someone sin? He would not! Please take the time to read the scripture passages again without bias and open you heart to the Holy Spirit as you read, so that the true message can be explained to you by the Holy Spirit. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground