Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Separation of Church and State

who's talking here?

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees 2
DrowningFish 4
KatieR 1
eterry2 7
RRay 1
bbjones 4
Justwatching72 13
Anderson 4
likeke27 1
Zionist NightOwl 1
Vicman 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

I wanted to bring something up to everyones attention that not everyone might be aware of ( I was not aware of this until I heard about and then did a little bit of research) There is no separation of church and state in the US constitution. It does not exist. There is the First amendment which guarantees peoples right to religion. but there is no place where it states there should be a separation of the government and religion. The 'separation of church and state' comes from a letter Thomas Jefferson wrote to the state of I want to say Connecticut, in where he was talking about the wall between church and state and basically he was saying the state(meaning the federal government), cannot come into Connecticut and tell them what religion to have). Surprised me as I always thought the Constitution said about the separation of church and state, but it doesn't. Just in the letter from Thomas Jefferson to those people. His letter is what led to the first amendment. So there can be religion in government which would make sense because most of the founding fathers were of one religion or another and they all believed in god and what he did for them especially in helping them establish their own country. I will admit it was disheartening to me to find this out, but at least now I will not use the argument 'well what about the separation of church and state when i am discussing politics and religion. Seems to me the founding fathers wanted it to be included in politics. (The president swears in on the bible.( In court you solemnly swear to tell the truth so help you god). Interesting as well that in the constitution, it has the oath the president must make to be sworn in, but it also leaves room for someone to be sworn in by not using the words 'swear' "I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will faithfully execute the office of President of the United States, and will to the best of my ability, preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of the United States." So if a person did not want to swear to god he was able to use the words affirm. Thomas Jefferson letter to the Danbury Baptists 

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees (Mod) --- 19 years ago -

Thank you! Have you seen the Law and Order episode where they discuss seperation of church and state, and Mccoy argues that its in the first ammendment of the Constitution? That episode always upset me because I knew it didn't exsist. Ok, no revelence, but I found a connection :-) 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

Right Amendment 1 - Freedom of Religion, Press, Expression Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances. It just states that they cannot make a law restricting or allowing any religion, but not anywhere does it say religion cannot be a part of the government. 

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees (Mod) --- 19 years ago -

This is completely off topic, but don't you think its sad that after 9/11, everyone bonded together and prayed to God and God was such an inspiration, and not a few months later there was a fight to take Him out of the Pledge of Allegience? I remember the whole arguement of seperation of church and state was brought up. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 19 years ago -

JW, nicely put. Thank you! 

eterry2 --- 19 years ago -

DD's looking for the "establishment clause" in the Constitution right now. hang on. 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

The establishment clause is the First Amendment. 

Vicman --- 19 years ago -

"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion" can be interpreted as that the U.S. Government may not support any religion. This debate has origins in the old "loose constructionist" and "strict constructionist" ideals of the U.S. Constitution. The former believes that the Constitution should be interpreted by its legislative intent and not by solely its actual words, while the latter believes that the U.S. Constitution should be interpreted by its words and not its legislative intent. 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

so, being they are public a.k.a government schools should have god in the pledge of allegiance. Granted I think it should be a parents choice whether or not to allow the children to say that part of of the pledge. but then again, if you choose to send your kids to public schools then you should have to abide by their rules, otherwise you can send them to private schools. I am not a fan of public schools either but thats another thread 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

or prohibiting the exercise thereof our founding fathers were making a legal and binding document , so it would stand to reason that it should be taken in that context, it's legislative intent. they were creating legislation. It just says they cannot make any law in regards to religion, either for it or against it. 

eterry2 --- 19 years ago -

When I said this to my kid, she said, that's a loophole. maybe so. (intent?) I guess that's why there's so much disagreement. There is also disagreement that some people think that omission of something in the Const. means it can be done and others think it means it cannot. 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

let me look that up, there is somewhere where it says if it is not in the constitution then it is up the the specific state to regulate it, not the federal government. What was a loophole eterry? everything the founding fathers wanted to regulate the put in the constitution, if they had wanted religion to stay out of government then they would have stated that in the constitution. 

eterry2 --- 19 years ago -

i think she meant the word "law" since I said that saying a prayer in the govt is not a law, or God on our money, etc. these things are not laws 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

true, but you have to look at it in the context of how the constitution was created. the pilgrims came over here to get away from religious prosecution. They did want to be forced into one religion by the ruling government. so they created the constitution to make sure the federal government would try the same thing that was going on in England. 

eterry2 --- 19 years ago -

true, but funny thing is that what the Puritans really wanted was freedom to have their religion. They wanted to force others to have their religion. 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

You have to look at the personal journals and letters written by the founding fathers to understand----they were Christian men and never dreamed their writings would be "interpreted" and not taken at face value of what they wrote. 

DrowningFish --- 19 years ago -

So do you believe that religion and government should be seperated? 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

I believe that the govt. should not ORDAIN a particular church as the "master" religion of our country. Meaning...the govt. should never say everyone must be Catholic or Baptist. But that does not mean that the govt. can't look to The Living God for answers in governing and in moral codes. 

DrowningFish --- 19 years ago -

Of course, we could attest the the fact that Jesus Himself was against it. "Render therefore unto Caesar the things which are Caesar's, and unto God the things that are God's." (Matthew 22:21) Darn, now I'm sounding like bbjones. But I found that interesting! :-) 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

lol...yes drowing fish.... ...but that scripture is Jesus saying to pay your taxes adn pay your tithes =) 

DrowningFish --- 19 years ago -

In England, in Medieval times, weren't Kings annointed and ordained by God Himself? From ancient history they were. I also believe that by the term "seperation of church and state" one can't take power because "God told him too." 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

in medieveal times the Monarchs themselves ordained themselves to be one with whoms gods words were to be heard. eterry: i think they just wanted to be able to practice their religion without being persecuted for it. i don't recall reading anywhere where they wanted to force everyone to be puritans. 

DrowningFish --- 19 years ago -

JW, i know this is further along in history but look at things such as the Salem witch trials. If that isn't perecution, I don't know what is. Of course, there are many other arguments that could be brought up concerning those times as well. 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

yes but that wasn't the whole country it was certain parts of the country..it was not like the entire government was forcing people to worship a certain way 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

gotta go get my leaf piles up before the KGB err i mean HOA write me a letter.. 

eterry2 --- 19 years ago -

jw, I remember reading in textbooks about american history that the Puritans (i think it was them) acted like it was "my way or the highway." I'll have to look that one up cuz it would make an interesting point if true and not well know. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

JW I am glad that you did the research for yourself. I posted that there was no separation of church and state approximately 11 days ago, but I knew that you would not believe it until you researched it yourself. Kudos to you for writing "but at least now I will not use the argument 'well what about the separation of church and state when i am discussing politics and religion. " 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

Do you realize the time span between the Puritans of the Mayflower/Salem witch hunt era and the Founding Fathers? Mayflower 1620 Witch Trials in early 1690's US Constitution written in 1780's Almost 100 years between the witch trials and the constitution....the Founding fathers were not of that generation/era----so it is not worthy of comparing the two as being simular. 

KatieR --- 19 years ago -

few months later there was a fight to take Him out of the Pledge of Allegience? I like the Pledge the way it is now, but God was added in 1954, it did not start out that way. 

eterry2 --- 19 years ago -

good point Anderson ;-) 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

bbjones, gotta be honest, did not recall reading that post of yours, i did hear about the speraration thing a few monhts ago and have been looking into since. thanks for your kudos though, though im not happy about what i discovered, nor do i believe thats the way it should be, but eh, I didn't get to create a country/government so, ill have to abide by what they decided to do. Thank you katieR, i did not realize that, still though, it is government run schools we are talking about, that means they pretty much has a say in what goes on, of course, as i said, public schools vs private schools is a different thread 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

JW Just a thought. Maybe you could put the same effort into doing Bible reading and research. You might also discover some truths that you will probably not be happy about nor believe that is the way it should be. However, I am confident, that upon that recognition, you would acknowledge the truth. Because you wrote "I didn't get to create a country/government so, ill have to abide by what they decided to do.", I believe that you would feel the same way about God. Since you did not create the universe, maybe you would abide by what God decided to do! 

RRay --- 19 years ago -

Interesting. 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

you know bb, i just cant do it. i appreciate the idea, but religion is based on faith in a higher power..and i just don't have any, nor really want too. beliefs in religion is a lot different than facts about the beginning of our country. I was under the impression that separation of church and state was in the constitution then i found out it wasn't, my mistake. Not the same thing not believing in god. It's not just christianity I don't believe in. I don't believe in any religion whatsoever. I am still going to side with the approx 75-89% of the world that believes in evolution and science. and just so you know, the only research i did on separation thing was type in 'jefferson separation church and state' and clicked on the first link. thats about as far as I went. don't want to get in a big discussion about it, but i have made myself very clear in this area. I do not want to be part of any religion whatsoever. You have made your beliefs known, thats cool, let me have mine. 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

i'm praying for you jw72 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

you are free to do as you wish, as we all are.. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I am still going to side with the approx 75-89% of the world that believes in evolution and science. If you believe in evolution, then you believe in religion because evolution is a religion. "It does not take much effort to demonstrate that evolution is not science but religion. Science, of course, involved observation, using one or more of our five senses (taste, sight, smell, hearing, touch) to gain knowledge about the world and to be able to repeat the observations. Naturally, one can only observe what exists in the present. It is an easy task to understand that no scientist was present over the suggested millions of years to witness the supposed evolutionary progression of life form the simple to the complex. No living scientists was there to observe the first life forming in some primeval sea. No living scientist was there to observe the Big Bang that is supposed to have occurred 10 or 20 billion years ago, nor the supposed formation of the earth 4.5 billion years ago (or even 10,000 years ago!). No scientists was there--no human witness was there to see these events occurring. They certainly cannot be repeated today. All the evidence a scientists has exists only in the present. All the fossils, the living animals and plants, the world, the universe--in fact, everything, exists now--in the present. The average person (including most students) is not taught that scientists have only the present and cannot deal directly with the past. Evolution is a belief system about the past based on the words of men who were not there, but who are trying to explain how all the evidence of the present (that is, fossils, animals and plants, etc.) originated. (Webster's Dictionary defines religion as follows: "... cause, principle or system of beliefs held to with ardor and faith." Surely, this is an apt description of evolution.) Evolution is a belief system--a religion!" (From the book: the Lie : Evolution by Ken Ham) 

eterry2 --- 19 years ago -

denotation? perhaps. conotation? no way. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

denotation? perhaps. conotation? no way. For what? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground