Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: What does it really do??

who's talking here?

poodle_lover 1
jbrechtel 1
Unichic 1
The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees 3
JDB2 2
MissT 1
jenihendricksphotography 2
mocha_mama 1
RRay 1
Mommee 2
bbjones 1
planemom 1
Anderson 22
CountryChick 1
gking 2
jjfingrainalready 5
Puppy again 3
Neo 16
mykidsmom 1
qpc 6
cowboyswife 4
NoNameNoLastName 2
robbie 1
CommonSense 1
Mr. Nice Guy 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: What does it really do??

Since we tend to end up in circles. I thought maybe a poll would be interesting. Does abortion kill a baby?

Always Vote
 
 80.3% (57)
Sometimes Vote
 
 11.3% (8)
Never Vote
 
 4.2% (3)
Not if done w/in 24 hrs. of conception Vote
 
 4.2% (3)
Anderson --- 19 years ago -

Since we tend to end up in circles. I thought maybe a poll would be interesting. Does abortion kill a baby?  

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

oppss...I messed up the title. LOL 

RRay --- 19 years ago -

OK........I must really be stupid here....Of course it does.....But maybe I misunderstood???? 

CommonSense --- 19 years ago -

This doesn't really address the issue in the other topic and you know it. Not everything is true/false, yes/no, black & white, and anyone who thinks otherwise is as dumb as a rock. 

MissT --- 19 years ago -

Have you ever known anyone to have an abortion and the baby live? 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

Seems like a pretty yes/no, black/white question to me. But then again, I guess I am a rock :) 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

Good grief Anderson, Does a fire burn down a building? - Always - Sometimes - Never - Not if it happens within the first 2 pieces of wood nailed together. Give me a break. Just ask: Does killing a baby....kill the baby? Does killing a zygote.....kill the zygote? Let's be clear and not mix apples and oranges here just for the sake of stirring up an abortion debate. Are you wanting to start something or are you genuinely confused and need some help and guidance? If it's "clarity" that you need - I don't think you will find it here. But I'll bet you already knew that. Have fun people. I can tell this thread's got huge potential. 

Puppy again --- 19 years ago -

I like you Neo. Great post! Stupid poll! 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

Have you ever known anyone to have an abortion and the baby live? Have you ever heard of a just poured foundation burning to a crisp and....the building stands? 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

Seems like a pretty yes/no, black/white question to me. The question is. The answers are not. 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

CommonSense, "dumb as a rock." Neo, "Let's be clear and not mix apples and oranges" This is not a mixing of apples and oranges in this poll. It is to demonstrate that there are people out there that do not think abortion kills a baby. Simple. It is only when human emotion is added to the abortion debate that people loose track of what abortion really is----The death of a baby. Period. How can that be confusing for anyone? 

mocha_mama --- 19 years ago -

Have you ever known anyone to have an abortion and the baby live? I have no opinion to post about this because I don't get into these kinds of debates, but I have heard of babies surviving. 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

Seems like a pretty yes/no, black/white question to me. The question is. The answers are not. No...the answer is either yes, a successful abortion kills or no, it doesn't. If there are different types of (successful...meaning they accomplished their intended use) abortions that you know of that sometimes kill and sometimes don't, then the statement doesn't apply, but it either kills or it doesn't kill based on the generally known about type of abortions available. The ambiguity that some like to put to the situation is in the following question: Is it ever justified to kill a baby? (aka "Is abortion ever justified?"). People don't like it asked that way, but if you believe that abortion kills a baby, then this is really the question that you are answering. 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

No confusion at all on this end. It's obvious that you may be a bit confused regarding the point I have been trying to make here. That being......WHEN IS IT A BABY. My analogy, although admittedly weak, about the building.....when is it a building? As soon as you nail 2 boards together? or 3? Or as soon as you begin driving that nail into the very first board? Or when? You see - the answers you provided in your "POLL" are just not adequate, in fact - not even useful. I think what you should be asking first is - when do people consider it a baby? That is the hot button issue - always has been. I don't think anyone is going to argue that if you kill something - it ceases to live. It's what you are killing, and at what point does one consider it a "baby" - irrespective of your own views and opinions of this Anderson. I mean, if you want to assert your own views, then do that. Not this stupid POLL. If you are interested in where everyone else sits then do a POLL - but you need to ask the right question. This poll is just not cutting it. (I refer you back to my first posting in this thread) Your question asks one thing, but the answers you provide answer something else. And by the way, it's lose (hard 's' as in hose) not loose (soft 's' as in moose). 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

No...the answer is either yes, a successful abortion kills or no, it doesn't. Agreed. Kills what is the part of this question that the answer choices do not adequately address! You can abort a take off - You can abort a landing - The REAL QUESTION here is - WHEN IS IT A BABY! Try this.... Q: Does abortion kill an adult? Answer choices: - Always - Sometimes - Never - Not if done before their 21st birthday. -----or----- - Not if done while they are a child WELL? Black & White - an abortion performed on an adult would no doubt KILL an adult. So....when are they an adult? When do they cease being a child? The answers are NOT Black & White, nor are the ones provided above really germaine to the question. 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

If someone did not consider a baby to be created at conception, then their answer to the question would be "no" or "sometimes". The question is still valid, and the answers are still yes, no, or sometimes. Notice that I said this above: People don't like it asked that way, but if you believe that abortion kills a baby, then this is really the question that you are answering. 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

Wow - you are way off here. Where does the question address conception? It only asks does it kill a baby? If I did not consider it a baby at conception - my answer to the question would still be YES. Really, how could the answer to that question be anything else? Puh-lease. The question alone is redundant and inane. Not much different than asking a similarly stupid question like - Does watering the yard make it wet? 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

If I did not consider it a baby at conception - my answer to the question would still be YES. Really, how could the answer to that question be anything else? Puh-lease. If you don't think that there is a baby to kill, how could you say "yes, it kills a baby"? If you don't think that there is a baby to kill, then you answer would be "no", it doesn't kill a baby. If you think that sometime while a woman is pregnant, that the cells become a baby, then your answer would be "sometimes" because it depends when the abortion was preformed. It's not that hard to understand. 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

Look - Anderson's question asks IF The answer choices Anderson gives us, answers WHEN. Does that help? That's all I'm saying. Put a little more thought into it and make it a valid and usefull POLL for crying out loud. Gees! 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

If you don't think that there is a baby to kill, how could you say yes, it kills a baby. If you don't think that there is a baby to kill, then you answer would be "no", it doesn't kill a baby. It's not that hard to understand. qpc - THE QUESTION DOESN'T ASK IF IT'S A BABY OR NOT!! IT ASKS IF AN ABORTION WOULD KILL ONE. DUH!!! 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

IF you don't think that it is a baby ever, then you answer no. IF you think that it is always a baby, then you answer yes. IF you think that it becomes a baby after some time, then you answer sometimes or not if done w/in the first 24 hours of conception. Does that help? That's all I'M saying. 

gking --- 19 years ago -

qpc - THE QUESTION DOESN'T ASK IF IT'S A BABY OR NOT!! IT ASKS IF AN ABORTION WOULD KILL ONE. DUH!!! Gotta go with Neo on this one. qpc, you're just not getting it. 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

If there isn't a baby to kill, then an abortion would not kill a baby so the answer would be no (it would be getting rid of an unwanted mass of cells or whatever, but it's intended purpose would not be to kill a baby). I get it just fine. 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

I edited myself...after I posted I realized it was rude, sorry. 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

Neo, "Q: Does abortion kill an adult?" Your trying to confuse people and distract from the truth of abortion. Maybe my question could have been asked a little differently.....but you know full well the intent of the question. Comparing a human life with that of a partially built building----is a mockery. Abortion---a successfully performed abortion kills a human life. Whether there is a zygot, embryo or human looking blob of tissue they are all still part of the human race and human life. 

gking --- 19 years ago -

No...you apparently don't get it. The question is: Does abortion kill a baby? The question is not: Does abortion kill a fetus? or At what point is it a baby? or Do you believe it is a baby that is killed no matter when an abortion is performed? There is no question that an abortion kills a baby. It doesn't merely injure it, or mame it, or attempt to kill. By very definition - a baby would indeed considered dead and therefore "killed" if its life were willfully "aborted." The answer then is fairly obvious. In fact - the way the question is asked, there could almost be no other reasonable answer - as in the other self-evident question Neo poses above: Does watering the yard make it wet. OF COURSE IT DOES. Does willfully ending a life of a baby kill it? OF COURSE IT DOES. Regardless of when one considers it a baby - at conception, before, during or after - that isn't what's asked. Do you understand that? If you still don't get it, I guess you just won't, and I just give up like Neo did. 

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees (Mod) --- 19 years ago -

Being a recovered fetus myself, I don't agree with abortion. 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

Hi Joelledrees....my name is Anderson, and I'm a recovered fetus too. LOL =) 

Mommee --- 19 years ago -

If the question is so dumb and everyone knows the answer...why is it still legal? Just a thought :) If you had an abortion and now you are a Christian, you will meet up with your baby in Heaven. How exciting :) 

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees (Mod) --- 19 years ago -

haha :-D yay you got it! 

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees (Mod) --- 19 years ago -

If you had an abortion and now you are a Christian, you will meet up with your baby in Heaven. How exciting :) And then you would have to answer to it. 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

MO3A, "If you had an abortion and now you are a Christian, you will meet up with your baby in Heaven." I think there is a book about that....I will have to look it up online. But my guess is that mother and child would recognize eachother. 

Mommee --- 19 years ago -

Anderson...that just makes me tear up to think that people are going to face that. I would be so nervous to meet someone I killed in Heaven. Shoot, I am a little nervous to meet our Maker. He's just so glorious. 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

MO3A, "I would be so nervous to meet someone I killed in Heaven." I don't think it will be viewed that way. There is some sort of "all knowing" awareness that we can not even comprehend. I think that aborted babies in Heaven will be full of love and joy at seeing their mother having turned her life around and make it into heaven. Don't forget---God is forgiving. When we ask God to forgive us of our sins---he does just that. Noone will have to "answer" for sins that have been forgiven. 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

Your trying to confuse people and distract from the truth of abortion. It's You're (A contraction of the pronoun 'you' and the verb 'are'; 'Your' is just a pronoun and leaves out the essential verb in your sentence.) And no, I am not at all trying to confuse anyone. I am merely trying to point out how stupid and pointless your question is. If you want to know at what point people consider a baby to be killed - then freakin' ask that! Maybe my question could have been asked a little differently.....but you know full well the intent of the question. You think? Yeah, I think I do know your intent here and I think that using a POLL (an ill conceived one at that) is a poor way of asserting your position. Comparing a human life with that of a partially built building----is a mockery. Asking a leading and self evident question and then providing a set of answer choices that answers a completely different question is an explicit exhibition of your shallow intellect. Abortion---a successfully performed abortion kills a human life. I agree completely - when performed on a human life. Now - care to craft a better POLL question that addresses your real issue? Whether there is a zygot, embryo or human looking blob of tissue they are all still part of the human race and human life. And to carry the logic of that statement out a little further - one would also have to say that that is true of every element of the periodic table that makes up the human body. The hydrogen, the oxygen, the iron - OH WAIT, these things aren't "alive", OK....the flora and fauna that live in our digestive tract - OH WAIT, these things are foreign to our bodies and are acquired, OK..... the cellular "bodies" that comprise our various systems - blood cells in our circulatory system, antibodies in our immune system, muscle cells, nerve cells - each a living entity, and each carrying our DNA. Your POLL is pointless. The question answers itself. The answer choices address another issue altogether. Sorry if you don't like it. 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

This makes me want to cry...PMS, yes, but still.... 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

excuse my typos...I know the diffence between your and you're when I am in a hurry I don't catch those.... 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

Neo...you sure seem to be taking this thread personally...care to share? 

jjfingrainalready --- 19 years ago -

Neo, I see your point about the poll, it does seem kinda obvious and silly....but you seem so passionate about this poll ......did I miss something? Do you have something against Anderson or the polls? Why don't you re-do the poll? Maybe it would illustrate your point better...just an idea... 

jjfingrainalready --- 19 years ago -

Anderson, we musta been thinking/typing same thing/same time! 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls
children
health
politics
religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground