Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Ice Box Suggestions - Reposted/Edited

who's talking here?

adam 1
mikesgal 5
Sandyr9111 1
gking 6
OldSchool 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

gking --- 20 years ago -

I made the following comments shortly after the "Ice Box" was first implemented. Most seemed to get very uptight over the idea of such a "device." It had struck me as a lot of noise over a somewhat tiny little issue. I think I still feel the same way about it now as I did when I originally wrote these comments (of course, I've never iced or been iced either!): There is clearly a need to address the issue of unreasonable, uncalled for and hurtful personal attacks and insults and inappropriate postings in general here on this forum. Stop. Think. Would anyone disagree with this? Now the subsequent issue is determining just what constitutes an unreasonable, uncalled for, hurtful and/or inappropriate posting. As we all have different beliefs and different threshholds of what we might find offensive, hurtful and inappropriate (including our omnipotent administrator) - I would submit that a "KU community" concensus system be employed to make these determinations; just as obscenity is defined by using "community standards" as a benchmark. Stop. Think. Would you disagree with this? A system where a single administrator is responsible for "judging" posts for their appropriateness is clearly not adequately representing the concensus of this KU "community". A system where the members of the KU Community, collectively, can make these determinations would better represent the concensus - and thus the resulting opinions are not of one (the admin) but of all - tempering the least tolerant opinions along with the most. Arguably a fair and somewhat democratic approach. Stop. Think. Would you disagree with this? So, what would be left is devising a system that allows for members to contribute to the concensus, in such a way that the system itself is - fair in its methodology, - immune from fraud and abuse, - not so cumbersome or complicated as to discourage its use, - could provide for self correction. So, some possible options could include: - Abiding by and relying on the sole judgement of an overseeing administrator to deem what is appropriate and what isn't. Besides contradicting the whole "community concensus" ideal, it would seem unfeasible to expect that this person could read, judge and deal with (meaning possibly having to take the time to post explanations, etc.) every single thread and post - 24/7. - holding an election of sorts where we could "elect" fellow members we believe represent our "community standards" that would then be empowered to police the posts on our behalf. In my opinion, this would not be a very practical solution either. Besides obvious reasons, I would consider such a system as unreliable and inviting of its own conflicts. Nontheless, could be open for further discussion and exploration. - Each member could be granted "voting" powers of sorts, whereby they could use their "vote" to express their individual discontent with a particular posting or poster. As with any voting system, the majority will rule the outcome. The outcome needs to be appropriate to the "crime". Obviously, I have just described what has just recently been implemented here. And if you have read any of my posts regarding this system, you already know that I certainly favor this option. In my opinion, there are several things that need to be carefully considered and addressed in implementing this sort of system: a) Community concensus needs to mean just that. Do non-posters (registered lurkers) get voting (flagging, icing) powers? b) What about offenders registering multiple names to gain more voting (flagging, icing) power? c) What are the concensus threshholds? Should they be based on the number of contributors to the thread? In other words - should it take more votes on a thread that has 20 different posters posting to it, than say, a thread that has only 4 or 5 unique posters? d) what about the "un-affected" users. I'm referring to some bored group of teenagers who like to go around different community forums (or maybe just this one) and either stir up trouble intentionally, or in our case cast a bunch of votes and go on their way. If I lived in Maine, and happened across KU, read a few posts, learned about our little flagging system and the difficulty it's presenting us - I might consider it great fun to wreak a little anonymous havoc and flag a bunch of people and be on my way. e) Punishment needs to fit the crime. Concensus affects an outcome, perhaps a concensus should be able to reverse that outcome as well? I have several suggestions - and have posted them before in other threads - that I believe might successfully address these concerns. First, I think a user should have to fulfill a time period and maybe even a personal posting quota before being given voting (flagging, icing) power. In other words, maybe you need to be a registered user for at least 30 days (the idea is to create enough time period for this "new" user to become adequately acquainted with other users, how they post, how KU operates, read older posts, etc - before being able to just start flinging flags), and Personally contribute a minimum of 5 (10?) posts themselves (again, the thinking here - provides an opportunity to invite some interaction with other KU members, get the potential experience of drawing their own criticism, praise, debates, etc.). This little "initiation" would eliminate the casual drop in from coming by our "community" and committing basically what would amount to voter fraud. This would also eliminate users that get sent to the icebox from being able to just register a new name and get back in the game - with revenge on their mind (spurring abuse). I believe that users should get only one vote. Once used, they do not get a replacement vote to use for a delayed period. How long? A week? 2 days? Experimentation would probably be the best way to determine what's best here. I believe that this measure would cause users to be very thoughtful and judicious about whom and/or what they would use their only vote on. Perhaps each user gets 1 each of 3 types of votes with a 7 day waiting period before replenishment. - 1 vote (red flag) for use on a topic they find offensive or inappropriate - no harm to the poster, just possible deletion of the post, - 1 vote (red flag) to use on a poster they feel has crossed the line too often and needs to be stopped. - 1 vote (green flag) to use to flag a favorite or most valued post or poster or both. The Thread or poster gets a special place of recognition on the home page? And, speaking of the votes (flags)..... Posters need to know when the concensus is not in favor of their posts and they are headed to the ice box. I believe that the red flags need to appear next to the "offending" poster's name so that that poster may make use of that information to try to redeem him/herself, back off or temper their future posts to possibly avoid hitting that threshhold and getting banished to the icebox (iced. Speaking of threshholds - it needs to be plain and clear, how many votes/flags it's going to take to land in the icebox for this particular post or poster. Perhaps concensus (KU users) can go into the icebox and "vote" an offender back in if/when for some reason the concensus feels time served has been adequate or unfair, etc. (case in point: RAY) I think it would be a nice touch to be able to recognize - by concensus - our favorite posts as well, by being able to cast a single special STAR vote/flag or something like that. People like to be positively recognized. Let's face it, it's obvious that many post just to see their words up on the screen - perhaps recognition enough. I think that it would inspire more positive, informative, useful posts - not to mention just more posters - if there were the potential of getting those positive votes next to our topic, or our name, and gaining a special spot on the home page for all to bow down before. Vote against this? Why? The system is flawed in its present state - that's a given (I can think of no system, past or present, without flaw). It's one thing to discuss all the features of a perfect system. It's quite another to code it! Let's give Adam a chance to be an Edison or an Orville here and count ourselves fortunate that we are able to participate in the formation of what will surely turn into a great solution. The concept is sound. Stop. Think. Re-read if you have to. Would you still disagree with this? 

adam (Wizard) --- 20 years ago -

(sigh) "Innocence" is such a subjective term. The ice box is to encourage people to be less offensive, intrusive, and antagonistic. Period. Because you think Ray is innocent doesn't mean others do not. The goal is not to democratically determine if someone deserves to be iced or not. The goal is to make every person and every comment cleaner, more positive, and more wholesome. So if Ray offended seven people, then let's hope that he'll be a little less offensive so he offends NO people. That will make KU that much better. (not to pick on Ray, per se, but since he's in the hot seat...) 

gking --- 20 years ago -

Slightly edited for clarity. 

gking --- 19 years ago -

In light of recent "icing" events and controversy, I thought it might be relevant to resurrect this thread. I know it's a long read - but I happen to think it contains some very good ideas that would seem to address most if not all our concerns regarding the use and abuse of our wonderful self-policing device. 

OldSchool --- 19 years ago -

If the ice box is destined to stay, my answer to the situation would be for a person to flag what they consider to be an offensive post. If that post gets flagged by 7 different people, then the post gets removed. If a poster gets 3 posts removed in a three day peroid, then they get iced for three days. Currently, all that I can see the ice box accomplishing is to cause people to take sides, and that is not making KU the better place that Adam thought would happen. 

mikesgal --- 19 years ago -

Why do we have flagging at all? To keep the site clear of offensive material, pornography, vulgarity, hate language, and everything else unseemly. We want the site to be peaceful, helpful, happy, and inspiring. I've said it before and I'll say it again . . . Admin expects us all to behave like adults; and it's unfortunate that some of us do not. I support Admin. This is their site we play on we all need to observe and follow the guidelines they have set forth. 

gking --- 19 years ago -

If that post gets flagged by 7 different people, then the post gets removed. If a poster gets 3 posts removed in a three day peroid, then they get iced for three days. That seems like a pretty good suggestion. 

gking --- 19 years ago -

Admin expects us all to behave like adults; and it's unfortunate that some of us do not. Do too. I know you are, but what am I? 

OldSchool --- 19 years ago -

I agree with you in principle mikesgal, but people are being put in the ice box when NONE of their posts are being removed. It only seems logical to me that at least one of your posts be deemed offensive enough to be removed before you are placed in the ice box. In another thread, Adam wrote The ice box rule is "Don't offend the minority." Seems like a strange rule to me to let the minority have that much power. And the minority is filling up the ice box right now. 

Sandyr9111 --- 19 years ago -

If the ice box is destined to stay, my answer to the situation would be for a person to flag what they consider to be an offensive post. If that post gets flagged by 7 different people, then the post gets removed. If a poster gets 3 posts removed in a three day peroid, then they get iced for three days. Old school I never thought I would say this but....i agree with this idea...lol 

mikesgal --- 19 years ago -

but people are being put in the ice box when NONE of their posts are being removed. It only seems logical to me that at least one of your posts be deemed offensive enough to be removed before you are placed in the ice box. Excellent point! I absolutely agree with it! My point was . . . is . . . we are all playing in Admin's sandbox and they have every right to set the rules. If we don't agree with them then we are free to leave. Sheesh, can you tell I was raised by a military Drill Sargent / MP? lol Please do not mistake my comments on this post as an agreement that certain KU-ers have been fairly put in the ice box. Again, I think there are posters that need to grow up! 

gking --- 19 years ago -

Again, I think there are posters that need to grow up! Do not. 

OldSchool --- 19 years ago -

My point was . . . is . . . we are all playing in Admin's sandbox and they have every right to set the rules. If we don't agree with them then we are free to leave. I agree in principle. I just think that the system they set up is skewed too much towards the minority. Please do not mistake my comments on this post as an agreement that certain KU-ers have been fairly put in the ice box. Again, I think there are posters that need need to grow up! Again I agree, but many of those posters never make it into the ice box. 

mikesgal --- 19 years ago -

Do not. Do too! 

mikesgal --- 19 years ago -

I agree in principle. I just think that the system they set up is skewed too much towards the minority. I agree but if we do not like the rules that Admin has set forth we are welcome to leave and start our own site. 

OldSchool --- 19 years ago -

Instead of leaving, I would rather make suggestions that could help make this forum a better place. Right now the forum is fracturing because people are taking sides. 

mikesgal --- 19 years ago -

Again, I agree . . . With that said, I still view this site the same way I view my domocile . . . I have rules and if you don't like them or abide by them then there's the door; don't let it hit you on the way out. Admin has spent countless time and money developing and maintaining KU . . . at no cost to any of us. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

ku
rant


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground