Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Prayer & Salvation

who's talking here?

ACwife 3
Hardshell 8
JDaddy 1
OldSchool 3
CyberSage 2
qpc 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Hardshell --- 20 years ago -

I've noticed in several of the more heated theological discussions on KU, that someone always mentions that they are going to pray for a non-believer to "come to Jesus", or pray for someone to "get" saved, etc. etc. etc. I've been reading alot on prayer lately, and I have a question that maybe someone can answer for me. Where is the scriptural passage that teaches anyone to pray for the salvation of the wicked, or to pray for another sinner to be Born Again? Honestly, If you can think of a passage, please let me know..... 

Hardshell --- 20 years ago -

Here are some of the things that I am questioning: If God has appointed some to disobedience (I Peter 2.8), does the scripture anywhere tell us to pray against God's will? Of those who rejected Christ, the scripture says that they could not believe because "He hath blinded their eyes, and hardened their heart, that they should not see with their eyes, nor understand with their heart, and should be converted, and I should heal them" (John 12.40) If God blinds and hardens some so that they will not be converted and believe, are we to pray against these acts of God? Wouldn't that be like saying "not Thy will, but mine be done"? 

ACwife --- 20 years ago -

Hardshell, I know as a Calvinist that you are a believer in "the elect". You also know that not ALL of the elect are saved at every particular point in time. So, with us not knowing who is chosen and who isn't, I assume we should pray for everyone's salvation. In HIS sovereignty, He will "have mercy on whom he has mercy and have compassion on whom he has compassion". 

Hardshell --- 20 years ago -

Hey ACWife, I totally agree that we do not know who will or will not be saved. By "saved" do you mean born again? 

JDaddy --- 20 years ago -

No answers for this one, but thanks for getting me thinking about the concept! 

ACwife --- 20 years ago -

By "saved" do you mean born again? Yes. Given the gift of salvation through grace. 

OldSchool --- 20 years ago -

I received this in a message. 1 Timothy 2: [1] I urge, then, first of all, that requests, prayers, intercession and thanksgiving be made for everyone— [2] for kings and all those in authority, that we may live peaceful and quiet lives in all godliness and holiness. [3] This is good, and pleases God our Savior, [4] who wants all men to be saved and to come to a knowledge of the truth. [5] For there is one God and one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus, [6] who gave himself as a ransom for all men—the testimony given in its proper time. 

OldSchool --- 20 years ago -

Another message. "If God has appointed some to disobedience (I Peter 2.8), does the scripture anywhere tell us to pray against God's will?" I believe to understand this scripture you have to include verses 1-7. Verse 4 talks about rejection and acceptance, and this theme is expounded in verses 2:6-8 which specifically focuses on the stone rejected by man but chosen by God and by those who believed. People will either reject or accept what God has provided as the only way of salvation. Peter explains these two different responses to God’s offer of salvation (Jesus Christ), and what will be the effect of such responses. Peter first quoted Isaiah 28:16. The original context of this verse talks about God’s promise of salvation in which his people had rejected. It is obviously clear that the NT believers have taken the "stone" to represent the Messiah which is Jesus Christ. In verse 7, "Now to you who believe, this stone is precious", Peter is referring to Jesus. Peter’s main point in quoting Isaiah 28:16 is to affirm from the Scriptures that those who accepted the salvation (Jesus Christ) that God has provided "will never be put to shame" or disappointed. Eventhough the choice may not be popular at the present time, they will be vindicated later for trusting God. For them Jesus, the living Stone, is precious. They have already experienced (v.2:3-tasted) that the Lord is good. "But to those who do not believe, "The stone the builders rejected has become the capstone," [8] and "A stone that causes men to stumble and a rock that makes them fall." Peter also quoted Psalm 118:22 and part of Isaiah 8:14. Psalm 118:22 was also quoted by Peter in Acts 4:11 as he preached to the rulers and elders of the Jews who rejected and crucified Jesus Christ of Nazareth. From these verses in the Old Testament, Peter based his message concerning those who will reject the living Stone, Jesus Christ. What is the ‘capstone’? It actually says "head of the corner" as in King James Version. Also called "chief cornerstone," this stone can refer to the last stone to be placed into a building. As in the use of ‘cornerstone,’ Peter’s main point in using the description is to emphasize the importance of what the rejected stone had become to the building. Peter quotes Psalm 118:22 to show us that the stone rejected by the builders was chosen by God, the chief builder, to be the capstone. Peter is pointing that Jesus Christ was rejected and crucified by his own people. But God, who is building the spiritual house (verse 2:5), has chosen Jesus Christ to be the capstone of that building made up of all the believers in Jesus Christ. Peter’s point in quoting Isaiah 8:14 to show us that there are two different responses to the living Stone - acceptance or rejection. Now, Peter shows two different functions of the living stone - as the cornerstone to those who believe or a stone that destroys to those who rejects. Isaiah 8:14 also affirms the failure or destruction of those who have rejected God’s offer of salvation. God’s judgment will come upon the unbelievers because of their rejection and disobedience to God’s message of salvation. "They stumble because they disobey the message—which is also what they were destined for." Peter’s uses the phrase "they were destined for." to mean simply that those who disobey are destined to stumble. It was not their disobedience or rejection that was destined - it was the result of their action that is destined. To put John 12:40 into context, verses 12-50 need to be included where John talks about the unbelief of Israel. The majority of the Jews did not believe on Jesus despite the many miracles that He performed that indicated His messiahship. John attributed Israel's unbelief to God's will, though he balanced that again with the Jew's human responsibility in verse 43. John used Isaiah 53:1 to show the prediction of Israel's rejection of her Messiah. The verse originally referred to the Gentiles' rejection of Israel, the servant of the Lord. However now John is using it to show the prediction of Israel's rejection of the Servant of the Lord whom He would send. The report or message that the people had rejected was Jesus' teaching, and the evidence of the Lord's arm or power was Jesus' miracles. In verse 39, John again affirmed that most of the Jews did not believe on Jesus because they could not. God had judicially hardened their hearts because they had refused to believe Him previously (Exodus 9:12; 2 Thessalonians 2:8-12). Verse 40, is the prophecy of Isaiah 6:10 that predicted this hardening. Originally God had told Isaiah that the people to whom he ministered would not welcome his ministry because God would harden their hearts. John explained that this verse also revealed the reason for the Jews' rejection of Jesus' ministry. The prophecy not only described Israel's unbelief as shown in verse 38, but it also explained it. To fully understand verse 40 and its connotations of predestination, you have to study Paul's explanation in Romans 9-11. In verses 44-50 John's use of Jesus' words summarize and restate some of the major points that John had recorded earlier. These themes include faith, Jesus as the One sent by the Father, light and darkness, judgment now and later, and eternal life. These verses are a final exhortation to believe. From these verses I see it as not God's will of predestination, but as what God knew would happen because of man's disobedience. 

Hardshell --- 20 years ago -

OldSchool, Thank whoever sent you the message, but it doesn't answer the question.... v.1-2 We pray for all so that "WE may live peaceful and quiet lives...." But do we pray specifically for the the spiritual quickening of the wicked? v.4 "who wants all men to be saved.." I don't know what translation of the scriptures was used here, but it appears to be some Campbellite translation. See Geneva Bible 1606: v.4 "who will that all men shall be saved...." See Authorized KJV 1611: v.4 "who will have all men to be saved" God does not "want" all men to be saved, as HE is the Author & Finisher of the believer's faith, and salvation is ONLY of the Lord. He could not possibly "want" men to be saved, unless you fall for the notion that God's will is subject to man's will. Yes, He will have all men to be saved; all men that He chose from eternity, all men, as in Jew and Gentile, or all men that he chose OUT OF every kindred, tongue, nation, and people, but not all men without exception. 

qpc --- 20 years ago -

Paul in Romans 10:1 Brethren, my heart's desire and prayer to God for Israel is that they may be saved. 

OldSchool --- 20 years ago -

Another message The translation was NIV In 1 Timothy 2:1 it says ...prayers ... for everyone. KJV 1 Timothy 2 [1] I exhort therefore, that, first of all, supplications, prayers, intercessions, and giving of thanks, be made for all men; [2] For kings, and for all that are in authority; that we may lead a quiet and peaceable life in all godliness and honesty. [3] For this is good and acceptable in the sight of God our Saviour; [4] Who will have all men to be saved, and to come unto the knowledge of the truth. [5] For there is one God, and one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus; [6] Who gave himself a ransom for all, to be testified in due time. v.1 says ... prayers,... be made for all men; v. 3,4 [3] For this is good and acceptable in the sight of God our Saviour; [4] Who will have all men to be saved,... Everyone could be saved, but they will not due to their own denial of Christ, not because God did not give them the opportunity, which he affords everyone, or not because God chose certain people to deny salvation to. 

CyberSage --- 20 years ago -

If God has appointed some to disobedience (I Peter 2.8), does the scripture anywhere tell us to pray against God's will? ...and if God is omniscient, why pray for ANYTHING? It would seem your question about salvation is a bit of a straw man. There's nothing more special about salvation than there is grass growing. That is, if God has willed it, who are we to pray against it? You seem to be focused on salvation because it is the little Reformed debate circle that you run in. Yet, your question poses the bigger problem of why we should pray at all? Yes, I know the Bible tells us to, and I know that Jesus did, but WHY? Ah yes, so our wills can be transformed to the will and mind of God, so that when He tells us no, we will be at peace because our prayer life has already brought us to that conclusion, because we were so close to Him, that his denial of our request may be received as a mere confirmation of what we were already perceiving as his will. But isn't there more to it than that? Are the Reformed willing to change their minds to accept that God desires to give his children good things, and that maybe, just maybe, he waits for us to ask in sincerity so that he can allow a different outcome? But you say, that would make him less than omniscient, if he were to allow our prayers to affect his decisions. Maybe yes, maybe no. Who am I to say? I am neither omniscient nor monolithic, nor am I qualified as a mortal to discern whether the one characteristic excludes the other. 

ACwife --- 20 years ago -

From these verses I see it as not God's will of predestination, but as what God knew would happen because of man's disobedience. So what your saying is that man is more sovereign than God and that man ultimately decides what happens? 

Hardshell --- 20 years ago -

OldSchool, Thanks for your comments. Regarding the two passages that I quoted earlier, you've done an excellent job of commenting on them and referencing the Christology of the pertinent Old Testament passages. So I will only address your conclusions, where you apparently feel that I need some correction. I Peter 2.8 You made the statement: "Peter's use of the phrase "they were destined for." to mean simply that those who disobey are destined to stumble. It was not their disobedience or rejection that was destined - it was the result of their action that is destined." Or, in other words, because they rejected Christ, they were destined to stumble. I believe this is incorrect and unscriptural. To "stumble" at Christ or "stumble at the word, being disobedient" is not the punishment, but the sin. To "stumble" at the gospel, or the message and miracles of Christ, is to reject them, "being disobedient". This is the sin of the unbelievers, not their punishment. A good example would be when one would break the old law, "ye have caused many to stumble at the law; ye have corrupted the covenant of Levi" Mal. 2.8 Or, "O Israel, return unto the Lord they God: for thou hast fallen BY thine iniquity." Hosea 14.1 Also, "They shall cast their silver in the streets, and their gold shall be removed: their silver and their gold shall not be able to deliver them in the day of the wrath of the Lord: they shall not satisfy their souls, neither fill their bowels: because IT IS the stumblingblock of their iniquity (NOT BECAUSE OF THEIR INIQUITY!). Ezek. 7.19 ........If needed, I can provide additional scriptural references to prove this point. So, unbelievers are appointed or predestinated to "stumble" at Christ BY rejecting Him and His gospel, not FOR rejecting Him. On the positive side, please read verse 9. Believers are a "chosen generation, a royal priesthood, an holy nation, a peculiar people; that ye should shew forth the praises of Him who hath called you out of darkness into His marvelous light" Do we have a scriptural basis to pray for the spiritual quickening of those whom God has not predestinated to call out of the darkness of unbelief? If the Lord "appointed" unbelievers to "stumble" by rejecting Christ, where is it written that we should pray for the Lord's will not to be accomplished? Do you remember the prayer "Thy kingdom come, Thy will be done"? ----------------- John 12.40 I am glad to see that you agree with these scriptures concerning the unbelief of the Jews being God's will. I am also glad that you referred me to Romans chapters 9-11. I have always thought that these chapters are a treasure trove. In this passage of John, the gospel was preached to the Jews, and they saw many miracles performed before them, but they did not believe, because they could not believe. Why? They were not given Divine Grace to believe on Christ. The “arm of the Lord” had not been revealed to them, “Therefore, they could not believe.” Now you say that “from these verses I see it as not God’s will of predestination, but as what God knew would happen because of man’s disobedience.” Well, who is it that provides Divine Grace? Who is it that reveals “the arm of the Lord”? Isn’t it the Lord Himself? Yet you say that “it is not God’s will of predestination? Does God not have a will concerning His own acts? Does He only know what He will do? He doesn’t plan what He will do? Nonsense! And lastly, you mention “exhortations to believe” in verses 44-50. Excuse me, but I find no exhortations at all in these passages……only statements of fact: “He that believeth” -----not, “He that ought to choose to believe” “He that seeth”-------not, “you should choose to see” “Whoever believeth on Me”-----that’s “Who ever believes on Me”….not, “you should be believe on Me” “He that rejecteth Me”…..not, “Don’t reject Me”. Well, back to my original question----Where in the scriptures are believers commanded to pray for the salvation of those whom the Lord has willed not to believe? By the way, for you and all of the other human freewill worshippers out there…….. if the ultimate decision in Salvation is dependent upon man’s freewill, why pray to God about the unbelievers? From your standpoint, He can’t or won’t do anything about it because His will is subservient to man’s in this area. Man’s will is like a golden calf to mainstream Christianity…..even God himself is not allowed to tread on it! 

Hardshell --- 20 years ago -

Hey Steve, What are Automatons????? Come on...did you make that up? 

Hardshell --- 20 years ago -

CyberSage, I’m asking a specific question about prayer and the Lord’s will in Salvation, and apparently I’ve hit a nerve with you for you feel that it’s necessary to put all of these words in my mouth. I’m not Reformed, whatever that means. I’m Baptist. And if I run in a circle, it’s a circle of one. When did I ever say that effectual prayer makes God less omniscient? I don’t believe that at all, and you don’t know me, so how did you come to that conclusion? We don’t know the will of God, but when it comes to prayer, THAT DOES NOT MATTER. Prayer is communion with God. Prayer is pouring out your problems to the Lord, confessing your transgressions, thanking Him for His mercy. And yes, prayer is divinely appointed to convey the blessings that God has purposed to grant to His people. The Lord leads His people to pray, and actually the spirit prays continually with “groanings which cannot be uttered.” These prayers are always heard. These prayers are always answered. This is true prayer, but it is not some insincere, silly ramblings about saving all the heathens and filling up heaven…it’s an inner, personal, spiritual, dialogue with God. AND NO, PRAYER DOES NOT CHANGE GOD’S WILL-----PRAYER IS ENCOMPASSED IN GOD’S WILL. If you find comfort in praying to a changeable God, then good for you….but I don’t think one exists! 

CyberSage --- 20 years ago -

Where is the scriptural passage that teaches anyone to pray for the salvation of the wicked, or to pray for another sinner to be Born Again? Wow, then, let me give the "fish in a barrell" answer. I doubt you'll change your mind, but that's your problem. Here goes... Are you actually suggesting that we are given the Great Commission, but we're not supposed to pray for the salvation of those to whom we are sent? I "win." 

Hardshell --- 20 years ago -

Sorry, The great commission was given to the apostles, not to you or me, and if you read the book of ACTS, you'll see that they fulfilled that commission, and they are still fulfilling it today, (ie. we have the scriptures.) But the "commission" never caused anyone to become a child of God or to be born spiritually anyway, so you're kinda off topic. Congratulations on that "win", Mr. Arminian. 

page 1
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

men
women
parenting
religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground