Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Johnny Can Spell - but can he teach your child?

who's talking here?

marthas attic 3
MissT 5
cmi 1
Fallon 6
karenact 8
ambergris 1
©Hanson♥ 1
Kris frm Tx 1
mdawg 2
ladybug678 4
Gigi 1
qpc 2
jimmy 1
Gumby 3
Big Mama 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

ladybug678 --- 20 years ago -

I recently moved to Trailwood from another village in Kingwood and my child now goes to Foster Elementary. The school seems to be good except for one major issue - the reading program "Johnny can Spell". This program is so very different from what was being taught at his other school and my son is really struggling now. I have talked to several other parents and so far, I haven't found anyone who likes this program. Has anyone out there had any experience with "Johnny can spell" and if so, what is your opinion on it. Also, do any other schools besides Foster use "Johnny can spell"? Thanks for your help. 

Fallon --- 20 years ago -

NO THEY DON'T It is, imo an idiot thing to implement. But this is the principles baby and she will not let it die. Kids who transfere to Kingwood and go to Foster have a terrible time understanding this. I would go to the school board, and file an official complaint. And see if you can get anyone else to join you. She will not take this out of the school until forced. It really is moronic! 

MissT --- 20 years ago -

I hated it. My dd transferred into Foster in 3rd grade and struggled with it. I used to get so mad about the spelling tests because although she would spell all the words correcly, she would get marked off for not marking the "johhny can spell" marks. My ds transferred in 1st grade and did better since he learned it earlier. I do remember last year or so they said "Johnny died" and they stopped using it. I'm not sure they do it anymore. 

ambergris --- 20 years ago -

what is Johnny can spell??? 

ladybug678 --- 20 years ago -

Oh Johnny is still alive and well at Foster and driving my 2nd grader crazy. My son is doing exactly like your 3rd grader - he spells the words correctly but fails the tests because of the markings. I am so frustrated because he has always loved school and now he comes home feeling defeated and he tells me he thinks he is to stupid to learn this stuff. I want to make a formal complaint to the school board but I think I will write up a petition and see if I can get parents to sign first. That way my complaint will have more weight. So look for me after school, I will be the crazy lady walking the car rider line asking for signatures. 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 20 years ago -

My dd transferred to Forster from another school in Kingwood also. She was in 2nd grade, excellent student and always spelled the words correctly, but missed on the markings. It finally came down to her teacher sending home the words already marked and told us just to have her memorize them! My son went completely through Foster and never really had a problem with it, but its insane. I would ask the teachers what I could do to help them study and there was nothing they could give me. The parents have no help on this program! My dd is now in High School and wonders why they pushed so hard for something that did not help her at all. I think all the schools in the area need to be using the same format since so many families move from one subdivision to another. I think its time for Johnny's funeral!! 

Fallon --- 20 years ago -

Get your petition signed and keep at it. Good luck, and call the paper maybe the publicity will help. 

Gigi --- 20 years ago -

"he spells the words correctly but fails the tests because of the markings" I am not at all familiar with this program....but isn't the idea to teach your child to spell?? How can a child fail at this program if they spell words correctly??? 

©Hanson♥ --- 20 years ago -

Steve wrote this: The markings are for tense, inflection, long and short vowels, consonant blends etc ad nauseum. Anderson... believe this is the part of the test that the kids are having a hard time understanding...or they forget to do it. 

karenact --- 20 years ago -

Hey I will sign a petition and I know a lot of others who might also! My one daughter is in second grade and the younger is in first grade at Foster. I have been in to talk to Terri and she thinks it is a wonderful program but I am not happy with it at all. I would love to file a complaint with the school board. My daughter is so upset when she gets all the words spelled correctly and still doesn't get 100. I agree about there being a uniform program across the district. I also think the home work is ridiculous and that they should have projects where they have to think and apply some skill they have learned. I wish my kids went to Deerwood because I am so impressed with their school! 

Fallon --- 20 years ago -

karen would love to see you at Deerwood, it really is a wonderful school! And my best freinds daughter would spell the words right but not get the inane rules of Johnny can Spell, so she would fail too. Finally the teacher just stoped grading her on the idiot rules of this and gave her the A she earned by knowing how to spell the word. I live in Sand Creek but would love to see this program go out! Too many children are having problems with it. Besides, the point of spelling is to do just that spell. Not inflate the ego of a principle who really did make a mistake bringing in this program. Why do you think no other school has it? Parents unite!:) 

karenact --- 20 years ago -

lol Fallon! WE almost moved back to sands creek but ended up staying here when our home didn't sell before school started. Maybe some day! 

jimmy --- 20 years ago -

My ex and I went through similiar @#$$ with my son when he was in second grade in a cyfair school. The principal routinely failed 25% of the boys based on some study she read. Go to the school board only they can control a principal.....Do not give up. 

karenact --- 20 years ago -

cool or we could all unite at the ptra meeting and raise hell about it! LOL that would be a site! 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 20 years ago -

my kids are in middle and high school now but I would attend a PTA meeting and voice an opinion. That might be the place to really get the word out! 

karenact --- 20 years ago -

PTA Meeting tomorrow night at 6:30 PM Foster Cafeteria 

MissT --- 20 years ago -

I wish my kids went to Deerwood because I am so impressed with their school! Transfer them! I finally got tired of Foster and took my 3rd grader out, moved my Kindergartner to Bear Branch. Tell them the reason is because you don't like the principal or the Johnny Can Spell program! 

mdawg --- 20 years ago -

Deerwood is awesome!! :) 

ladybug678 --- 20 years ago -

I was talking to a parent today and she said that the Johnny can spell program has been scaled back so that it is only taught through the 2nd grade now. Does anyone know if this is true or not? 

karenact --- 20 years ago -

I thought 3rd grade but look around at other schools and see what wonderful spelling activities they have! The words are much more challenging as well! 

Kris frm Tx --- 20 years ago -

Johnny cant spell is thru the 3rd grade. Then 4th and 5th they spell like the rest of the world does. My son is in 5th and I think I remember in 4th he had no Johnny can spell. Thank goodness he caught on to it because I couldnt fiqure it out. I tell my daughter who is 2nd that she needs to talk to her brother about it because I am clueless, so far this year she is getting it, but if she has problems the teacher will have to help her because again I dont get it, and I tried too. 

qpc --- 20 years ago -

I don't know anything about the Johnny Can Spell system, but it sounds like it is a phonics system. My kids use this in A Beka (private school curriculum) but it is with reading. They learn the "rules" and it makes reading and spelling easier (when you learn it from the get go....my son started later and can't spell worth a dime!) My kids DON'T however have to mark their spelling words. It doesn't seem like it would be helpful AT ALL if you you didn't learn the reasons BEHIND the markings. My kids that started in K with the program have no problems at all with the markings, and by the time they are out of 2nd grade, they don't mark words anymore anyway. A system can be the most wonderful in the world, but if it is not used correctly or it is not working, then it is a pretty useless system. You would think they would figure it out, but the pricipal has probably already spent a lot of MONEY on the curriculum, and doesn't want to have to rebudget for a new one. 

karenact --- 20 years ago -

Well I just talked to a mom at Foster who is putting her house on the market so she can move her kids out of Foster and get away from Johnny can spell! Wow, anyway we have been collecting samples of the work the kids do and are collecting info on what other schools do in regard to spelling and vocabulary and once we have enough info we will go to the school board with our evidence. Anyone want in let me know. 

karenact --- 20 years ago -

It seems like our kids will be very behind the other schools at this rate. 

cmi --- 20 years ago -

First of all, the school has messed up by not really explaining the point or benefits of the program to parents. Second, it sounds like it is a huge problem for transfer students. Any program should always consider transfers before being implemented. Third, go to the board and show the level of words compared to other schools. Show why the other schools are doing better with spelling. 

Fallon --- 20 years ago -

Awesome response cmi. And good work Karen. By the way, you can add that Kingwood has a lots of new kids all the time. Shell, Continetal, Exxon, etc. So they need to have a program where an honor student can come in and not start making F's. The principle will not back down on this because of what she had to go thur to bring it in. This is one crusade that does need to be taken on. There are several people who move or transfere their kids to another school from Foster because of this program. 

MissT --- 20 years ago -

That is so strange. My kids pinky promised me that "Johnny died!" I guess the resurrected him! 

karenact --- 20 years ago -

Fallon, What is your connection to Foster? How do you know so much about the principal? 

Fallon --- 20 years ago -

I use to live there, and really wanted mine to start school there. I liked the big yards with the houses, and the big mature trees. But when I found out about this program, from my best freind who had moved here about year before me, I talked to the guidence councellor about it. I was assured that kids who begin with it learn it with no problem. But the entire program is crap as far as I could see. (I use to be a teacher). I asked how much longer it would be at Foster, and was told quite strongly it would be there as long as the principle. Teachers will take short cuts around it to help honor students not get F's, so it must not be that effective. That was one of the factors of us buying out of Trailwood. Now that my oldest is at Deerwood, I am really glad we did move! 

Gumby --- 20 years ago -

I do know other schools that also use Johnny Can Spell. I think it's sad that someone would move because of a spelling program. I think there is much more to that story besides spelling. Before starting a petition, wouldn't you want to talk to the principal/teacher to understand more? in my current job, there is a chain of command and we deal with who can help us rather than just blindly complaining. I have complaints about my son's school but I also know that he will always encounter things/people/programs that aren't perfect and that is life! I can't fix everything for him nor do I want to. He needs to live through some things he doesn't like to appreciate the things he does like. I don't think Johnny Can Spell every kept anyone out of Honors/GT or college! :-) 

MissT --- 20 years ago -

Ok, A&A tell me that THIRD GRADE and UP had the funeral for Johnny.... not 1st & 2nd...... 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 20 years ago -

As far as kids being behind who go to Foster that is not so. I do not endorse Johnny can spell it is aweful, but the rest of the education at Foster is wonderful! Both my kids went there, they are now in middle school and high school and my daughter takes all honors classes and my son is in several honors classes also. I would not move because of johnny can spell, I would go as far up as I could to get rid of it or have the principal replaced if need be. There should be a standard in all of Kingwood schools that everyone is on the same page with what they teach. 

MissT --- 20 years ago -

As far as kids being behind who go to Foster that is not so. I have heard from several people who have kids at KMS now, that when they first got there, they were behind. One example, the Honors Math teacher gives an inventory test during the first week, all the Foster kids fail it. Kudos to your kids for doing so well - you should be proud of them! 

Gumby --- 20 years ago -

Yes, there should be a standard in all Humble ISD schools for spelling but that is an issue with the district...not with the principals. The district has a reading/la coordinator that gets these programs...or leaves them up to schools. The district has been saying they are looking into spelling programs (because if you want to see aweful look at the state spelling books)for years but nothing has come of it. 

Gumby --- 20 years ago -

I have heard from several people who have kids at KMS now, that when they first got there, they were behind. Actually-my neighbor shared with me that last year's Junior National Honor Society at KMS was made up of more than half Foster students...that's pretty darn good! 

ladybug678 --- 20 years ago -

I fully intend to take my complaints to the principle in private first before I make a formal public complaint, and that is why I am not going to bring up the issue at tonight’s PTA meeting. I have already had many meetings with the teacher about the issue and we are working together to solve the problem. I started this discussion because, as I stated earlier I am new to Foster and I wanted to see if there were other children out there that had problems with Johnny can Spell or if it was just mine. After talking to many parents as well as reading everyone’s response I have found that my child is clearly not alone and that this is definitely not a new problem, but has been going on for many years. As far as just telling my child to “tough it out because that is life” as Gumby has suggested, well I just can’t do that. My son has always loved school and had a wonderful attitude about himself and his ability to learn before we moved to Foster. When he first started at Foster he was very excited and made many new friends very quickly, but after a few weeks he started complaining that his stomach hurt and he didn’t want to go to school. When I asked him what the problem was he finally confessed that during spelling time he didn’t understand what the teacher was talking about and he had decided that he was just to stupid to understand it. I have been working closely with the teacher to help my son so that he can once again feel confident about himself but after listening to other parents, this is clearly not an isolated incident. That being the case, I don’t want to just sit back and say, well my child has been taken care of so to hell with all the other students that may be having the same issues today and in the future. When I posted my question on this board I didn’t bash Johnny Can Spell but instead asked if anyone had experience with it and if so, what was their opinion. Clearly I am not alone and I have yet to see anyone who has had first had experience with it who finds this to be a useful learn tool for their children. I love the idea of a phonics based program but Johnny Can Spell places so much importance on marking the words that it seems to lose focus on the real objective of teaching the children to read. I think that I will go ahead and get my petition together and get signatures before my meeting with the principle. I am also going to research what the other schools in Humble ISD are teaching and their success rate. I want to be fully informed and prepared to make my case before I ever go into any meeting. I want to thank everyone who has taken the time to share his or her opinion about this issue, as it has been very helpful to me. 

Fallon --- 20 years ago -

Keep following your instincts Irb, you are doing a great job. Especailly for parents who want to stand up for their child but really may not know how to! 

qpc --- 20 years ago -

Can anyone whose kids are in public school share some examples of spelling words that their child is working on? I'm interested in seeing 1st, 3rd, and/or 4th grade. Just wanted to see how my kids' work related. Thanks! 

Big Mama --- 20 years ago -

I was talking to my daughter the other day and she was telling me about this site and how some parents were complaining about the Johnny Can Spell program. I was so irritated after reading the comments that I felt like I needed to voice my opinion. My grandchild goes to Foster and learned Johnny Can Spell in K-3rd. I'm very involved with my grandchild and I found that it really improved his reading, spelling, and writing because of the solid foundation that the teachers provided. I know that many people disagree with the program because they cannot send the list home, but my grandchild was very successful because the teachers taught the program so well. As I was reading this discussion I found it ironic that several of the complaining parents themselves cannot spell correctly. I appreciate Foster and admire the principal (aka-principle)/teachers for all the hard work and dedication they provide for our children. 

mdawg --- 20 years ago -

There are good teachers and bad teachers. The way one teacher teaches the program, does not mean others will teach it the same way. Every teacher has their own teaching style. Also not all children learn the same way. The program may work for some and it might not work for others. Going by numbers it's pretty easy to say the program does not work for the majority of students. Sooner or later the school will have to drop this cirriculum and go with what other schools are doing. JMHO! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
children


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground