Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Need Advice - Jehovah Witness Friend at Work

who's talking here?

mugglemom 1
MAD 5
blessed 1
poodle_lover 2
Proudmomof2 3
FirePrincess 4
GCan 1
Lilteapot 1
Fallon 3
Stephanie 8
ACwife 2
I Love Horses 3
bbjones 8
Maria C 2
Sandyr9111 1
Anderson 3
NowandThen 1
momofthreeatascosita 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

OK - I want your views and advice on a situation. I DO NOT want this thread to turn into any sort of bashing at all - please. I have a very good friend at work who is a Jehovah Witness. We're only friends at work so there is not interaction outside of work. She and I very much respect each other's faith and when things such as what's going on in the middle east comes up we ask each other our religious perspective so we know where each "religion" stands so to speak. Anyway, yesterday we were sitting at lunch chatting about one of her niece's who is autistic and one that has down syndrome. A couple of us made the comment that it takes the right kind of person to raise a child like that and I piped in that I think God chooses those who he wants to raise those children because he knows who can and can't handle it. My friend was very nice but sternly said "it's a pet peeve of mine, God doesn't give anyone those kind of children." I was a little taken back by this remark that I couldn't answer. She saw the surprise on my face and just said she was sorry but she hates it when people say that. After thinking about this, I thought, well, I need to respond because this is bothering me. Doesn't God make every child "perfect" in his eyes? I mean, to me, that's like saying that people who find out ahead of time they may be having a child that's going to have a disease or something when they choose to abort, it's ok, because it wasn't a perfect child from God. I'm just looking for your views. Especially if you feel the same as she does or has experience with her religion. Thanks. 

Sandyr9111 --- 20 years ago -

Sounds like her own religious thing. We believe that God does everything for a reason. Maybe someone else doesnt. Think that would be a subject I just left alone. 

Lilteapot --- 20 years ago -

gotta say, i agree with your view on this one, i have no idea where she is coming from??? 

Maria C --- 20 years ago -

If you believe in Satan being ushered out of Heaven? My brother was told, by God, when he ushered Satan out of HEAVEN, that SATAN was going to get revenge on him while on Earth. SO God caused him to be Mentally Retarded, so Satan will not be able to affect him. INTERESTING when you see the bigger picture of life. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Stephanie, "I piped in that I think God chooses those who he wants to raise those children because he knows who can and can't handle it" Sort of true....because GOD NEVER GIVES US MORE THAN WE CAN HANDLE. Stephanie, "Doesn't God make every child "perfect" in his eyes?" I would say yes to that also....but his eyes see what ours can not. But....and I am probably gonna get shafted for saying this.....some children suffer the consequences of their parents own sin. Take a look at a drug addicted baby....would God want to call that perfect?..NOPE...but God did not make the child drug addicted---the sinful mother did!! 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

Stephanie, Let me say that I think that Jehovah Witness is a cult. If you want to know why, I can get to that later. That being said, on your topic, your friend is right. God created Adam and Eve perfectly. We do have the genetic code from that perfect creation, however it has been degraded because of sin. He DID NOT create each one of us individually. "Psalms 51:5 Behold, I was shapen in iniquity; and in sin did my mother conceive me." He WOULD not because of sin entering the world. Genesis 3:16 "Unto the woman he said, I will greatly multiply thy sorrow and thy conception; in sorrow thou shalt bring forth children; and thy desire shall be to thy husband, and he shall rule over thee." We are born through reproductive conception. We become "perfect" in God's eyes when we accept His Son as Lord and Savior and then God creates a new spirit in us and we are "born again". You wrote "I mean, to me, that's like saying that people who find out ahead of time they may be having a child that's going to have a disease or something when they choose to abort, it's ok, because it wasn't a perfect child from God." We are told by God that it is wrong to do this - each individual, eventhough conceived in sin, has the opportunity to accept the free gift that God has provided. 

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

Yes, yes, I can see... Thanks for the scripture Steve... I needed this. I always try to base my responses on biblical scripture when responding to her. Anderson, sitting here thinking about it - you are right... It's hard to think about in that context because we are also admitting that we're not perfect which is why it's so important for us to bring our children up knowing the bible and how to make the right choices... Wow.... 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

Sort of true....because GOD NEVER GIVES US MORE THAN WE CAN HANDLE I know where you are coming from on this Anderson, so please don't take this as criticism. I think that sometimes we misinterpret the Scripture behind this (I can do all things through Christ which strengthens me). I think that sometimes we DO get more than WE can handle, just not more than HE can handle in and through us. It is a minor distinction, yet one that can make a tremendous difference in the way a person views trials. I know that there are things I have gone through that I kept thinking and telling God "I can't do this" but God said to me "I know you can't, but I can". 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

"It is a minor distinction, yet one that can make a tremendous difference in the way a person views trials." I completely agree with MAD....just didn't want to get too detailed...LOL...skipped to the "easy" version. =) 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

Oh. believe me....I understand :) 

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

I totally agree that God will give us major things that will either crush us or bring us closer to him. We've had this happen a few times in my family/marriage and I have to tell ya, I think without the definite help of my husband helping me with my faith, I would have walked away from the situation. Now, I'm really thanking God for him!!! 

Proudmomof2 --- 20 years ago -

I know some religions believe that kids with disabilities are kids of satan rather than god.... I totally disagree of course... I have mentally handicapped brother and I think he was "gifted" to my family to teach my father to love all people including those with handicaps... Make since?? 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Lonnie, "some religions believe that kids with disabilities are kids of satan rather than god" Really??? Wow...I had no idea anyone thought that. 

FirePrincess --- 20 years ago -

I would probably just talk to her and agree to disagree. Apologize if your comment offended her, and move on. I wouldn't ignore the situation...it would probably cause tension. That being said...I do not agree with her beliefs. I slam the door on the Jehovah's Witnesses when they show up at my door. That's JMO though. 

Proudmomof2 --- 20 years ago -

Anderson, I was shocked also, I happen to have a Brother in Law that feels this way. I know these children are as innocent and pure as they come , if anyone is sin free its these kids... 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

MAD I am not trying to be confrontational and this may only be a minor distinction, but the Scripture behind "GOD NEVER GIVES US MORE THAN WE CAN HANDLE " is actually 1 Corinthians 10:13 "There hath no temptation taken you but such as is common to man: but God is faithful, who will not suffer you to be tempted above that ye are able; but will with the temptation also make a way to escape, that ye may be able to bear it." Paul is warning the Corinthians against idolatry and immorality like that engaged in by the Israelites in the desert (1 Cor.10:6-11). The actual promise, found in 10:13 is that God will not let us be tempted beyond our ability but will provide a way of escape so that we can withstand the temptation without giving into sin. Philippians 4:13 "I can do all things through Christ which strengtheneth me." does deal with the same issues but the other verse is the one which has been paraphrased. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

Lonnie No one is born sin free or born innocent and pure. 

poodle_lover --- 20 years ago -

i kinda like the J.W. religion I think they got it going on. Thinking about joining them. I tell my kids every Christmas that next year Im turning J.W. they dont have to buy Christmas presents, birthday presents, dont have to go in inlaws for HOlidays because they dont celebrate holidays. Sounding pretty good to me. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

Stephanie, Do you really believe that "God will give us major things that will either crush us or bring us closer to him"? Would a loving God do that? God does allow bad things to happen to us, which will shape our faith, because of free will and sin. He is not doing this to us, but He does know that they will happen. He can choose to protect us and He will when we rely on Him. 

Fallon --- 20 years ago -

You know Connie, putting it like that sounds gooood. We took care of all that family stuff by moving over a thousand miles away from all of ours:) But they still managae to find during Christmas. Now as for birthdays, no options there, got to have a cake and one pretty box nicey wrapped. Don't care if it is a can opener that I get, I just want one pretty box:) I have Christmas taken care of already, I just don't do a ton of toys and useless gifts. But I do donate a huge, last year 3 large bags, amount of toys and food to St. Stevens Socitey at Kingwood United Methodist Church. I'm not a member there, but they have a rockin program. 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

Philippians 4:13 "I can do all things through Christ which strengtheneth me." does deal with the same issues but the other verse is the one which has been paraphrased. I guess it is who you talk to. I've had the Phil. verse also quoted to me as proof that "God doesn't give us more than we can handle" as well as the 1 Cor. verse. I chose the Phil verse bacause it didn't deal with "temptation" which having a child with a disablity didn't really have anything to do with. 

Maria C --- 20 years ago -

CONNIE nice comment ! Ha I am with you. 

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

I slam the door on the Jehovah's Witnesses when they show up at my door. Kelli - my friend told me that the JW take this as a sign that they are doing something right. That they are "right" when this happens to them. My whole point on the issue of God giving us things that will either crush us or move us closer - well, that was just the way I said it. I believe that we as Christians aren't immune from the sins of this world, or the things that come to pass. God will allow things to happen and it will either bring us closer to Him or it won't. It's a test of faith. Maybe I'm just not conveying that correctly. Anyway, I think many of you here hit the nail on the head and gave me what I needed to respond. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

Stephanie You have to understand that God does not give us "non-perfect" children, temptation, hardship, etc. Those all come from sin which entered this world through misuse of free will. God does give us a way to deal with these issues - by relying upon Him. By saying that God creates us all in the womb, we would be comparing our selves to the "immaculate conception" which would put us on par with Jesus - which we are not. 

poodle_lover --- 20 years ago -

JW have not been back to my house since the day my husband answered the door. He can talk the ears off an elephant. He just invites them in and starts rambling on and on and on about anything. They never got to mention their religion and were just happy to get away from my husband 

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

Wow - I didn't know this. I thought the 144k were Jews?? Anyway, she got angry with me one time because I mentioned the "rapture." She said she couldn't believe in a word that isn't in the bible. My comment was that "watchtower" wasn't in the bible yet they use that more than scripture itself. I do know that the JW believe you can't get into heaven without "works" which is one reason they are knocking on doors. 

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

Anyway, I don't want to get off point here. I really thank you for the input. I don't have time to learn about other religions, so I take this as an opportunity to listen and be heard. Who knows, maybe one day I'll say something that will strike the right chord in her. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

MAD It is only a technicality, but I was just pointing out that the "GOD NEVER GIVES US MORE THAN WE CAN HANDLE" phrase is a paraphrase of "but God is faithful, who will not suffer you to be tempted above that ye are able". Temptation does have something to do with it because some people decide to abort the child with a disability and some institutionalize them, and some treat them with physical abuse. They are "tempted" to do these things. Like I said previously, Philippians 4:13 "does deal with the same issues but the other verse is the one which has been paraphrased." You are not wrong by saying that we need Christ to deal with the adversity and not succumb to the temptation to do the wrong thing. 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

Psalm 139:13-14 For Thou didst form my inward parts; Thou didst weave me in my mother's womb. I will give thanks to Thee, for I am fearfully and wonderfully made; wonderful are Thy works, and my soul knows it very well. God ways are not our ways and His thoughts are not our thoughts. What we may consider a burden is considered "fearfully and wonderfully made" by the Creator 

I Love Horses --- 20 years ago -

You know people like that really get on my nerves, i have a cousin that is a wonderful person, and she was blessed with a beautiful baby that had down sydrom and hydrocephalis sp? he was only on this earth for 5 years and he was the most precious child i have ever been around, i and his mother believe he was a GIFT FROM GOD and was put on this earth for a reason, he touched the lives of every person he came in contact with, and reading this just brought me to tears i was soo upset about how close minded people really are! I dislike jahova witnesses altogether, i respect that is the choice they made but that does not mean i have to like it. I had a freind going up that was a jahovas witnes and her dad was a horrable person and tried to abuse me and my other freind and when we refused he said that is fine in heaven he can have us anytime he wants. I said i dont think so because you will in hell!! so that is what probably turned me off to them to begin with but my experiences with them after that have not changed any of my views toward them. Anyways sorry for the rant, i just could not sit by and not say anything. 

GCan --- 20 years ago -

I have a relative that's being "converted." His wife was the first to go and now she's dragging him along. He tries to explain his point of view about only believing in the bible but it's a JW bible and it is read in conjunction with the WT booklet. Basically, it's like Cliff Notes for the bible. They believe that they have a direct channel of communication God, etc. and they are schooled in methods/arguments to refute other religions teachings. I could go on and on! 

I Love Horses --- 20 years ago -

They also belive they are the only religion that is going to heaven. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

MAD Psalm 139:13-14 refers to the fact that God created human reproduction and through His Creation we were able to be conceived. Everyone that is born is due to God's initial Creation, so by default you could say that God had a hand in all babies being "created". 

I Love Horses --- 20 years ago -

Amen bbjones, thanks for quoting that. 

FirePrincess --- 20 years ago -

Stephanie, The reason I now slam the door on them is because I've had them get VERY RUDE when I've tried to nicely tell them I'm not interested. I hate to hear that it gives them satisfaction. They just really scared me the time they were yelling at me. 

ACwife --- 20 years ago -

Stephanie, I have a book entitled "Jehovah's Witnesses Answered...verse by verse" by David A. Reed...formerly a very zealous Jehovah's witness. It's an easy read and a great book if you ever encounter the opportunity to speak with her about her beliefs...OR, you could just give her the book to read. After all, the author WAS a Jehovah's witness, so maybe she'll be more likely to accept it and read it. 

MAD --- 20 years ago -

 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

ACwife That is a good idea, but Jehovah's Witness is very familiar with that person and their fellow cultists have been told that he is a liar. It is doubtful that she would read it. 

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

Kelli - I don't blame you at all for slamming the door in the case. I personally have not had that happen to me. The JW who have in the past come to my door have been very nice. I personally won't get into a biblical conversation with them. In my experience, it really does no good - they believe everyone is wrong and thier truth is right. I have had my friend actually agree with several things I told her I believe and several that we've ended to agree to disagree. ACWife - thanks for the book offer, I may read it for my own personal gain but she would never read it. 

FirePrincess --- 20 years ago -

I've had nice jehovah's witnesses ONE time at my door. That was before the weirdos. Now I just ignore the door if I can tell it's them. The mormons are always nice when they come to the door and I have no problem with them. They are on more of a mission type thing. The JW treat you like dirt if you don't agree with them. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground