Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Foreign Aid

who's talking here?

wayward1 1
SoupIsGoodFood 1
Porter Wagoner 1
Dorothy Parker 1
Joe Blow 1
gunsnroses 1
Emperor of Kingwood 7
Butterbean 2
AMDG 18
Zapper009 1
fuzz81 1
Publius 5
urabunchcats 10

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Joe Blow --- 9 years ago -

"Take Jordan and Lebanon, fragile islands of stability in the Middle East today. Increased American assistance could be the difference between those two nations surviving as functioning states and sliding into a Syria-like chaos. The financial support Jordan and Lebanon need to remain economically viable is a drop in the bucket compared to the cost if either one descended into civil strife. Seven decades ago, amid the rubble of World War II, the United States understood the value of spending money to repair economies, democracies, and civil societies [-the "Marshall Plan"]. That commitment to funding the building blocks of peace has disappeared. In 1949, the United States spent 3 percent of its gross domestic product on this type of foreign assistance [-And this, after going heavily into debt prosecuting an expensive war.]. Today, that number is about two tenths of a percentage point [0.2%], a 93 percent reduction. To use another illustration: Today, the Defense Department has more military band members than the State Department has diplomats [-There are less than 7000 foreign service personnel in the Dept of State.]." -Chris Murphy, "Marshall Plans, Not Martial Plans": NY Times, OP-ED: p. A-15. Monday, January 2, 2017. 

gunsnroses --- 9 years ago -

Obamas vacation cost the American taxpayers over 85 MILLION dollars! Not to mention the latest one to Hawaii. Why didn't he wait three weeks when he is out of Office and go on "his own dime". What a LOSER ! 

urabunchcats --- 9 years ago -

^^^ understatement! ^^^

JB - Have you looked at our cash reserves?

FYI - we don't have any.

We are 19+ Trillion in debt.

The U.S. life boat won't carry/can't support everyone.



. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

JB - Have you looked at our cash reserves?

FYI - we don't have any.


We have an unlimited (almost) amount of cash 

urabunchcats --- 9 years ago -

I don't believe ability to print more "cash" is a viable method to make our debt go away.

It would be cool if we could get away with it. I wonder how much 19 Trillion dollars worth of 100 dollar bills weigh?

Robbing Peter to pay Paul is not a good plan. Unfortunately our country has been borrowing money from our future families for decades. Someday our heirs will be paying our debts.

I doubt anyone of us here would ever consider doing that to our children or grandchildren.

Except maybe DP, Fuzz, Miss, Joe, Tink, Butter, .....

You know - "them"



. 

Publius --- 9 years ago -

US supporting the responsible parties in the middle East (Lebanon, Jordan, Israel, the Egyptian military)? - what a novel thought... 

Zapper009 --- 9 years ago -

Obamas vacation cost the American taxpayers over 85 MILLION dollars! Not to mention the latest one to Hawaii. Why didn't he wait three weeks when he is out of Office and go on "his own dime". What a LOSER !?

I am so glad that you are ALWAYS so perceptive - and focus on the really important things in life...NOT!!! 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 9 years ago -

Best part?

He'll be on a permanent vacation in about 16 days.

Hallelujah 

urabunchcats --- 9 years ago -

Yeah but unfortunately on our dime.



. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

-Chris Murphy, "Marshall Plans, Not Martial Plans": NY Times, OP-ED: p. A-15. Monday, January 2, 2017.

Obviously someone who has no clue about the original purpose of the Marshall Plan. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

Today, that number is about two tenths of a percentage point [0.2%], a 93 percent reduction. To use another illustration: Today, the Defense Department has more military band members than the State Department has diplomats [-There are less than 7000 foreign service personnel in the Dept of State.]."

Good. At least the band members have a skill and can do something useful.

Its a ridiculous analogy. 

wayward1 --- 9 years ago -

We give food or military equipment as foreign aid. Both are controlled by contracts with corporations.

That's what controls our foreign aid. Just try wrestling away $3B in military aid for Egypt from General Dynamics.
Or, try taking food aid to Africa away from Archer Daniels Midland (ADM).

It's a money making scheme controlled by lobbyists and congressman. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

I don't believe ability to print more "cash" is a viable method to make our debt go away.

It would be cool if we could get away with it. I wonder how much 19 Trillion dollars worth of 100 dollar bills weigh?

Robbing Peter to pay Paul is not a good plan. Unfortunately our country has been borrowing money from our future families for decades. Someday our heirs will be paying our debts.

I doubt anyone of us here would ever consider doing that to our children or grandchildren.

Except maybe DP, Fuzz, Miss, Joe, Tink, Butter, .....

You know - "them"


urabunch - look up modern monetary theory - do some reading with an open mind. It is not a perfect theory (no such thing) but it is the best explanation of how our modern economy works.

The common belief that deficits are by definition bad - is just not true. They are neither good nor bad, they just are. And the way a fiat economy works has absolutely nothing to do with how a personal economy, or for that matter a public non-fiat economy works.

Worth and hour or two to understand this economic theory IMO 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

It would be cool if we could get away with it. I wonder how much 19 Trillion dollars worth of 100 dollar bills weigh?

Actually, in theory it would weight nothing. In theory the government could pay every debt with a key stroke on a computer.

There is just no economic reason to. As long as there is faith and confidence in the ability of the government to meet its obligations, which there is, has been, and will be - as long as there is no artificial debt celling enacted. Than there is no reason to pay any debt before maturity.

As an additional aside, and a point all those who abhor the deficit should remember is that every single dollar, that is every single dollar of the deficit was a dollar created by the government and placed in the private sector. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

As an additional aside, and a point all those who abhor the deficit should remember is that every single dollar, that is every single dollar of the deficit was a dollar created by the government and placed in the private sector.

Are you meaning deficit or debt? 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

Are you meaning deficit or debt?

Deficit - 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

deficit is just the difference between revenue and expenditures. Closing that gap is debt.

Mounting debt is not a good thing unless your a Keynesian theorist. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

the difference between what the gov spends, and its tax revenue is money created and moved to the private sector. Every dollar - by definition. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

the difference between what the gov spends, and its tax revenue is money created and moved to the private sector. Every dollar - by definition.

the difference between what the gov spends, and its tax revenue is money BORROWED FROM THE FUTURE and moved to the private sector. Every dollar - by definition. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

BORROWED FROM THE FUTURE

no it is not, not in the least - any more than if you had a large credit card bill and an unlimited money making machine - It would make no difference at all what your balance was. Your only choice is would it be in your interest to make the payments or pay it off. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

In a macro sense - you, me, all of us - our tax payments have nothing to do with paying down the debt - the only macro reason the government takes back dollars in taxes is to curb inflation, that's it.

It has no need of our money to buy anything. It could take all the tax dollars collected on april 15th and burn them - and it would have no impact.

I know it is very weird - but the entire world changed when we left the gold standard. Almost everything I learned in macro economics in the late 60's was about irrelevant by the mid 70's.

I am just having some fun pointing it out here, with some what would appear crazy scenarios - but it is truly worth spending some time to read and understand MMT. The use of the deficit and the fear it generates is much much much more political than economic. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

Looking for a short summary of MMT - this is not bad

Here we go with the basics of Modern Monetary Theory.

For the past four thousand years (?at least?, as John Maynard Keynes put it?see note at bottom), our monetary system has been a ?state money system?. To simplify, that is one in which the state chooses the money of account, imposes obligations denominated in that money unit, and issues a currency accepted in payment of those obligations. While a variety of types of obligations have been imposed (tribute, tithes, fines, and fees), today taxes are the most important monetary obligations payable to the state in its own currency.

There is an approach that begins its analysis of money from this perspective, now called Modern Money Theory (MMT). It is based on the work of Keynes, but also on others such as A. Mitchell Innes, Georg F. Knapp, Abba Lerner, Hyman Minsky, Wynne Godley, and many others?stretching back to Adam Smith and before. It ?stands on the shoulders of giants?, as Minsky put it.

Its research has stretched across the sub-disciplines of economics, including history of thought, economic history, monetary theory, unemployment and poverty, finance and financial institutions, sectoral balances, cycles and crises, and monetary and fiscal policy. It has largely updated and synthesized various strands of theory, most of it heterodox?outside the mainstream.

Perhaps the most important original contribution of MMT has been the detailed study of the coordination of operations between the treasury and the central bank. The central bank is the treasury?s bank, making and receiving payments on behalf of the treasury. The procedures involved can obscure how the government ?really spends?. While it was obvious two hundred years ago that the national treasury spent by issuing currency, and taxed by receiving its own currency in payment, that is no longer so obvious because the central bank stands between the treasury and recipients of government spending as well as between treasury and taxpayers making payments to government.

However, as MMT has shown, nothing of substance has changed?even though taxpayers today make payments from their private bank accounts, and banks make the tax payments to treasury for their depositors using reserves held at the central bank. And when treasury spends, its central bank credits reserve accounts of private banks, which credit deposit accounts of recipients of the government spending.

In spite of the greater complexity involved, we lose nothing of significance by saying that government spends currency into existence and taxpayers use that currency to pay their obligations to the state.



MMT reaches conclusions that are shocking to many who?ve been indoctrinated in the conventional wisdom. Most importantly, it challenges the orthodox views about government finance, monetary policy, the so-called Phillips Curve (inflation-unemployment) trade-off, the wisdom of fixed exchange rates, and the folly of striving for current account surpluses.

For most people, the greatest challenge to near-and-dear convictions is MMT?s claim that a sovereign government?s finances are nothing like those of households and firms. While we hear all the time the statement that ?if I ran my household budget the way that the Federal Government runs its budget, I?d go broke?, followed by the claim ?therefore, we need to get the government deficit under control?, MMT argues this is a false analogy. A sovereign, currency-issuing government is NOTHING like a currency-using household or firm. The sovereign government cannot become insolvent in its own currency; it can always make all payments as they come due in its own currency.

Indeed, if government spends currency into existence, it clearly does not need tax revenue before it can spend. Further, if taxpayers pay their taxes using currency, then government must first spend before taxes can be paid. Again, all of this was obvious two hundred years ago when kings literally stamped coins in order to spend, and then received their own coins in tax payment.

Another shocking truth is that a sovereign government does not need to ?borrow? its own currency in order to spend. Indeed, it cannot borrow currency that it has not already spent! This is why MMT sees the sale of government bonds as something quite different from borrowing.

When government sells bonds, banks buy them by offering reserves they hold at the central bank. The central bank debits the buying bank?s reserve deposits and credits the bank?s account with treasury securities. Rather than seeing this as borrowing by treasury, it is more akin to shifting deposits out of a checking account and into a saving account in order to earn more interest. And, indeed, treasury securities really are nothing more than a saving account at the Fed that pay more interest than do reserve deposits (bank ?checking accounts?) at the Fed.

MMT recognizes that bond sales by sovereign government are really part of monetary policy operations. While this gets a bit technical, the operational purpose of such bond sales is to help the central bank hit its overnight interest rate target (called the fed funds rate in the US). Sales of treasury bonds reduce bank reserves and are used to remove excess reserves that would place downward pressure on overnight rates. Purchases of bonds (called an open market purchase) by the Fed add reserves to the banking system, prevent overnight rates from rising. Hence, the Fed and Treasury cooperate using bond sales/bond purchases to enable the Fed to keep the fed funds rate on target.

You don?t need to understand all of that to get the main point: sovereign governments don?t need to borrow their own currency in order to spend! They offer interest-paying treasury securities as an instrument on which banks, firms, households, and foreigners can earn interest. This is a policy choice, not a necessity. Government never needs to sell bonds before spending, and indeed cannot sell bonds unless it has first provided the currency and reserves that banks need to buy the bonds.

So, much like the relation between taxes and spending?with tax collection coming after spending?we should think of bond sales as occurring after government has already spent the currency and reserves.

Most Americans are familiar with the phrase ?raise a tally?, which referred to the use of notched ?tally sticks? that served as the currency of European monarchs. The sticks were split (into a stock and stub) and matched by the exchequer on tax day. The crown?s obligation to accept his tally debt was ?wiped clean? just as the taxpayer?s obligation to deliver the tally debt was fulfilled. Clearly, the taxpayer could not deliver tally sticks until they had been spent.

It surprises most people to hear that banks operate in a similar manner. They lend their own IOUs into existence and accept them in payment. A hundred years ago, a bank would issue its own banknotes when it made a loan. The debtor would repay loans by delivering bank notes. Banks had to create the notes before debtors could pay down debts using banknotes.

In the old days in the US, notes issued by various banks were not necessarily accepted at par?if you tried to pay down your loan from St. Louis Bank using notes issued by Chicago Bank, they might be worth only 75 cents on the dollar.

The Federal Reserve System was created in part to ensure par clearing. At the same time, we essentially taxed private bank notes out of existence. Banks switched to the use of deposits and cleared accounts among each other using the Fed?s IOUs, called reserves. The important point is that banks now create deposits when they make loans; debtors repay those loans using bank deposits. And what this means is that banks need to create the deposits first before borrowers can repay their loans.

Hence, there is a symmetry to the way the sovereign spends currency (or central bank reserves) into existence first, and then taxpayers use the currency (or central bank reserves) to pay taxes.

Sovereigns spend first, then tax. In that sense, they do not ?need? tax revenue in order to spend. This does not mean that sovereigns can stop taxing, however. MMT says that one of the purposes of the tax system is to ?drive? the currency. One of the reasons people will accept the sovereign?s currency is that taxes need to be paid in that currency. From inception of the currency, no one would take it unless the currency was needed to make a payment. Taxes and other obligations create a demand for the currency that can be used to make the obligatory payments.

Note that we can say something similar about banknotes and bank deposits. Part of the reason we will accept them in payment is because ?we? (at least, many of us) have obligations that need to be paid using banknotes or bank deposits. We?ve got a mortgage debt, or a credit card debt or a car loan debt?all of which normally are paid by writing a check on our bank deposit account. We can fill-up that account by accepting checks drawn on other bank deposit accounts, and with the Fed ensuring par clearing, our bank will accept those checks.

While there is a symmetry between government currency issue and private bank issue of notes or deposit, there are also asymmetries.

Government imposes a tax obligation on (at least some) citizens. Private banks rely on customers voluntarily entering into an obligation (that is, they decide to become borrowers). We can all ?choose? to refuse to become borrowers, but as they say, the only thing certain in life is ?death and taxes??these are much harder to avoid. Sovereign power is usually reserved to the state. This makes its own obligations?currency and reserves?almost universally acceptable within its jurisdiction.

Indeed, banks and others normally make their own obligations convertible into the state?s obligations. This is why we call bank checking accounts ?demand deposits?: banks promise to exchange their own obligations to the state?s obligations on ?demand?.

For this reason, MMT talks about a ?money pyramid?, with the state?s own currency at the top. Bank ?money? (notes and deposits) are below the state?s ?money? (reserves and currency). We can think of other financial institution liabilities as below ?bank money? in the pyramid, often payable in bank deposits. Lower still we find the liabilities of nonfinancial institutions. And at the bottom we might find the IOUs of households?again normally payable in the obligations of financial institutions.

A lot of people have great difficulty in getting their heads around all this ?money creation? business. It sounds like alchemy or even fraud. Banks simply create deposits when they make loans? Government simply creates currency or central bank reserves when it spends? What is this, creation of money out of thin air?

Yes, indeed.

Hyman Minsky used to say that ?Anyone can create money?; but ?the problem lies in getting it accepted?.
You must understand that ?money? is by nature an IOU. You can create a dollar-denominated ?money? by writing ?IOU five dollars? on a slip of paper. Your problem is to get someone to accept it. Sovereign government has an easy time finding acceptors?in part because millions of us owe payments to government.

Bank of America has an easy time finding acceptors?in part because millions of us owe payments to Bank of America, in part because we know we can exchange deposits at the bank for cash, and in part because we know the Fed stands behind the bank to ensure par clearing with any other bank. However, very few people owe you, and we doubt your ability to convert your IOU to Uncle Sam?s IOU at par. You are low in that money pyramid.

Both Uncle Sam and Bank of America are constrained in their ?money creation?, however. Uncle Sam is subject to the budget authority that is provided by Congress and the President. Occasionally he also bumps up against the crazy (yes, crazy!) Congressionally-imposed ?debt limit?. Congress and the President could and should remove that debt limit, but we surely do want a budgeting process and we want to ensure that Uncle Sam is constrained by the approved budget.

Still, Uncle Sam ought to be spending more whenever we?ve got unemployment.

Bank of America is subjected to capital constraints and limits on the types of loans it can make (and types of other assets it can hold). Yes, we freed the banks from most regulations and supervision over the past couple of decades?to our regret. Those with the ?magic porridge pot? do need to be constrained. Banks can, and frequently do, make too many (bad) loans?which can bubble up markets and create solvency problems for them and even for their customers. Prudent lending is a virtue that ought to be required.

The problem is not the ?thin air? nature of the creation, but rather the quantities of ?money? created and the purposes for which it was created. Government spending for the public purpose is beneficial, at least up to the point of full employment of the nation?s resources. Bank lending for public and private purposes that are beneficial publicly and privately is also generally desirable.

However, lending comes with risk and requires good underwriting (assessment of credit worthiness); unfortunately our biggest banks largely abandoned the underwriting process in the 1990s, with disastrous results. One can only hope that policy-makers will restore the good banking practices that were developed over the past half-millennium, shutting down the largest dozen global banks that have no interest in good banking.

Some have given up hope in our banking system. I?m sympathetic to their pessimistic views. Some want to go back to ?greenbacks? or to the Chicago Plan?s ?narrow banks?.

Some even want to eliminate private money creation! Have the government issue ?debt-free money?! I?m sympathetic, but I don?t support the most extreme proposals even if I support the goals. Such proposals are based on a fundamental misunderstanding of our monetary system.

Our system is a state money system. Our currency is government?s liability, an IOU that is redeemable for tax obligations and other payments to the state. The phrase ?debt-free money? is based on a misunderstanding. Remember, ?anyone can create money?, the ?problem is to get it accepted?. They are all IOUs. They are either spent or lent into existence. Their issuers must accept them in payment. They are accepted by those who will make payments, directly or indirectly, to the issuers.

In the developed nations we have thoroughly monetized the economies. Much (maybe most) of our economic activity requires money, and we need specialized institutions that can issue widely accepted monetary IOUs to enable that activity to get underway.

While our governments are large, they are not big enough to provide all the monetary IOUs we need for the scale of economic activity we desire. And we?at least we Americans?are skeptical of putting all monetized economic activity in the hands of a much bigger government. I cannot see any possibility of running a modern, monetized, capitalist economy without private financial institutions that create the monetary IOUs needed to initiate economic activity.

The answer, it seems to me, to our current financial calamities does not reside in elimination of our for-profit financial institutions, even if I do see a positive role to be played by new public financial institutions (maybe some national development banks and some state development banks and a revived postal saving system?).

We do, however, need fundamental reform?including downsizing (probably breaking up or closing) of the behemoths, greater oversight, more transparency, prosecution of financial fraud, and putting more of the ?public? in our ?public-private partnership? banking institutions. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

MMT - Video

If you would rather watch than read 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

I understand that you are a Keynesian theorist. I'm not, I'm much more neo classical because it more closely aligns with my view of the role of government. Because something is "modern" doesn't make it more correct. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

Did you watch the video ??? By the way Modern in the title I think means like post 1972 - it is Keynesian in some ways - but very different in others. 

Butterbean --- 9 years ago -

Most foreign aid helps American's bottom line. I'm an American. I like most foreign aid.

Call it a redistribution of wealth, if you like, and rail about it. Generally, it's good for General Bullmoose. 

urabunchcats --- 9 years ago -

AMDG - Everyone has opinions and preferences.

1) Some people lease a car.
2) Some people buy a new car every year.
3) Some people begrudgingly buy a newer USED car only when it make best economic sense as the maintenance required to keep the older existing car operational is getting to the point where it will cost more money to maintain the existing car than the buying and maintaining a newer USED car.

I could be a 1 or a 2 - I am a 3 - because I want to be a 3. I want our government to be a 3.

Our GOBERMENT is a 1 because MONEY IS FREE. The GOBERMENT spends like a drunken sailor.
0

As long as the GOBERMENT is spending someone else's money - GOBERMENT will not spend our money well.

Water finds it own level - stand back and don't ARTIFICIALLY upset (manipulate) the apple cart. (our economy)

Especially when it comes to the GOBERMENT spending our money in bad ways and impacting OUR apple cart.

Like a FOUR BILLION dollar Air Force One.

It would be in our best interests to TRIM government back to the bare minimum - as originally intended.

No professional politicians. It is a service - not a career.

Debt is BAD. Living within your means is GOOD.

The money is not the GOBERMENT's money - is is OUR MONEY.

(We are not their servants - they are not our land lords - they work for us)

The GOBERMENT borrowing money to GIVE money away - is TOTAL CRAP!

SERVICING the DEBT will cost TAX PAYERS TRILLIONS. DEBT is BAD!

Interest Expense on the Debt Outstanding

TAXING us less is good.

TAXING us more to pay for anything that is not good (you fill in the blank) .... is bad.
Like a FOUR BILLION dollar Air Force One.

Taxing us more to give to (you fill in the F'ing blank) .... is bad.

BTW: Good = military/roads/police/courts/....

Government has a place - Ours has just grown WAY TOO BIG!

We can't afford to give money away.


. 

Butterbean --- 9 years ago -

I like being General Bullmoose.

I like making money.

I like hiding my income any legal way I can.

I like it when you pay more taxes than me.

Edited to add: I see you found my publicity picture. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

Urabunch - did you watch the link? 

urabunchcats --- 9 years ago -

Yes.

MMT seems to completely ignore 2 huge variables:

Competition with other countries
Propensity for private sector investment

At some point on the horizon the confidence in our nations ability to repay its ever growing debt will stagger and crash.

Civil unrest will be very bad.

The train wreck is coming unless we change course and get our spending and debt under control.



. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

urabunch - thanks for looking at it.

MMT seems to completely ignore 2 huge variables:

Competition with other countries
Propensity for private sector investment


Both are accounted for in MMT

if a country has a trade surplus, than more dollars to spend are entering the country, contributing to activity - generating employment - meaning less need for government spending, lower deficits.

If a country has a trade deficit - the opposite. Dollars leaving the country - need to be replaced, more need for government spending, larger deficit.

Money leaving the economy due to private investment, is handled by the bond market - the government take dollars out of bank reserves and in return give them t bills -

Investment is economic activity ( buying stock, opening businesses, etc is spending for MMT purposes.)

There are 2 related issues with MMT. The first is, does the government spending directly reduce unemployment - which should be the only real goal. So if the dollars spent do not stimulate growth - they probably should not be spent. The related issue is the amount of wealth held by the ultra rich. In MMT terms this is hording - and all those dollars need to be replaced into the economy. It is related because there is a school of thought that says much of the deficit spending eventually ends up in these peoples hands. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

At some point on the horizon the confidence in our nations ability to repay its ever growing debt will stagger and crash.

The surest way to crash the economy would be to give into the unsupportable fear that the current deficit is crippling ( no proof at all that it is, or will be) or the fear that it will be some burden for future generations that we need to address ( no proof at all either)

There are only 2 ways to do this.

1. reduce government spending down to where tax revenues are greater than spending. - the almost immediate effect of that will be a dramatic slow down of demand for products and services, putting pressure on business which will reduce productions - lay people off and slow down the economy.

2. Increase taxes, to a point where tax revenue is greater than spending. Other than being completely undoable from a political POV - It will have the same effect as above - the increased taxes paid - are dollars that will not be spent in the economy - same cycle as above. 

urabunchcats --- 9 years ago -

To me - I am in support of taking the bad tasting medicine (austerity measures) to cure the disease (debt)
before the patient is permanently disabled or dies.

I can't believe it is in our best interest to simply grow our debt forever!

At some point the lenders will stop lending - what happens then?

The U.S. will see an an Economic CRASH like we have never seen.

We can take steps to manage it now of suffer the devastating consequences when the time comes when we can't borrow any more money.

What do think will happen to our DEBT SERVICE cost when the historically low interest rates return to say 10% or 15%? It could happen and it will probably happen - we might see even higher rates - when we do the roof will be falling for sure.

To me there is just too much wasteful Goberment spending.

Private sector businesses are better avenue to fill worthy needs - will be born or existing businesses will expand to fill a demand for a "needed" service but only at a price level that will spur the investment when the investors believe there is opportunity to harvest adequate rewards.

Unfortunately our goberment does not seem to evaluate the "worthiness" of spending/investing in programs.

Why should it - money is free!
(It seems you support the theory that the more the gobermant spends the better off we will be - debt be dammed!)

Too much Goberment spending on programs that are not ROI worthy!
Too many "services" are offered by the Goberment that don't meet the value test.
Too many are not justifiable from a value delivered to the whole of our society perspective.

. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

To me there is just too much wasteful Goberment spending.


Yes. Year over year deficit spending thus creating debt. Its not sustainable. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

Not sure where to start. Firstly, MMT does not support unlimited or unproductive spending. It only supports government spending to eliminate unemployment.

Secondly, the government does not need to borrow one penny to buy anything. It can buy anything in the market that accepts its currency. The government issues bonds to move dollars out of bank reserves and into the fed. The objective is price stability and managing the money supply to meet short term interest rate goals.

Thirdly, the only thing that will make people stop buying government bonds is an artificial debt ceiling imposed by the government that would cause buyers to lose faith in the governments ability to meet its obligations.

Fourthly - there is no evidence, or serious ecconomic thought that in any way validates the chicken little screams of a day of reckoning coming because of the deficit. We have had a deficit in this country every year since we left the gold standard except for 3 or so years during the Clinton presidency (more on that in a sec). Many as a percent of GDP worse than today. And for the whole time politicians and the talking heads on both sides have screamed about the horror that will happen if it keeps up. It is just not true.

We are still recovering some from the years of surplus. With the government removing money from the private sector, and a large trade deficit removing more, the American people compensated for the loss of dollars by going to the lowest saving rate, and the highest level of private debt ever. Puplic debt by a government that can issue its own currency is not bad, excess private debt is bad, it can default, it can raise interest rate as more and more people compete for fewer dollars.

Usa - the key thing, and this is not opinion, it is an eccomic fact. The economy of a. Nation that can issue its own currency, has nothing at all in common with your household economy. Nothing. All the rules that you think apply to the government economy because they apply to you and me do not apply. 

urabunchcats --- 9 years ago -

Well we will agree to disagree.

Your Third item is poo.

We are at the point where "buyers to lose faith in the governments ability to meet its obligations" - I think. Many people (maybe even most) are risk adverse and act based on their perceptions and perceptions of others. We are on a very steep slippery slope. When the economy cracks it will crumble.

I am afraid that at some point our goberments ability to meet its obligations. I bet there a TONS who are also afraid. I don't have great faith in our elected officials.

I agree with 4 re: we have had a deficit - FOR FAR TOO LONG!


. 

Dorothy Parker --- 9 years ago -

Why do you continually spell government wrong? What is the point in that? 

fuzz81 --- 9 years ago -

To inform of us of his level of intelligence. We do thank you for that, urabunchcats. I don't know how else I would have made the determination. 

Publius --- 9 years ago -

Firstly, MMT does not support unlimited or unproductive spending. It only supports government spending to eliminate unemployment.

This is inherently false. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

Pub- what is inherently false, that MMT states the role of government spending is to eliminate unemployment, or that government spending does not eliminate unemployment? 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground