Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Why Journalists Got It Wrong

who's talking here?

SoupIsGoodFood 1
FANCY PANTS 1
Hiro Protagonist 2
Holling Vincoeur 2
idontplaynice 1
Dorothy Parker 2
Emperor of Kingwood 4
Butterbean 2
mutton 1
JimBecka 3
them 2
BestOne 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

JimBecka --- 9 years ago -

Why Didn't Journalists See the Trump Election Coming?

In 1979 I was covering a news story about the mysterious death of Karen Silkwood, an Oklahoma nuclear facility worker. I met the Nederland, Texas Silkwood family and they felt her death was a murder. My news judgment was that the story was going to be big.

As a United Press International (UPI) reporter for Louisiana and Texas, I filed my stories through New Orleans, but, the UPI bureau chief did not agree with my feelings about the story. Reluctantly, UPI used my story and a week later the CBS Evening News picked up the story. It eventually became a Hollywood movie with Cher and Meryl Streep.

Fortunately, I had good journalism teachers. But, future journalism students may not be as fortunate.

As a journalism teacher and news consumer old enough to remember the Goldwater-Johnson election, I have seen journalism go from objectivity and fairness to activism, sensationalism, and irrelevance. The Trump election is a great example. The major culprit is high schools replacing certified journalism teachers with English and art teachers.

When I arrived at New Caney High School in 1997 I attended a journalism workshop where one English teacher said she does not teach the First Amendment, the Fairness Doctrine, or how students should be able to recognize a newsworthy event. She said ?all that stuff in the first half of the journalism textbook does not need to be taught.?

Bobby Hawthorne, retired Texas UIL director, authored the Radical Write, the story of how high school journalism classes have drifted toward English essays that end up on refrigerators with no serious readers. Hawthorne jokes that he sometimes takes English essays on long flights to help him sleep.

He says that high school is an exciting time in a young person?s life; however, high school journalism classes are churning out publications with cover stories featuring routine school club meetings.

My 90-year-old mother-in-law died with copies of her high school newspaper in her bedroom. The stories held her interest for 70-plus years. But, high school newspapers are dying from lack of school administer support.

Journalists predicted the defeat of Trump because of an unwillingness of look at the election the way it would have been viewed by Walter Cronkite, David Brinkley, or Katharine Graham. Objectivity and news judgement are not difficult to understand.

When Kinky Friedman ran for president he spoke for a high school workshop at San Jacinto College. My students grabbed him for an interview as he stepped off the stage. The rest of the students watched.

?Why are all the students watching us interview a guy running for president?? said one of my students with a puzzled look. ?Why aren?t they interviewing him??

The answer is that many high school journalism classes have become writing busywork with few real-world experiences outside the classroom. 

FANCY PANTS --- 9 years ago -

JimBecka, Can our journalists ever become objective and fair again? I know they have been very coddled but they should report the events with truth, not pushing their personal agenda. Watching the news these days is ridiculous with all the hype, activism, and sensationalism they present.

I think the press wanted HC to win so bad they were not able to see what America wanted. They were blinded by their own agenda. 

Dorothy Parker --- 9 years ago -

What half of America wanted...Trump did not win by a landslide and he lost the popular vote. Let's keep things in perspective. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

I think the press wanted HC to win so bad they were not able to see what America wanted. They were blinded by their own agenda.

Exactly 

BestOne --- 9 years ago -

What half of America wanted...Trump did not win by a landslide and he lost the popular vote. Let's keep things in perspective.?

Let's do that. She won the popular vote of 2 big states to give her the popular vote win. She won the vote of the liberals not conservative America. She didn't even win some of the states that Obama won. Would you like to count the states that went to Trump versus the states that went to Hillary?

Trump won 30 states
Clinton won 20 + DC

So one could say he won the maority of the states. 

Butterbean --- 9 years ago -

A couple of years ago, I was asked to be a guest speaker at a historical society. I had done some work in the area, attempting to describe life as it happened in my neighborhood. I chose to speak about the non-integration of the community since the civil rights efforts of the 1960s.

I used a local person's doctoral thesis as a basis for the speech and the following discussion. I knew that my excursion into local history was probably not going to be well received; I knew many of the people in that local organization.

I had promised a talk that would, perhaps, be a little uncomfortable for some.

The day arrived and I was a bit nervous, but felt the topic was timely and they probably would not lynch me. I was hopeful, anyway.

It was a small group, as many small town historical societies are. I saw no black, brown, or tan faces among the attendees. The author of my reference was in attendance. I saw the audience as a perfect example of my point. They looked at me, expectantly.

Any history of that town did not include black churches or black leaders or black businesses, in spite of the fact that there were many. An accurate history is inclusive, not exclusive.

The last part of my presentation was a declaration that community integration in that county needed to be actively pursued, if it was going to have the historical accuracy that the members espoused. Passive permission to participate will not work. Persons long denied an active role in community history and direction would not voluntarily put themselves at risk. They would have to be personally invited and encouraged to participate.

As the talk progressed, I could sense a certain tension growing among the listeners. At the conclusion, during the questions segment, it was quiet. A single, aging, white face responded that no one was denied membership in their group. That was an actual fact.

I don't know if my presentation missed the mark or the members were not ready to take responsibility for the tacit racial segregation that persists in the community, as it does in so many others. I don't know if it will ever change.

I'm convinced that it will not in my lifetime. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

Donald Trump won an overwhelming 7.5 million popular vote victory in 3,084 of the country's 3,141 counties or county equivalents in America's heartland. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 9 years ago -

Donald Trump won an overwhelming 7.5 million popular vote victory in 3,084 of the country's 3,141 counties or county equivalents in America's heartland.?



So?

Do the people from the coasts count less than those from "America's heartland?" 

them --- 9 years ago -

According to the US Constitution, a document you loathe, they're equal. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

As I'm sure you are aware, we don't elect a POTUS by popular vote, for good reason. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 9 years ago -

I actually don't have a problem with the electoral college. It makes candidates campaign for the whole country's votes not just the most populous areas. Just don't act like the "heartland" is better or more American than the coasts. 

idontplaynice --- 9 years ago -

This article in the Huffington Post states the missteps in the Clinton campaign: arrogance and lack of grassroots efforts.

link 

them --- 9 years ago -

Just don't act like the "heartland" is better or more American than the coasts.

That's because you're from one of those coasts. Why again don't you live there? 

Holling Vincoeur --- 9 years ago -

I live on a coast...and even though it's a blue state it's really conservative in local govt.


As for the electoral college, opinion of it is solely based on which side wins. 

Dorothy Parker --- 9 years ago -

As for the electoral college, opinion of it is solely based on which side wins.

Absolutely! Can you imagine if Clinton had won the electoral college but Trump won the popular vote???

Exactly what's happening now in reverse....lol. 

mutton --- 9 years ago -

Exactly DP, and sad for both sides, like now. It is over, done with, move on people. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

As for the electoral college, opinion of it is solely based on which side wins.

On the contrary. There are numerous people who understand its value and why its in place regardless of outcome. 

Holling Vincoeur --- 9 years ago -

If Trump lost the electoral but won the popular you'd be cursing the electoral college along with every other trump supporter...he'd tell you to. 

BestOne --- 9 years ago -

If Trump lost the electoral but won the popular you'd be cursing the electoral college along with every other trump supporter...he'd tell you to.

I don't think so. 

JimBecka --- 9 years ago -

Can our journalists ever become objective and fair again?

That is a question I ask myself. Several of my journalism teacher friends have quit or retired. They have given up. As a society, we have lost something that Thomas Jefferson considered important. 

JimBecka --- 9 years ago -

Butterbean - Appreciate your story. You write well. I agree that things never seem to change.

I listened to an interview with Quannel X one day and he made the point that blacks were wealthier in the pre-civil rights days (50's) than after the Civil Rights Act was past.

I have come to believe that government cannot improve things, unless society wants to improve things. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 9 years ago -

Simply put: Journalists got it wrong because they failed to do their job. 

BestOne --- 9 years ago -

Simply put: Journalists got it wrong because they failed to do their job.?

And were biased in favor of Hillary. They tried everything to get her elected. 

Butterbean --- 9 years ago -

You write well.

Thank you. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground