Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Is migration a basic human right ??

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 3
SoupIsGoodFood 21
Holling Vincoeur 2
Dorothy Parker 6
Joe Blow 4
sheddy 2
Iwonder 8
DatBoyHooD 7
Texan65 4
Emperor of Kingwood 29
a889324uu 7
Not KU 5
Butterbean 1
Prolix Raconteur 1
mutton 3
AMDG 42
Zapper009 1
fuzz81 9
Karras 1
Jeff11233 9

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

So been starting to think about this some - my core belief, is probably yes - like our right to life, humans should have the right to move around the world in search a better of safer life.

Or stated another way, can political lines, drawn on a map by men, take away a persons freedom to move around the planet.

Problem is, there are all kinds of problems of safety, security, economics, etc. that are or could be impacted by this "natural freedom" - all of which are real and important.

Guess the base conflict would be the "good or the right" of a people to control their borders, vs the "good or right" of human beings being free to move around the world in search of a better life.

I don't have an answer yet - but I find it an interesting question. 

a889324uu --- 10 years ago -

In a sense, wouldn't migration be a concept of Manifest Destiny? 

Karras --- 10 years ago -

Shouldn't a country have it's own border language and culture? How can a nation survive if there is not some commonality? Look at what is happening in Europe where you have middle easterners not assimilating and trying to force their culture on the host country. The USA has become the best country on the planet because we have had a "melting pot". Those that have legally immigrated here from second rate countries, wanted to do so because they believed in the American idea, our constitution and that we are the only country ever, who in their founding documents, say our Freedom is given to us by our Creator, not by other men.

You turn the USA and any other country into the Mos Eisley Cantina then our nation crumbles. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

In a sense, wouldn't migration be a concept of Manifest Destiny?

Thinking even more basic than that. If it is a natural right to life, and a pursuit of happiness, can a line on a map trump that (no pun intended).

All that said - Karras's has a point - borders do have value. They have economic and security value.

Not really an easy one for me. 

Joe Blow --- 10 years ago -

So been starting to think about this some - my core belief, is probably yes - like our right to life, humans should have the right to move around the world in search a better of safer life.



Good topic. I agree.


Shouldn't a country have it's own border language and culture? How can a nation survive if there is not some commonality?



Stupid thoughts.

No borders. No boundaries. No fences. They are all man made not God made. 

Prolix Raconteur --- 10 years ago -

Like God enters into anything you consider. LMFAO! 

sheddy --- 10 years ago -

I don't have a problem with people moving here, if they do it legally and I don't have to support them. I understand people wanting to move here, but don't come here and try to change this country into what you just left. If it was so great, stay where you were. Look at Europe, see how happy they are with open borders. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Sheddy - the question is should there be such a thing as an illegal alien. Just by being human - isn't it an inalienable right to move freely about the world?? 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Karras - can you answer just one question for me?

If you were born in Juarez and your children's lives were in danger, and you watched them be hungry, most of the time. And you knew that if you brought them across the border illegally they would be safe, and better feed. Educated better and have a chance at a better life. Would you do it ??? 

sheddy --- 10 years ago -

Most people say they don't want to leave their country and family. I'd say they should stay and work hard to change things where they are, but that is easy to say, hard to do. To be honest, I really wouldn't care who came here, but I do have a problem supporting them. 

Butterbean --- 10 years ago -

The earth survived quite well for a long time before fences and gates.

Boundaries are a human construct. Much of that was about safety from marauders, much was about economics.

Most of it was/is about political domination.

Edited to add:

Boundaries are usually set/enforced by force. 

Joe Blow --- 10 years ago -

Karras - can you answer just one question for me?


Of course she can't. *crickets*

1. she has no kids
2. she has no logic 

Dorothy Parker --- 10 years ago -

I'd say they should stay and work hard to change things where they are, but that is easy to say, hard to do.

Especially when as Americans, we can't relate to life in a 3rd world country. I think it's arrogant to tell people to fix a problem you've never had to deal with.

I think it should be easier to gain legal entry and I think companies encouraging day laborers hanging out at Lowe's every day for work, should be fined and forced to pay taxes on those workers. It would nip it in the bud pretty quick! However, it would raise the cost of living in TX exponentially. 

mutton --- 10 years ago -

Agree for the most part DP. How do you Know that Lowe's encourages the hanging out part though? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

companies encouraging day laborers hanging out at Lowe's every day for work

What companies are those? 

Dorothy Parker --- 10 years ago -

Contractors of many trades.

Where did I say Lowe's encourages it? I said it's known they hang out there looking for work. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

Thinking even more basic than that. If it is a natural right to life, and a pursuit of happiness, can a line on a map trump that (no pun intended).

What if these illegals decided that your abode was well within their natural right to life?

Would you just step aside an allow them free access to your household? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

No answer, AMDG? 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

What if these illegals decided that your abode was well within their natural right to life?

Would you just step aside an allow them free access to your household?


Sorry - RL gets in the way. My question was more of a basic natural moral right - such as the right to life. Don't think your example fits in that mold -

Yours is saying someone can just decide any right for them self with no moral or natural basis. Not a whole lot different than them deciding that they could kill you - just a matter of degree.

Don't think your scenario is any kind of a valid example of what I was talking about. 

Zapper009 --- 10 years ago -

Only if you are a wilderbeast, a goose or a duck...lol

Would you just step aside an allow them free access to your household?

Why not...lol 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

So you don't have an answer?

I assume you're taking the "just as long as it isn't my ox getting gored" stance 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

So you don't have an answer?

If that is for me, I think I did. If you want it clearer - No I would not give them access to my home. I do not think man has a natural or moral right to other people's property. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

What about other people's possessions or money?

Do you feel they same way? 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

absolutely - not sure the point you are trying to make.

Not sure how the natural right to move about the world ( if there is one) has anything at all to do with anyone's possessions - I must be missing something. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

If there is a basic human right to traverse the world at will and live anywhere you like without vetting of any sort, then there is also a basic human right to protect what is yours. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Not sure those 2 points are in conflict Emp ? What does free migration, have to do with protections of personal property.

I am not getting these points - 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

Wow 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

Personal property includes land. Therefore, my land is not available for anybody but me, therefore no free migration to my land.

However, I said "what is yours" not personal property. 

Holling Vincoeur --- 10 years ago -

AMDG I think you might be a bit too thoughtful to indulge these two... 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Personal property includes land. Therefore, my land is not available for anybody but me, therefore no free migration to my land.

What does your personal property - including your land - have to do with migration -

I am talking about them entering countries - not walking on your lawn. 

Joe Blow --- 10 years ago -

What about other people's possessions or money?



Less is more. You must be a hoarder. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

amdg is very thoughtful.

I'll give her that.

Shes just a bit short sighted 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Wow

Sorry guys - just missing the point you are making -

Can you try another way? or just make the point in a statement, instead of question. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

amdg is very thoughtful.

I'll give her that.

Shes just a bit short sighted 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Soup - I'm a he by the way. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

Not sure i could make it any more clearer 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

Oh yeah. Got you confused with another 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

What does your personal property - including your land - have to do with migration -


I thought that was pretty clear. You can't migrate on others property if they don't want you too. Others property could be a lawn or a nation. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Not sure i could make it any more clearer

Please give it a try - just make a definitive statement of the point.

I don't see the inherent connection between someone walking freely from one place to the next, and anyone's private poverty.

Does the ability to walk from texas to Oklahoma have any impact on the property rights of anyone in either state ??? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

I don't see the inherent connection between someone walking freely from one place to the next, and anyone's private poverty.

Does the ability to walk from texas to Oklahoma have any impact on the property rights of anyone in either state ???


I'll try one more time, then I will conclude that you only care to parse words and not focus on meaning.

You cannot walk from Texas to OK without setting foot on someone else land. 

page 1 2 3 4 5
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground