Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Apple says U.S. 'Founders would be appalled' by DOJ order - I have to agree with Apple here.

who's talking here?

FANCY PANTS 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 2
gunsnroses 1
Emperor of Kingwood 11
witchywoman 1
Judas 1
AMDG 11
fuzz81 8

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

SAN FRANCISCO ? Apple Inc. charged Tuesday that a court order forcing the tech giant to assist the federal government in unlocking the iPhone of San Bernardino terrorist Syed Farook was based on non-existent authority asserted by the Justice Department.

"According to the government, short of kidnapping or breaking an express law, the courts can order private parties to do virtually anything the Justice Department and FBI can dream up,'' Apple lawyers argued in new court documents. "The Founders would be appalled.''

http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/news/2016/03/15/apple-founders-would-appalled/81820804/ 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 10 years ago -

Usually im all for privacy and the gov't staying out but in this case where we actually have a crime committed and info stored in ONE phone, i think the DOJ should be allowed in. When there is a good reason to seize info, its ok with me. The process is such that it takes a court order and special legal actions, as it should be. 

witchywoman --- 10 years ago -

I agree with SSFG. 

gunsnroses --- 10 years ago -

We're at war with Radical Muslims. They need to see what is in that phone to save American lives. We Re talking about one phone. Will never buy another Apple product from that Liberal IDIOT that runs it. He's good with profit over American lives. 

FANCY PANTS --- 10 years ago -

info stored in ONE phone

The question is after the government wins what will happen? Will they decide they have the right to look at everyone's phone and push it to where they can? It's one thing to spy on terrorists and another to spy on law abiding citizens. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

Since none of you have a clue how cryptography works, then trust the experts on this one. Unless you want China, Russia, Iran or any other adversary to also have access to your data. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

I am not sure what exactly the difference is between a phone or a house when it comes to a subpoena to look inside.

I don't see it as any slipperier a slope than - well then they will want to look in all the houses/cars/persons etc.

Just don't see the philosophic difference between an encryption or a deadbolt lock.

If there is probable cause, and they get a warrant for an individual phone - I don't see apples point. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

A deadbolt is a crude, rudimentary device that can be bypassed with a swift kick.

Good Cryptography is by design unbreakable without knowing the cipher keys. The encryption used on an iPhone is done in a special dedicated ASIC chip that generates and stores the cipher keys internally, which can only be exposed by the PIN or fingerprint. Apple implementing a way to break the ciphers, means that anyone can subsequently break them.

your safe in your house isn't connected to China or other nations with state sponsored hackers by a submarine fiber optic cable. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

thanks Fuzz -better understand the slippery slope they are concerned about.

still not 100% sure it is philosophically different, than say having a vault manufacturer refuse to open a vault for the government - to prevent future safe crackers from learning how.

Guess key point is does being electronic, and/or complicated make it by definition different. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

A vault isn't at risk of being broken into over the Internet. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

Apple published details on how their system works last year.

https://www.apple.com/business/docs/iOS_Security_Guide.pdf 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

I am not sure what exactly the difference is between a phone or a house when it comes to a subpoena to look inside.

Exactly. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

A vault isn't at risk of being broken into over the Internet.

so it is a combination of complexity, electronic, and access that makes so different from any other type access to personal property, by court order.

so how about if I store the location of my drugs, guns, bomb, nuke bomb in my phone. Should the government be able to have the phone manufacturer get it if they can?? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

so how about if I store the location of my drugs, guns, bomb, nuke bomb in my phone. Should the government be able to have the phone manufacturer get it if they can??

No, not without probable cause that a crime has been committed. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

yea Emp - with probable cause and a subpoena 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

The more power given to government under the guise of protecting your security the more you become a subject (like those in the British Commonwealth) and the less you become a citizen. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

The more power given to government under the guise of protecting your security the more you become a subject (like those in the British Commonwealth) and the less you become a citizen.

Ok - but not an answer.

Here is the scenario -

An undercover FBI agent hears first hand that suspected terrorist X, has just obtained a biological weapon, which the informant says he has buried in a specific location that he has stored in his phone.

The FBI goes to a judge who determines there is probable cause to arrest Mr. X and search all his property, including his phone.

Mr. X refuses to unlock his phone. Should the phone manufacture be required to unlock this phone if possible?? 

Judas --- 10 years ago -

Bob, then don't complain about terrorism if they are denied access to researching the terrorist sources. You can't have it both way. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

Bob, then don't complain about terrorism if they are denied access to researching the terrorist sources. You can't have it both way.

Wrong. I can and will complain about terrorism as well as demand my government solve the problem while at the same time respecting our civil liberties. Government will say they a re mutually exclusive, and they have to have those rights but I'm not buying it. If my government can't achieve that objective then its time for a new government. We the people have the absolute right to demand from government both the what and the how. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

Here is the scenario -

An undercover FBI agent hears first hand that suspected terrorist X, has just obtained a biological weapon, which the informant says he has buried in a specific location that he has stored in his phone.

The FBI goes to a judge who determines there is probable cause to arrest Mr. X and search all his property, including his phone.

Mr. X refuses to unlock his phone. Should the phone manufacture be required to unlock this phone if possible??


No, because phone manufacturer is not a party to the suspected wrong doing. Therefore government cannot compel manufacturer to assist in the development of their case. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

OK - that is an answer - Respectfully disagree - but that is fine.

Seems your way gives bad guys an impenetrable place to hide their secrets. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 10 years ago -

"Spying on your phone"


No, Fancy Pants, thats not what it is. They arent spying. They have been asked to investigate the crimes in which that phone was a part. Its EVIDENCE. Spying is what they do when they are surveilling you and have an end game to get something. Here in this case, the phone is evidence in a crime. How is that any different than collecting evidence in a murder or anything else. No one was spying on the guy. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

Seems your way gives bad guys an impenetrable place to hide their secrets.

It might but it also protects the manufacturers rights. If we give up rights and liberty in the name of security we no longer have a government by and for the people, we have instead a nanny state. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

They have been asked to investigate the crimes in which that phone was a part. Its EVIDENCE.

They suspect that but they don't know that. In any case, phone manufacturer is not a party to this at all and shouldn't be compelled by law to divulge anything. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

It might but it also protects the manufacturers rights. If we give up rights and liberty in the name of security we no longer have a government by and for the people, we have instead a nanny state.

Understand the position, and it has merit. Not sure there is much of a philosophic difference than having a landlord open a door, instead of LE breaking it down. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

having a landlord open a door, instead of LE breaking it down.

It is different. A landlord has some level of access to property he is leasing but in no way is compelled to let the police into the property without a warrant.

Kicking in the door requires a felony warrant. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

No, Fancy Pants, thats not what it is. They arent spying. They have been asked to investigate the crimes in which that phone was a part. Its EVIDENCE. Spying is what they do when they are surveilling you and have an end game to get something. Here in this case, the phone is evidence in a crime. How is that any different than collecting evidence in a murder or anything else. No one was spying on the guy

You're missing the point.

If Apple were to reduce the security of their products, it allows an introduced backdoor for either criminals, or foreign governments to spy on you. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Emp - assume probable cause and a legal warrant in all my cases. Guess my key point is I don't see any difference between information hidden in a phone vs hidden on your person or in your house. And don't see any reason why a corporation or person should not assist the government in carrying out a legal warrant.

You issue of excessive search and seizure should be addressed in the warrant process, not in a third party private refusal to assist. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

If Apple were to reduce the security of their products, it allows an introduced backdoor for either criminals, or foreign governments to spy on you.

I think that is a valid point, that Apple should, as it did, bring attention to the court. And it is up to the court to decide if it is valid or not. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

The ciphers used are developed and approved by the government (see NIST FIPS AES standards).

Should we just destroy secure cryptography under the guise of making us feel secure? 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Should we just destroy secure cryptography under the guise of making us feel secure

No, but I think the question being asked is, if the information on this one phone it retrieved by Apple, does it really destroy the all this cryptography.

Our courts are very far from perfect, but it is the process we have. It is apples right to make their case to the court of all their perceived issues with retrieving this data. It is the courts job to hear it and render a decision.

After that decision, and appeals etc etc. once decided, it is decided. Sometimes the process seems awful for one side or the other, but that is the process. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

It's not possible to just do it for "one phone".

That's the point.

First off, they won't be able to do it for this phone without having had a backdoor a priori. The media is making it sound like Apple can just flip a magic switch. That's not how it works.

What they're trying to prevent is being forced to introduce a weakness in future devices. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

seems like they have done a bad job of convincing the court of the dangers you described. 

fuzz81 --- 10 years ago -

I'm guessing you haven't been following the BS that had been brought into court.

Testimony like there are plans of an attack that are ONLY contained on that phone.

Yeah, ok. How did you know about it then if it's encrypted on that phone? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

Emp - assume probable cause and a legal warrant in all my cases. Guess my key point is I don't see any difference between information hidden in a phone vs hidden on your person or in your house. And don't see any reason why a corporation or person should not assist the government in carrying out a legal warrant.

Because if the government wants to search your car, and its locked and they can't get in it, they don't go to whomever manufactured your car to get the keys. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

You issue of excessive search and seizure should be addressed in the warrant process, not in a third party private refusal to assist.

That's not my issue. The issue is about a third party that's not a party to the criminal activity. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground