Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Expecting untrained civilians to shoot down terrorists is recipe for more dead innocents.

who's talking here?

d:-] 1
SoupIsGoodFood 7
Warren Peace 2
Let Logic Prevail 1
steinhoister2016 2
Dorothy Parker 1
Defcon1 3
DVaz 1
them 2
Barnstormer 1
CartmanUK34 1
Pixtor 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Let Logic Prevail --- 10 years ago -

The 'good guy with a gun' myth
James Hatch 11:50 a.m. EST December 11, 2015


After the slaughter of 14 Americans in San Bernardino, Calif., when two people armed with high-powered rifles and handguns ambushed unsuspecting Americans in a conference room, United States senator and Republican presidential candidate Ted Cruz held a press conference to issue a familiar refrain we hear after every major gun tragedy:

If only there had been a ?good guy? with a gun there. Or, as Sen. Cruz put it:

?You stop bad guys by using our guns.?

We heard the same call after the recent tragedy at a medical clinic in Colorado Springs, and after attacks in Paris, where 129 people were murdered in a theater by terrorists armed with guns and explosives. That?s when former presidential candidate and Speaker of the House Newt Gingrich took to Twitter to issue his call to arms:

?Imagine a theater with 10 or 15 citizens with concealed carry permits.?

I know that the political advocates for this ?good guy with a gun? mantra like Sen. Cruz and many of the other politicians and lobbyists think that this is a politically expedient catch-phrase to support their own interests.

I doubt career politicians like Sen. Cruz and the rest of the Washington operators have had much experience with gunfights.

In my experience, being the good guy when the bullets start flying is very difficult.

I say that as someone who spent 25 years serving our military. For many of those 25 years, I was a member of a Special Missions Unit.

I?ve been in dark rooms with ?good-guys and bad guys? going at it with guns, and let me tell you something:

Gunfights are crazy.

Gunfights are hard.

On my final combat mission, I was shot in the leg with an AK-47 from about 30 feet away and it blew my femur in half.

I hope that was my last gunfight.

Here at home, there are almost 13 million Americans who have a license to carry a concealed weapon. The vast majority of them are responsible, law-abiding and good-hearted people. Many of them want to be prepared to be the good guy, to do the right thing and to save lives.

I hope they never have to face being the target of a dangerous person with a gun. Because it?s hard to make the right decisions.

There are groups of individuals, like me and my fellow Special Operators, both military and law enforcement, who train for years to be good at close quarters shooting: shooting with discernment, keeping your head clear and making snap decisions before you pull the trigger ? all while being shot at by the enemy.
And after dedicating their lives to being good operators in those extreme circumstances, even those professionals make mistakes.

Then consider that people like us trained for firefights for years, and that in many states there is virtually no training required for someone to legally carry a loaded, hidden gun.

So think about 10 or 15 people, who are weekend shooters with limited tactical training, deciding to shoot it out with a criminal in a crowded office holiday party, a medical clinic or a darkened theater, while people are screaming and running, and no one knows who or how many of the people shooting are the ?good guys? and how many of them are the ?bad guys.?

In some cases, can a ?good guy? with a gun neutralize the threat and help save lives? Absolutely. But it doesn?t happen very often. It is, for the most part, a myth perpetuated by people who?ve never been shot at.

I am a proud Navy combat veteran. I risked and nearly gave my life in dozens of combat situations in defense of our Constitution. I value the Second Amendment and the right of responsible Americans to own guns for self-defense.

But people need to know that it is a fallacy to believe that the everyday gun owner can be expected to make all the right choices in a dangerous, fast-moving situation like a mass shooting with high-powered weapons.

When the bullets are flying, determining ?who's who in the zoo? is hard.

If the scenario that Sen. Cruz envisions were to ever unfold, we?d have a lot more dead innocents. And it would probably include some of the ?good guys.?

Senior Chief Petty Officer James Hatch (USN, Ret.) is the founder of Spikes K9 Fund and a member of Veterans for Responsible Solutions. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

Keep reaching.............. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

Remember the screams from the anti-gun crowd when Texas was starting to implement CHL?

They said Texas would turn into the wild-west again with shootouts all over the place.

Yeah. Never happened. A total over reaction.

Just like this. 

d:-] --- 10 years ago -

zzzzz

Heard this crap before.

If you don't want a gun then don't buy one. End of story. 

Pixtor --- 10 years ago -

I don't disagree with Chief Hatch on this.

Simply because someone has a CHL (which I do have) doesn't mean you can go John Wayne on the bad guy(s) and expect to come out the winner. 

CartmanUK34 --- 10 years ago -

Agreed, IF guns have a place in the hands of the public in a civilized society, then it is in a PERSONAL defense and HOME defense capacity only, not under the delusion that "good guys with guns" are going to solve problems or prevent massacres. But I would argue that the moment you have young children then they are at more risk of your own weapon (if it is ready to be used for defense) than they are of any outside attacker, and if you go far enough to make sure they aren't at risk then the weapon becomes useless for defense. 

Barnstormer --- 10 years ago -

That BS don't fly with me. He's saying we are too stupid to protect ourselves. The way he chooses his military terms, I don't believe him. Thanks Hatch, but I'd rather protect myself from real problems with real solutions. It's getting too real out there to listen to you and your ilk. 

them --- 10 years ago -

The liberals have seen too many movies. Their views of reality are skewed.

That's why they ofter reference "Dirty Harry", "John Wayne" and "Rambo" when discussing CHL holders.

Ask this chief, who I've never heard of before, if he'd prefer to be armed or unarmed when someone is shooting in his direction. 

Defcon1 --- 10 years ago -

I shoot much better than any police officer I've ever encountered on a gun range.

I always set up my targets next to them when I can just because it's fun shooting better groupings than them.

Moral of the story...most gun owners can handle their weapons just fine. 

Pixtor --- 10 years ago -

I shoot much better than any police officer I've ever encountered on a gun range.

I always set up my targets next to them when I can just because it's fun shooting better groupings than them.

Moral of the story...most gun owners can handle their weapons just fine.


Defcon1, I'm sure you're a crack shot on the range and you can stand your own gronnd, but there is a difference between shooting at a stationary target as opposed to someone who is shooting back at you. 

Warren Peace --- 10 years ago -

Defcon1 --- 7 min ago - quote - hide comments
I shoot much better than any police officer I've ever encountered on a gun range


No doubt this is true. You probably go to the range far more than the average cop. Most cops only go at the bare minimum frequency required by their agency.

But most non-LEO shooters don't train the same way LEOs do. The article is also referring to the decision making that goes into a shoot/don't shoot decision that LEOs train for.

I also concede the no-brainer the OP ignores - that good guys and bad guys going at it with guns is far better than bad guys with guns going at unarmed good guys that can't shoot back. 

DVaz --- 10 years ago -

I also concede the no-brainer the OP ignores - that good guys and bad guys going at it with guns is far better than bad guys with guns going at unarmed good guys that can't shoot back.?

Haven't you learned by now that liberals tend to lack common sense?! 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

Simply because someone has a CHL (which I do have) doesn't mean you can go John Wayne on the bad guy(s) and expect to come out the winner.

Most CHL's don't think like this.

This is all a fabrication of the anti-gun crowd. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

not under the delusion that "good guys with guns" are going to solve problems or prevent massacres.


But it does happen. 

Pixtor --- 10 years ago -

Soup, 99.99% of the time I agree with you on the issues, but on this one I have to disagree my friend. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

What do we disagree about on this issue? 

steinhoister2016 --- 10 years ago -

I've been carrying for years and have never come anywhere near pulling out my gun on someone else...now a friend of mine, as soon as he got his chl he had numerous "reasons" to pull his out...I told him he really shouldn't be carrying and he quit speaking to me. lol 

Pixtor --- 10 years ago -

What do we disagree about on this issue?

"That most CHL's don't think like this".

Edited to add: I went back and reread what you posted Soup and I think I know what you meant. Meaning some CHL holders think they can go John Wayne on the bad guy and be victorious. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

Most don't think like this.

This is just a scenario created by gun grabbers. Just like they said Texas would turn back to the wild-west and shoot-outs would spring up all over the place if CHL became law.

That never happened. The whole "John Wayne" scenario wouldn't happen either. 

Dorothy Parker --- 10 years ago -

The argument about the Wild West was concerning OPEN carry, not concealed carry. If Open carry was the norm, the bad guys could blend in even better...and confrontations could become more frequent.

Concealed carry was never the concern. 

Defcon1 --- 10 years ago -

I am absolutely certain that I could effectively stop a threat if it ever happened.

I don't EVER want to have to and will probably never ever come close to needing to but IF it happened I just hope I'd be ready. Screw getting caught up in something like what just happened in California while being unarmed.


But most non-LEO shooters don't train the same way LEOs do. The article is also referring to the decision making that goes into a shoot/don't shoot decision that LEOs train for.


Tons of folks are taking training courses. If you're ever interested check out MAST Solutions. Here is their website. 

Defcon1 --- 10 years ago -

the bad guys could blend in even better...and confrontations could become more frequent.


No way. You think a criminal is going to try to attract attention by openly carrying a weapon?! Yea right. We are going to have to show our CHLs every 10 minutes if we open carry.

Criminals are going to either

A. Carry concealed or
B. Come in guns blazing not caring

People open carry in plenty of states and gee golly...no wild west shootouts there. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

The argument about the Wild West was concerning OPEN carry, not concealed carry

You're wrong. They were saying the same thing about concealed carry. 

Warren Peace --- 10 years ago -

If you're ever interested check out MAST Solutions. Here is their website.?

Thanks but no thanks. I might look into it after retirement though. 

steinhoister2016 --- 10 years ago -

0 

them --- 10 years ago -

Tons of folks are taking training courses. If you're ever interested check out MAST Solutions. Here is their website.?


Another option is the Conroe Shooting Academy.

http://www.conroeshootingacademy.com 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground