Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Sanders doesn't understand his own Socialism.

who's talking here?

SoupIsGoodFood 7
steinhoister2016 1
OhBrother 2
DVaz 1
Not KU 2
ugly yapper dog 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

Bernie Sanders?s Denmark Comments Show He Doesn?t Even Understand His Own ?Socialism?

by Kevin D. Williamson October 14, 2015 12:49 PM

It had to be Denmark, didn?t it?

If you are the sort of person who has better things to do ? which is to say, a fully functioning adult who is not professionally obliged to follow these things ? then you probably missed the exchange between Mrs. Clinton and Senator Sanders at last night?s debate, when she lectured him that the United States isn?t Denmark and he responded with a rousing defense of the Danish model.

Never mind, for the moment, that neither of these batty old geezers has the foggiest idea of what?s going on in Denmark, or in the other Nordic countries. Denmark, like Sweden before it, has been engaged in a long campaign of reforming its famously generous welfare state. The country?s current prime minister is the leader of a center-right party, which, strangely enough, goes by the name ?Left,? Venstre. (You might even call it libertarian; its former longtime leader wrote a book bearing the positively Nozickian title ?From Social State to Minimal State.? ) Denmark has been marching in the direction exactly opposite socialism for some time. Our friends at the Heritage Foundation rank its economy the eleventh most free in the world, one place ahead of the United States, reflecting Denmark?s strong property rights, relative freedom from corruption, low public debt, freedom of trade and investment, etc.

Don?t tell Senator Sanders, but Denmark?s corporate tax rate is a heck of a lot lower than our own.

RELATED: Bernie?s Strange Brew of Nationalism and Socialism

Senator Sanders is not very serious about imitating Denmark. Denmark has a large and expensive welfare state, which Senator Sanders envies. He doesn?t envy the other part of that handshake: Denmark pays for that large and expensive welfare state the only way that you can: with relatively high taxes on the middle class, whose members pay both high income taxes and a value-added tax. If Senator Sanders were an intellectually honest man, he?d acknowledge forthrightly that the only way to pay for generous benefits for the middle class is to tax the middle class, where most of the income earners are. Instead, he talks about taxing a handful of billionaires to pay for practically everything. Rhetorically, he?s already spent the entire holdings of the billionaire class many times over.

Sanders?s line of thinking seems to go: ?Bankers, money, evil, greedy, Make Them Pay!? But Senator Sanders does not seem as if he thinks a great deal about these things. He worries about the size of the holdings of our largest banks (I?d bet a dollar that he could not explain the difference between an investment bank and a commercial bank) and frets that six big banks have assets equal to 65 percent of U.S. GDP. He does not consider that in Switzerland there are two banks whose combined assets are well more than twice Switzerland?s GDP, a reflection of the fact that the moneyed people and institutions of the world have a great deal of confidence in Swiss financial institutions, or that similar parties invest with American institutions for similar reasons. And never mind that Denmark?s largest bank has assets totaling 1.6 times Denmark?s GDP ? a lot more than the 65 percent split among six banks in the United States that so troubles Sanders. Sanders?s line of thinking seems to go: ?Bankers, money, evil, greedy, Make Them Pay!?

RELATED: The Debate Lesson: America Now Has an Openly Socialist Party

Democrats are positively delusional about this stuff, talking about Glass-Steagall as though not repealing it would have changed one thing about the way business was done at a pure-play investment bank such as Lehman Bros. or Bear Stearns. The policy is entirely unrelated to the problem, but neither the Democratic presidential candidates nor their voters understand the problem or the policy. They know only that Copenhagen is lovely, and people like Senator Sanders enjoy citing its ?example? while shouting such nonsensical sentences as ?Free health care is a right!?

Denmark is on the mind of Francis Fukuyama, whose Political Order and Political Decay has now been issued in paperback, to the delight of cheapskate readers everywhere. Fukuyama, borrowing from a group of developmental economists, introduces his readers to the phrase ?isomorphic mimicry,? by which he means the error that poor and developing countries make when they adopt the formal institutions of the developed world in the absence of the underlying values, habits, and culture that make those institutions effective. This is part of the problem he calls ? surprise ? ?getting to Denmark.? Fukuyama:

The problem is that Denmark did not get to be Denmark in a matter of months or years. Contemporary Denmark ? and all other developed countries ? gradually evolved modern institutions over the course of centuries. If outside powers try to impose their own models of good institutions on a country, they are likely to produce what Lant Pritchett, Michael Woolcock, and Matt Andrews call ?isomorphic mimicry?: a copying of the outward forms of Western institutions but without their substance.

(Here is the Pritchett-Woolcock-Andrews paper, which is well worth your time.)

That isomorphic mimicry is a great stumbling block. We?re right now in the end stages of failing, spectacularly, in a project to impose liberal democratic institutions on a Muslim world that isn?t much interested in them, but some of our more energetic conservative interventionists still seem to believe that one day an Arab or a Chinese is going to happen across a copy of the U.S. Constitution and build a Connecticut in the Orient. Cult is the first word in culture, which bears some consideration: The American revolutionaries emerged from a Puritan-Quaker culture shaped by the hardships of colonial life with the savage frontier in front of them and the Atlantic Ocean at their backs; the French revolutionaries emerged from a decadent Catholic culture shaped by court life and European rivalries. Both parties cried ?Liberty!? but one produced the Bill of Rights and the other produced the Terror. The cultural distance between 21st-century Anglo-American liberals and tribal jihadis in the Hindu Kush is rather greater than was the distance between Thomas Jefferson and the Abbé Sieyès.

Aping the superficial attractive forms of alien polities is not an error limited to the poor and the backward. Our progressive friends argued that Obamacare is just like the Swiss health-care system, which is generally quite highly regarded, and it is, with one important difference: Switzerland is full of Swiss people and the United States is not. The Swiss health-care system turns out to be poorly suited for a country that isn?t Swiss. Any bets on how well the Danish welfare state is going to play in Mississippi and New Jersey?

Progressives who imagine that Americans are one election away from getting to Denmark do not understand Denmark, or America, or much of anything.

Read more at: http://www.nationalreview.com/article/425566/bernie-sanders-democratic-debate 

ugly yapper dog --- 11 years ago -

Thats the thing with leftists, they make huge judgement calls based on the appearance of things on the surface when it comes to political ideology. There is no country in the world that offers free healthcare to everyone as a right just for being born a human. But if we say it enough times it will become true...

While other nations are realizing their failed healthcare systems are unsustainable and moving to capitalism, the US is chasing their past.

Leftists fight freedom because of the personal responsibility it naturally comes with, leftists HATE personal responsibility for things they think government should do for them behind the scenes. 

OhBrother --- 11 years ago -

This is what Bernie understands!

Congress does not regulate Wall Street, Wall Street regulates Congress 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

Does he also know that Wall Street regulates Hillary? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

While other nations are realizing their failed healthcare systems are unsustainable and moving to capitalism, the US is chasing their past.

Exactly. 

OhBrother --- 11 years ago -

Wall Street probably regulates the vast majority of candidates on both sides of the aisle. But Wall Street does not regulate Bernie. The Citizens United ruling by the U.S. Supreme Court has done immense harm to our democracy and has put the wheelers and dealers of Wall Street in power. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

I laugh at those who complain about CU, but ignore the $$$$ influence the Unions have. 

ugly yapper dog --- 11 years ago -

Who gives wall street the money to regulate congress? We the people. 

DVaz --- 11 years ago -

The Citizens United ruling by the U.S. Supreme Court has done immense harm to our democracy and has put the wheelers and dealers of Wall Street in power.?

What exactly are you talking about? 

ugly yapper dog --- 11 years ago -

Every time we buy stocks, even in our 401k's, we help wall street oppressing us. At the end of the day it's this kind of money/support that will have the final say. And it's like that with everything. 

Not KU --- 11 years ago -

From a person that doesnt even know what socialism is. Has the audacity to state the following about a libertarian:
Sanders doesn't understand his own Socialism.

Like Soup does. I suppose it makes for entertainment. If that. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

You make no sense whatsoever, mark. 

Not KU --- 11 years ago -

That's Mr Mark to you. Its not my problem if you have clarity issues. I gave you instructions yesterday. If you cant follow them. That's your problem.
If you don't mind. Please suffer in silence so topics like this can continue.

Thank you 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

More nonsense. 

steinhoister2016 --- 11 years ago -

Hey the far right is criticising the far left...good find soupy, think you can find an article where Jesus says Satan is the bad guy? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

Google broke.

Sorry, steiny. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground