Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Parents' outrage after their autistic daughter is kicked off flight because she made the pilot 'feel

who's talking here?

sunshine1881 1
Jpgirl 1
FANCY PANTS 1
Hiro Protagonist 1
Quixote 2
*LOL* 2
Work in Progress 1
Puss In Boots 1
Dorothy Parker 1
needsleep 1
TinktheSprite 4
snowprincess 1
Identity Crisis 1
Leila 2
mutton 3
You can call me Michelle 1
Zapper009 1
XpressUrself 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

*LOL* --- 11 years ago -

An Oregon family on their way back from Disney World was unceremoniously taken off an airplane because of their autistic daughter after the pilot refused to fly with her on board.

Dr Donna Beegle said that she is filing a discrimination lawsuit after she and her 15-year-old daughter Juliette were taken off a plane at an emergency stop in Salt Lake City as they flew on a connecting flight from Houston to Portland.

Juliette Forbes refused the food that her family had brought along, and the United Airlines economy passenger was eventually given hot food from first class after her mother argued that it was necessary to prevent a meltdown.

Dr Beegle says that the Tigard, Oregon, family, was escorted off the plane by police thirty minutes later.

'Well, the captain doesn't feel comfortable flying to Portland with your daughter on the plane,' Dr Beegle was told as she was taken off the plane Tuesday.

Juliette, who is high-functioning but has difficulty communicating, had calmed down by the time the plane made its emergency landing in Utah, according to KOIN.

Dr Beegle, who heads up an anti-poverty organization, is good at anticipating her daughter's moods and had requested the food so that her 15-year-old didn't become upset and possibly scratch someone.

She and Juliette had previously traveled all over the world to her speaking engagements before the family, including Juliette's brother and father, were all booted from the United flight.

The mother says that the captain never checked to see if the situation had improved after her daughter had food.

Juliette, who was sitting in a window seat, soon began watching a video, and other passengers said they did not feel threatened by the girl's behavior.

A YouTube video taken by a fellow passenger and given to KOIN shows a calm aircraft on the ground in Salt Lake City, with the Beegle family, including Juliette, calmly shuffling out of their seats.

'That's ridiculous,' a man on the plane says.

'That's gonna be a lawsuit,' another adds.

Her mother said that their treatment was prompted by the 'fear of autism'.

'After working to accommodate Dr. Beegle and her daughter during the flight, the crew made the best decision for the safety and comfort of all of our customers and elected to divert to Salt Lake City after the situation became disruptive,' United Airlines said in a statement about the incident.

'We rebooked the customers on a different carrier and the flight continued to Portland.'

Dr Beegle has filed claims with the Federal Aviation Authority and United, according to KATU.

She says her main aim is to bring attention to the issue of autism and to make sure that airline employees have proper training to work with passengers that have special needs.

news article 

snowprincess --- 11 years ago -

I would be p!$$3d if I was diverted for that! Seriously! What a waste of time. 

FANCY PANTS --- 11 years ago -

I think most are sensitive and understanding of people with disabilities. It is a shame this happened. 

You can call me Michelle --- 11 years ago -

"Possibly scratch someone"

Well, no wonder the pilot felt there was a danger. Her mother thought she may become violent. 

Quixote --- 11 years ago -

"Requested food from first class", "anticipted her daughter's moods", "prevent a meltdown", and "scratch someone"? "Lawsuit?"

Biased reporting - again. Mama's looking for money and/or publicity for her "speaking engagements".


The captain made the right decision! 

Identity Crisis --- 11 years ago -

This mother knows what is going to set off her daughter. She should have brought her daughter's own food. The mother should be apologizing, not complaining.
Kicking her off was a little extreme considering the girl calmed down. 

Quixote --- 11 years ago -

The story is obviously slanted - we don't know what, if any, behavior the child was exhibiting. Basically, the he article says the mother told the flight crew to give her daughter first class food or suffer the consequences. If the twit was so attuned to the kid, she would have planned ahead instead of holding the airline hostage. She should be prosecuted for delaying a flight. 

mutton --- 11 years ago -

I feel bad for them, but thinking a bit of planning ahead, as others stated, would possibly have helped. Not totally sure how I feel about the whole situation. 

Puss In Boots --- 11 years ago -

Juliette Forbes refused the food that her family had brought along,

She did bring food for her daughter. Says so in the article. 

*LOL* --- 11 years ago -

I also think there is more to the story.

It sounds like the mother insisted her daughter be given a hot meal from first class instead of the for purchase food in coach and told the crew that if she had a meltdown due to the food issue she could scratch people. Even though she had calmed down, I think they felt there was a risk to other passengers if she got upset again.

I have all kinds of empathy for parents traveling with children and babies and anyone with special needs.

But I think an attitude that included demands and arguing along with threats of the "meltdown"with aggressive behavior might have made this situation escalate into something that might led to the decision. 

XpressUrself --- 11 years ago -

If they do decide to sue, they won't win if I'm on that jury. I feel for the little girl but the mother made demands and knew if those demands were not met other passengers would or could be harmed. All of this is a distraction for the pilot and the crew. I would have thrown them off to. Let them be someone else's problem. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

I have to agree, the mother apparently stated repeatedly that her daughter might hurt someone if she melted down. I feel for the family, truly, but the Pilot was looking out for the rest of the passengers as well. 

Dorothy Parker --- 11 years ago -

Not sure what to think about this situation. I saw an interview with the family, and the daughter is high functioning physically, but non verbal. I think if they knew she would need hot food in order to avoid a meltdown, they should have paid for a first class ticket and maybe that would've prevented any issues.

Also, maybe speaking with the crew ahead of time as a warning/courtesy of their situation, could have helped as well. 

Leila --- 11 years ago -

She wasn't discriminated against. Once the mother informed the crew that she could have a meltdown and scratch other passengers she became a threat, autism or no autism.

What would have happened if she did erupt to that level and harmed another passenger? Then we would be talking about another kind of lawsuit. Not to mention, the attendants were having to spend a considerable amount of time trying to placate the girl and her mother.

The idea that she had to have a hot meal from the 1st class cabin in order to be soothed goes beyond the normal accommodation expected from the crew. What if they had not had an extra meal? (often they do not) Would she sue over that?

What if a passenger demanded baby food for their screaming toddler or a first class meal because a passenger had a diet need that wasn't considered with the "for purchase' coach meals? That would open up all kinds of special situations that should not be expected.

Bottom line, the airline has the right to remove any passenger that they deem disruptive or threatening to the welfare to the flight or other passengers. The mother was the one that stated she might harm others. The airline did the right thing and I do not believe her suit will have any basis. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 11 years ago -

I think this was the parents fault. It's not the airlines responsibility to make special arrangements so a special circumstances customer can fly. It's the parents responsibility to not put their child in a situation where they will freak out. 

TinktheSprite --- 11 years ago -

I side with the pilot. What's the difference between the mother insisting they give her First Class hot food "or else..." and "Take me to the Captain or I will hijack this plane." Both are threats albeit at different levels but threats of harm just the same.

I feel for parents with children who act up in public. It is embarrassing. And it is no different for parents with children with special needs. But it is not up to everyone to stop what they are doing, break rules or inconvenience others to help control their children, special or not. 

mutton --- 11 years ago -

Is what I meant by planning ahead. Can you not order that meal for extra without the plane ticket? Maybe am wrong. Still hard place to sit and judge. 

needsleep --- 11 years ago -

"The paramedic said this was an over-reactive flight attendant and started shaking his head, and said 'We have real work to do' and left," she said. "We were still baffled."

Police then came to their row, Beegle said.
They see this little teenager sitting there watching a video and they asked if there was an issue, and I said, 'No.'"

When the officers started to leave, the captain stepped out of the cockpit and said something to them, Beegle said. They then asked her family to leave, she said.

"He said, 'The captain has asked us to ask you to step off the plane.'" Beegle said. "I said, 'She didn't do anything' ... But the captain said he's not comfortable flying on to Portland with [Juliette] on the plane."


From another article about the story. Paramedics view point when arriving to the situation. 

Leila --- 11 years ago -

"The paramedic said this was an over-reactive flight attendant and started shaking his head, and said 'We have real work to do' and left," she said. "We were still baffled."


This is really unprofessional for him to be discussing since he wasn't there during the inflight ruckus. It is well and good that she had calmed down by that point but had the flight continued who is to say she wouldn't have had another meltdown?

Many drunks and other belligerent passengers that have been kicked off planes were also calm and cooperative at the time of their diverted landing but they didn't get a pass. And before anyone points it out, I am not saying a teenager with with a disability is the same thing as a non-disabled passenger acting out except that their behavior can all be viewed as threatening regardless of the reason for it.

I have a relative with autism. His mother has stressed to us that although he has difficulty coping in certain situations it doesn't mean she gives into all of his desires and demands. She has worked very hard to teach him that his tantrums will not result in him getting whatever it is he wants, and my heart has ached for her many times. She structures her life around this child but she doesn't expect everyone else to because she wants him to be able to cope in the world as it exists. I totally realize the incredible challenges parents of exceptional children face and my hat is off to them.

However, it seems to me this mother could have prepared some hot food in a thermos or bought some at the food court before boarding and avoided making all of her demands and her threats of her child harming others in flight.

She was on the national news tonight still raising heck and talking about her law suit against United. IMO she is going to milk this for every second of publicity she can get. I fully expect her to be on the talk shows tomorrow morning. It's about the attention and the $$$. 

TinktheSprite --- 11 years ago -

I do believe that the pilots of airplanes are governed by more than just local laws that most of us are familiar with. They follow the rules under the Federal level, the FAA. There must be a Federal law that has been broken, or one that the pilot decided to follow or the family and the child would not have been removed. 

Zapper009 --- 11 years ago -

Having seen United and Continental, in several dicey situations - I predict that she gets nothing, but maybe a chance not to fly again on this airline...PERMANENTLY! 

TinktheSprite --- 11 years ago -

Recent reports state the the child received a hot sandwich offered for purchase in her Economy section. But the mother complained the sandwich wasn't "hot enough". That was when she demanded a hot meal from First Class. I am certain there was a lot more to this story than what the woman tells. 

TinktheSprite --- 11 years ago -

Hedlund told KOIN6 that the 16-year-old girl wasn't removed because she has autism but because her behavior threatened the safety of everyone onboard the plane.

'She wasn't put off the plane because she had autism, she was put off the plane because she was maybe proposing some kind of a threat, to (about) 170 other people at 36,000 feet, which doesn't make anyone feel safe,' Hedlund said.

'What if she got crazy and got up and opened an exit door at 36,000 feet?'

She praised the flight attendants for how they had been working quietly with the family for nearly an hour before the pilot made the decision to make an emergency landing.

'There was a lot of howling, and we thought well, what's going on? And it never stopped,' Hedlund said.

The Oregon family were on their way back from Disney World when they were unceremoniously removed from the airplane.

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3075752/It-s-fear-autism-Fellow-passenger-says-SUPPORTS-plane-decision-kick-little-girl-family-United-refuse-apologize-mother-calls-action.html#ixzz3Zqc4SWq2
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook 

Jpgirl --- 11 years ago -

I really can't judge the situation- I can say that I understand meltdown- my son as most of you know has mental illness and learning disabilities- and I understand that he didn't ask for his condition and sometimes he can't control it. BUT having said that-as a Mother of a special needs child I knew what his triggers were and I also raised him to understand that he wouldn't get coddled or catered to. We rarely travelled by plane until his tantrums were under control. Thankfully his level of functioning was much higher than this girls' level. There is NO way I would've travelled if I sensed a meltdown coming and I could tell just by looking at him if it was going to be a good day or bad. I side with the pilot- I've had to deal with meltdowns and been hurt. I've seen other parents hurt from their teenaged special needs child meltdowns. It's like they have super human strength once that adrenalin gets going. If this child has a complete meltdown over temperature ( and yes it happens) then eiter the Mom should be prepared for that or maybe stay away from situations like air travel where there is no control over a situation like this. Perhaps a bit more therapy will help. As a parent I totally understand that the world at large wouldn't be always accommodating - I never expected that and tried to make sure my son knew that. Sometimes I think parents ( both with "normal" and those with special needs) feel that the world should make so many allowances to fit the world to the child instead of fitting the child for the world. 

sunshine1881 --- 11 years ago -

Sometimes I think parents ( both with "normal" and those with special needs) feel that the world should make so many allowances to fit the world to the child instead of fitting the child for the world.

I think this is the biggest problem with a lot of these situations and with people in general. People seem to think that the world should conform to their needs and desires instead of understand that it is not all about them.

I think we are going to see a backlash against this from businesses in the near future, and hopefully the courts will back them up.

I've been doing a lot of reading about this lately, because we've been dealing with a problem client here at work, and it seems a lot of businesses are becoming more and more willing to cut ties with problem customers instead of holding fast to the "customer is always right" mentality. 

mutton --- 11 years ago -

Nicely stated JP. You always amaze me with you knowledge and understanding of one who is there in those shoes! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground