Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Which method of individual taxation is the fairest to all

who's talking here?

wayward1 2
Red Heifer 3
RiteWingKing 23
SueRDH 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 5
RedMulch 1
Work in Progress 7
Dorothy Parker 1
Miss Understanding 1
Joe Blow 13
IrvingShwartz 1
TinktheSprite 1
sheddy 1
Emperor of Kingwood 49
Not KU 18
mutton 2
jacobson 3
Porterican 1
SgtRock 1
ugly yapper dog 1
Impiety 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Which method of individual taxation is the fairest to all

Which method of individual tax collection do you think would be the fairest to tax payers without creating a larger government bureaucracy and why?

1. Keep the current system as is Vote
 
 20.0% (5)
2. Keep the current system but eliminate all deductions and special treatments. Vote
 
 8.0% (2)
3. A non progressive flat tax Vote
 
 28.0% (7)
4. Consumption based tax like a VAT or national sales tax. Vote
 
 44.0% (11)
Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Which method of individual tax collection do you think would be the fairest to tax payers without creating a larger government bureaucracy and why? 

Red Heifer --- 11 years ago -

the problem with the second option is the "all". I would keep the charitable deduction and some limited investment incentives or credits. 

Red Heifer --- 11 years ago -

besides being regressive, the flat tax and VAT would be at a higher rate than most people realize, and would have a negative impact on consumption (which may or may not be a good thing). 

SueRDH --- 11 years ago -

I wonder what the rates on flat and consuption would be.

Can someone explain the 999 plan Herman Cain introduced a while back? From what I gathered, it sounded good. What were the cons of that plan? 

Not KU --- 11 years ago -

Tax the rich 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Everyone should have some skin in the game called America. A consumption tax places the consumer in control of the amount of taxes paid. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Tax the rich?

Mark, the upper 5% already pay over 70% of the individual income tax collected. How much more do you want?

Mark, heres a question for you. What is the most inefficient method of redistribution of wealth? 

RiteWingKing --- 11 years ago -

Mark, the upper 5% already pay over 70% of the individual income tax collected. How much more do you want?

That only represents a little over 40% of Federal Revenues. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

That only represents a little over 40% of Federal Revenues.?

Stated another way, 95% of taxpayers pay just slightly over 50% of all federal revenue leaving just 5% of Americans carrying the burden for the other 95%. 

RiteWingKing --- 11 years ago -

RiteWingKing Tax System:

Based on Milton Friedman negative tax.

Eliminate all Welfare Programs. No minimum wages.

In return we will provide a minimum income. Structured so that you are still incentivized to work.

You will just be above the poverty line. The only social agency is child protective services. If you do not take care of your children we will without you. They are innocent and deserve a chance.

The tax structure is progressive but with minimum deductions. Poverty exemption and that's it.

All income is treated the same. Unearned verse Earned income are taxed at the same rate.

However Investment income is not income until it is consumed. So you can trade Investments without paying taxes.

Everyone will still pay Payroll taxes without any income limits and all income is included. (Maybe a progressive rate) I would give small business a payroll tax exemption is they are losing money.

So you would need to determine the progressive rate based on generating taxes at about 20% of GDP.

There my outline.

The progressive rate is a detail that needs to be figured out. 

RiteWingKing --- 11 years ago -

Stated another way, 95% of taxpayers pay just slightly over 50% of all federal revenue leaving just 5% of Americans carrying the burden for the other 95%.

That's not true. Look up who pays the payroll taxes. As a percentage of income (on all taxes) the middle class get's screwed.

I posted that before, I am too lazy this morning to find it again. 

Impiety --- 11 years ago -

Fair Tax - everyone pays.

"we will provide a minimum income" You a Commie? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

That's not true

How when its just the numerical reciprocal of what you said? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Look up who pays the payroll taxes. As a percentage of income (on all taxes) the middle class get's screwed.?

Yoj are mixing two different things, payroll and all taxes. 

RiteWingKing --- 11 years ago -

"we will provide a minimum income" You a Commie?

No...I do not want to nationalize our businesses.

On Meet the Press ... Local Taxes & State Taxes.

Bottom 20% pays at a rate of 10.9% of their income where as the top 1% pays 5.4%. 

RiteWingKing --- 11 years ago -

Yoj are mixing two different things, payroll and all taxes.

Payroll tax is a component of all taxes. A very regressive tax that makes up about 40% of Federal Revenues. 

TinktheSprite --- 11 years ago -

"...fairest to all". Impossible. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 11 years ago -

My thoughts, Tink- I couldn't decide because of that- 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Payroll tax is a component of all taxes. A very regressive tax that makes up about 40% of Federal Revenues.?

Regressive could likely describe an individuals total tax burden but certainly not payroll withholding and individual income taxes. 

RiteWingKing --- 11 years ago -

Regressive could likely describe an individuals total tax burden but certainly not payroll withholding and individual income taxes.

Payroll taxes are very regressive since you pay only on the first 120k and only on earned income.

Individual income more progressive but there are so many qualifications to that. Too Many.

Deductions, Credits, Different tax rates on earned/unearned income. 

Not KU --- 11 years ago -


Mark, the upper 5% already pay over 70% of the individual income tax collected. How much more do you want?


Im not so sure your stats are correct. I just saw a segment on Meet the Press that dispute your claims. TAX the RICH 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Payroll taxes are very regressive since you pay only on the first 120k?

Wrong. Thats social security withholding. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Deductions, Credits, Different tax rates on earned/unearned income.?

Also incorrect since deductions and credits deminish as AGI goes up. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Im not so sure your stats are correct.?

It is correct as far as individual income tax goes. Read the statistics section of the IRS website. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 11 years ago -

Mark, the only reason you think that is because you're not rich, so it doesn't affect you- 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 11 years ago -

The term "rich" is very subjective- it usually means someone who makes more than you do- 

RiteWingKing --- 11 years ago -

Wrong. Thats social security withholding.

So what. People with lower incomes pay more into this than the very rich as a percentage of income. It is limited to 120k of earned income and no tax on unearned income. It is a fixed rate. That is called regressive.

Just like local and state taxes. 

Not KU --- 11 years ago -

Mark, the only reason you think that is because you're not rich,

That may or may not be the case. Irrelevant. The income gap increases as does the cost of living. Those in the middle are being squeezed and the wealth continues to go to the top %. I don't care why. Tax the Rich. 

RiteWingKing --- 11 years ago -

Also incorrect since deductions and credits deminish as AGI goes up.

To a certain extent. This makes it way to complex. Get rid of all the deductions. Have one poverty rate deduction based on family size. Maybe include your place of residence. New York city is more expensive than Porter Texas. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 11 years ago -

You should be talking about corporations, not people- people work all their lives to get to that place- they deserve to keep that money, not support a bunch of people who did nothing to earn it- people with no ambition shouldn't be rewarded- 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

People with lower incomes pay more into this than the very rich as a percentage of income.?

No, the total paid into social security is 14%. You pay 7% and your employer pays 7%. If you are self employed, you pay the total 14% on a total of 120k. 

RiteWingKing --- 11 years ago -

Tax the Rich.

Too a certain extent I agree with you. You do not want to tax so much that it inhibits economic activity. But you should also take into account the marginal utility of money.

People with the resources should fund the government at a higher rate. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Just like local and state taxes.?

A person who lives in a half million dollar house naturally pays more property tax than does the one in a 90k home. Measuring that delta as a percentage of income is nonsense, its means nothing since property tax is based on assessed value and milliage rate and has nithing to do with income. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

People with the resources should fund the government at a higher rate.?

They do. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Get rid of all the deductions

Deductions do diminish and eliminate as AGI increases. 

RiteWingKing --- 11 years ago -

They do.

That's not true with local, state, and payroll taxes.

And in some cases the very wealthy pay at a lower rate on unearned income.

You need the statistics on what percentage of taxes does a group pay on their income. 

RiteWingKing --- 11 years ago -

A person who lives in a half million dollar house naturally pays more property tax than does the one in a 90k home.

That is probably a fairer local tax to a certain extent. School property taxes can be very unfair in poor areas. That was the whole basis of the Texas Robin hood school tax solution.

Sales tax is a very regressive tax. The poorer tend to spend 100% of their income just to live. Thus more of a percentage of their income is taxed via sales taxes. 

Not KU --- 11 years ago -

You do not want to tax so much that it inhibits economic activity.

At this point I don't care. Tax breaks for the top % have proven to be in-effective for stimulating the economy. Trickle down does not work. That money in the hands of the bottom would be better for our economy. Most middle class families do not have off-shore accounts to hide from the tax man. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Thus more of a percentage of their income is taxed via sales taxes.?

Well of course. If you change either the numerator or denominator the quotient changes.

In terms of raw dollars, those with the greater incomes pay far more in sales taxes. 

RiteWingKing --- 11 years ago -

Trickle down does not work.

I know. That's a bumper sticker by the way. Try to find a class at a University that has a Trickle Down 101 economics class.

At the turn of the 20th Century they use to call it Horse and Sparrow Economics. Overfeed the horse so the sparrows can pick the undigested oats from the crap.

That money in the hands of the bottom would be better for our economy.

In a economic slow down that is true. Since their propensity to spend is much higher they increase demand. Thus increase production to meet it. 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground