Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

What happens when you ask a Muslim to make a gay wedding cake?

who's talking here?

smartypants 3
SoupIsGoodFood 5
Perfection 2
Dorothy Parker 2
Emperor of Kingwood 3
a889324uu 1
Slider152 3
Prolix Raconteur 1
jacobson 7
AMDG 5
alldayredux 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 11 years ago -

Wow, where is the outrage? 

Prolix Raconteur --- 11 years ago -

Because Muslims are perceived as a protected/discriminated against class/group of people, whereas Christians are not. It's a double standard for sure.

People feel free to attack Christians for adhering to their beliefs, accusing them of bigotry, because conservatives are accepted as fair game by the media and the left. Whereas Muslims escape much of that persecution due to their being represented in the west as oppressed.

And this is coming from an avowed agnostic; I have no skin in this game.

It's hypocrisy at the highest level. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

Let's see how the KU Christian Hater's Club weighs in on this one. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Lets see, lets explore the options.

1. Cut your head off because you are Christian or Jewish
2. Cut your head off because you are American
3. Cut your head off because you are gay
4. Cut your head off because you are female and wish to become educated, vote, drive or choose your own husband. 

Perfection --- 11 years ago -

Hmmm 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

Where are the entertaining comments from jams and smartypants? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

Silence from KU Christian Haters Club.

The silence here should tell you all you need to know about the fake outrage with RFPA. 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

Where are the entertaining comments from jams and smartypants??

JL, unlike you, Soup, et al some of us do not live and breathe on KU. We have careers, families, friends, hobbies, etc.

Any business who is open for the public good that refuses service to anyone based on their gender, race, sexuality, etc. is wrong.

Muslim bakeries open to the public that refuse service are wrong.

Christian bakeries open to the public that refuse service are wrong.


I'm not sure how much clearer we can be.
However, you being you, and feigning that poor, persecuted woe is me Christian pew fainting don't care what I say about Muslim bakeries. All you care about is that your people can legally discriminate homosexuals because Jesus, Guns, 'Murica!!!

How is THAT for entertaining?

Now..I'm heading out for a riding lesson and crawfish boil and won't be back until later tonight.

I have no doubt that you and Soupster will have posted at least 50 comments telling me how I don't really care about Muslims being bigots (even though I do) just so you can feel justified in your own self righteous bigotry. 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

Any business who is open for the public good that refuses service to anyone based on their gender, race, sexuality, etc. is wrong.


In your opinion, but your opinion is wrong. 

alldayredux --- 11 years ago -

American Taliban fundies and Islamic fundies are closer than people realize in ideology.
It's amazing that it's not discussed.
PC run amok that you can't call Christians what they are....irrational, discriminatory and hiding their discrimination behind the bible just like 200 years ago. 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

allday you are ridiculous. Your post was discriminatory. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

How is THAT for entertaining?

Is that all? You usually run on page for page telling how wrong it is when it's a Christian. 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

I'll apologize for the length of this post up front. Sorry, I just have a lot to get out there.
And while I'm leaning this toward Christian business owners, I could just as easily use this same line of thinking with any religious group... Including Muslims. So, I haven't tried to hijack the thread... I promise.

Though I'm Christian and have my faith, I'm not super devout. I don't hate anyone for any reason until they give me a reason to dislike them (their sexual preference or skin color is not, and will never be a reason for me to dislike someone... their behavior can be a reason though).
This doesn't mean I accept everything that someone else may stand for, but I tolerate it as THEIR chosen lifestyle.
So, while I can feel sympathetic towards all people, I feel empathetic toward business owners... Because I am a business owner.
So I personally wouldn't refuse to serve a gay or lesbian couple, though another Christian business owner may hold tighter to their morals.
What's happening here is that we're literally pitting ethics (social norms and acceptances (and sometimes laws)) against morals (an individual's personal compass of right vs wrong).
Regardless of how you feel about the bible, we know what it says. Those who are devout Christians and who hold the bible sacred are being forced to abandon their morals in order to continue to own their business from their point of view. In essence they feel that to continue to own/operate their businesses, they must sell their souls. This perceived religious attack would be no different that forcing a Jewish restaurant to cook dairy and meat in the same area, or forcing the Muslims to prepare and serve ham to any Christian who walked in... In the sense that they are asked to give up or suspend their morals.
Their may be some concessions to be made on the Christian business-owner front, but for those of you who have total disdain for those business owners you're protesting against, remember that the owners are people also, and they are being asked to give something up that they feel morally obligated to follow.
Small business owners typically operate on a very thin margin and every waking moment goes into their business. It becomes who they are in a sense because they spend up to 18 hours a day working on keeping their business running. They and the business are the same person.
Even the IRS says that if you're a sole-proprietor. When I file my taxes, my business and I are the same entity.
I get it from both angles, and I don't know how to fix this. Ethically I have one point-of-view, yet morally I have the opposite point-of-view.
Do my rights get trumped by someone else simply because I own a business?
I have gay and lesbian friends, I don't want to see them refused service because of what their sexual preference is, but I also have friends who are business owners who I don't want to see attacked should they refuse to accommodate someone because they believe in their religion and want to follow it's rules.

So what do we do...? 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

Allday - I am not sure I could disagree more that all Christians are irrational and discriminatory. As a matter of fact that statement is irrational and discriminatory.

Slider - well said. 

Dorothy Parker --- 11 years ago -

I don't understand why people would want to discriminate against anyone when it comes to running a business. Money is money. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

I don't understand why people would want to discriminate against anyone when it comes to running a business. Money is money.

Dorothy - think the vast majority would agree with you. But for a few, it is not as important as their conviction. Which still leads me to think this should be a non issue. There will plenty of business to meet the gay wedding demand. No need to force by threat of law suit someone to act counter to their convictions.

Now if only the politicians and professional rabble rousers would stay out of it. 

Dorothy Parker --- 11 years ago -

No segment of the population should be discriminated against, that's why it's an issue. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

Dorothy. - the issue is not, not serving gay people. No one has been denied service because they are gay. The issue is some peoples convictions prevent them from bring an active participant in a gay wedding. It is the ceremony that is the issue. Not the people. This seems to be a very hard concept to explain clearly. 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

Thank you AMDG. that was my point.
This isn't an issue of what somebody wants. It's about religious conviction.
The very cornerstone of the Christian religion is sacrifice. Christians are taught from very young that what we want and what we need (religiously speaking) are rarely the same. We wear our sacrifices and convictions as a badge of honor. The more we're tested here on earth and we prevail, the stronger reward we build for ourselves in heaven.
What they want doesn't even come into play (sure... There will be some exceptions). They're living by a set of rules handed to them from a higher power.
This is about an ideology that's bigger than any one person.
As for money... A devout Christian will sacrifice money for their beliefs (tithing for example). They may very well WANT to serve a gay wedding and get the money for doing so. But doing so would require them to disobey something very sacred to them and possibly squander their salvation (some people are this devout...). How to you convince someone to compromise what they feel is paramount to their salvation in order to serve someone a cake.
Whatever your convictions... Would you give them away to make a few extra bucks? How much is your salvation worth to you? 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

Money is money.

Morals are morals, and convictions are convictions.

This seems to be a very hard concept to explain clearly.

No, it's a simple concept. They purposely don't want to understand, or they do understand and are purposely ignoring the truth. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

If morals (which became law) weren't integral to business decisions then the best business would be coccaine dealer.

Business people are faced with morals versus profit decisions everyday. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Define segment of the population?

Government sanctioned discrimination occurs everyday in the form of affirmitive action. 

alldayredux --- 11 years ago -

How "much" is your salvation worth to you?

Summed it up right there.

I don't know how much your premium is but save the money. It's a selfish endeavor played upon the weak by the preachers. 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

The truth for you allday

"For what is a man profited, if he shall gain the whole world, and lose his own soul? or what shall a man give in exchange for his soul?" 

smartypants --- 11 years ago -

The issue is some peoples convictions prevent them from bring an active participant in a gay wedding. It is the ceremony that is the issue. Not the people.

It's about religious conviction.

If only. This is about discriminating against a group of people who they find sexually immoral. They don't want to serve at a gay wedding because they are personally put off. I don't hear any of those who object to such saying they won't serve at a divorced person's remarriage, or the marriage of anyone who isn't a virgin. Adulterers, thieves, same thing. If they want to focus on one subset of what they deem "sinners", it isn't genuine and it isn't following some sort of sacred conviction. It's random and it's bologna.

The more we're tested here on earth and we prevail, the stronger reward we build for ourselves in heaven.

It could be a test of Christian love, to go ahead and serve anyway, and set aside your personal prejudices. There is only one Lawgiver and Judge. Who are you to judge your neighbor? Let he who is without sin cast the first stone. Love ye one another. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

If only.

As if you get to decide peoples beliefs for them. 

Slider152 --- 11 years ago -

All we have to go by is what is written. We're all free to interpret it in whatever way we deem fit.
For some, it means diluting the message and trying to force a square peg in a round hole. For others, it's about keeping traditions and lessons that were pretty specifically spelled out over and over again.

To each their own. The fact is that we all think we're right... For me... I'll stick to what was written as far as I personally am willing to.
You can do whatever you like, though it may be different than what I do... So if you won't be offended with my life choices... I won't be offended by yours, I just may choose not participate in it. 

smartypants --- 11 years ago -

As if you get to decide peoples beliefs for them.?

I'm not deciding people's beliefs. I'm not the one who claims to be a Christian, who then picks and chooses, because that's what they're doing. It's arbitrary and dishonest to claim otherwise. How about having a "conviction" to be honest about that. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

If only. This is about discriminating against a group of people who they find sexually immoral. They don't want to serve at a gay wedding because they are personally put off. I don't hear any of those who object to such saying they won't serve at a divorced person's remarriage, or the marriage of anyone who isn't a virgin. Adulterers, thieves, same thing. If they want to focus on one subset of what they deem "sinners", it isn't genuine and it isn't following some sort of sacred conviction. It's random and it's bologna.

Smarty you are just wrong with almost all those assumptions. It is not about the person or their homosexuality. Many of these people have been customers of these shops for years.

To these people, and to me, Actively participating in a sinful ceremony, is a sin. a
And they should not be pressured to do it. On your point about other sinful ceremonies, for example, for Catholics a second marriage without the first one being annulled, is exactly the same thing.

I personally have been in that situation with a good friend. After much though, I valued the friendship more than the sin, and willfully participated. I knew that was sinful, but it was my choice.

Not sure about you, smarty, but for many, I don't think they truly understand, or want to make an effort to understand the level of commitment these people have to their beliefs. If it was almost anything other than Christian, this level of commitment would be universally admired and applauded. 

smartypants --- 11 years ago -

I valued the friendship more than the sin, and willfully participated.

ty for your honesty. You passed the test of love. I respect that a heck of a lot more than hypocrisy. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

Thanks Smarty,

Sometimes there is no right answer. I am a victim of a Jesuit education, we were taught discernment of spirits. Your decisions should always be what would bring you closer to God.

If the choice is between good an evil, that is pretty easy discernment. My friends wedding was between two bad things, sin or hurt a friend. Those are harder. The hardest ones though are choosing between two goods. In those it is always easy to justify the good you want more, than the one you probably know God would want more. 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

After much though, I valued the friendship more than the sin, and willfully participated.

There was no sin there by your reasoning. There is no Scriptural backing for annulments.

If there was sin there, you wouldn't have passed the test of love. You would just be going against God.

Sometimes there is no right answer.

What? That ridiculous. There is ALWAYS a right answer. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

I'm not deciding people's beliefs.

But when they say it's not about the people but the ceremony. You scoffed.

Are you calling them liars? 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

I'm not deciding people's beliefs.

You want to though. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground