Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The fight over Confederate license plates in Texas

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
smartypants 1
wayward1 2
SoupIsGoodFood 23
AwesomeTattooedDragon 8
Gigix4 1
Dorothy Parker 2
Defcon1 30
Emperor of Kingwood 8
Judas 6
a889324uu 12
Butterbean 12
mutton 2
jacobson 11
RayofHope 6
AMDG 3
FNHO 1
alldayredux 2
JuanSequin 9
Impiety 6
ForeverInkedandFabulous 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Judas --- 11 years ago -

0


The right to free speech means nothing if not the right to express ideas that other people might find offensive. Protecting the exercise of that right is essential to democratic government, as the world was reminded, horrifically, by the mass murder of Muhammad-mocking cartoonists at France?s Charlie Hebdo magazine in January.

Whether, and under what circumstances, the government might be obligated to foster or facilitate potentially offensive speech is a much different question, with which the Supreme Court is currently wrestling, apropos a most un-French context: the rear ends of Texas gas-guzzlers.

Like many other states, Texas allows motorists who pay a fee to display special designs on their license plates. Some of these messages are created by the state legislature; others by private groups, subject to pre-approval by the state Motor Vehicles Board. The program generated $25 million between 2009 and 2014. Most designs honor colleges or military veterans and win easy authorization.

Yet when the Sons of the Confederacy asked to stamp the Confederate battle flag on Texas?s tags in 2011, the board refused, citing protests from African Americans and others who saw the flag, justifiably, as a symbol of slavery and secession.

Then-Gov. Rick Perry opposed the design, too: ?We don?t need to be scraping old wounds,? he said. At the time, he was seeking the 2012 Republican presidential nomination and coping with fallout from a Post article noting that his family once owned a hunting camp nicknamed with a racial slur.


So the Sons of the Confederacy went to court, where Texas argued that its law empowering the board to bar ?offensive? messages is perfectly constitutional. The tags are state property and therefore a means of ?government speech,? Texas argued; the Supreme Court has said governments have a right to get their messages out clearly and freely, just as individuals do.

A New Orleans-based federal appeals court sided with the Sons, though, ruling that a reasonable observer would associate the flag with the motorist, not the state.

Texas appealed, and in oral arguments Monday, the justices quickly identified the essential problem with its case. Permitting the board to ban ?offensive? designs gives it ?too broad a discretion,? as Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg put it. It smacks of ?viewpoint discrimination,? which is not allowed in state-established public forums.

Once a government opens up its license plates to private organizations? messages, including, as in Texas, political slogans such as ?Fight Terrorism,? it?s hard to draw the line at the Confederate flag, or any symbol ? doubly so in a state that commemorates Confederate Heroes Day on Jan. 19.

Everything?s bigger in Texas, it seems, including the contradictions. Still, the justices also seemed hesitant to force the state to allow any conceivable message on its license plates.

Again, it was Ginsburg who cut to the chase, asking the Sons of the Confederacy?s lawyer whether local Nazis have a right to slap swastikas on their tags. ?Yes,? he responded forthrightly but unsettlingly.

The trouble here, as Justice Sonia Sotomayor noted, is that a license plate ? owned by the government and manufactured under government auspices but displayed by a private individual on private property ? is ?hybrid speech. It?s both government and the individual speaking at the same time.?


And it?s hard to devise a constitutional rule that would protect the legitimate interests of both consistently. At least no court has managed to do so yet.

One option, discussed in court Monday, is to consider license-plate messages to be government speech, as long as the available messages result from an act of the state legislature ? not a bureaucratic process like Texas?s.

Alas, federal judges have had difficulty crafting such a standard in the context of ?Choose Life? tags ? the ones with simulated drawings of smiling children. Innocuous to the naked eye, they are promoted by anti-abortion groups and have thus triggered repeated lawsuits from abortion rights advocates.

One appeals court did approve Tennessee?s ?Choose Life? tags as legislatively authorized and, therefore, government speech. But another said South Carolina?s ?Choose Life? tags, also legislatively enacted, still amounted to viewpoint discrimination because the legislature didn?t offer a pro-choice alternative.

The only clear, consistent rule would be: States must either throw open their specialty-tag programs to all comers, from Daughters of the American Revolution to Citizens for Jihad, or eliminate them.

This would not only simplify free-speech law but also strike a small blow for transparent government. As Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. said Monday, Texas is ?only doing this to get the money.? He might have added: ?Without raising taxes.?

Yet if this case proves anything, it?s that a specialty tag program is no free lunch, just a smarter-than-usual fiscal gimmick. The next time a governor brags about how much his state?s program has raised, ask him if he counted litigation costs.



Cue Defcon. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

AHHHHHHHH!!!!! CONFEDERATES!!!! 

wayward1 --- 11 years ago -

No one ever cares for the 30-40 years of brutal, calculating politics that lead up to the civil war. All of the stonewalling, back room deals, heavy political lobbying. None of it is remembered or cared about even though it was about exactly what the war was about. Once someone finally said, to balls with this legislation and talking nonsense and grabbed their rifle, then poof, heroes were born for the ages. 

Judas --- 11 years ago -

Cue Soup Confederate. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

That was hours ago. Ketchup. 

FNHO --- 11 years ago -

Texas could raise serious money with this effort. I'd advise any against getting out of Kingwood though.
It's easy to be a gun wielding Confedrate idiot among friends. Not so much in other places. 

alldayredux --- 11 years ago -

Guess this answers the question always asked about "where are those confederates?"
Bahahaha
Laughingstock 

wayward1 --- 11 years ago -

The south may never rise again (darn you diabetic foot problems).
But it does have plenty of disposable income at the ready to give to state government social programs that benefit minorities.
God I love this country. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

Laughingstock

Yes. You are. 

Judas --- 11 years ago -

Confederate Soup with his stupid responses on cue. LOL 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

Judas with his bitter responses on cue. LOL. 

Dorothy Parker --- 11 years ago -

Each set of plates comes with one of these:

0 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

Seems to be something missing.

Sex change? 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

LMAO DP 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

That has all the class and dignity of a tattoo joint 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

I've been to some classy ink joints in my life. 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

For $25. extra, this special edition is available:0undefined 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

Oh yeah. I saw that one. You have to order it through the DNC. Only place it is available. 

Defcon1 --- 11 years ago -

Each set of plates comes with one of these:


And the dumbest comment so far of 2015 award goes tooooooo...

Not a SINGLE person I've ever seen out of thousands within the SCV I've encountered had a pair of truck nuts. Dumbest thing I've ever heard suggested be related to the Sons of Confederate Veterans.


Let me start by saying not just any person is even permitted to purchase this plate. You must PROVE your lineage to a Confederate Veteran who served HONORABLY during the war and must be a member in good standing with the Sons of Confederate Veterans.


I've approached a ton of morons around town during recruiting attempts who had Confederate Battle Flag stickers and whatnot and not a single one of them had a clue what the flag or the war was even about.

The SCV is a group of well educated, honorable men who's ONLY goal is to protect Confederate history from being erased and lost in the sea of modern myth commonly taught as fact regarding the war.

Not only do we clean up old Civil War veteran's grave sites, we erect new Confederate monuments and fight to protect those that have been long-standing that are under attack by those who wish to see them removed.

The flag belongs to me and those who also are descended from Confederate veterans...not the klan or anyone else.

"To you, Sons of Confederate Veterans, we submit THE VINDICATION OF THE CAUSE FOR WHICH WE FOUGHT; to your strength will be given the DEFENSE OF THE CONFEDERATE SOLDIER?S GOOD NAME, the guardianship of his history, the emulation of his virtues, THE PERPETUATION OF THE PRINCIPLES HE LOVED and which made him glorious and which you also cherish. Remember, it is your duty to see that THE TRUE HISTORY OF THE SOUTH IS PRESENTED TO FUTURE GENERATIONS."
-General Stephen D. Lee 

Defcon1 --- 11 years ago -

For example, we placed these in Palestine, TX along with an official Texas Historical Marker and a courtyard with each brick bearing the names of our Confederate ancestors and a couple other neat little things. Our hard work paid off on that one.

0 

Defcon1 --- 11 years ago -

0 

Defcon1 --- 11 years ago -

And it appears we've won the battle and we will be getting our plates soon...that is, if this article holds any truth...never know with huffingtonpost.

Court rules Texas can't prohibit CONFEDERATE plate.

Edit: This was an older article that's being passed around so who knows what's going on. I'd like to be a little more closely involved with the whole thing and help out if possible. Every other state who has filed to get their own SCV license plate and had to take it to court has won, so I have no doubt we will, too.

They can approve it or drag it out as long as it takes. We will fight until they give in. 

Defcon1 --- 11 years ago -

I'm particularly fond of this photo I took of our meeting place and our camp Commander.

0

If anyone is interested in joining the SCV, attending a meeting or anything else let me know and I'd be more than happy to help you research your ancestry and begin your entry into the SCV.

-Michael Fuhre
Adjudant, former 2LT Commander
PVT Kyle Needham Camp #2171
Sons of Confederate Veterans, Texas Division

Don't let your bloodline's sacrifices be forgotten and lost to the ages.

"Hear their stories from beyond the grave...So many left untold." 

ForeverInkedandFabulous --- 11 years ago -

Defcon, I think it's pretty cool that you've done search for your ancestors. 

RayofHope --- 11 years ago -

This is a pretty tough issue.

I have a black friend who gets very upset over the confederate flag and I feel I should be respectful of what her ancestors endured in the South (Though it was pretty bad in the North too).

At the same time, my family were confederate solders and our family never owned slaves. It's hard to forget about their sacrifices for what they viewed as an invasion. 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -


"To you, Sons of Confederate Veterans, we submit THE VINDICATION OF THE CAUSE FOR WHICH WE FOUGHT; to your strength will be given the DEFENSE OF THE CONFEDERATE SOLDIER?S GOOD NAME, the guardianship of his history, the emulation of his virtues, THE PERPETUATION OF THE PRINCIPLES HE LOVED and which made him glorious and which you also cherish. Remember, it is your duty to see that THE TRUE HISTORY OF THE SOUTH IS PRESENTED TO FUTURE GENERATIONS."
-General Stephen D. Lee


Let's examine that real reason:

"That in this free government all white men are and of right ought to be entitled to equal civil and political rights; that the servitude of the African race, as existing in these States, is mutually beneficial to both bond and free, and is abundantly authorized and justified by the experience of mankind, and the revealed will of the Almighty Creator, as recognized by all Christian nations; while the destruction of the existing relations between the two races, as advocated by our sectional enemies, would bring inevitable calamities upon both and desolation upon the fifteen slave-holding states."

Celebrating valor is appropriate.

Obfuscating cause is the antithesis of valor. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

With malice toward none, with charity for all, with firmness in the right as God gives us to see the right, let us strive on to finish the work we are in, to bind up the nation's wounds, to care for him who shall have borne the battle and for his widow and his orphan, to do all which may achieve and cherish a just and lasting peace among ourselves and with all nations. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

As a Son of the American Revolution, and having ancestors who were Confederate Officers as well as slave owners, the Confederate flag means nothing to me. They lost. 

Defcon1 --- 11 years ago -

That flag means everything to me. Honor, courage, sacrifice. They had to fight or lose everything.

Facing certain death in the face of an enemy that was slaughtering civilians on a massive scale, burning entire cities to the ground.

We will forever protect and honor the Confederate soldier and the cause for which he fought. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

and the cause for which he fought.?

What cause was that? 

Dorothy Parker --- 11 years ago -

Slavery and "states rights" to own them. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

No, the states rights issue had more to do with Congressional representation. 

ForeverInkedandFabulous --- 11 years ago -

When you see the confederate flag certain things automatically come to mind. When I see it, my first thought is slavery or white pride. I was raised to think that way and I don't know if my mind will ever change that way of thinking. Sorry- 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

the cause for which he fought.

This cause:


"That in this free government all white men are and of right ought to be entitled to equal civil and political rights; that the servitude of the African race, as existing in these States, is mutually beneficial to both bond and free, and is abundantly authorized and justified by the experience of mankind, and the revealed will of the Almighty Creator, as recognized by all Christian nations; while the destruction of the existing relations between the two races, as advocated by our sectional enemies, would bring inevitable calamities upon both and desolation upon the fifteen slave-holding states." 

ForeverInkedandFabulous --- 11 years ago -

As for slavery, blacks owned blacks during that time. It was not not just a white/black issue.

There are a few people who are very proud to live and be apart of the south and it's history. For example my mother's family is from Kentucky. She never lived there. Now she does. But she has this picture in her house that says....I'm not from the south, but I got here as fast as I could. 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

Inked, did you read the above quote from the Texas articles of secession?

In Texas, especially, it was a black and white issue. 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

Another special edition for an additional $25.

0 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

Another special edition for an additional $25.

Did you send your $25 in already? 

Defcon1 --- 11 years ago -

I love how convinced people are regarding the myth of the righteous yankee army volunteering to fight the evils of slavery.

Why, then, did Lincoln wait until 1863 to even address southern slavery?

Why, then, didn't union officers give up their slaves? Or as the history books like to refer to them as "servants." You'd really think they'd lead by example.

Why was slavery and endentured servitude allowed to persist within the union until months after the war's end?

You all seem to forget the union's massive participation in the slave trade or Lincoln's own words saying he didnt care about slavery or blacks and that the war was only for the purpose of forcing the rebel states back into the union against their will.

Your perception of the war and it's causes couldn't be further from the truth. Millions of men who never owned a single slave fought to protect their homes and they are who we honor. 

Defcon1 --- 11 years ago -

And if my southern flag reminds you of slavery or oppression then this flag DEFINITELY should.

0 

page 1 2 3 4
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground