Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Oil spill

who's talking here?

smartypants 11
SoupIsGoodFood 13
Perfection 4
voice of reason 5
Mark 2
AGME98 2
Dr Aborto 1
Miss Understanding 1
PreciousAngel 1
Joe Blow 2
Nightshade 1
SGDmom040708 1
Emperor of Kingwood 21
DVaz 2
a889324uu 3
Not KU 16
Leila 1
jacobson 50
AMDG 47
Wicked 8
FNHO 3
satsuma 10
logic 1
alldayredux 3
greaser1952 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Wicked --- 11 years ago -

http://www.dailykos.com/story/2015/01/19/1358683/-50-000-barrels-of-oil-spill-into-Yellowstone-River?detail=facebook



How is XL Pipeline looking now? 

AGME98 --- 11 years ago -

So, what's your solution to this? Should we stop using oil all together immediately, or should we just stop moving it by pipeline? If we stop moving it by pipeline, does that mean that we should immediately de-commission all tens of thousands of miles of pipelines in this country? Would you prefer that all of that oil move around the country via trucks? Pipeline is by far the safest and cheapest method of transporting products around to different markets.

So, I'd really like to hear your solution. Because, I'm fairly certain, you don't have a real solution. You just would rather live in your total ideological world where the world can function on rainbows and sunshine, all the while you drive your own car made and run on petroleum and use all of the products that you have in your home that make your life easier that are made from petroleum derivatives. 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

"they are unaware of any threats to public safety or health"

And the kos headline is incorrect. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

For all the pipeline experts out there - has the industry given any thought to a double skinned p/l when crossing sensitive areas. Something like encasing a 20 inch pipe with a 36 inch pipe for the run between valves over sensitive areas, like rivers? Just wondering. 

Dr Aborto --- 11 years ago -

as the industry given any thought to a double skinned p/l when crossing sensitive areas.

That just sounds expensive. It will cost jobs. You know who had double skinned pipelines? Stalin and ISIS. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

yea Doc - what was I thinking. Thanks for the shake back to reality. 

Not KU --- 11 years ago -

Thanks for the link Leila. 

FNHO --- 11 years ago -

as the industry given any thought to a double skinned p/l when crossing sensitive areas.

Nope. Damn the results and keep costs down. 

Mark --- 11 years ago -

Thicker walled pipe is commonly used under water crossings. As for casings, pipe inside of pipe, they are used sometimes over rivers and under roads/ train tracks with vents on either side to show if a release has occurred. Again, this is some 30 year old pipe. Keystone will be the latest PLM technology and materials. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

thanks Mark - thought something like this must be going on -

Makes me wonder if there would be more to gain environmentally, and maybe more jobs created if there was some mandated age restriction on pipelines. As opposed to building Keystone. For all I know we may already have such a restriction.

Have no clue on what that does to infrastructure, supply disruptions etc, but I have confidence that if you incentivize really smart folks, you get pretty good answers. 

Mark --- 11 years ago -

No, please no more regulations. Pipeline operators must run smart tools, not to exceed so much time, and repair any anomalies. Most pipeline systems are 30-50 years old, but, are being replaced/repaired/added too more often than not. No minds will be changed but at least understand the business. We get paid per metered barrel, not sucked up off the ground. BTW, I love solar, BHO needs to send me some panels and a fuel cell to put back in the grid from which I take. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

No, please no more regulations

Yea - sorry what was I thinking. 

smartypants --- 11 years ago -

So, what's your solution to this? Should we stop using oil all together immediately, or should we just stop moving it by pipeline?

How about we let Canada pipe the oil they want to sell to China through their own country? 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

How about we let Canada pipe the oil they want to sell to China through their own country?

LOL, the oil will be refined here in the US. Jobs. 

Perfection --- 11 years ago -

Where does oil come from? 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

God. 

Nightshade --- 11 years ago -


Where does oil come from?

God.




LOL! Funniest post of the year so far.




0 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

LOL! Funniest post of the year so far.

So you think the truth is funny? Now I understand why you post like you do. 

Not KU --- 11 years ago -

How about we let Canada pipe the oil they want to sell to China through their own country?

Yes...

the oil will be refined here in the US. Jobs.

That's fine. No ecology needs a pipeline of tar sands oil going thru it. 

Wicked --- 11 years ago -

"they are unaware of any threats to public safety or health"

And the kos headline is incorrect.





The governor has declared a state of emergency. The water is now undrinkable. I'm not sure what your definition of public health and safety is but when the majority of these people get their drinking water from the Yelliwstone, it becomes a problem. It affects ME and MY family. The Yellowstone River is the longest undammed river in the nation. It is interesting to me how with many of you, your wealth and getting to the 1% in income takes precedence over keeping the environment around you healthy and fit for future generations. 

Perfection --- 11 years ago -

I wonder what the loss of those barrels will do to their profit margins.......

UGH 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

The governor has declared a state of emergency.

No surprise that he would overact and be pc. He's a Dem.

I'm not sure what your definition of public health and safety is but when the majority of these people get their drinking water from the Yelliwstone, it becomes a problem.

The intake from the Yellowstone is 14 ft below the surface (the oil floats) and has been closed as a precaution. Water is being trucked in so no threat to public health and safety.

FYI, the "they are unaware of any threats to public safety or health" quote came from the article YOU posted the link to. 

Wicked --- 11 years ago -

FYI. I was posting updated info. This governor is a moderate democrat as are all Montana dems. We are a red state. But the reason we don't let all this oil boom go on is because of these types of problems. Remember. Poverty with a view. Health and keeping our land and water pristine takes a priority because we love our children. 

Perfection --- 11 years ago -

Poverty with a view. Health and keeping our land and water pristine takes a priority because we love our children.

We love them, just keep them poor.

Which is worse? 

Wicked --- 11 years ago -

How do you define poor Perfection? 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

LOL, the oil will be refined here in the US. Jobs.

US Gulf has, and will continue to refine oil with or without keystone. No one, not even the proponents themselves, are making any claim for increased refining jobs due to the pipeline.

If I can ask, where are you getting this ?? Or what is the logic behind it ?? 

Perfection --- 11 years ago -

Wicked --- 18 sec ago - quote - hide comments
How do you define poor Perfection?


How do you define it, it is your quote. 

Wicked --- 11 years ago -

Yes, so typical to redirect the question. It is interesting. Texas is one of the states who is doing pretty well yet has a really high rate of hunger. Why is that? And please don't blame it on the Mexicans. There is no excuse for hunger in a developed nation. 

AGME98 --- 11 years ago -

I've got a better solution, for all of the states/localities that are of the mind that they don't want to extract and utilize their own resources, you can pay a utilization fee to the states/localities that will. That way, you can be happy to not produce your own resources and pay a "tax" to get the resources into your state. It is funny that you want to demonize fossil fuels and at the same time, enjoy all of the products and modern conveniences that it provides YOU!

As far as the doubled walled pipes being used in river crossings, that can actually cause more problems than it helps. Mark is correct that the better solution is using heavier wall pipe for road and river crossings. This has been done as a matter of practice for years and years. Double walled pipe can lead to higher instances of corrosion on the pipe. 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

US Gulf has, and will continue to refine oil with or without keystone. No one, not even the proponents themselves, are making any claim for increased refining jobs due to the pipeline.

Many of the refineries on the Gulf coast constructed refining units (expansion) specifically designed to be capable of handling the Canadian crude. Therefore, there has ALREADY been an increase in jobs in both construction and refining.

The pipeline would be safer and more cost effective than rail or truck to those refineries. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

The pipeline would be safer and more cost effective than rail or truck to those refineries.

Agree with this

Many of the refineries on the Gulf coast constructed refining units (expansion) specifically designed to be capable of handling the Canadian crude.

I don't know of one refinery that has made any significant expansion/investment specifically for Canadian crude.

Don't think they had any need to, think all the major usg refineries have been configured to run heavy crude for quite some time ( ie - Maya, a bunch of ven stuff, and Arab Heavy) 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

As far as the doubled walled pipes being used in river crossings, that can actually cause more problems than it helps. Mark is correct that the better solution is using heavier wall pipe for road and river crossings. This has been done as a matter of practice for years and years. Double walled pipe can lead to higher instances of corrosion on the pipe.

Thanks - was pretty sure there was a answer for this from the folks who actually know something about it. 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

I don't know of one refinery that has made any significant expansion/investment specifically for Canadian crude.

I can't help it if you were uninformed. Now you aren't.

Don't think they had any need to, think all the major usg refineries have been configured to run heavy crude for quite some time ( ie - Maya, a bunch of ven stuff, and Arab Heavy)

Has nothing to do with viscosity, It is the BS&W content. 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

Thanks - was pretty sure there was a answer for this from the folks who actually know something about it.?

I thought that anyone with a high school education would know that liquid moving through a pipe results in heat from friction which causes condensation on the pipe which would be trapped in the space between the pipes. Therefore, I didn't think it was worth commenting on. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

Has nothing to do with viscosity, It is the BS&W content.

Ah so you are telling me that USG Refineries have made significant investments, that are creating jobs in
usg refineries, to run solely Canadian crude oil, because of sentiment and water cuts.

You sir have no clue at all what you are talking about. 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

You sir have no clue at all what you are talking about.

No, you're the one who doesn't know what they're talking about.

"Reducing crude oil cost is the major incentive driving crude and vacuum unit projects to handle heavy Canadian crudes. But such crudes - Albian Heavy, Christina Lake, MacKay River and others derived from oil sands?today present refiners with a unique set of problems not just because of extra-low API gravity, but also because of asphaltenes, vanadium and nickel, high solids content and extremely high viscosity vacuum residues. To process such crudes reliably over a 4-5 year run length, and to maximize product yields and quality, demands fundamentally sound process and equipment design. And some features are unique."

Refineries have been able to handle heavy crude for years, but the high corrosion factor of the tar sands oil within the refining units requires refineries that are specially equipped. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

"Reducing crude oil cost is the major incentive driving crude and vacuum unit projects to handle heavy Canadian crudes. But such crudes?Albian Heavy, Christina Lake, MacKay River and others derived from oil sands?today present refiners with a unique set of problems not just because of extra-low API gravity, but also because of asphaltenes, vanadium and nickel, high solids content and extremely high viscosity vacuum residues. To process such crudes reliably over a 4-5 year run length, and to maximize product yields and quality, demands fundamentally sound process and equipment design. And some features are unique."

firstly not one word of that has anything at all to do with BS&W which was the "lynch pin" of your argument - just one post ago. Guessing you read the post you found that on and saw had nothing to do with this.

Further - here is the English translation of what you just posted.

Canadian Crude oil is cheap, but it sucks, and requires refinery investment to run it.

You see the only thing that makes Canadian tar sands crude attractive to the USG is the price. The reason the crude is cheap, besides its quality is that it does not have easy access to foreign markets. The pool of available buyers is small, it is cheap because hardly anyone can buy it.

Surprisingly, and quite contrary to your argument, the solution to Canadian producers on how to get rid of this discount on the price due to lack of markets is the, wait for it, Keystone pipeline.

I repeat my first and main point, as you try and wiggle the conversation away from it, there is not 1 refining job in the USG that is dependent of the Keystone pipeline/ 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

firstly not one word of that has anything at all to do with BS&W which was the "lynch pin" of your argument

LOL, solids in crude are a component of BS&W in crude.

You just continue to make yourself look foolish with your lack of knowledge.

The Bible and oil e&p and refining are topics you should stay away from.

I repeat my first and main point, as you try and wiggle the conversation away from it, there is not 1 refining job in the USG that is dependent of the Keystone pipeline/

And you are still incorrect. 

Miss Understanding --- 11 years ago -

The governor has declared a state of emergency. The water is now undrinkable. I'm not sure what your definition of public health and safety is but when the majority of these people get their drinking water from the Yelliwstone, it becomes a problem. It affects ME and MY family. The Yellowstone River is the longest undammed river in the nation. It is interesting to me how with many of you, your wealth and getting to the 1% in income takes precedence over keeping the environment around you healthy and fit for future generations.


Lovely post that cuts to the heart of the matter.


You just continue to make yourself look foolish with your lack of knowledge.

How rude. You cannot possibly be a man of God, not in my book! 

page 1 2 3 4 5 6
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground