Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Outrage Over Grand Jury Decision In Eric Garner's Death

who's talking here?

SoupIsGoodFood 4
Red Heifer 1
SleightOfHand 1
Perfection 2
RiteWingKing 1
Humbletexan1 1
Warren Peace 8
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
Mark 1
Dr Aborto 2
Jeff 4
Work in Progress 6
SagaciousSighFiGurl 3
Joe Blow 4
sheddy 1
kwgraniteguy 1
Texan65 1
Emperor of Kingwood 8
a889324uu 6
Not KU 13
Prolix Raconteur 3
mutton 2
jacobson 1
FNHO 1
them 1
logic 12
Cigawitz 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

them --- 11 years ago -

The grand jury was wrong this time.


WASHINGTON -- Opinions on the decision reached by a grand jury last week not to indict the police officer who killed 18-year-old Michael Brown largely broke down along partisan lines, with many conservatives agreeing that Darren Wilson should not have faced a trial. But another grand jury's decision not to indict a New York City police officer who placed 43-year-old Eric Garner into a chokehold, resulting in his death, seems to be playing out much differently so far.

The fact that Garner's death was captured on video and that Officer Daniel Pantaleo used a chokehold tactic that has been banned by the New York City Police Department seem to be key factors for many on the right who believe the officer should have been indicted.

"The grand jury's decision not to bring any charges against the officer who killed Garner is inexplicable. It defies reason. It makes no sense," wrote Sean Davis at The Federalist. "Unlike the Michael Brown case, we don't have to rely on shaky and unreliable testimony from so-called eyewitnesses. We don't need to review bullet trajectories or forensics. All we have to do is watch the video and believe our own eyes." 

Warren Peace --- 11 years ago -

I can understand why people would find this more outrageous than what happened in Ferguson. But there's still a rational explanation for what happened. Yes, the medical examiner ruled the death a homicide, but that just means the death was caused in part by someone else - it was not entirely the deceased's actions or state of health that were sole factors in his death. Homicide in that context does not mean the same thing as the criminal act of homicide, which requires intent. Even a potential charge of negligent homicide requires the state to prove criminal negligence. Criminal negligence requires a reasonable person standard. When a law enforcement officer is involved, the court may get into a "reasonable officer" standard. Good luck getting any jury to agree what a reasonable officer would do. I still maintain the officer was negligent in his application of the technique he used, but the grand jury seems to have determined it did not rise to the level of criminal negligence. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

I still have a problem with that level of force for selling untaxed cigarettes. Why was there ever a need to take him down? 

Not KU --- 11 years ago -

I still have a problem with that level of force for selling untaxed cigarettes.

Me too. Bob..the need came from resisting arrest. Discretion on part of NYPD was seriously lacking. 

SleightOfHand --- 11 years ago -

"Why was there ever a need to take him down? "

If I recall the video correctly, he began backing away. He is a big guy and when people start backing away when they aren't free to leave, they tend to run. Would I have taken him down for cigarets, most likely not, but I have never dealt with him before, these officers had. 

Texan65 --- 11 years ago -

Seems like manslaughter to me.... 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Ok, so he runs. He's a big fat guy, he wont go too far too fast. There was no other options available to deal with this blood thirsty criminal? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 11 years ago -

I saw some of the video. There were several officers there and it didn't look like to me they didn't have control of him so I don't see why the escalation to extreme measures.

I know he was big, but either something not really visible to an audience watching the vid was going on or there was lots of force that maybe wasn't necessary going on.

Totally different from Ferguson. 

Not KU --- 11 years ago -

Justice Dept. to Investigate NYC Chokehold Death
WASHINGTON ? Dec 3, 2014, 8:06 PM ET
By ERIC TUCKER Associated Press

source ABC news 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

I thought it to be a bit excessive. 

Warren Peace --- 11 years ago -

I still have a problem with that level of force for selling untaxed cigarettes. Why was there ever a need to take him down?

The level of force wasn't applied for the act of selling untaxed cigarettes. A level of force was used to effect an arrest because a crime was committed and Garner did not comply with a lawful arrest. From there, the appropriate level of force can be disputed. Courts will give officers leeway to be imperfect in making arrest, particularly when reaction time is limited.

What we see on video is what most officers would classify as passive resistance - failure to comply with a lawful command without an attempt to harm the officer. Typically, low levels of force can be used to counter this. It may range from pain compliance techniques such as pressure points or joint locks to takedowns. But officers will disagree on whether the type of takedown this officer attempted on this subject was necessary. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

The level of force wasn't applied for the act of selling untaxed cigarettes. A level of force was used to effect an arrest because acrime was committed and Garner did not comply with a lawful arrest

I know that. My point is that the underlying charge is a very low level misdemeanor, basically a ticket. Was an arrest really necessary? 

Cigawitz --- 11 years ago -

 

Warren Peace --- 11 years ago -

There was no other options available to deal with this blood thirsty criminal?

I believe there had to have been better options because common use of force policies have better techniques (lower risk and lower profile) available than what this officer used. We can't say for sure without knowing the NYPD training manual, but I can think of several common techniques that occurred to me as I was watching the video for the first time.


My point is that the underlying charge is a very low level misdemeanor, basically a ticket. Was an arrest really necessary?

My initial reaction was that it was not necessary. The officer often has discretion, but there's a chance the decision to arrest may not have been his. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

I just wonder if the cop in the green jersey tried to avoid it going physical or escalated it. 

Cigawitz --- 11 years ago -

Maybe it was just his time. The cop in the green jersey is just as free as the cops in the Rodney King video. 

RiteWingKing --- 11 years ago -

From there, the appropriate level of force can be disputed. Courts will give officers leeway to be imperfect in making arrest, particularly when reaction time is limited.

Then I ask where was the CPR. Where is the call to Medical Resources.

A loss of life over illegal cigs.

Totally different situation than Ferguson.

Maybe not Homicide but negligence. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

This one really bothers me. I hear what you are saying Warren, but I understand the outrage and feel it myself.

Totally different situation from Ferguson. This one I "get." 

logic --- 11 years ago -

Totally different situation from Ferguson.

I don't see the logic behind that statement. They both broke the law and they both resisted arrest.

When do we hold people accountable for the actions that instigate an incident? All they had to do was follow the instructions of the police and they would both be alive today. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

All they had to do was follow the instructions of the police and they would both be alive today.

Yes, you are right. But what still bothers me is the question was an arrest for such a low level ticketable crime really necessary? Did the cop do everything at his disposal to avoid the violence?

There are some very good and reputable police officers that I believe would have handled the situation much differently. On the other hand, there are those that are just itching to exert their power at any opportunity. 

logic --- 11 years ago -

But what still bothers me is the question was an arrest for such a low level ticketable crime really necessary?

Apparently he was a repeat offender. The law may be stupid, but the police don't make the laws. They are there to enforce them. That is their job.

Did the cop do everything at his disposal to avoid the violence?

The cops did everything necessary. The man was given the opportunity to go peacefully. They asked him several times. All the man had to do was to go with the officers peacefully.

I hate that it turned out that way, but the man was the instigator. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

Brown didn't merely "resist arrest." He reached for a cop's gun and then charged him. The scenarios are as different as night and day. I have no sympathy for Brown. He got the inevitable consequence of his very, very poor decisions.

This guy? No, I'm really bothered by it. I do realize that the intent to kill was not there. But it is definitely disturbing. 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

I never saw him charge a cop in all the videos.

Can you link a video that shows him going for the gun and charging?

Did you guys hear about the cop who killed the 12 year old? He was released by one department and found not fit for duty. He was an emotional crybaby. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 11 years ago -

"Totally situation from Ferguson.

I don't see the logic behind that statement. They both broke the law and they both resisted arrest."




Why? There were several cops directly involved in the scuffle. More involved witnesses, providing what Ferguson situation didn't have.

Seems rather important to me. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

The 12 year old is disturbing too. He had taken the Orange tip off of his plastic gun, and was waving it around. I do understand that the cop had no way of knowing whether it was real or not. Very sad situation. 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

The cop shot him within TWO SECONDS. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

Did he point the fake gun at the cop? They shoot if you point a gun at them. A 12 year old with a gun with make you just as dead as a 22 year old with one.

I do agree that it needs to be investigated. They are never to be above the law. And the right to kill is a giant responsibility and needs to be overseen. 

Perfection --- 11 years ago -

How can someone say the Grand Jury was wrong when they did NOT sit in the room and consider ALL the evidence?

While I agree, the video is horrible - I don't know what else was presented.

The autopsy report noted his obesity and his other chronic conditions as causes as well.

But the main cause of his death was his breaking the law then not abiding when caught.

With all this scrutiny on the actions of the policy and this willingness to immediately believe them wrong and criminals RIGHT, why would anyone take that job?

Seriously, look at yourselves - you are giving more credence to criminals and wanting to let them off all the time for breaking laws.

Do you really want that? What makes you feel you can determine what laws are okay to enforce and others not okay?

In NY, they don't allow selling cigarettes without high taxes, the State and City need those taxes to pay for services to the citizens of the state. As such, they have created a ton of laws that people have to abide by so the state and city can collect that revenue.

So let me ask you this........... if you feel this is not theft, what is?

Is it only theft if it directly impacts you or your neighbors? 

Perfection --- 11 years ago -

The cop shot him within TWO SECONDS.


Delayed response.

The officer also requested THREE times for him to put it down.

THREE trumps TWO 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

You're saying that the cop asked three times within a 2 second period? That's crap.
The child was shot almost immediately by a cop that was UNFIT FOR DUTY DUE TO HIS LACK OF MATURITY AND INABILITY TO PERFORM BASIC FUNCTIONS DURING A WEAPONS TRAINING EXERCISE with a previous department.
He was described as "weepy" and his handgun performance was dismal. Other descriptions of him were "dangerous loss of composure, emotional meltdown" and a memo regarding him states "time, nor training will be able to change or correct these deficiencies."

The cops, prior to arriving on scene, were informed that the gun was "probably fake" and after shooting the child, they offered no assistance.

If you're OK with cops shooting a child with a fake gun, do you have an age cutoff? If 12 is OK, what about 10? How about 7? Would you be OK with them blasting the skull of a 4 year old? 

Prolix Raconteur --- 11 years ago -

This thread would not exist if:

black cop/black perp
black cop/white perp
white cop/white perp

The mainstream media continues to fan the flames and perpetuate the continuum of a white oppressor/black victimhood narrative , all in the name of sensationalism and ratings. 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

Perfection, are you OK with cops being judge, jury, and executioner for theft?

Where do you draw the line?

If a toddler steals a pack of gum, do we just get rid of the problem before he grows up?
Seriously...

I'm amazed at how many people are OK with the fascist police state. 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

Prolix, and yet seem to be the only one bringing up race.
Interesting. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

Hey Jams, I read that the 911 operator was told that it was probably a fake gun, but that he/she did not tell the cops that. Am I mistaken? 

Prolix Raconteur --- 11 years ago -

Prolix, and yet seem to be the only one bringing up race.
Interesting.


Don't be coy. This case has been piggy backed by the media on the Ferguson finding as a direct example of a campaign by white police targeting and brutalizing "innocent" black citizens.

This case is ALL about race, lest we would never have heard about it. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

And I don't think any of us want a police state. We just want to be reasonable, just, and fair to all parties.

That's where the jury comes in. We are on the same side here, I think. I am, obviously, not ok with unjust killings. I also recognize a cop's right to protect themselves and enforce the law within the law.

If we know for sure that has been broken, then we are absolutely on the same side. Sometimes, we disagree about whether or not that has been broken, as humans are prone to do. 

logic --- 11 years ago -

The scenarios are as different as night and day

They resisted arrest differently, but they both resisted arrest which instigated a response by the police.

The bottom line is - if they had obeyed the police instructions, they wouldn't have died that day. They aren't as different as night and day. 

Dr Aborto --- 11 years ago -

Here is my opinion and thus, the correct opinion.

Cops come up to you because you were selling cigarettes. You can state your case, argue, yell or whatever. The moment they say, "You're Under Arrest". DO NOT FIGHT IT. Unless the cops secretly plant cocaine on you, you'll go to jail for a moment. You'll get a court case and probably just get community service or worst case scenario, a ticket.

This guy resisted arrest so the tiny cops had to bring down this giant of a man to get the cuffs on. It's sad he died but the guy wasn't in best of health (asthma and heart probs) so that didn't help either. But he would still be alive if he played it cool.

No doubt, there is a race relation problem in America. People assume the worst out of blacks and other minorities. I see it even on KU all the time. It's frustrating when it happens over and over again. But I think we live in an age with cameras and the internet, that if we play it cool, we can eliminate a lot of unnecessary death and bring out the ugliness of racial prejudices out into the light. 

Not KU --- 11 years ago -

The bottom line is - if they had obeyed the police instructions, they wouldn't have died that day. They aren't as different as night and day.

That reads like your ok w/heavy handed law enforcement tactics. That is your prerogative. I hope nothing like this happens to you or your loved ones. To digress a little off topic. Last night I was going home from playing out. A constables car was behind me at an intersection. When the light changed he sped past me and exceeded the speed limit w/out any lights on as if, that law enforcement officer is above posted speed limits. I don't have a lot of tolerance for law enforcement breaking the law under any condition.
They are to be the example. Not the exception. 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

Cops even shoot their own 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground