Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Pew Research Center study on religion and public life.

who's talking here?

Work in Progress 9
Emperor of Kingwood 2
a889324uu 2
Butterbean 3
jacobson 7
AMDG 12
satsuma 3
alldayredux 6

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Not sure what this all means - but found it interesting

Pew Research Center study on religion and public life.

Findings:

72% - think religion is losing influence on public issues
49% - belief churches should express views on social and political issues (up 6%)
47% - believe Republicans are friendly toward religion
29% - believe Democrats are friendly toward religion
30% - believe Obama administration is friendly toward religion (down 7%)
28% - Catholics believe Obama administration is "unfriendly" to religion (up 13%)


Republican Resentments
Pew reports that many Republicans say their party is doing a "bad job" and want it to be more conservative on abortion and same-sex marriage.

Democratic Dangers
Increases in those who see the Democratic Party as unfriendly toward religion reflect battles over contraceptive mandates, conscience rights and religious freedom.

A related danger may be electoral strategies that focus primarily on those with no religious affiliation, single women and educational elites, along with African-Americans and Hispanics

This progressive version of the culture wars can make the Democratic Party less welcoming for people with traditional religious beliefs. 

satsuma --- 12 years ago -

Religion in public life 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Thanks for the posting the link 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

When did the democrats become so anti-Christianity? Was it a result of the religious right siding with the Republicans? Or did the religious right side with the Republicans because the democrats were already anti-Christianity? 

a889324uu --- 12 years ago -

Democrats aren't anti-Christianity.

They are anti Christians confusing their version of the bible and religion with the Constitution.

But you knew that. 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

Democrats aren't anti-Christianity.They are anti Christians confusing their version of the bible and religion with the Constitution.But you knew that.

No, I disagree with that.

So back to the question, when did it begin? It's gotten worse as of late, but when did it start? 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Democrats aren't anti-Christianity.

Yes, they are. 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

But how did it start and morph into what it is now? Basically 180 out from all Christian values? 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Not sure WIP, I think the shift became more dramatic with the Jerry Falwell, moral majority movement. This is just memory and opinion, but before that I think folks did a better job of keeping the secular - secular, and the religious - religious.

Of course the moral majority arose because of a perceived need - as the secular government drifted farther and farther away from some moral norms that were unchallenged before.

So not sure which is the chicken, and which is the egg, but IMO the social revolution of my generation in the 60's, brought about the moral majority reaction in the mid 70's.

The northern working class, union member democrat's priorities were getting pulled between the union affiliation and these, lack of a better word family value candidates from the right.

In the south, the bible belt Christians fled the traditional democratic south in favor of this movement.

Prior to all of this, there wasn't much of a perceived religious difference between say a Tip O'Neill Catholic, and good Presbyterian Republican, so the fight was secular. I miss those days. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

Do I get to split my opinion between the years as a republican and years as a democrat?

Neither were/are "anti-Christianity." 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

Thanks AMDG, that was a really good and insightful answer. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Just speaking for me, and not looking for a fight. But I am more a secular Republican ( small goverment, fiscal resoponsibility, etc), and more a religious democrat ( immigration, social programs, etc)

I don't need anyone to point out the inconsistencies of this position, I am aware of them. Not to mention the big one issue items, like abortion. 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

The smaller the government, the less those differences would matter other than on message boards tiffs. But the bigger the government, the more our personal views get punished or rewarded by bureaucrats. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

I think folks did a better job of keeping the secular - secular, and the religious - religious.

A good example of why religion is bad.

God wants his people to involve Him in ALL aspects of their lives, therefore there should be no "religious" only or "secular" only for a Christian. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Neither were/are "anti-Christianity."

You are anti-Christianity right now. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

and more a religious democrat ( immigration, social programs, etc)

Conservatives have no problem with immigration - the legal kind, and they have no problem with social programs - just not the ones Democrats favor that keep people in bondage for their entire lives. 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

Neither Republicans nor Democrats have done squat to stop the surge in illegal immigration.

Both parties have benefitted from the surge. Republicans talk against it, but they aren't actually against it, or going to do anything about it.

And pretty much ditto on the social programs as well. They talk a good game during election cycles, then nothing. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

You are anti-Christianity right now.

May be time for an early chill pill, Jake. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

Just speaking for me, and not looking for a fight. But I am more a secular Republican ( small goverment, fiscal resoponsibility, etc), and more a religious democrat ( immigration, social programs, etc)

I don't need anyone to point out the inconsistencies of this position, I am aware of them. Not to mention the big one issue items, like abortion.


I'm somewhere in that category, AMDG. I'm comfortable with it. 

alldayredux --- 12 years ago -

It's just more proof we're becoming more educated and as that happens religion goes the way of Apollo.

And Work in Progress is elcorrecto. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -


It's just more proof we're becoming more educated and as that happens religion goes the way of Apollo.



I don't think there is any direct relationship between education, and atheism. I know, and know of some insanely, scary smart people in a few disciplines. Most theists, some atheists.
One has little to do with the other. 

alldayredux --- 12 years ago -

You don't think there's a direct relationship between education and atheism??

Then your statement does have 1 fact. You don't think. Or more fairly stated you don't research. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

A 2011 Gallup poll found 92% of Americans said yes to the basic question "Do you believe in God?", while 7% said no and 1% had no opinion.[73]


A 2012 WIN-Gallup International poll showed that 5% of Americans considered themselves "convinced" atheists.

Numbers vary, but something over 90% of Americans are theists. It is just atheist elitism that make them think they are smarter than the other 90%. 

alldayredux --- 12 years ago -

Thar's this thingy called science/studies/research that proves it. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Thar's this thingy called science/studies/research

Which you don't understand. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

No problem allday, have a good night 

alldayredux --- 12 years ago -

It's not just "no problem," it's fact. 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

There was an article in the Huffington Post a few years ago that claimed that Atheists were smarter than people who believe in religion. It was junk statistics that was easily debunked, but I think that is what he/she is remembering. They used the same statistical trick that gets used when they compare red states and blue states to each other to show how blue states are better in some way.

They aren't comparing actual people, or even actual demographics, they are comparing regions made up of a mix of all the people with another region. It's absolute junk statistics. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Yea WIP - I also think I remember some study with a conclusion that Atheists has on average an IQ 3.5 pts higher than theists, and 1.5 pts higher than agnostics. Don't think I have ever seen that study with a confidence interval, or margin of error. Didn't look that hard. Even if 3.5 pts is statistically significant, you would have a hard time telling me it is practically significant. And I am very sure know thoughtful person would use it to conclude that atheists are "smarter" than theists.

There was also a study that regressed education with belief in God, that showed a negative correlation, but the R2 was like .6 or something. Not a very convincing correlation of anything. 

a889324uu --- 12 years ago -

Over 60 studies over several decades disagree - reviews and studies have been conducted and published. Check out Personality and Social Psychology Review.

That isn't to say there aren't smart theists or ignorant atheists, but overall, atheists score higher intellectually than those who worship a belief over verifiable facts/science.

You not believing in the results/studies doesn't make them less accurate. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Thanks 88 - i skimmed the article. Will try to read it in detail at some point.

The only conclusion I read in skimming the meta analysis they did of 63 other studies, was there was a negative correlation between IQ and theism. I looked for some order of magnitude - but didn't see any. Would like to find the slope of the regressed line they chose, will see if it is in the details somewhere.

There is a significant difference, I think, if the slope of the regressed line is - 2 or - 0.000001. They are both negative, but say different things.

Will see if I can find it in the study and let you know. Or if you have a chance you can take a look and let me know. 

alldayredux --- 12 years ago -

Would like to find the slope of the regressed line they chose, will see if it is in the details somewhere.

LOL. Go ahead and find that and I'm sure it'll change the conclusion of the 60 studies.

You're great fun. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

You know what - Allday - I concede. On average, the give or take 5% of the world that is Atheist, will have a higher IQ score than the 95% that are Theist.

Given that concession, what conclusions do you draw from it. 

satsuma --- 12 years ago -

You not believing in the results/studies doesn't make them less accurate.

but healthy skepticism would lead one to ask how acurate they were. AMDG's comments are perfectly reasonable.

A statistically significant, non-spurious negative correlation between two traits in a large representative sample of the population can still be meaningless. Especially when the data plugged into the equation is a quantification of concepts as nebulous as intelligence and religiosity.

That's just a practical reality. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

And I am very sure know thoughtful person would use it to conclude that atheists are "smarter" than theists.

Only those that do not understand the statistical methods, standard deviation and regression would conclude that. 

satsuma --- 12 years ago -

Only those that do not understand the statistical methods, standard deviation and regression would conclude that.

But isn't that just about everyone? 

alldayredux --- 12 years ago -

My conclusion is this is simple stuff. California, Oregon (not very religious) are more innovative than Alabama and Missisippi just as Germany and Japan (not religious at all)are more innovative than Pakistan and Iraq.

We have to face that science and religion really are enemies regardless of how much static noise comes from the attempts and changes in religious doctrine to attempt to appear at ease with science.

Also scientists and post grads are ateist at about a 64% clip vs around 10% of the population at large. That is not insignificant.

It's simply reason and thought supplanting "blind faith" as a source of truth. Admitting the findings as accurate aren't something to take so personally but it's ironic that the backlash helps bear proof. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

My conclusion is this is simple stuff. California, Oregon (not very religious) are more innovative than Alabama and Missisippi just as Germany and Japan (not religious at all)are more innovative than Pakistan and Iraq.

Your conclusion is nonsense.

We have to face that science and religion really are enemies regardless of how much static noise comes from the attempts and changes in religious doctrine to attempt to appear at ease with science.

Again your conclusion is nonsense. The ONLY "science" that believers disagree with is the FALSE scientific hypothesis of evolution. Bad science isn't real science.

It's simply reason and thought supplanting "blind faith" as a source of truth.

A believer's source of truth isn't "blind faith". A believer's source of truth is God.

Reason and thought doesn't always yield truth. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

We have to face that science and religion really are enemies

neither me, or my religion is an enemy of science. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

It's simply reason and thought supplanting "blind faith" as a source of truth.

Allday - the "blind faith" in your statement above seems to assume there is no good, well-reasoned, logical case to be made to be a theist. That is not true, I can give you about 10 or so from memory. Many have been around for hundreds of years. By the same token, there are, I think only 2 good logical arguments against the belief in God, these 2 have also been around for a long time.

There is nothing illogical, or magical in being a theist. Both sides have counter arguments, and I think, using good reason someone can come to either conclusion, and continue to be reasonable.

So I disagree with what I think your premise is above, that being is a theist a leap of faith, devoid of reason and logic.

As an aside - I think science is perfect for finding and proving facts, I think it is not very good at finding and proving truths. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground