Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The agnostic fence sitter

who's talking here?

Warren Peace 2
AwesomeTattooedDragon 9
RedMulch 2
Dr Aborto 3
Work in Progress 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
Friday 1
AMDG 12
satsuma 6
logic 2
a5071578uu 6

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

In that mess of a thread yesterday, I took a position that agnostic was the weakest intellectual position in the theist - atheist continuum. Several folks commented back, and I wanted to answer, but didn't want the answer to get lost in the machine gun of trolling questions that were flying in the thread.

So here is a more complete thought on that position.

There are a few different definitions, and degrees of agnosticism, for the purpose of my point, I understand it as a belief that man is incapable of knowing if God does, or does not exist.

I think that is a weak intellectual position from a few perspectives.

The first one is, that I think for many, they are really much closer to atheist than agnostic, and either don't want the label, or will not take a position without adding a qualifier on their position. So, a truer position for many is I am a 90% atheist, but I want a hedge , just in case.

Secondly, and I always find this paradox interesting. Strong agnostics will state with absolute certainty, that you can not know the existence of God with absolute certainty. Other than the blatant paradox, it is maybe the most intellectually weak argument. This is best summed up in the quote:

You claim that nothing can be known with certainty ... how, then, can you be so sure?"

We correctly accept thousands of physical and metaphysical things as true without 100% certainty. We accept them because an overwhelming amount of evidence exists that proves it, as in gravity for example.

Thirdly, agnosticism is IMO, more a theology, a matter of faith, that the existence of God is unknowable. Rather than an intellectual position that the evidence may exist, but has not been discovered, but the proof of a God is possible.

I have others, but finally, from the atheist side of the debate here is Richard Dawkins view,

Dawkins also identifies two categories of agnostics: Temporary Agnostics in Practice (TAPs), and Permanent Agnostics in Principle (PAPs). Dawkins considers temporary agnosticism an entirely reasonable position, but views permanent agnosticism as "fence-sitting, intellectual cowardice".

I agree with him with the only stipulation that I would prefer to label the TAPs as searching, again a reasonable position.

So there you have it, I think humans are capable of making a reasoned choice with a high degree of certainty that God, does or doesn't exist, I think the evidence is available, it just takes real intellectual effort, and courage in you convictions to decide if you do, or if you don't. 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

That's like saying "you have to be either a republican or democrat. You're weak intellectually if you're a moderate".

You can label me agnostic if you want. I believe that if there is a God, cool. If there isn't a God, I'm cool too. Either way, I'm content with the idea that we are all going to do what is destined for us after we die. We either meet our maker or burn out like a candle. There's a lot of evidence that points to No God. But there are a lot situation that occur today that cannot be explained that point to a higher power.

We're all just a spec of a spec in the larger scheme of things. I mean look at this pic. We live in one Galaxy with billions of stars/suns. The Milky Way Galaxy is just one galaxy in a universe full of hundreds of billions of galaxies. To think that we as a species claim to know all the answers is what I find "weak intellectually".

0 

Friday --- 12 years ago -

Ashame people cant see the balance in life to keep them alive. There is nothing you can do to change the weather, the heart that beats in you, or the time you will die. There is a balance and a God that keeps it. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Dr a.

I disagree that it is like being forced to chose rep or dem. those are a frameworks of beliefs, not a belief. The analogy I would make is agnostics would question if it was possible to know that politics existed or not.

Whether rep or dem is a secondary question such as choosing how you believe in God. Are you Jewish or Christian or Moslem etc. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Friday - not sure your point exactly, sorry. 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

You only disagree with my analogy. Exclude that one sentence. What about the 12 other sentences. 

logic --- 12 years ago -

To think that we as a species claim to know all the answers is what I find "weak intellectually".

I don't think I've ever heard anyone say they know all of the answers. Do you have a quote from someone who has made that claim that you can direct us to? 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Dr a - the other 12 were really not IMO part of the issue. That is a completely different philosophy, more existential, simplistically put, God no God it makes no difference. I think that can be a valid philosophy, if arrived at after consideration of the theist atheist issue. I do not think it is a valid philosophy if arrived at because it just isn't worth thinking about it. 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

I don't think I've ever heard anyone say they know all of the answers.

0 

logic --- 12 years ago -

I can't see anything. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I totally disagree- I was an agnostic most of my life- I thought there was some sort of life force, either the universe, God, something- I don't see how an agnostic definitively believes any of the above- he just doesn't know, but he's open to different theories- 

a5071578uu --- 12 years ago -

If you are sitting on the proverbial fence than look at it as if it were law.

Do you think or not think given all the proof that you know - is there a God - beyond a reasonable doubt?

After answering that question than explain why you believe that way. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I have no proof, so there is no way that can used as a basis for an explanation- 

a5071578uu --- 12 years ago -

Are you looking to prove that there is a God? Or are you looking to prove that Jesus is the Messiah? Because in proving that Jesus is the Messiah, you can prove that the Bible is true, Scriptures are true in the prophecies they speak of and in turn that God is real.

From me reading what ya'll have said on this topic and the other long one - you guys are separating God from the Son. And you can not do that. You must prove the Trinity. God, the Father, Jesus the Son and The Holy Spirit. They are each different but one in the same.

There is so much more to this topic than just wanting to prove that there is some higher being out there in the wide universe. 

a5071578uu --- 12 years ago -

Also I want to add that yes, our religion is faith based but it is so much more. The Bible has been proven already to be true. So many scholars have gone out to disprove the Bible but in their search have proven it to be correct instead.

For example, look at C.S. Lewis among many others. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I'm not trying to prove anything- I'm just saying that it took until recently for me to accept that there is a God, and I believe in him as the creator- things have happened in my life that felt like they were God given- I don't care about forcing anyone to believe that, that's up to them- I would just ask them to keep an open mind, because without that, there's no way God can come in to one's life- 

a5071578uu --- 12 years ago -

I think that is wonderful for you!

How do you feel about Jesus now? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I'm a believer- 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

i have to admit, though, I've gone thru some shaky times- 

a5071578uu --- 12 years ago -

I am extremely happy for you and as far as shaky times - girl - haven't we all? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I hope i'm not alone in that- i came from no belief at all, so I've come a long way- I remember my mom laughing at the idea there's a God- it had a strong influence on me, although i never was an atheist- 

satsuma --- 12 years ago -

Strong agnostics will state with absolute certainty, that you can not know the existence of God with absolute certainty

1) This is not a paradox / self-contradictory

Prop1) "you can never be certain of anything"
is self-contradictory:
The set of 'things you can never be certain of necessarily includes prop1 itself, leading to a contradiction.


prop2)"you can never be certain of the truth or falsity of any proposition"
is self-contradictory:
The set of things you can never be certain of (any proposition) necessarily includes prop2, leading to a contradiction.

Prop3)"you can never be certain of the truth or falsity of a particular proposition."
is not self-contradictory:
The set of 'propositions whose truth or falsity cannot be known' does NOT necessarily include prop3. Thus, there is no contradiction.

So to state that:
"You can never be certain of the truth or falsity of the proposition 'God Exists'"
is not contradictory or a paradox, and neither is the statement that:
"You can never be certain of the truth or falsity of the proposition 'God does not Exist'".




So, a truer position for many is I am a 90% atheist, but I want a hedge , just in case.

atheist/theist are exclusive. you can't be 90% atheist any more than you can be 10% theist. If they weren't exclusive, then there wouldn't be all this talk about "Fence Sitting".

furthermore, the term "hedge" means insurance or protection from a potential loss/harm, and thus it implies that the agnostic is only acknowledging the possibility of those theistic traditions (or of a particular theistic tradition) that punishes non-believers in some way.
Put differently: it sounds like you think agnostics are embracing some form of pascals wager. which is not necessarily true.





... certainty that God, does or doesn't exist, I think the evidence is available, it just takes real intellectual effort,

I'm going to assume that you're being technical and not condescending there.


First, what is meant by "Certainty"?
to some, certainty is limited to that which can be tested/demonstrated via empirical methods to be a true proposition/hypothesis.

To some, certainty can be derived from non-empirical methods. (example: I can't empirically prove that god exists, but I know in my heart that he/she/it does.) an atheist might argue that the example is explainable in terms of neuroscience, whereas a person of faith might refer to it as "revealed knowledge"-as in through some metaphysical interaction with deity.


Do you think or not think given all the proof that you know - is there a God

Please provide me some proof for or against the existence of a god. I know of nothing that can only be explained by the intervention of a higher power. I know of nothing that demonstrates that a higher power has never and could never have either existed or intervened in our world. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I was trying to say some of those things, but you did a much better job- there's no proof of either- you believe or you don't- 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

The first one is, that I think for many, they are really much closer to atheist than agnostic, and either don't want the label, or will not take a position without adding a qualifier on their position. So, a truer position for many is I am a 90% atheist, but I want a hedge , just in case.


How about the billions of people that say they believe in god because they don't want the label. I've had Christians tell me if I just say I believe I get to go to heaven... Why wouldn't I just say I believe just to be safe? 

RedMulch --- 12 years ago -

I am glad to see a civilized discussion on the subject without the trashing and bashing going on.

All I have to say is that I believe in Jesus and accept Him as my savior. I believe the Bible is the word of God and would only refer to Hebrews 11:1 " Faith is being sure of what we hope for and certain of things unseen". i know the Holy Spirit has come to me many times and brought me comfort and assurance. We are not meant to know when Christ returns or what our afterlife holds. We are here to the best we can, to all we can, for as long as we can. We just need to accept Christ and help and love each other. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

Dr A, I'm smokin what you're rollin on the mind-blowing size of the universe, and the comparative insignificance it reflects on our lives on Earth. But the significance of our place in the universe does play a role in my view of whether or not there is a God. If I may pass the doobie back to you, you may be interested in these graphics if you haven't previously come across them. It just illustrates our place in the universe on a grander scale.

It has been known that our galaxy is among a cluster of other galaxies, but scientists are now estimating the cluster to contain 100,000 other galaxies that stretch 500 million light years across and are now calling our cluster of galaxies Laniakea (Hawaiian for "immeasurable heavens"). They have produced this image representing a map for this portion of the known universe:
0

This below image is another representation of a small portion of our known universe. Each speck of light in the below and above images represents a galaxy. Each of those specks of light representing a galaxy has anywhere from millions to trillions of stars within that speck of light. Inhale:
0

If I didn't emphasize it enough, the above image only represents a single galaxy supercluster in one portion of the known universe. How many more superclusters of galaxies are there out there? Dunno. 

RedMulch --- 12 years ago -

I wondered where God was going fit all of us. 

a5071578uu --- 12 years ago -

God will wipe away the old earth and heaven an create a whole new. As Christians we will be taken to heaven before that happens. In the new earth - there will be no sin, pain or anything bad. It will be awesome. Amen! 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

As to whether or not any of that mind blowing size of the known universe is any indicator one way or another as to whether or not there is a God, I think it does influence my opinion. My insignificant opinion is that our ability to think and process all of this information (everything in addition to we're mapping the damn universe) as a unique and rare life form indicates we're a pretty special life form. We know of no other life form that can do this and we know a whole hell of a lot of life forms. How can we be that special? I don't know, but I'm going with...cuz God. I want to thank someone for gifting me with life's pleasures and saying, "Thank you, Randomness!" is not very satisfying. Without even attempting to measure or define a degree of certainty, belief in God is just more satisfying to me.

But the size of the known universe is what influences my opinion of what God expects of us. My opinion is that humans mostly overthink it. Yes, we know of a pretty significant book written on this speck of sand 2,000 years ago, but how significant is that book? When I look at the size of the universe, I can't help but conclude it ain't about a book. It makes no sense to me that a God who created all of this beautiful variation and seeming randomness would require such nth degree of rule making as our iced committed biblical literalists and numerous other practitioners of organized religion would like us to believe it does. How can you have an awareness of our place in the universe with all the diverse forms of life on this planet, all the different cultures, all the variations in human genetic makeup, and conclude that there is only one approved set of behaviors, and one ideology to guide your choices? I think it is beyond a mistake to consider this and still think there is only one true set of rules for living your life, and those rules are conveniently documented in a book of collective writings that were consolidated 2000 years ago at one moment in time. It seems to be a grand mistake of thinking that spirituality comes with a script packaged in a box of right and wrong.

Religions are a human coping mechanism and the Bible provides a very useful tool for providing psychological comfort to this rare life form of ours. It fills the gap of uncertainty. Uncertainty is a lot more uncomfortable for our human mind, even though uncertainty is a more accurate representation of what is known. I doubt anyone can convince me that the Bible is the word of God, but I respect the hell out of the role it plays in helping humans cope with their difficult lives. When people say it was inspired by God, I respect that too because that is essentially what I believe. It was inspired by this magnificent act of creation.

[puff, puff, pass] 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Strong agnostics will state with absolute certainty, that you can not know the existence of God with absolute certainty

Satsuma - to me anyway the paradox is the self contradiction of being absolutely sure about being absolutely unsure. If that is not text book - mea culpa 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

atheist/theist are exclusive. you can't be 90% atheist any more than you can be 10% theist. If they weren't exclusive, then there wouldn't be all this talk about "Fence Sitting".

Agree, and that is my point. IMO many who call themselves agnostic, are in main atheist. But prefer the softer label of agnostic, and are hedging their bet. And I think that is a weak intellectual position. If you have given it enough thought to have a considered opinion. And your considered opinion is overwhelmingly atheist, then own it

If you have not given it enough thought to have a considered opinion, then you are none of the above, and agnostic the label you chose instead of unthoughtful. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

... I think the evidence is available, it just takes real intellectual effort,

I was not being condescending, and I stand by my position, As empirical evidence in support of my position, I would say that many, many, many thoughtful people have, with the evidence available have decided to believe, or not believe. They are in conflict with the many who have decided it is impossible to decide. Again IMO, that is a weaker position. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

you make no sense to me- I thought about it a lot- and read about different views, reincarnation, all of them- what you're saying, IMO, is the opposite of the truth- 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Please provide me some proof for or against the existence of a god. I know of nothing that can only be explained by the intervention of a higher power. I know of nothing that demonstrates that a higher power has never and could never have either existed or intervened in our world.

My point in the post was philosophic not theologic. It is not to convince anyone to believe or not to believe. If I had any ulterior motive, it was push folks off the comfortable agnostic couch, and put in the effort to decide. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

to me, strong agnostic is the paradox- 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -


you make no sense to me- I thought about it a lot- and read about different views, reincarnation, all of them- what you're saying, IMO, is the opposite of the truth-


Don't think I understand sorry can you give me some more or restate. Not being snarky, really not sure 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

How can you have an awareness of our place in the universe with all the diverse forms of life on this planet, all the different cultures, all the variations in human genetic makeup, and conclude that there is only one approved set of behaviors, and one ideology to guide your choices? I think it is beyond a mistake to consider this and still think there is only one true set of rules for living your life, and those rules are conveniently documented in a book of collective writings that were consolidated 2000 years ago at one moment in time. It seems to be a grand mistake of thinking that spirituality comes with a script packaged in a box of right and wrong.

I think the problem here, is thinking about it as merely a package of "right and wrong."

Perhaps what is right is a reflection of who God is, and what is wrong is a turning away from that. It's not about a set of rules, but about a way that humans were created to be.

The Bible is, at its essence, an epic love story about a God who loves mankind so much, that He consistently, passionately, and zealously seeks to be reconciled to us, though we continuously scoff, sneer, and run the other direction.

The rules are merely a signpost to see how far we've strayed. We CAN'T follow them. Even when we try, we can't do it. It's ultimately about how we CANNOT do what is right. It's against our nature. So He did it for us. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

And ATAD - wanted to get back to your first post. I think there is a very big difference between agnostic, and searching. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Warren - the framework of how and what you believe, or how you perceive God, is a second level debate. The first question is always does God exist or not. I personal am more interested that folks work to answer that question, then debate the framework they chose to follow that belief. 

satsuma --- 12 years ago -

It is not to convince anyone to believe or not to believe

My comment there was more in response to A5.

off the comfortable agnostic couch, and put in the effort to decide.

Why? you have yet to demonstrate or argue why choosing a side is a sign of intellectual strength, only asserted that it is so.

so please provide an argument for why an intellectually honest person who musters the intellectual effort would necessarily decide to either reject the possibility that a higher power exists, or accept that a higher power necessarily exists. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground