Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Another crash and 116 killed...but who really cares here?

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
randyjet 5
SoupIsGoodFood 3
Humbletexan1 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 7
Joe Blow 2
Winning 1
Mayberry 1
freebyrdll 3
Just stuck 1
The Day I Tried to Live 1
mutton 7
Franklin 1
Oregonian 3
Eclipse 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Oregonian --- 12 years ago -

 

Just stuck --- 12 years ago -

SSDD 

freebyrdll --- 12 years ago -

Do you know how to edit the topic? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Is it that we don't care.......... or are you looking for attention? 

whatchamacallit --- 12 years ago -

I care. Can't do much about it, but I care. There is another thread about this same subject and there is some fool complaining about the wordage used in the title. Priorities, everyone has them, some are just foolish. 

Franklin --- 12 years ago -

What makes you think no one cares? Just because YOU don't care? 

Mayberry --- 12 years ago -

Oh geeze, here we go again.... 

freebyrdll --- 12 years ago -

Indeed...... 

Oregonian --- 12 years ago -

What makes you think no one cares? Just because YOU don't care?

I won't admit or deny if I care or not.

After the bashing I took over the M-17 that I posted....I done been taught the acceptable KU way to post.

At least this thread does not have the usual POTUS bashing.

I just couldn't admit that the loss of pea soups upset me. 

Joe Blow --- 12 years ago -

No Americans on board so they don't care. 

Joe Blow --- 12 years ago -

Besides this happened on the dark continent. We all know how the KUers feel about those people. (Not all KUers but watcha and her ilk.) 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

LOL........ hey Bloodloss!! 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Mo drama. 

freebyrdll --- 12 years ago -

!!!! dontcha just love autocorrect!!!!

couldn't admit that the loss of pea soups upset me. 

The Day I Tried to Live --- 12 years ago -

I haven't stopped caring about the last one yet to move to another one. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

how many over the world can you mourn for? I compare it to charities- I wish I could give to all of them, but I have to pick the ones that emotionally affect me the most- how do you manage your life, while suffering over every thing that happens? 

Humbletexan1 --- 12 years ago -

Just another reason I stopped using my Louis Vuitton luggage. I would hate to see it go missing! 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

I care about the loss of peoples loved ones...no matter the country. 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

You can mourn for many... 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

Death is not the same as a charity... 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

mutton, do you read it and feel badly, or do you really mourn? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

words are cheap- honesty, not so much- do you think joe blow is sitting at home grieving? we all feel bad when something like this happens, but I seriously doubt y'all have lost any sleep over it- 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

my analogy meant I feel for women with cancer, children with diseases, plane crash victims- but the things I really do suffer over is where my money goes- but then I think you knew that- 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

Cheap we see on these boards. When someone posts do I care, I say yes I do. I mourn for how callous we have become when it does not affect us directly... 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I'm impressed you're able to mourn for us callous souls- when do you fit it in to the mourning for every tragedy on earth? 

Winning --- 12 years ago -

0 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

Sorry but I do feel for these tragedies. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

feel or grieve? we callous souls feel for the people, too- most of us have hard enough lives that there isn't a lot of time left to sob over every tragedy in the world- 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

I did say "how callous we have become"...feel, grieve, mourn how different can they be? I feel bad if you feel I have called others out as non feeling, was not the intent. And there I am... 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

umm..I'm pretty sure you were- 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

Ok 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

I just hope that Putin does not do what Reagan did when the USS Vincennes shot down and killed over 220 men, women, children on the Air Iran flight that the US shot down in INTERNATIONAL airspace. He gave the skipper a medal for his successful cruise. Just how do you think the rest of the world viewed that one? Think Putin is a 'MONSTER'? What do you think Reagan is to much of the world?

I saw where the Dutch Prime Minister called for justice to be done to whoever shot the plane down. I wonder what the Dutch PM said after the US shot down the Iranian airliner. Think he asked for justice to be done to the skipper? I doubt it. 

Oregonian --- 12 years ago -

Well, the Russians also shot down a Korean 747....never hear anything about that do we?

Flying internationally is inherently dangerous I guess. 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

Well, the Russians also shot down a Korean 747

The problem with that one was that the Soviets had every RIGHT to shoot it down since it was in Soviet and PROHIBITED air space. When I flew around Ireland in a rented airplane, I asked the flight instructor who checked me out what all those prohibited circles were about. He told me that they were prisons, and that if I flew into them even by accident, they had 50cal machine guns which would SHOOT ME DOWN! I made damn sure I did not even come close to them since a C-172 will not even slow down a 50 cal round. I figure if I could be shot down in a little inoffensive C-172 for violating that airspace. the Soviets had every right to shoot down the KAL 007 which was a spy plane. 

Eclipse --- 12 years ago -

the Soviets had every right to shoot down the KAL 007 which was a spy plane.

Randy, KAL 007 was not a "spy" plane.

The KAL 007 crew did not engage the INS when they departed Anchorage and as a result it flew north of it's "intended" route on a magnetic heading and inadvertantly ventured close to Soviet restricted airspace.

Unfortuntately, it's flight path intersected the flight path of a "real" spy plane (an RC-135) the Soviets had been tracking at the same time, thereby confusing the Soviets as to which plane they were tracking, and as a result the Soviets mistook KAL 007 for the real spy plane and shot it down.

Years later, after the Soviets gave up the DFDR and the CVR, it was confirmed the the INS was not engaged.

It was crew error that contributed to the downing of KAL 007, but it was not a spy plane. 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

It may well not have been a spy plane, but there are too many things that indicate otherwise. I find the number of 007 rather odd to say the least since spooks love to do things like this. There is a long history of using commercial airliners as spy planes. Germany did this in pre-WWII with Lufthansa. The CIA got Air France to install cameras to photograph the Soviet Union as they flew into Moscow when they were one of the few Western airlines flying there. The CIA asked the crews to divert slightly off course to get better shots of interesting places. In the Flying White House, the author said that they outfitted Air Force One with special cameras to photograph the territory as the President went to Moscow. It is also strange that the pilots did not bother turning on their radar. I do this all the time to have something to do and to pick up the land mass as you come close to land. It is strange that they did not do this too.
Another problem is that according to the transcripts I read of the intercepts of radio, the pilot of the fighter reported the position lights were OFF on KAL007.

I seriously doubt the US CIA had anything to do with the spy mission for the simple reason the CIA did not need photos. The Korean CIA is another matter completely, and it was more than likely the sponsor of the off course mission. So while it may well be just a crew error, I have my doubts, and I think most people will agree with my take on this one.

The Soviets were legally in the right in this shoot down too. It was obviously a PR nightmare, but still legal and it is irrelevant what kind of mission the plane was on. You don't follow the rules you get shot down. 

Eclipse --- 12 years ago -

As far as the Soviets having the legal right to shoot down KAL 007, you could be right. I have no idea if they did, or, they didn't.

When the Soviets finally turned over the FDR and the CVR (some 10 years after the downing), it was determined that the position of flight was dangerously close to entering sensitive Soviet airspace. Which, rightfully, gave the Soviets cause for alarm and perhaps the right to shoot it down.

Concerning the transcript you read that KAL 007 had it's position lights off, that's the first time I heard this. That's not to suggest such a transcript exists. I've just never read it.

However, Colonel Osipovich (the fighter pilot who fired the missiles), reported that he could see "blinking lights" on both the top and the bottom of the plane.

I suspect what he was referring to was either the rotating beacons or, possibly, the strobe lights. But if it was the rotating beacons then the navigation lights would have been on.

Undoubtedly, there will always be controversy over why KAL 007 was so close to Soviet airspace, but I believe it was the result of the crews failure to recognize that the INS was not engaged causing the autopilot to fly a magnetic heading that took it north of the intended flight path and close to Soviet airspace. Which was suspected early on in the investigation, but not verified until the Soviets handed over the flight recorders.

Also, had the crew been alert they might have figured this out when they were talking to their sister flight (KAL 015) about the head winds they (KAL 007) were experiencing, versus the tail winds KAL 015 was experiencing only 15 minutes behind them at the same attitude.

As pilots, I'm sure you and I would have been trying to figure that out.

Was KAL 007 on a spy mission? I don't believe it was. I believe it was a tragic event that was completely avoidable had the flight crew not had their heads "up and locked".

Stay safe up there, Randy --- 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

Undoubtedly, there will always be controversy over why KAL 007 was so close to Soviet airspace, but I believe it was the result of the crews failure to recognize that the INS was not engaged causing the autopilot to fly a magnetic heading that took it north of the intended flight path and close to Soviet airspace. Which was suspected early on in the investigation, but not verified until the Soviets handed over the flight recorders.

What I read showed that KAL 007 was in Soviet airspace, and one of the considerations in giving the order to fire was that they were close to getting out of the prohibited airspace. Also I read that the pilot was running low on fuel, which made for more pressure to fire. Thus while legal, it was a tragic decision for the poor folks on the flight.

I did not know about them talking to their sister flight. That sure would have made for raising my interest in what was going on. Plus at that point in the flight, they had little else to do and it would take no major effort to turn on the radar and pick up land mass as they approached it.

Of course, we will never know for sure what KAL 007 was doing in terms of spying. The best case scenario is that it was crew error. The worst is that they were deliberately where they were and that the Korean CIA is to blame for the deaths that resulted. 

Eclipse --- 12 years ago -

You peaked my curiosity, so I went back and did some research and you are correct, Randy.

The Soviet pilot did initially make the claim that the planes position lights were off, however, he later admitted that it was a lie (in addition to other lies they made), in what was an attempt to fabricate a cover-up as to what actually took place that night.

Also, KAL 007 did, in fact, violate Soviet airspace as you stated.

I may have known this before, but over the years the cobwebs have settled in. 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

I know that my memory of this fades too over the years and not thinking of it. Just a word of caution, if you fly around Ireland, make damn sure you stay well away from overflying any prison. It is well worth the effort to fly there though since it is beautifully green and has some great sights.

Go to the Irish Flying Club in Dublin. It would drive the FAA batty since the biggest thing there is a long BAR with all you could want to drink. I guess they do a lot of hangar flying there too. They also charge only for actual flight time, not block time. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground