Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: What do you think/believe?

who's talking here?

zapper007 2
AwesomeTattooedDragon 2
Work in Progress 2
Dorothy Parker 3
Winning 1
DVaz 1
Gigolo Bloodline 1
Judas 2
Lord Cheezus DeSufferbus 1
Butterbean 11
mutton 1
jacobson 17
AMDG 2
Wicked 1
Franklin 1
Oregonian 1
citrus 14
Ellen Ripley 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: What do you think/believe?

Based on some discussions on the Higgs Boson thread I wonder what the community thinks?

In one form or another, the universe has always existed (no God or related concept). Vote
 
 46.3% (19)
There was complete nothingness and God (or a related concept) thought/willed the universe into existence. Vote
 
 34.1% (14)
In one form or another, the universe has always existed, and the intervention of God (or a related concept) thought/willed it into it's current form. Vote
 
 7.3% (3)
The universe (even the laws that govern it) sprang into being from nothingness spontaneously. Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
God (or a related concept) IS the universe, one cannot be without the other. Vote
 
 2.4% (1)
None of the above - please explain. Vote
 
 4.9% (2)
mind like totally blown dude. Vote
 
 4.9% (2)
citrus --- 12 years ago -

Based on some discussions on the Higgs Boson thread I wonder what the community thinks? 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

Physically, the universe has always existed, at least as far as my concept of always is.

My God is a come lately concept, but is more comforting to accept that alongside the physical universe, God was.

Be it a psychological or physiological concept of a Creator, it is comforting to me to believe the grand plan is as it is supposed to be, without my interference.

The absence of something is as challenging as the concept of the presence of nothing. Perhaps at some future date, language will evolve to include words that can explain it.

My ability to understand is demonstratively less than a considerable number of others. My ability to believe is equal to others.

In my life, God is alive and personal. He is non judgmental, forgiving, kind, and loving, and can forgive my lack of understanding of things that are beyond my abilities.

In my life, natural processes = God at work. The pursuit of knowledge = God at work. I embrace it fully, and, for myself, understand that checks and balances in the scientific world work pretty well.

So crank up the power of nuclear accelerators and see what's there. I look forward to the next spurt of knowledge that I will be hard pressed to understand. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Your God is a figment of your imagination. 

Winning --- 12 years ago -

Where is JohnLynch? I feel like he would know the answer to this. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

Push the button and ask for a chill pill, Jake. They'll help you. 

citrus --- 12 years ago -

Your God is a figment of your imagination.

John, [sigh] nevermind.


The absence of something is as challenging as the concept of the presence of nothing. Perhaps at some future date, language will evolve to include words that can explain it.

Agreed. talking about it is a pain in the arse, but mathematical logic allows us to talk about "the null set" which is as good a concept of nothing as I've ever heard.

Language might eventually get there. On the other hand, it's at the center of of "Godel's incompleteness theorem". As I understand it, no logical system of expression can ever be used to derive all valid expressions that may exist within that system. Thus, All logical systems are inherently either incomplete OR inconsistent (contains logical contradictions).... I think I said that poorly.
:/

If I recall correctly, the problem came to a head after Bertrand Russel published his Principia Mathematica which was supposed to be a proof of the logical foundations of mathematics. Logicians/Mathematicians attacked an apparent contradiction in the treatment of the "null set". Godel was the one who solved it, proving a fundamental limit on the ability of ANY logical system to express truths. 

citrus --- 12 years ago -

I lean toward the "universe always existed in some form or another" option. I'm on the fence (agnostic) wrt whether or not a god (or similar/related concept) was involved 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

In my life, God is alive and personal. He is non judgmental, forgiving, kind, and loving, and can forgive my lack of understanding of things that are beyond my abilities.

In my life, natural processes = God at work. The pursuit of knowledge = God at work. I embrace it fully, and, for myself, understand that checks and balances in the scientific world work pretty well.

So crank up the power of nuclear accelerators and see what's there. I look forward to the next spurt of knowledge that I will be hard pressed to understand.


like ^^^^ 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

And I vote nothing (or at least my weak understanding of it) + God = Everything 

DVaz --- 12 years ago -

The Supreme Being is beyond the comprehension of the human brain.

This Being/Force does not care about any of us or answer prayers. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I actually had to pick one- it's more than I can comprehend- I checked the 3rd, but it's way too overwhelming for me to really have an answer- 

Lord Cheezus DeSufferbus --- 12 years ago -

Physically, the universe has always existed, at least as far as my concept of always is.

My God is a come lately concept, but is more comforting to accept that alongside the physical universe, God was.


So you accept neither science nor religion, you're just pulling nonsense out of the side of your head either way... 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

I believe the universe has always existed and the idea of God and religion is man-made. Does that mean there is no supreme being? Not necessarily.....truth is, nobody knows til they're dead and they aren't talking... 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

I lean toward the "universe always existed in some form or another" option. I'm on the fence (agnostic) wrt whether or not a god (or similar/related concept) was involved

Your ideas are just figments of your imagination.

The first and second laws of thermodynamics display that fact.

The first law is one of conservation, which implies that the substance of the universe, which is matter and energy, is a constant. The second law places an additional constraint on the possible states that a given system can attain by a defined process, precluding perpetual motion machines and the spontaneous creation of the "availability" of energy. All real processes are shown to be "irreversible"? by the implications of the second law, resulting in a decrease in energy available to affect further processes. In other words, real processes result in a net increase in the "entropy" of the universe, a property defined in thermodynamics as movement toward a final stable equilibrium where all processes cease.

The implications of these two laws are profound. The first law states clearly that no matter or energy is currently being added to our universe, and the second law states that, given infinite time, the universe will come to final equilibrium, where no processes can occur. That final state has been described as a heat-death of the universe. Since that condition has not yet been reached, the universe must have a beginning.

Those statements are perfectly compatible with the biblical declaration that all things were created in six days, and then God ceased doing the labor of physical creation as stated in Genesis 2:1-2 - the first law. Furthermore, the fall of man brought about "the curse" which is the cause for the earth and the heavens to "wear out like a garment", as stated in Psalms 102:26 and now "the whole creation groans and suffers" as stated in Romans 8:22 - the second law.

The second law of thermodynamics essentially precludes the spontaneous development of the earth?s ecosystem or life itself. In engineering, we are knowledgeable in the fact that heat engines do not develop spontaneously, and without a heat engine, no efficient useful work is produced by the flow of heat. In addition, without both a source of work and a refrigeration machine, no heat will flow from a cold place to a warm place. Likewise, without the engine of reproduction (the genetic blueprint and the miracle of the womb), not even the material aspects of mankind could be built by raw power.

The required patterns and engines of reproduction cannot be accounted for by spontaneous generation as declared by the evolutionists (atheists), and the passing of long periods of time cannot constitute or facilitate an independent cause for the development of human bodies, aptitude, or ability. The rule of history is not one of continual creation, but one of extinction, as specific creatures become unable to survive the decay of the earth's ecosystem and are eliminated from the planet forever.


truth is, nobody knows til they're dead and they aren't talking...

That is not the truth. Many people know. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

That is not the truth. Many people know.

Looks like you can quote Wikipedia,s truth, Jake.

Ask for another chill pill. It'll help. 

Wicked --- 12 years ago -

Jacobson, do you believe in reincarnation? 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

And, Jake, if you're going to steal another's words, please give them credit.

Dr. Walter would probably appreciate it.

Ask for another chill pill, Jake. Two is better than one. 

citrus --- 12 years ago -

LOL!

I'll be back later to point out the very very very basic misunderstanding of Thermodynamics using your author's own words John. 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

The Universe might be a hologram. 

Oregonian --- 12 years ago -

Jacobson: Our resident copy and paste expert. Plagarism is a sin too, you know. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Jacobson, do you believe in reincarnation?

No to reincarnation.

And, Jake, if you're going to steal another's words, please give them credit.

I didn't "steal" anyone's words. They are still there. Permission was given for brief quotations. Some people should know what they are talking about before they make their statements. 

Ellen Ripley --- 12 years ago -

So I'm guessing Constatines actions with removing reincarnation from the bible in efforts to solidify church control over the populace is not a popular belief on here. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

So I'm guessing Constatines actions with removing reincarnation from the bible in efforts to solidify church control over the populace is not a popular belief on here.

There was no reincarnation in the Bible for Constantine to remove. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

You didn't quote Dr, Walter, Jake. You didn't quote the ever popular Wikipedia.

You lied: You presented another's work as your own.

You cheated: See above.

You stole: See above.

What does the KJV say about people who lie , cheat, and steal, Jake?

Your actions validate and illustrate the meaning of the "null set" and the presence of nothing. If you had credibility, it's gone. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

The Universe might be a hologram.

Now THAT is interesting. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

You presented another's work as your own.

No, I did not. Where did I say that it was my opinion or my derivation? I never said it was my work and apparently it was readily recognizable as having been copied, as I assumed everyone would know.

You're just upset because he tells a scientific truth you can't disprove. Another one of your "smear the messenger so no one will pay attention to the message" deceptions.

Your actions validate and illustrate the meaning of the "null set"

It's obvious that you don't even know what that means, and you aren't the judge of credible information, especially since the information wasn't mine. See previous deception statement.

Btw, most of the information you know came from someone else. I guess you "cheat" and "steal" and "lie" each time you open your mouth or type on the keyboard. 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

I believe this thread will go down the same path as all others that started out with this little bit o bait. Forgive me if not meant to be but...some find it as such... 

Franklin --- 12 years ago -

I believe the children are our future. Teach them well and let them lead the way.

Show them all the beauty they possess inside. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

Sorry, Jake.

If you had credibility, it's gone. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Sorry BB, but my credibility doesn't matter. It doesn't change the truth of what was posted.

With that being said, my credibility is much better than yours because I post truth and you don't. 

zapper007 --- 12 years ago -

Sorry BB, but my credibility doesn't matter. It doesn't change the truth of what was posted.

With that being said, my credibility is much better than yours because I post truth and you don't.



JL - you are hilarious!!!!!!! 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

the hologram sounds fascinating- maybe someone will pm me what it means- (I get quantum physics, so if you could explain from there, I might even get it!
LOL!) 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

JL - you are hilarious!!!!!!!?

What is hilarious is the fact that you are so easily fooled into believing that I'm John Lynch. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

What's hilarious, is the fact you think people will believe you AREN'T John Lynch!

No one is buying it. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

No one is buying it.?

It doesn't surprise me that you're one of the fooled. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

No one is fooled. Then only fool is you, John Jacob(son) Jingleheimer Schmidt. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

No one is fooled.

Like I said, it doesn't surprise me that you're one of the fooled. 

citrus --- 12 years ago -

First he says this:

The first law is one of conservation, which implies that the substance of the universe, which is matter and energy, is a constant. The second law places an additional constraint on the possible states that a given system can attain by a defined process, precluding perpetual motion machines and the spontaneous creation of the "availability" of energy.

The first law states clearly that no matter or energy is currently being added to our universe, and the second law states that, given infinite time, the universe will come to final equilibrium, where no processes can occur.

The second law of thermodynamics essentially precludes the spontaneous development of the earth?s ecosystem or life itself.


Hidden in the author's own words is the lie: Entropy cannot decrease in an isolated (or closed) system. So the author is correct wrt our Universe which is an isolated system (at least, we think it is...) HOWEVER, the earth (our solar system, our galaxy, our galactic super-cluster, etc....) are sub-sectors within the system, and are NOT isolated systems. They're open, free to exchange energy with each other and the rest of the universe.

wikipedia:
First Law
Second Law

Where will this go next?

Further comentary on the subject...


believe as you wish, but don't lie about science to support it. Own your faith. 

citrus --- 12 years ago -

I believe this thread will go down the same path as all others that started out with this little bit o bait. Forgive me if not meant to be but...some find it as such...

Mutton,
I know some do, but I try to be respectful of others beliefs in the writing of the poll options and comments (with one notable exception wrt the latter). 

Gigolo Bloodline --- 12 years ago -

I guess John got tired of the reasoned beatings and retired.
Bye Johnny. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground