Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The 9/11 Memorial Museum, at center of debate.

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 2
Polly Ester 3
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
JohnLynch 2
Dr Aborto 1
Work in Progress 1
Joe Blow 4
JAMS 2
Oregonian 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Oregonian --- 12 years ago -

The 9/11 Memorial Museum, set to open to the public this Friday, is at the center of an intense debate.

The New York City-based museum costs $24 to enter, and the gift shop offers pricey coffee mugs, T-shirts, key chains and stuffed animals. A separate part of the museum also houses some 8,000 unidentified human remains from the terrorist attacks.Those juxtapositions ? tribute and commercialism, trinkets amid tragedy ? have victims? families fuming.

Jim Riches doesn?t plan on visiting. His son Jimmy, a firefighter, was 29 when he died in the attacks. It took more than six months to find some of Jimmy?s remains. The rest, Riches believes, are unidentified and in the repository.

?My son?s friends are going to have to pay $24 to go down and pay their respects,? Riches said. ?I think that?s a disgrace. It?s the only cemetery in the world where you have to pay a fee to get in.?

Diane and Kurt Horning tells ABC News they?re appalled by what they?re calling ?greed and commercialism.? They lost their son Matt Horning in the twin towers and his remains were never found.

?I wouldn?t expect such an intrusion at Arlington Cemetery or at the Pentagon Memorial or at any cemetery,? they said.

In a statement, museum representatives tell ABC News that the museum receives no government funding and ?relies on private fundraising, gracious donations and revenue from ticketing and carefully selected keepsake items for retail.?

Attorney Norman Siegel, who represents several of the victims' relatives, thinks there?s an easy solution to the controversy.

?Take the remains out of the museum and then I think there will be less opposition to the selling of the trinkets and the hats and shirts,? Siegel said. 

Joe Blow --- 12 years ago -

Who do you think should pay for the two memorial pools, the upkeep of the whole park itself, and the museum? It's owned by the Port Authority of NY/NJ. You think they should just pay for it out of the kindness of their hearts? It cost $700 million to build and needs $1 million per week to run. HELLO!

It's FREE to go on the land and see the pools. 

Joe Blow --- 12 years ago -

Jim Riches doesn?t plan on visiting. His son Jimmy, a firefighter, was 29 when he died in the attacks. It took more than six months to find some of Jimmy?s remains. The rest, Riches believes, are unidentified and in the repository.?My son?s friends are going to have to pay $24 to go down and pay their respects,? Riches said. ?


NO THEY DON"T HAVE TO. Let them go whereever the family buried the remains they did receive and go for free. Mr. Riches obviously has deep seated entitlement issues. 

whatchamacallit --- 12 years ago -

The human remains should not be included in the store front. It is a ploy to make money off the dead and in very poor taste. They could have just as easily put the remains in a free area alongside the pools. They are holding the remains hostage as a means to make money. Disgusting 

Joe Blow --- 12 years ago -

The human remains should not be included in the store front. It is a ploy to make money off the dead and in very poor taste. They could have just as easily put the remains in a free area alongside the pools. They are holding the remains hostage as a means to make money. Disgusting



What a crock. The remains aren't the reason the people go to the museum. Besides you conservative thing, who should pay for the memorial and museum?? 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

Where are the human remains? I don't understand that part. For public viewing? In what capacity? Buried?

As for the gift shop--I don't think it's that big of a deal. I do understand how the families must feel about touristy crap being sold in the place where their loved ones died. That must be awful.

But it is also how museums make money for upkeep, and many visitors will want the touristy crap. It's not inherently disrespectful, but I understand why the families view it that way. 

Joe Blow --- 12 years ago -

The families can access it for free. I'm so tired of someone chronically whining about one thing or another. Find something really important for the good of humanity to whine about and you got my ear. Until then they should all STFU. 

whatchamacallit --- 12 years ago -

?Take the remains out of the museum and then I think there will be less opposition to the selling of the trinkets and the hats and shirts,? Siegel said.?


This is how it should be.^ 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

You guys should read this article from a Buzzfeed writer who lost his sister on 9/11. It kinda makes you look at the whole thing from a different set of eyes. Talks about visiting the museum and about the gift shop and human remains section.

The Worst Day of My Life is Now New Yorks Hottest Tourist Attraction 

Polly Ester --- 12 years ago -

When the twin towers collapsed, multiple floors of concrete, drywall, carpeting and furniture were compressed into single, meteorlike objects. Two of these fragments, known as composites, were recovered during the excavation and were among the many thousands of artifacts considered for display in the National September 11 Memorial Museum.

Though the composites had been tested and showed no evidence of human remains, debate ensued. Should the objects be included in the museum at all? If so, how should they be preserved? And where?

A history museum crafts a narrative about the past by making choices. But in this case the choices that define the story have been predictably fraught. The museum must speak to competing audiences: survivors and families, those who watched on television, others not yet born, New Yorkers, and tourists from around the world.

The resulting museum is the product of years of conversation among architects, designers, curators, Sept. 11 families, psychologists and historians. Every detail has been considered, from the placement of a 58-ton steel column to the display of a woman?s shoes.

So it is that one of the composites now sits in a secluded alcove in the footprint of the north tower. Not too far away there is a stand with a box of tissues ? also placed there by the exhibition designers.
The New York Times



From the New York TImes an Interactive tour 

Polly Ester --- 12 years ago -

You guys should read this article from a Buzzfeed writer who lost his sister on 9/11. It kinda makes you look at the whole thing from a different set of eyes. Talks about visiting the museum and about the gift shop and human remains section.


That was worth reading. To be honest, I really have not paid much attention to the memorial and museum controversy. I visited the 9/11 site a few years ago and found it to be an emotional visit. People were selling (unofficially) trinkets and pictures all around the site and there were a few tourist type shops around it selling hoodies and things with NYFD, etc.

So if I read it correctly, the remains that were not identified are in wooden cabinets so the remains themselves are not visible to view . It also said you need an appointment and must be granted permission to visit it, as in family members. It is set up to be sort of a place of mediation for those with the right to be there, not busloads of school kids on field trips. (correct me if I'm wrong)


I think he had an interesting perspective, even if irreverent at times. The thing is, there are memorials and monuments to horrific events all over the world that people visit. I understand the connection that people are looking for when they visit these places but I also understand that people are still raw and are still grieving. It isn't that they have the memorial and the souvenirs so much as it may be just too soon. 

Polly Ester --- 12 years ago -

?My son?s friends are going to have to pay $24 to go down and pay their respects,? Riches said. ?I think that?s a disgrace. It?s the only cemetery in the world where you have to pay a fee to get in.?


I understand his point. 

JAMS --- 12 years ago -

You can buy Twin Tower earrings, scarves, and men's neck ties!

Next, they'll start peddling ashtrays at the Holocaust museum.

Nothing screams America like profiting off tragedy.

A tie? Seriously? 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

that's what you get in a liberal city... 

JAMS --- 12 years ago -

Oh FFS you imbecile, it has NOTHING to do with liberalism.
Jesus, would you go slap yourself for being such a dolt? 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

LOL...it has EVERYTHING to do with liberalism... 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

it was really hard for me to read Dr. Aborto's article- it was so raw and sad, I can't imagine being in that position- heartbreaking- his father getting sick and yelling it to everyone- I felt that right in the pit of my stomach- 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground