Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Jet Tub or Soaker Tub?

who's talking here?

Keystone 1
planemom 1
I Kissed Frogs 1
jennycrocker 1
Perfection 1
Jpgirl 3
Warren Peace 1
voice of reason 1
RedMulch 1
Gigix4 2
*LOL* 2
K.T. 3
sheddy 1
Mayberry 2
BuiltinTX70 3
MissPris 1
Sweet Cherub 2
Wicked 6
Elsa 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Wicked --- 12 years ago -

We have this massive bathtub in our master bath. After thousands of gallons of water and every type of cleaning solution, the black goo particles keep flowing. Now, I have seized up the motor. Even if we fix the motor, we still have the black sludge. So, we have decided to just replace the tub altogether. Should we put in another jet tub? Or go with a soaker? I just don't know what will be more alluring to a new buyer. Any thoughts? 

RedMulch --- 12 years ago -

I vote for the jet. 

Mayberry --- 12 years ago -

If you don't go with a heater, then soaker tub. Jet tubs cool the water...and as you've already experienced, can cause cleaning challenges. 

Gigix4 --- 12 years ago -

Been contemplating replacing the tub in my master bath as well and when I finally do that, it's going to be soaker tub.

A jetted tub would not be an incentive for me if/when buying a house. Just something else needing maintenance. JMHO 

Keystone --- 12 years ago -

I would take it out altogether and make a giant shower. That's what we're doing. 

BuiltinTX70 --- 12 years ago -

Soaking tubs are very deep, right?

Unless you just mean a standard tub. 

*LOL* --- 12 years ago -

Go with a soaker. When I replace my tub, that is what I am doing. Most people I know don't even use their jet tubs. I think they breed bacteria. That black stuff looks like mold to me and it is PITA to keep maintained. 

BuiltinTX70 --- 12 years ago -

The soaking tub I have has jets, but they are tiny holes that propel the water versus a "jet". A new technology that pro sports team now are employing (or so I was told).

And, when you're all done there is a fan that supposedly cleans the holes so there is no water for bacteria to grow........... 

BuiltinTX70 --- 12 years ago -

And, when you're all done there is a fan that supposedly cleans the holes so there is no water for bacteria to grow...........

You can hear it go on about 10 minutes after you've emptied the tub........sounds like a jet taking off!!! 

voice of reason --- 12 years ago -

the problem with a bigger tub is it takes too much hot water so if you can get one with built in heating elements you'll be all set otherwise to fill it, the water will get cold before it's even full. 

*LOL* --- 12 years ago -

the problem with a bigger tub is it takes too much hot water so if you can get one with built in heating elements you'll be all set otherwise to fill it, the water will get cold before it's even full.

Good point! 

Wicked --- 12 years ago -

This tub is 42 x 60 and it sits on a marble base. So, I need to go with the same size, or re do the whole deck. This house has become a money pit already. The strange thing, the pool has an 8 person spa attached. Why did these people get a jet tub as well? Thank you for your thoughts, you brought up some points I never even thought of. We do have a tankless water heater so that does help when filling, not that I would know. i have never used this tub other than the 100 plus times I filled it, trying to clean the pipes. 

K.T. --- 12 years ago -

Wicked:

How are you cleaning the jets? I put in a bottle of bleach and dishwasher soap and run a cycle of it for about 15 minutes through the system about once a month. 

Wicked --- 12 years ago -

KT, we did everything. I went through two boxes of Cascade powder, a bottle of clorox, a bottle of drano, a gallon of vinegar, I went to the pool store and bought two bottles of the super duper jet pipe cleaner, I put a whole bottle of enzymes in. I ordered, from Amazon the AHH-Some, which really worked better than any of them, but then I burned out the motor, LOL. About 100 tubs full of water. No wonder I used 15,000 gallons of water in December :) We have really done it all. It is a lost cause. The people who owned this house, never showered. She used the bathtub daily and bathed in oils and glycerin type soaps, etc. I'm sure the pipes are so coated, there is no saving this thing. 

planemom --- 12 years ago -

This is the soaker tub I'm putting in my new house. Even if you're good about cleaning the jets gunk builds up over time and I didn't want to mess with something else to clean and maintain. If I decide I want bubbly water I'll have a hot tub put on the patio. 

K.T. --- 12 years ago -

Oh boy, that sounds disgusting, sorry, lol! She probably never cleaned the jets, yuk!

How is your water bill going? Nice to have the wonderful rain last night!!! 

I Kissed Frogs --- 12 years ago -

Jett a brand sells some of their jetted tubs as soaker only. They are guaranteed to hold heat within 2 degrees for 30 minutes. 

Gigix4 --- 12 years ago -

Love that tub, planemom. I thought they would be more expensive than that. 

sheddy --- 12 years ago -

I'd tear it out and put in a linen closet. Never can have too much storage. We never use the tub and I wouldn't even put one in if I was building a custom home. 

Wicked --- 12 years ago -

sheddy, we thought about doing something else, but unfortunately, there is this huge window over the tub and the house is all brick. I thought about a skate boarding half pipe for the grand kids :)

How is your water bill going? Nice to have the wonderful rain last night!!!

I just got sent a weekly update from the good old City water dept and my bill is projected to be over 300 dollars this month based on my current usage. I am so thankful for the rain as I'm sure every one else is. 

K.T. --- 12 years ago -

300.00, yikes! That would be an August bill for me! Projected 156.00 this next go round. 

Sweet Cherub --- 12 years ago -

I would also take it out and put in a giant shower. I HATE tubs. The idea of sitting in your own filth totally grosses me out. Not to mention they are a pain to clean and keep clean. Yuck. 

MissPris --- 12 years ago -

Walk in shower. 

Jpgirl --- 12 years ago -

We're doing a giant walk in shower too. If you go for the jet tub- look into the new ones that completely drain- otherwise there is no way to clean the tubes and jets. When we dismantled ours I was soooo grossed out- we've been here 12 years and have used that tub 3 times- the last being 3 years ago. The tubes that connect the jets were still filled with black moldy water!! 

Sweet Cherub --- 12 years ago -

The tubes that connect the jets were still filled with black moldy water!!


That is so gross! 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

When we bought our house it had a jet tub upstairs and in the downstairs master bath. I loved the idea of having one until taking it for a test drive. It's just not powerful enough to satisfy me. I want jets that give me a deep tissue massage. These jets just seem to create water turbulence.

After using them we noticed the holes where the jets were cut started to crack. That created another unsightly area that required extra cleaning and obviously a leak concern.

So we've already replaced one with a soaker tub as part of a bathroom remodel and will probably be replacing the other one in about a year.

A good substitute was side mounted water jets in a walk-in shower. It provides a better massage with less water. When adult female family members come over for extended visits, that becomes their favorite part of the stay once they learn the lowest water jet can be angled just right. Even guys comment about how their filthiest parts end up so much cleaner. 

Jpgirl --- 12 years ago -

The problem with the jetted tubs are not the jets- it's the tubing. We discovered the poor design when we tore ours out. The tubing that connects all the jets is horizontal - so you can clean with whatever product all day long- but when you drain the tub - water remains in the tubing ( because it is horizontal and has no way to drain) and it gets moldy. So the next time you take a bath the water that remains gets circulated in your tub.
I was totally grossed out when we dismantled it and I'm very happy that we decided on a spa shower! 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

we are doing a walk in tub in our remodel. We are looking at selling our house later as a downsizer so older folks like the walk ins. 

jennycrocker --- 12 years ago -

We just replaced our jetted tub with a soaker. I never liked the jets as I prefer a bubble bath anyway! 

Mayberry --- 12 years ago -

We went with large walk in shower ( to accommodate a wheelchair if necessary in our future) and for soaking, we put in a two seat hot tub on the screen deck. 

Wicked --- 12 years ago -

We decided to go with a soaker tub. No more jets and people can use the pool spa anyway. Thanks everyone for your input! 

Elsa --- 12 years ago -

We just bought a house and it has a jetted tub. I was a little worried when I cleaned it but so far so good. I have bleached the holy heck out of it and run the tub per the manufacturers instructions. I let it run longer than they suggested though. 

Jpgirl --- 12 years ago -

Elsa- the water still sits in the tubing no matter how much bleach you put in. I thought ours was ok too- did exactly what you're supposed to do. I was shocked at the gross black water when we tore it out!
Soaker tub was a consideration for us as well- but I loved my walk in shower in Ohio so we went with that 

Wicked --- 12 years ago -

Also Elsa, look for little pepper like specks, even the smallest ones are evidence that a problem exists. To be honest, I do not know how the previous owners could bathe in this tub as this was not a new problem once we moved in. It is disgusting. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground