Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Earth Age

who's talking here?

wayward1 3
Donkey Hodie 1
Hiro Protagonist 2
jtcitrus 7
JohnLynch 71
Dr Aborto 3
JchnLynch 1
Defcon1 1
Are we great again yet 1
Edgar Po Wong 3
JAMS 20
Emperor of Kingwood 3
GeorgiaPeach 1
DVaz 5
Butterbean 6
Snake Plissken 19
Commoner Sense 29
jacobson 1
AMDG 15
Wicked 3
Oregonian 10
Inferno 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Earth Age

In 1951 while studying uranium's radioactive decay to lead in meteorites, Scientist George Tilton discovered that the earth is about 4.5 Billion years old. In 1650, an Irish Bishop used the death of Nebuchadnezzar in the Bible to trace back the generations and come up that the earth was created 4004 BC. So biblically speaking, the earth is 6018 years old. Here are the ages of the earth. What say you in the political spectrum?

Earth is 4.5 Billion years old. Anybody who disagrees is lost. Vote
 
 53.5% (23)
Earth is 6000 years old. Anybody who disagrees is lost. Vote
 
 11.6% (5)
We don't really know. Vote
 
 9.3% (4)
Uranium decay is caused by the devil. Vote
 
 4.7% (2)
Obama's father and a young Nancy Pelosi fudged up 1950 numbers only to help Hillary hide the facts about Benghazi. Vote
 
 20.9% (9)
Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

In 1951 while studying uranium's radioactive decay to lead in meteorites, Scientist George Tilton discovered that the earth is about 4.5 Billion years old.

In 1650, an Irish Bishop used the death of Nebuchadnezzar in the Bible to trace back the generations and come up that the earth was created 4004 BC. So biblically speaking, the earth is 6018 years old.

Here are the ages of the earth. What say you in the political spectrum? 

JAMS --- 12 years ago -

Benghazi! 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

" 4.54 billion ... To be precise, this age represents the last time that lead isotopes were homogeneous througout the inner Solar System and the time that lead and uranium was incorporated into the solid bodies of the Solar System. " USGS

"The value for the age of the Earth in wide use today was determined by Tera in 1980, who found a value of 4.54 Ga from a clever analysis of the lead isotopic compositions of four ancient conformable lead deposits. Whether this age represents the age of the Earth?s accretion, of core formation, or of the material from which the Earth formed is not yet known, but recent evidence suggests it may approximate the latter." - The Geological Society of London 2001

If you can't tell, I'm going to have to go with Benghazi too. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

By all means, Benghazi, or Bengazi, or Ben Gazzy. Who or whatever is the current diversion from the newest Blue Bell flavor.

I've seen the Vishnu Schist and I'm convinced. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

it may come as a shock for those of you who believe in an old earth to learn that C-14 has been found in allegedly very ancient substances...such as coal and diamonds

in the evolutionary view...coal supposedly formed millions of years ago...also the diamonds in which C-14 has been found are supposed to be over a billion years old in the evolutionary view...

the presence of detectable C-14 indicates that the true age of these things is only a few thousand years since the half-life of C-14 is 5,736 years...carbon dating definitely challenges the billions of years view of the foolish evolutionists... 

JAMS --- 12 years ago -

LOL

John Lynch, PhD 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

John Lynch, PhD

how did you know? 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

Actually JAMS,
John brings up a valid point.

C14 IS present in very old coal/diamond deposits. I fact checked my assumptions before dismissing him, because of the unusual coherence and specificity of the claim.

There are many seemingly OLD carbon deposits with C14 present. The concentrations of C14 in these deposits is apparently extremely variable (i.e. not uniform), which suggests contamination of the deposit in some way:

1) C14 can be formed in situ by radioactive decay of other isotopes - example: there's an iridium isotope which is common rock formations that may cause it, but is apparently insufficient in and of itself (by a factor of 3) to cause C14 at the levels seen in some of the contested samples
2) biological factors
3) atmospheric contamination etc.
both of the latter seem to still be in question, and there are other isotopes and/or radioactive activity that may account for the rest.

Thus, John is correct that there is an apparent inconsistency in the radioactive decay dating. But this is NOT sufficient to undermine the old-earth story given that it is both directly and indirectly supported/corroborated by so many other data. 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

like most such things, the presence of C14 where it isn't supposed to be will be explained, and it may one day change what we think we know about the related physics...

Don't worry though. Re-interpreting/ignoring the evidence to cram it into a young-earth model will remain a laughable endeavor for the foreseeable future.

It took a while to find actual studies while googling, because the young-earth creationists take any seemingly anti-old earth tid-bit and run with it. but the data is out there (thank you google scholar!)

and thank you john for the interesting diversion. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

But this is NOT sufficient to undermine the old-earth story

it absolutely is...

FYI...the contamination issues could be present in the rocks surrounding the coal...but not within the coal itself...

and that brings up the point that the rocks that are "dated" do face those contamination issues...not to mention daughter ion assumption issues...

Re-interpreting/ignoring the evidence to cram it into a young-earth model will remain a laughable endeavor for the foreseeable future.

actually...the re-interpreting/ignoring the evidence to cram it into a old-earth model will remain a laughable endeavor for the foreseeable future...until God shows them the fallacy of their thought process... 

Wicked --- 12 years ago -

So are you saying that Jesus had a pet dinosaur? 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

So are you saying that Jesus had a pet dinosaur?

wow...what an intelligent comment...you should be proud... 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

So are you saying that Jesus had a pet dinosaur?

no. I'm saying that until we understand why those contaminants are there, the C14 in coal/diamonds will be in-congruent with either our understanding of C14, radioactive decay more broadly, the dynamics of the geologic/biological/chemical interactions that form and interact with coal/diamonds, or some component of any-of-the-above. 

Are we great again yet --- 12 years ago -

So are you saying that Jesus had a pet dinosaur?

Yep.
I saw a picture of him riding it after he saddle trained it. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

I'm saying that until we understand why those contaminants are there

the C-14 isn't a contaminant...your diatribe has no merit...just a bunch of empty words... 

Commoner Sense --- 12 years ago -

Dude, if you guys are seriously arguing the age of the earth with the loon...uhmmm...

I guess the plus is that the guy that believes the bible is a history book also believes the earth is whatever thousand years old. So you could deduce that his whacko religious views are just as god awful freaking ridiculously idiotic and stupid as his earth age theories.

For the love of Zeus, don't even bother arguing this. Holy Christ. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

I guess the plus is that the guy that believes the bible is a history book

you can't even be truthful on even the simplest stuff...i never said the Bible was a history book...

but even though it's not a history book...the history contained within is absolutely correct... 

Edgar Po Wong --- 12 years ago -

the history contained within is absolutely correct...


0 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

the C-14 isn't a contaminant

correct. It was wrong of me to call it a contaminant. And that wasn't a diatribe, I was stating the set of possible avenues, as far as I know, for explaining the presence of C14 in those samples. If the evidence leads to a new understanding of the age of the earth, so be it. If it doesn't it doesn't. I don't need it to go either way. 

Edgar Po Wong --- 12 years ago -

your diatribe has no merit

LOL...You obviously don't know the meaning of the word 'diatribe'... 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

I was stating the set of possible avenues, as far as I know, for explaining the presence of C14 in those samples.

let me give you the REAL reason...it is naturally occurring in any carbon containing entity 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

wong again wong...it's clear that you don't know what it means... 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

seriously arguing the age of the earth with the loon

I'm not arguing the age of the earth. Although his interpretation is unsound, JL presented valid information. Valid information shouldn't be discounted just because you dislike the source. 

Edgar Po Wong --- 12 years ago -

wong again wong...it's clear that you don't know what it means...

So you DO know what it means, you just chose to use it incorrectly. Got it. Good work, stench. 

Wicked --- 12 years ago -

wow...what an intelligent comment...you should be proud...


You are hardly one to make a comment like that JL. Be respectful. If you think the planet is 6000 years old, one would have to assume that dinos started inhabiting the earth around that time. And we cannot prove just how old the dino is according to your theories. So, I must assume that Jesus roamed this earth with the dino. The other thing, dinos apparently were killed off by a catastrophic event. How do we explain how humans survived this event and not the dinosaur? 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

So, I must assume that Jesus roamed this earth with the dino.

why would you have to assume that?...many species of animals are extinct...would it be within the realm of your understanding that possibly the dinosaurs were extinct long before Jesus walked the earth?

dinos apparently were killed off by a catastrophic event. How do we explain how humans survived this event and not the dinosaur??

the Ark... 

wayward1 --- 12 years ago -

I would think the dinos would have had to eat it either before or after the flood. If they walked the earth at the time of Noah, he would have protected them:

"Of fowls after their kind, and of cattle after their kind, of every creeping thing of the earth after his kind, two of every sort shall come unto thee, to keep them alive." 

Commoner Sense --- 12 years ago -

0 

JAMS --- 12 years ago -

Did he just say The Ark?

LMFAO 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

Would anybody vote for someone who believes he earth is 6000 years old? You can believe all you want, put your faith in a higher power or book but come on, there are facts you just can't ignore. 

Wicked --- 12 years ago -

And supposedly Noah was 480 years old when he started building the ark and 600 years old when he finished. It took 120 years to prepare for a flood. This is just not realistic in my view. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

If they walked the earth at the time of Noah, he would have protected them:

LOL...why would you say that?...

it's obvious that you forgot context since you overlooked "two of every sort shall come unto thee"


there are facts you just can't ignore.

LOL...what FACTS would those be aborto?...remember...speak facts...NOT assumptions or hypotheses 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

And supposedly Noah was 480 years old when he started building the ark

actually...the Bible doesn't say that...

It took 120 years to prepare for a flood.

the Bible doesn't say that either...

regardless...your view means nothing if it contradicts what God says... 

wayward1 --- 12 years ago -

If they walked the earth at the time of Noah, he would have protected them:

LOL...why would you say that?...


God said two of everything. Dinos would be considered an everything. If they lived then, two of them would have been on the ark. It couldn't be any more clear in the bible. That means the dinos would have had to perish before the flood or some time after it. "keep them alive," said God. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

God said two of everything

actually God didn't say that...trying to add to what God said?...actually God said "two of every sort shall come unto thee"

that doesn't guarantee a dinosaur... 

DVaz --- 12 years ago -

John, do you believe men tamed and rode dinosaurs or are dinosaurs a atheist-science fraud? 

wayward1 --- 12 years ago -

trying to add to what God said?

No, I wouldn't want to make an assumption based on a lack of clear information.

Now, what we're you saying about dinosaurs possibly not being guaranteed as a "sort." 

JAMS --- 12 years ago -

Apparently, some of you have never seen The Flintstones.

Dinosaurs helped build this country. 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

Would anybody vote for someone who believes he earth is 6000 years old?

Should anyone vote against someone (or abstain) because of one vector? Obviously it depends. I wouldn't want someone who believes in a young earth to be on many science and education related committees. However, if they're effective legislators, I might want them to work on other measures that I do agree with them on. Like tax, immigration, and regulation reforms. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

it's obvious that you forgot context since you overlooked "two of every sort shall come unto thee"

By the way, here is the definition of context in the literal bible dictionary.

Context - a word to use whenever the literal words don't say what you literally want them to say. 

page 1 2 3 4 5 6
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground