Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Rehoming an adopted child. I never knew this was possible and I am glad Wisc is stopping it.

who's talking here?

ladybeachbum 1
Perfection 2
AwesomeTattooedDragon 24
*LOL* 3
Work in Progress 6
Dorothy Parker 15
FabFive 2
schaghticoke 3
Sweet Cherub 4
Elsa 7
beyoutiful 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

I hope more States do this too. How horrible for these kids.

WASHINGTON ? Wisconsin has become the first state in the nation to pass legislation cracking down on parents who try to give away their adopted kids.

On Wednesday, Gov. Scott Walker signed a bill that would bar adoptive parents from finding a new home for their children without court permission. The legislation sought to protect adopted children from the unregulated practice of ?re-homing,? where adoptive parents use underground networks to find a new family for children they don't want.

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

?With virtually no oversight, children could literally be traded from home to home. In Wisconsin, that is now against the law,? Republican Rep. Joel Kleefisch, who sponsored the legislation, said. ?Hopefully citizens of the country will follow our lead.?

The Wisconsin push comes after hundreds of parents were caught using social media sites to give away their adopted kids to strangers they met on the Internet. In some cases, that meant to predators and pedophiles.

Presently, there are no federal rules that prevent the practice of ?re-homing? children -- a term typically used by pet owners looking for new homes for their unruly animals.

Many nations don?t disclose if the children they are putting up for adoption are victims of physical abuse or mental trauma. The adoptive parents in these scenarios often are unable to adequately care for the children, and some are left looking for questionable outs, Kathy Ledesma, national project director for Adopt US Kids, told FoxNews.com.

Ledesma, who has worked in the past on international adoptions, says states aren?t funded to handle issues that arise with these types of adoptions. Because these parents are often stuck in a situation, they turn to underground networks to dump the children they don?t want or can?t care for.

The legislation comes following a series of reports from Reuters looking into the underground trade of adopted minors.

Reuters analyzed 5,029 posts from parents of adopted children over a five-year period on a Yahoo Internet message board. The news agency found that, on average, one child per week was advertised for ?re-homing? In total, 261 kids were offered up via Yahoo.

The kids on the site, offered up for ?re-homing,? typically ranged in age from 6 to 14, although the youngest was 10 months old. Most had been adopted from other countries, including China, Russia and Ethiopia.

One reported case involved a Wisconsin couple. When couple Todd and Melissa Puchalla adopted Quita, a 14-year-old girl with a history of mental problems, from Liberia, they thought it would be easier. But after two years with the troubled teen, they decided to give her up, posting an ad on the Internet.

Less than 48 hours after posting the ad, Illinois couple Nicole and Calvin Eason contacted the Puchallas, saying they were interested in Quita. On Oct. 4, 2008, the Puchallas drove from their Wisconsin home to Westville, Ill., ready to hand over Quita. They didn?t know anything about the Easons.

They reportedly didn?t bother doing a simple background check on the couple they were handing their child to. Had they, they would have found that child welfare authorities had taken away both of Nicole Eason?s biological children, including a newborn baby boy. The deputy who had taken the infant away said in his report that the ?parents have severe psychiatric problems as well with violent tendencies,? Reuters reported.

Police reports also showed that children the couple baby-sat in the past had accused the Easons of sexual abuse. The only official document attesting to the Easons parenting skills was later found to be doctored by the Easons.

During her first night with the Easons, Quita told Reuters, her new guardians told her to join them in their bed. Nicole was naked, Quita said, according to Reuters.

In July 2009, Tom and Misty Mealey also welcomed the Easons to their Roanoke, Va., home. The Mealeys were prepared to give the Easons one of their children ? a 5-year-old adopted boy from Guatemala they had adopted earlier.

Tom was a cop.

?It?s horribly embarrassing,? he told Reuters of being misled by the Easons. ?The thought that I spent a career dealing with people like this is even more embarrassing. I wish we had done more.?

Following the Reuters investigation, Yahoo shut down their Adopting-from-Disruption bulletin board. Yahoo also took down five other discussion boards.

The Reuters investigation also found a forum on Facebook, but that one remains active. Emails to Facebook for comment by FoxNews.com were not returned.

Quita, now 21, is enrolled at the Milwaukee Area Technical College where she is studying social work. She lost her apartment over the summer and is now in temporary housing.

The little boy the Mealeys gave up is now 9-years-old. He is currently a ward of New York state. 

schaghticoke --- 12 years ago -

I remember reading that Reuters article last year. Horrible. I'm glad someone is finally doing something for those kids.

Reuters article 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

That is horrific. I had no idea that was happening. 

FabFive --- 12 years ago -

Dear God. 

ladybeachbum --- 12 years ago -

I read this earlier and it was just so horrific to me, I couldn't post. I can't imagine rehoming a child. It is not in my ideas of possibilities. 

Elsa --- 12 years ago -

Sometimes when you adopt a child from another country, you have no idea what kind of "baggage" they come with. Someone I heard about through an adoption page (I work in this industry) adopted a child from another country and he had been sexually abused in the orphanage...of course they were not told that. Then when he came home, he started going after the other children in the home in a sexual way.

They had to rehome him (not as easy as you think IF you do it legally...certainly not Craigslist!) for the sake of the other children. He ended up in a home where he was the only child and he did MUCH better.

I can't stand the thought of rehoming a child....it sounds terrible. But there ARE cases where it is actually necessary especially if they are a danger to other children in the home.

Sadly, there don't seem to be any regulations or accountability with overseas (and even some domestic) adoptions as there are many instances in which the parents were not given FULL disclosure.

Sadly the child suffers... 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

Elsa, you raised a good point. Sometimes a person does have to be in a different environment for everyone involved.

But the idea of giving a child away to. . .(skin crawling) pedophiles and abusers who are trolling the internet and searching for victims. I just can't fathom not caring what could happen to that child. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

that little boy needed professional help, not a single child home! do you think that predatory behavior will just go away? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

this is beyond disgusting- and I can't stand to read about re-homing pets- 

*LOL* --- 12 years ago -

I can't stand the thought of rehoming a child....it sounds terrible. But there ARE cases where it is actually necessary especially if they are a danger to other children in the home.

How is this any different than finding out that one of your biological children is seriously emotionally disturbed? It happens, you know and it isn't always through any fault of the parents.

I believe when you adopt a child, they are your child just as one you gave birth to.

Of course, it is possible to give up a naturally born child too but it sounds like these people just considered their adopted child a commodity they could dispose of when they were unwanted or didn't live up to their expectations. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

yeah- "oh, this child is defective, let's see if a neighbor will take it-" 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

I read an article about this recently. .

.link to article


What would you do in her situation? 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

that little boy needed professional help, not a single child home! do you think that predatory behavior will just go away?
Perhaps I'm wrong but I was under the impression that the child was receiving professional help as well as being removed from his/her victims.

I told you guys one time about the boy I knew growing up that was adopted from infancy. He had some serious psychological issues and they had to have him committed when they physically caught him picking the lock to his sister's bedroom in order to kill her.

He had to be removed from the situation, or the whole family was in danger.

If the child is placed in a family situation where they don't have the ability to hurt other children, I don't necessarily see that as wrong. It's probably better than being committed, granted that they are receiving professional help as part of the deal. HOWEVER, it is absolutely heinous to give away a child to God knows who over the internet where THEY become the victim. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I wouldn't be in that situation- who adopts a child without extensive background on him/her? the pits I've had I did lots of background checks first- 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

How can you do an extensive background check on a foreign adoption? 

Elsa --- 12 years ago -

The people in the article are not the norm nor is rehoming an adopted child. If you are truly interested, read up on Reactive Attachment Disorder...people with RAD have been known to kill their adoptive (and even biological) parents, burn down houses, hurt animals and the like.

I am not condoning rehoming a child...especially just randomly picking someone off of craigslist or yahoo. That should be a criminal offense.

The child that was successfully placed in a family where he was the only child was done so because he was sexually abusing the other children in the home because of learned behaviors from the orphanage he lived in. When moved to a new family his therapy continued yet there were no other victims.

Again, I work in the field of adoption. RAD is complicated and often deadly. Do your research. 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

DP, I don't know what to make of that story. Wow. I just. . .words rarely fail me, but I have nothing.

I will say that if I were to adopt, I would adopt younger than my children. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

I agree with you, Elsa. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

if you can't and you adopt anyway, (especially knowing that Eastern European countries like Romania have children that were never held, you better be willing to contend with the consequences- or of course, you can put them down, the way you advocate for pit bulls-are you comparing kids with dogs? 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

I agree with you too, WIP. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

You brought up the dogs, Tat, not me.

I was asking how you would go about doing an extensive background check dealing with an orphanage in Haiti.

Calm down, weirdo. 

Elsa --- 12 years ago -

DTD, I totally understand your point. It seems unconscionable doesn't it? NOTHING prepares you for RAD, domestically adopted kids can have it too as can biological children. It is a TERRIBLE mental illness.

I don't know if you are speaking about me advocating for pit bulls, I don't recall ever speaking about them on KU.

If you are interested in RAD, read "Deatched" or "Dandelion On My Pillow, Knife Underneath"...you will be stunned to see how terrible this illness is.

Dorothy-I just read the article. It seems that boy had RAD. It was also a milder case from what I can tell. They get worse.

I would never disrupt the natural birth order in my family either.

Remember there are MANY international and domestic adoption that are wonderful and successful. :) 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I'm perfectly calm and far from weird- I was making a point- if it bothers you, don't answer- personal attacks are unnecessary- unless you've got your panties in a wad- 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

I do understand what you are saying DT. Talking about rehoming a child as if the child were a dog. But certainly no one has suggested putting a child "down."

It's an interesting, yet terrible dilemma isn't it? Is it better for a child to leave one family for another if the present situation is dangerous for the original family? We don't usually think in those terms. We think of removing children if the adults are the aggressors.

Like I said, I am rarely at a loss for opinions, but I don't know the answer to this. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

You mentioned dogs then asked if I was comparing dogs to children.

Maybe you're getting senile? It happens to the elderly. You aren't immune. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

oh, someone pull the knife out of my chest!! maybe you're just being petty- 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

oh, someone pull the knife out of my chest!! maybe you're just being petty- 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

No knives here...just asked a question and you responded like a weirdo comparing dogs to kids.

Old people...bless their hearts! 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

umm.. I wasn't comparing dogs to kids-you were- my point was you acted like a child adopted from a country well known for disturbed orphans were expendable- you're not too happy when someone disagrees with you, are you? you get really childish and petty- perhaps you need to take a break, and control yourself- 

*LOL* --- 12 years ago -

I wonder how much training and education parents seeking adoption, (especially foreign adoption) receive prior to adoption. I know with legal adoption, the parent's background is looked into, but how prepared are they for the emotional issues children may come with?

I think some people have an idealized perception and well intentioned goal of giving a child a new life, but reality is not often like that.

Do these adoptions agencies that specialize in foreign adoptions continue to see the families and work with them when early signs of RAD start to appear? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

EXACTLY. 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

I think the horror of the predicament is making us attack each other instead of thinking through the problem.

TD, I understand your position. There is a visceral gut reaction to thinking about giving a child away from his/her family. That is just terrible to imagine, and I can completely understand how when you think that is wrong with dogs, you are a billion times more disturbed by the thought when it comes to a human child. I am too.

But DP, I see your point too. Leaving other children in the home as potential victims to the mentally disturbed seems every bit as wrong. If another family is a safer haven for all involved, is it wrong to supply that?

My head hurts just trying to morally reason through it. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

Please show me where I compared dogs and kids.

You said they should do extensive background checks..I asked how one would go about that in a foreign country, you then went off about putting down kids like dogs.

It's like you can't follow along on the thread, Tat. Maybe it is you that needs a break from KU.

But then, what would you do all day long? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

there are certain countries I'd never adopt from- once you take that responsibility, you're stuck- I even feel that way about animals, and therefore, I'm very careful which animals I adopt- even adoptions in this country can be disastrous- a baby born with alcohol syndrome or drug addicts on both sides of their family can end up in a heart breaking end- you just can't "re-home" a child that's damaged- 

Elsa --- 12 years ago -

I wonder how much training and education parents seeking adoption, (especially foreign adoption) receive prior to adoption. I know with legal adoption, the parent's background is looked into, but how prepared are they for the emotional issues children may come with?

I think some people have an idealized perception and well intentioned goal of giving a child a new life, but reality is not often like that.

Do these adoptions agencies that specialize in foreign adoptions continue to see the families and work with them when early signs of RAD start to appear?



Well said...I know the domestic ones do to a point. This area is sorely in need of psychologists and psychiatrists that truly understand adoption issues and RAD. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

certainly an understatement- what's more important than the children? 

Elsa --- 12 years ago -

you just can't "re-home" a child that's damaged-

In some cases, a child with RAD has killed a family member or sexually abused a sibling.

What would you do? Allow it to continue? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

that's happened with natural children, too- all you can do is get as much help as possible, and report any incident to the authorities- it's a horrible situation- 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

What would you do? Allow it to continue??


If it's an adopted child, putting them in a better situation for them, would be the best case scenario.

If it is your natural child, you could always seek help with other relatives to see if they would thrive better in another home. So, while that isn't an adoption scenario, it is still removing them from the current situation into a better, safer situation.

Natural child or adopted child, I would not allow my family to be terrorized or abused at their hand. I would do something to remove them from the situation. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

should you give this child to someone who'll kill a different family member? sexually abuse another child? I have no answers, other than you have to at least try- I wouldn't put myself in that situation- unfortunately, I know better- 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground