Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Tremors of the Big Bang: First direct evidence of cosmic inflation

who's talking here?

jtcitrus 7
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
JohnLynch 9
Dr Aborto 1
TheZooKeeper 1
Texan65 4
Butterbean 1
Snake Plissken 1
Commoner Sense 1
AMDG 4
citrus 3
satsuma 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

"Almost 14 billion years ago, the universe we inhabit burst into existence in an extraordinary event that initiated the Big Bang. In the first fleeting fraction of a second, the universe expanded exponentially, stretching far beyond the view of our best telescopes. All this, of course, was just theory. Researchers now announce the first direct evidence for this cosmic inflation. Their data also represent the first images of gravitational waves, or ripples in space-time. These waves have been described as the "first tremors of the Big Bang." Finally, the data confirm a deep connection between quantum mechanics and general relativity."

...
"These groundbreaking results came from observations by the BICEP2 (based on NASA technology btw!) telescope of the cosmic microwave background -- a faint glow left over from the Big Bang. Tiny fluctuations in this afterglow provide clues to conditions in the early universe."

...
"The [signal they were looking for-based on the predictions of the equations of Inflationary Cosmology] is a unique signature of gravitational waves [according to the otherwise thoroughly successful equations of Quantum mechanics - they've never been able to probe gravity empirically, but the rest of the quantum world is explained pretty well by QED] because of their handedness. This is the first direct image of gravitational waves across the primordial sky," said co-leader Chao-Lin Kuo (Stanford/SLAC).

...They were surprised to detect a [signal predicted by the model] considerably stronger than many cosmologists expected. The team analyzed their data for more than three years in an effort to rule out any errors. They also considered whether dust in our galaxy could produce the observed pattern, but the data suggest this is highly unlikely.

..."This has been like looking for a needle in a haystack, but instead we found a crowbar," said co-leader Clem Pryke (University of Minnesota)."





So, here's a fantastically crude timeline:

1) the equations of general relativity predict that the universe may not be static (Einstein rejected the possibilty)

- Edwin Hubble proves the universe is expanding.

2) Run the equations of an expanding universe backwards in time and they suggest a "big bang", and (thanks to the likes of Einstein, Neils Bohr, etc.) Quantum Mechanics develops and the equations predict something like an "afterglow" of heat/radiation that a big bang should leave uniformly throughout the universe.
- Evidence was accidentally discovered and matched the predictions of the model.

3)Inflationary Cosmology says that quantum effects (very small, and early in the universe's history - within the framework of their equations) would leave an imprint on the universe which would become stretched out (macroscopic) as the universe expanded. One of these effects would be the effect of gravity on the CMB. They predicted it would look a certain way.
- we just found what the model predicted! Furthermore, this may be the first INDIRECT evidence for the existence of the Graviton.

VERY COOL TIMES!

again, this does NOT mean that inflationary cosmology is right. It does however limit the set of plausible explanations in favor of inflationary cosmology.


Geek-out over... for now.
;) 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

One of several sources with good links :) 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

Very very cool.

 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Edwin Hubble proves the universe is expanding.

someone finally listened to God...

"Who coverest thyself with light as with a garment: who stretchest out the heavens like a curtain"

Run the equations of an expanding universe backwards in time and they suggest a "big bang",

yep...as "In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth" 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

someone finally listened to God...

"Who coverest thyself with light as with a garment: who stretchest out the heavens like a curtain"


Well, not so much listened to god as independently corroborated your implied interpretation of that scripture through careful measurement of the red-shift in the spectra of galaxies.


yep...as "In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth"

That's one way to interpret it, but there's nothing in Genesis that necessarily would be interpreted to mean a "big bang" of the type suggested in physics. The dominant belief (Judeo-christian and scientific) up until Hubble was in a steady-state universe. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Well, not so much listened to god as independently corroborated your implied interpretation

do you mean you can't understand those simple words?

The dominant belief (Judeo-christian and scientific) up until Hubble was in a steady-state universe.

just goes to show that the majority is seldom right... 

Texan65 --- 12 years ago -

The dominant belief (Judeo-christian and scientific) up until Hubble was in a steady-state universe.

I don't understand this statement. I wasn't aware of the steady state universe theory so I read about it and it seems to be a modern (1920) theory that holds that matter is continuously being created. It has little in common with Judeo-Christian thought.

Other than a finite life, the big bang isn't consistent with historical Judeo-Christian thought either..
Earth is flat, center of universe, stars revolve around it etc 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Earth is flat, center of universe, stars revolve around it etc?

that isn't Judeo-Christian thought either... 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

John, I see nothing in your postings that enhances civilized thought. You have no civilized relevancy. 

Texan65 --- 12 years ago -

that isn't Judeo-Christian thought either.

It was for a long time... 

Texan65 --- 12 years ago -

There are some sects that still believe the earth is 6000 years old and that animals haven't evolved.... 

Texan65 --- 12 years ago -

JL please start a separate thread about your religious views on science and leave this one alone...

Let this be a science thread to discuss the wonders of the universe 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

There are some sects that still believe the earth is 6000 years old and that animals haven't evolved....?

there are some people that correctly believe God

Let this be a science thread to discuss the wonders of the universe?

you haven't been discussing science...scientific fact in the Bible as told to us by God isn't a "religious view"

believing in the big bang and evolution is the "religious view" 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

"When men of learning were convinced that there were only about 3,000 stars, Jeremiah wrote that nobody would be able to count the stars. Let us consider an imaginary dialogue between Jeremiah (J) and a well known astronomer (A) of that day, about 600 years before Christ:

A: Jeremiah, you write about the number of stars as if you knew what you were saying. My colleagues and I have studied astronomy for a long time and daily concern ourselves with the stars. Our researches have made astronomy the most advanced science. Even kings appreciate and respect our findings.

J: You may have discovered many things, but you are mistaken about the number of stars.

A: How do you know that? You have not studied astronomy, not even for a single semester. So do not speak about matters which you do not understand!

J: Yes, of course my studies were in a totally different field. But I still maintain that nobody is able to count the stars, because they total such a large number, similar to the number of grains of sand on the beach.

A: We have recently completed a survey of the number of stars in the sky, employing our younger colleagues whose vision is sharp and unimpaired. They did not miss any stars, and their count was 3,000. Revise your biblical text; it has been disproved by our scientific findings.

J: I still maintain that I have written the truth. I am no expert, but I know Him Who created the stars. He has told me and I believe Him.

It is noteworthy that only now in the 20th century can we fully appreciate the astronomical import of such biblical affirmations. It behooves us to trust biblical pronouncements in other cases as well." 

Snake Plissken --- 12 years ago -

believing in the big bang and evolution is the "religious view"


The Big Bang doesn't require tithe. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

The Big Bang doesn't require tithe

that's not what constitutes "religion" 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

I wasn't aware of the steady state universe theory so I read about it and it seems to be a modern (1920) theory that holds that matter is continuously being created.


you are correct, and I spoke incorrectly. Steady-state theory is as you described. I should have said "static" universe. Einstein for one believed that the universe itself was static (neither expanding nor contracting). Even with the huge demotion in our sense of self-importance over the prior 100 years (our solar system becoming a mundane member of a galaxy, our galaxy becoming a mundane member of a universe filled with galaxies....) the scientific, religious, and philosophical communities still largely thought of the universe as unchanging in its basic features. 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

just goes to show that the majority is seldom right...

no it doesn't it shows one instance of the majority being inaccurate about something wholly outside their experience. 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

Other than a finite life, the big bang isn't consistent with historical Judeo-Christian thought either..
Earth is flat, center of universe, stars revolve around it etc


other than the fact that it was cannon of the catholic church (more or less, i think) for a long time, I don't think those are essentially judeo-christian beliefs. The intelligent design community within christianity doesn't have a problem with the big bang, but I don't know how far back that line of reasoning goes. 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

believing in the big bang and evolution is the "religious view"


JL is right in one respect here: as with ALL belief systems, certain principles are taken on faith. In science, we believe the fundamental laws of physics to be consistent throughout the universe and invariant over the life of the universe (remember, time itself is a function of the laws of the universe).

I embrace evolution and the big bang because, despite the flaws and holes in the concepts thus far, they are the best explanations we have for the data we've observed. That embrace is not sacred, not inviolate, and is subject to the scrutiny of empiricism (acknowledging its limits).

The extent to which those theories are compatible with any other religious view is irrelevant to their validity.

One of the fascinating things about Astrophysics is how it continually brings pie-in-the-sky mathematical philosophy (always evidence based) out of the abstract and into the concrete world of empirical science. It is amazing that the equations of physics can make such powerful and testable predictions about our universe: from predicting the existence and properties of sub-atomic particles to predicting features of our whole universe decades before the technology exists to test it. 

Commoner Sense --- 12 years ago -

One of the true consistencies of religion is that it has constantly had to realign itself to accommodate for scientific discovery. The next time science has to change a theory or law or realign itself because of a religious discovery will be the first. I was a liberal arts major, but I'm pretty sure that God created the heavens and earth doesn't pass the scientific method muster. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

but I'm pretty sure that God created the heavens and earth doesn't pass the scientific method muster

Did God create heaven and earth is not a scientific question. What created heaven and earth is a scientific question.

God created heaven and earth, is a matter of faith, not science.

One of the true consistencies of religion is that it has constantly had to realign itself to accommodate for scientific discovery

Agree, completly, as it should. You should never have to suspend your knowlege of the pysical/natural world, inorder to believe in God. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

no it doesn't it shows one instance of the majority being inaccurate about something wholly outside their experience

God says the majority isn't correct...so i'll go with that

One of the true consistencies of religion is that it has constantly had to realign itself to accommodate for scientific discovery.

absolutely FALSE

You should never have to suspend your knowlege of the pysical/natural world, inorder to believe in God.

absolute heresy...

"Who changed the truth of God into a lie, and worshipped and served the creature (created things) more than the Creator" 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

You should never have to suspend your knowlege of the pysical/natural world, inorder to believe in God.

absolute heresy...


Is the inverse true, you should always suspend your knowlege of the pysical/natural world, inorder to believe in God ?? 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Is the inverse true, you should always suspend your knowlege of the pysical/natural world, inorder to believe in God ??

you should ALWAYS believe in God...

throughout the ages...what we thought we knew about the physical world...has had to be continually revised... 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

you should ALWAYS believe in God...

thanks - I do.

throughout the ages...what we thought we knew about the physical world...has had to be continually revised...

Agree 100%

Neither of which answers the question.

which statement is correct:

You should never have to suspend your knowlege of the pysical/natural world, inorder to believe in God.

or

you should always suspend your knowlege of the pysical/natural world, inorder to believe in God ?? 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Neither of which answers the question.

which is incorrect...

btw...just curious...do you not know how to spell physical? 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

nevermind 

citrus --- 12 years ago -

Are the BICEP2 Results Invalid? Probably Not.


...Soon after the BICEP2 results, another team noted a foreground effect that could effect the BICEP2 results. It involves an effect known as radio loops, where dust particles trapped in interstellar magnetic fields can emit polarized light similar to B-mode polarization. How much of an effect this might have is unclear. Another project being done with the Planck satellite is also looking at this foreground effect, and has released some initial results (seen in the figure), but hasn?t yet released the actual data yet.

Now it has come to light that BICEP2 did, in fact, take some of this foreground polarization into account, in part using results from Planck. But since the raw data hadn?t been released, the team used data taken from a PDF slide of Planck results and basically reverse-engineered the Planck data. It is sometimes referred to as ?data scraping?, and it isn?t ideal, but it works moderately well. Now there is some debate as to whether that slide presented the real foreground polarization or some averaged polarization. If it is the latter, then the BICEP2 results may have underestimated the foreground effect. Does this mean the BICEP2 results are completely invalid? Given what I?ve seen so far, I don?t think it does. Keep in mind that the Planck foreground is one of several foreground effects that BICEP2 did account for. It could be a large error, but it could also be a rather minor one.

The important thing to keep in mind is that the BICEP2 paper is still undergoing peer review. Critical analysis of the paper is exactly what should happen, and is happening. This type review used to be confined to the ivory towers, but with social media it now happens in the open. This is how science is done. BICEP2 has made a bold claim, and now everyone gets to whack at them like a pi?.


Read more: http://www.universetoday.com/112008/are-the-bicep2-results-invalid-probably-not/#ixzz357XYFpg7




lots of links and articles 

citrus --- 12 years ago -

BICEP2 has made a bold claim, and now everyone gets to whack at them like a pinata


Ohhhhh the Drama! 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

jt, that's AWESOME- 

citrus --- 12 years ago -

jt, that's AWESOME

isn't it!?
:) 

TheZooKeeper --- 12 years ago -

 

satsuma --- 12 years ago -

Yo...

;)




Came across this. Though it worth sharing...

Scientific American



"On June 20, Physical Review Letters published a revised version of BICEP2?s original paper. In this new paper the astrophysicists seriously qualified their gravitational-wave interpretation. Most significantly, they deleted references to data about dust that was obtained from an unpublished presentation given by scientists from the European Space Agency?s Planck space observatory, which was doing similar research. They also incorporated Planck data about dust that had not been available when they posted the first version of the paper. With footnoted nods to Spergel and his colleagues, the BICEP2 scientists acknowledged that they could no longer ?exclude the possibility of dust emission bright enough to explain the entire excess signal.?
.
.
.

How do you think this controversy will affect the public?s perception of how science works?
The optimistic scenario is that the public will say, hey, this is great, it helps science when people check each other?s data. If the sausage is cleanly made, a good restaurant will not mind having a window into the kitchen. The negative side is, as one of my right-wing Facebook friends remarked: If the scientists get gravity waves wrong, why should we believe them on global warming?" 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground