Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Seeking advice on promotion -vs- pay

who's talking here?

ProudTXN 1
ET 1
Perfection 1
Warren Peace 1
Cajun Gris Gris 2
combatkenpo 2
AwesomeTattooedDragon 4
Quixote 2
Dr Aborto 1
sheddy 1
FabFive 1
Ender 9

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Ender --- 12 years ago -

I was recently "promoted" at work and I am wondering if the way my company is handling this transition is the 'norm' or if i am getting screwed over.

Until the fall of 2010 I have either been in the Marines or worked on drilling rigs, both of which use rigid job/pay structures.

When I was expected to take on different responsibilities on the rig, I could expect my pay-grade and title to change in order to reflect that. Obviously it would not be immediate, but my supervisor would explicitly state when the change would take place. I understand that the reasoning for the pay/title delay was to be sure that the employee could perform at his new job, but this was clear up front before the new job is taken on. Once your supervisors were satisfied with your ability to do the new job you usually got back-paid the difference in pay to when you started.

In the Marines if you took on a 'billet' that was above your pay-grade, you knew that it would reflect positively in your proficiency and conduct rating (which accelerated promotion).

As you can see, I am accustomed to a definable structure in my career path. In the fall of 2010 I transferred off of the rigs and into the engineering department of my company. Last month I was given another (much larger) set of responsibilities and moved to a different area of the company. My project manager (who decided to move me here) has made it clear that he knows that this is a step "up" and a much more demanding role, but has not made any mention of a salary increase.

Is this normal for corporate jobs? My current salary is not within the range that I have found for this position, and i am not sure if I should bring it up or not. I am happy that my career is progressing, but I do not want to be underpaid either.. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

bring it up- you're getting screwed- 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

your boss needs to see that you consider yourself worth more than they're paying you- strangely, people tend to see others by their own self worth- 

Cajun Gris Gris --- 12 years ago -

Ender,
I've been in the Oil & Gas Industry for a bit over 20 years and have been through roughly the same thing you are inquiring about on quite a few occasions. Although I am not a Big Company/Corporation employee; I do work as a contractor for one. They consider me and my co-workers "Company Reps" and we are evaluated annually as if we were Company Employees. In the good turnouts when promotions came about, it would be a 6 month period before there were any salary increases which was understandable to ensure you were capable of doing the job and meeting or exceeding the Supervisors expectations. On one of the not-so-good results (following a good evaluation) which resulted in a "in name only" promotion, I found myself asking the same question you are. I waited the 6 month period, and bit my tongue as another 6 months passed with nothing being done. I'd made subtle hints on numerous occasions to my Supervisor's, and it took me getting to the point of being borderline irate for them to address it. Some companies will try and play you for the fool and reap the rewards off of your efforts. "Hey we have this guy doing this and that for half the pay we're giving this other guy!". They?re billing out your time on invoices to the Customer based off of your title/position, and paying you a fraction of what?s fair.

My suggestion would be to talk to your Supervisor or Department Lead directly and in a professional manner and say what's on your mind. They may have just overlooked it and mentioning it is all it takes to have it resolved. If you bite your tongue indefinitely, you're going to regret it to the point that it's eating your lunch. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

Thank you for the good advice Cajun.


One of the problems about my place of business is that there are NO evaluations of any kind. You have no way to gauge whether the project manager here is happy with your performance or not.

Another problem is that the 'rank structure' is extremely flat-- we ALL report directly to the project manager, so I have no supervisor that I interact with on a regular basis. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

Whatever you decide, good luck.

And CONGRATS on the promotion 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

Whatever you decide, good luck.

And CONGRATS on the promotion


Thank you 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

Welcome to civilian life. Companies try get as much out of you for less. Not all, but most. The employee on the other hand doesn't want to make it all about money so you feel kinda douchey for bringing up money. Cajun might be right, they might have just overlooked it. I know it sounds ridiculous but it could happen. HR thought corporate would handle it, corporate thought the supervisor was going to handle it. You get it. Bring it up to your supervisor and work your way up there. If they F'ed up then you should get retro pay. Good luck and congrats on the "promotion". 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

everyone believes you should speak up- so go for it- 

ET --- 12 years ago -

Be a good idea to have some idea what pay rates are in the industry for the work you are doing. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

Welcome to civilian life.

I should hang that over my bathroom mirror.

I am probably going to do something along the lines of what Cajun said..

The timing of this move is pretty complicated, so i am hoping that it is a combination of things that has kept this subject from being addressed. A major factor in my move is the fact that we are implementing an ERP system at my location, so you can imagine the massive fustercluck that is going on right now.

In fact, most of my time right now is devoted to creating the job that I will be doing once our ERP system goes live (my current position doesn't even have a job description).

Fun times..

And thank you Dr. Aborto 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

Be a good idea to have some idea what pay rates are in the industry for the work you are doing.

That is pretty difficult considering that I have no job title yet, and I do not know what an equivalent title would be to compare it too..

The only thing that I have been able to base it around is the perceived compensation and known benefits of my "peers" that i work with. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

the very fact that you've taken on more responsibility should be enough- tell them you deserve more money- 

ProudTXN --- 12 years ago -

Know someone that worked long hours for years, got paid a nice hourly wage plus OT, then was "promoted" and given a salary no more hourly wage. Still expected to do the same job with all the extra hours required to complete the jobs. When they brought this up to the boss, it was a take it or leave it type of deal. They did not want to accept the "promotion" but had no choice. Alternative was leave. Eventually company went under. Karma! 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

got paid a nice hourly wage plus OT, then was "promoted" and given a salary no more hourly wage. Still expected to do the same job with all the extra hours required to complete the jobs.

^ This is something that I am extremely worried about.

There are about 300 or so people working at my location and only 13 work for my company. (all of the labor & administrative positions are contracted out)

Out of those 13 employees, only 4 are hourly: The two HSE guys, myself, and another guy who is in my situation.

This company treats our income as salary even though we are paid hourly, and with overtime we consistently make about 70% more a year than base.

If they swap us to salary without taking this into account we are screwed.. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

I might have something worth adding to the conversation, but I think it's obvious that my response is more about economic theory than it is a direct answer to your question. But on this issue, you may not get a direct answer because the question is a philosophical one.

Yes, you are being underpaid. Most people spend the rest of their careers being underpaid. I don't mean that to sound like a form of injustice, that's just the nature of not being self-employed.

Here's what I mean by that. No one pays for anything without believing that they are getting the better deal. This is as true for the employer as it is for the employee who provides labor in exchange for an agreed upon compensation. This means the nature of being employed by someone else means that you are being underpaid from their perspective. If they did not believe they were getting the better deal, you would not have that job.

When negotiating salary, don't forget to assess how easy it would be for someone else to do your job for less money. So my rule of thumb has always been to be astonished that anyone would pay me to do what I do. I felt that way when I was making minimum wage for working in agricultural fields and collecting fresh manure from herds of livestock to the levels of income I now receive for the more cerebral forms of "labor". If a difficult and complicated task must be done at work, I do it without compensation. Doing it for "free" means you have more margin for error until you get good at it. This is what opportunity looks like. You've got to provide the labor before you can monetize the labor. Performing extra labor that seems beyond the pay grade is exactly what I attribute to receiving a series of paid promotions that pulled me up the organizational ladder.

You can make of this philosophy what you will, but I have never been fired, demoted, or asked to leave. Basic economics dictates that they should do the opposite, and they have. When asked to take on additional responsibilities, I do them without asking what's in it for me because I know the key to being compensated more is to provide more valuable labor than others are providing. Also don't forget that assessing the value of human labor is not limited to the speed, quantity, or quality of tasks performed, it's also about adding something valuable to the culture of an organization.

In the workplace, responsibility is a finite resource much like real estate. Take it when it comes and monetize it later. 

FabFive --- 12 years ago -

In your position, I would accept the non raise for awhile. I'd get experience and show that I'm adding value to my company and show that I'm worthy of a raise. Not sure how long this will take you to accomplish, but once you do accomplish it, start looking around discreetly at other positions to see what they pay. If you're getting robbed, see how easy it is to get the same job with another company. If you feel good about your odds, speak to your supervisor. Feel it out and then go from there. 

combatkenpo --- 12 years ago -

Ender, thanks for your service. I did 21 years (10 active/11 guard) of my own in boots and I feel your pain about the opaqueness of the civilian market.

My experience has been very much in line with what WP said. 15 years ago I was working for half of what some of the other engineers in the office were making. I was either being given or volunteering to do all of the jobs no one wanted to touch. When it got to me I'd just remind myself that 1) my salary was enough to sustain my family's needs, 2) that I agreed each day to work for my salary and not their's, and 3) had faith that my managers would recognize and reward my efforts.

Of course, each situation is different but patience and perseverance paid off handsomely for me. For the last decade I've been fortunate enough to be on an elite team of top-shelf design engineers working on all the cool new toys and technologies. My company also long-ago recognized my value and brought my compensation up accordingly.

Your company very well may cross the line between validating your worth and just plain taking advantage of you. Only you can decide when that time has come but I'd recommend giving them the benefit of the doubt.

Just my 2 cents. YMMV. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

When asked to take on additional responsibilities, I do them without asking what's in it for me because I know the key to being compensated more is to provide more valuable labor than others are providing. Also don't forget that assessing the value of human labor is not limited to the speed, quantity, or quality of tasks performed, it's also about adding something valuable to the culture of an organization.

This is the same work ethic that my father taught me, and is how i have conducted myself so far.

I have always 'heard' that the corporate world is far more likely to take advantage of rather than recognizing performance, which is why I asked for advice.

Thank you all for sharing your experiences with this type of situation. I will definitely give it some time (6 months or so) before I bring it up to my boss. 

sheddy --- 12 years ago -

I would have thought it would have been brought up when he gave you the extra responsibility. Some people will take advantage of employees if they think they can get away with it. 

Quixote --- 12 years ago -

I left a large software company after being "promoted" from a "Senior" position to that of "Principle" and promised a six week retroactive raise while they "process it" the change. When the increase didn't show up on my check, I was told that I hadn't received promotion, I'd been given a "title change". I told them they were "right about a change" and immediately took a job with one of their clients (replacing two of my former employer's consultants) - and dared them to pursue the non-compete so I could make a stink with former clients. They got really nice after that and routinely call to see if I want to come back - at the "promised" rate. My advice is that whatever you do, always get promises in writing - with specific dates and numbers. Don't give anything away for free. It's all about respect. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

Thanks sheddy & Quixote

My advice is that whatever you do, always get promises in writing - with specific dates and numbers. Don't give anything away for free. It's all about respect.

I get what you are saying here, but unfortunately I do not think that this necessarily applies to me. It sounds like you were already well established in your career when you had to put your foot down, whereas I am still in the early stages of mine and this could be considered "my shot"... more or less. 

Cajun Gris Gris --- 12 years ago -

Man, I swear it sounds like you're working for an Engineering firm on one of Chevron's Major Capitol Projects going on in Houston!

I wish you the best in the long run. Do a little more digging and asking around within the group. If nobody can shed any light on the matter, that sounds a bit strange. A reasonable question that you should be able to bring to any of the persons at a higher level would be...

"Escuse me, I was wondering if there are any performance evaluations done on the personnel here?"

"I was kinda wondering if there's anyone here that is following up on, or reporting, my performance that could shed light on what I'm doing good and what could use improvement? I'd really hate to screw myself out of an opportunity to better myself financially."

Hitting them with either question is perfectly logical. Don't sell yourself short by going in everyday wondering and ending up frustrated further down the line! 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

"Escuse me, I was wondering if there are any performance evaluations done on the personnel here?"

"I was kinda wondering if there's anyone here that is following up on, or reporting, my performance that could shed light on what I'm doing good and what could use improvement? I'd really hate to screw myself out of an opportunity to better myself financially."


I have called two meetings with my project manager and done exactly what you just said.

He just got the "deer in the headlights" look and told me he was happy with my performance, they don't have an evaluation system here, and "good things will come my way if i keep up the good work".

I am quickly coming to the realization that Engineers make terrible leaders 90% of the time..

I was a platoon sergeant when before I got out, so i cannot fathom being any sort of manager/leader without systematically giving your guys feedback.

As I mentioned earlier, there are very few employees from my company (not Chevron) at this location. Most of them are superintendents who were already established in their careers when they got here. My boss got sent here about 10 years ago fresh out of school as a project engineer, and ended up as the project manager a few years later.

Because of this unique situation he has not had to learn to be a leader at all, he just didn't get in the way of the guys who knew what they were doing. Myself and the other guy I mentioned (in the same boat as me) are the only two employees that he as hired directly and had any influence on. 

Quixote --- 12 years ago -

I am quickly coming to the realization that Engineers make terrible leaders 90% of the time..

It's been my experience that communicating with an engineer is just a small step above communicating with the dead - only a lot louder. 

combatkenpo --- 12 years ago -

I was a platoon sergeant when before I got out, so i cannot fathom being any sort of manager/leader without systematically giving your guys feedback.

Sorry, but this is another "welcome to the civilian world" moment. After living under "an informed soldier is a happy soldier" banner for years it was a tough transition to the semi-secretive civilian world where you sort of have to make your own way.

You'll be amazed at how many of your managers either don't have a direction for you, are terrified of making decisions, or both.

I found good people and I've worked with and for them for years but every once in a while I have to ring that bell and/or kick them in the hind-end to give me the information/direction that I need to do my job.

Good luck and have patience. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground