Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Credit check rant/POLL

who's talking here?

marthas attic 1
sunshine1881 3
ukchristine 7
ladybeachbum 4
SoupIsGoodFood 2
SleightOfHand 2
Perfection 4
Cookin' Queen 1
zapper007 1
Warren Peace 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 9
Dr Aborto 1
Clovis 1
Dorothy Parker 2
itstxdaddy 10
snowprincess 1
FabFive 1
Semper 3
kinz 2
waterfall 2
Gigolo Bloodline 1
Not KU 22
Butterbean 1
Prolix Raconteur 2
mutton 4
Sweet Cherub 1
Chef Justin 2
Oregonian 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Credit check rant/POLL

WTF...These days when a person wants employment for a job. Some companies feel its there right to check your credit history and score...As if its has anything to do with a persons ability to do the job they are applying for. I understand Drug Testing, I dont understand why a persons Credit rating matters to a persons skills. Also, I dont understand why it is NO ONE has a litmus test to find out if a potential employee is crazy or violent. Please [b]do not[/b] try to explain why a credit check is (ok) [b]I wont buy it[/b]. A person credit has nothing to do with a persons skill or wage demands. ok, I feel better. Comments welcome. Keep it clean and on topic. Thanks. Poll closes in 24 hrs

Credit info has no relevance. Vote
 
 29.4% (15)
Credit info has relevance. Vote
 
 70.6% (36)
Not KU --- 12 years ago -

WTF...These days when a person wants employment for a job. Some companies feel its there right to check your credit history and score...As if its has anything to do with a persons ability to do the job they are applying for.

I understand Drug Testing, I dont understand why a persons Credit rating matters to a persons skills.
Also, I dont understand why it is NO ONE has a litmus test to find out if a potential employee is crazy or violent.

Please do not try to explain why a credit check is (ok) I wont buy it.
A person credit has nothing to do with a persons skill or wage demands.

ok, I feel better. Comments welcome. Keep it clean and on topic. Thanks. Poll closes in 24 hrs 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

Credit information is used for many positions.

Credit scores demonstrates an individuals ability to manage situations and to be prudent with money - valuable attributes when dealing with many positions.

Someone with a poor score may be more of a risk due to situations they are in.

While it is never the single item HR should look at, it does need to be one.

If an employee has the potential to impact the company through poor decision making then yes, a company needs to know that ahead of time. 

Not KU --- 12 years ago -

Credit scores demonstrates an individuals ability to manage situations and to be prudent with money - valuable attributes when dealing with many positions.

That is so vague, its lame!...Why is it anyone's business if your prudent or not? Can you do the job? now Im ranting again....I needs something to eat...:[ 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I agree- it shows a person's honesty, many times- hopefully extenuating circumstances can be discussed- 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

Agree with Perfection.

Credit worthiness is not an indicator of ability to perform a single work function. I think it is a direct indicator of a persons ability to abstract think, and manage life affairs accordingly. 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

A friend of mine has a very poor credit score due to the inability to control her spending. The person will spend more money on an expensive pair of shoes than pay her bills. She uses poor judgement in her personal life and it does run into her professional life. Many times, not all but many if a person cannot make good decisions in this are of their life a company can wonder how they will be able to make good decisions for them. Now if a poor credit rating is due to loss of job or illness, than I think that needs to be explained as it could be beyond the control of the person looking for the job. 

Chef Justin --- 12 years ago -

If a person is applying for a position were they will be handling money they will do a credit check.

Poor credit, may be more likely to steal.
Just a thought. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

that's kind of what I was referring to- 

Prolix Raconteur --- 12 years ago -

sounds like a rant from someone with bad credit to me 

Chef Justin --- 12 years ago -

Also now-a-days employers will google you and check your facebook and twitter accounts. They will go to extreme lengths to find out everything about you before making a decision to hire you or not. 

Not KU --- 12 years ago -

a company can wonder how they will be able to make good decisions for them.

Why cant the company just give that person a task and see if it can be done to that companies standards? Or, why cant that company call/contact fmr employers for references? Why the personal probing? That is one more entity that can be hacked and your personal info is at risk. 

ukchristine --- 12 years ago -

I a expect statistics can prove bad credit can lead to problem employee. However I totally disagree with this. There are always exceptions and reasonable explanations such as job loss or divorce. But nowadays employers can be very picky and need not take any risks. And btw I have excellent credit. But there have been times that wasn't so. During those times I still had total honesty and integrity. I know somebody who has bad credit not caused by over spending and they would NEVER EVER steal. 

ukchristine --- 12 years ago -

It might be a way of circumventing certain laws. 

Not KU --- 12 years ago -

ericb --- 10 min ago - quote - hide comments

sounds like a rant from someone with bad credit to me


Sounds like your not ON TOPIC. 

Prolix Raconteur --- 12 years ago -

why would a company hire someone, spend the money and time training them etc on the premise that, despite the fact they can't manage their own personal life/finances, they just mightbe able to do manage their job duties, or mightnot consider committing some nefarious act within the company to augment their own personal gain....

pretty simple logic really, don't hire losers 

sunshine1881 --- 12 years ago -

If you're working with money or someone's personal information, I have no problem with credit being checked. However, in most other jobs, it's pointless.

Life happens. Often times people are looking for jobs because of financial difficulties, so not-so-stellar credit shouldn't hold them back. 

itstxdaddy --- 12 years ago -

you have the free will not to agree to the credit check.

it's like ANY job. the employer has the right to determine on what terms they will hire someone. you have the right to accept those terms or not. if you don't like it, apply somewhere else. i doubt Red Lobster does a credit check. 

ukchristine --- 12 years ago -

I wonder if the ACA navigators had credit checks or FBI checks. 

Not KU --- 12 years ago -

why would a company hire someone, spend the money and time training them etc on the premise that, despite the fact they can't manage their own personal life/finances, they just mightbe able to do manage their job duties

Thats more like it. Personal circumstance can ruin or enhance a persons credit score...Deaths, Marriages, to many variables to pin-point the reasons why...Thats why I am ranting as to, Why? 

waterfall --- 12 years ago -

MrMark - It doesn't sound like you are looking for information. It seems like you are only looking for people who agree with you. You've been given many answers. 

Not KU --- 12 years ago -

you have the free will not to agree to the credit check.

No you dont. We must work to live. There is no freedom to grow a garden in your back yard to feed your family and you cant burn in your front yard to heat your home. You, me, all of us are under the thumb of labor and laboring. You are not free. So throw that logic out the window. 

ukchristine --- 12 years ago -

I like to think any company whose employees handle very detailed personal info vet new hires thoroughly. For businesses where employees don't handle such info I don't think it's that necessary for the credit check. 

Semper --- 12 years ago -

Is there a credit check done on our government? Senators, Congressmen, the President?

Their decisions are the ones that have an impact on our country's economy. 

Not KU --- 12 years ago -

MrMark - It doesn't sound like you are looking for information. It seems like you are only looking for people who agree with you. You've been given many answers.

You might be right....thats why Im ranting. If im going to take over the world. I need followers....KU is my target... Ok, now thats out of the way. :D 

Not KU --- 12 years ago -

Semper --- 35 sec ago - quote - hide comments

Is there a credit check done on our government? Senators, Congressmen, the President?


Off topic....good point, but off topic 

itstxdaddy --- 12 years ago -

No you dont. We must work to live.

you don't think you have the free will to choose where you work? strange. 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

820 over here boyeeeeeeeeeee!!! 

itstxdaddy --- 12 years ago -

You are not free.

I am free. i am free to walk out of my job anytime I want. That doesn't mean there are no consequences for doing so, but I am free to do it. 

ukchristine --- 12 years ago -

For once ( and prob only once) I mostly agree with Mr Mark. Many people on here have obviously lead perfect lives....an even if they had problems that would send most people's financial lives in a tailspin they managed to still keep good credit scores. And that's commendable. But bad things can happen to good people!

But employers make the rules. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

you even have the right to post on KU- too bad, that- 

Not KU --- 12 years ago -

you don't think you have the free will to choose where you work? strange.

Big Oil companies that pay big money like to probe.

So you choose..Big money, probing you, or willie-nillie chump change burger flipper. Is that a choice? No, its not. 

ukchristine --- 12 years ago -

The notion that no background checks on our countrys' leaders has always seemed ironic to me. Some presidents couldn't pass the most basic of credit or FBI checks to even enter the military at the lowest level yet they are Commander in Chief! ( but I digress...whoops) 

sunshine1881 --- 12 years ago -

I lost out on a job once because of my credit. They specifically told me I was the best candidate, but they couldn't hire me because of the credit check -- the job had nothing to do with finance/personal information etc.

My credit was trashed at the time because it was right after my husband had walked out and left me with every bill we had handled jointly except his truck note and my income was a third of what his was at the time. In a situation like that, you can't immediately cut expenses, so it was a few months of juggling until I could bring things in line where I could handle them myself, but my credit took a hit.

There was no room for explanation. In all honesty, they lost out on not only the person who they already felt was the best candidate for the position, but someone who did have enough financial responsibility to remedy that bad situation and make the moves to hang on to everything even with the reduced income even if the transition wasn't completely smooth. That was their loss based on a stupid, arbitrary policy. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I just wish I had their insurance, and pension plan- 

ukchristine --- 12 years ago -

Sunshine....you have exactly made my point, thank you. 

Semper --- 12 years ago -

but off topic?

Not really. I believe the discussion centers around whether employers should be checking their employee's credit background before hiring them.

Govt workers (including the president and congress) are drawing a salary so they are employed. If the private sector is starting to delve into the credit worthiness of it's potential staff prior to giving them a job...why shouldn't the federal govt be subjected to the same standard? 

itstxdaddy --- 12 years ago -

So you choose..Big money, probing you, or willie-nillie chump change burger flipper. Is that a choice? No, its not.

Operative word being or...yes it is a choice. I am glad you see that. 

FabFive --- 12 years ago -

If an employer wants you bad enough, they will hire you regardless of credit. They may ask for an explanation but if they want you they want you.

If I had the choice to pick between two equally qualified candidates I'd pick the one with the better credit. Credit has been proven as a great determination of people's patterns.

I think there are exceptions, especially since 2008/2009 with the economy in the tank. But that's where an explanation comes in to play.

They use credit to determine car insurance rates too. It is what it is. Pay your bills. 

Not KU --- 12 years ago -

but off topic?

Not really.


Yeah huh. We the people elect those officials. So the vetting is ours. Besides that league of scrutiny is not really relevant to ours...Off topic 

itstxdaddy --- 12 years ago -

Big Oil companies that pay big money like to probe.

let's go back to this one mrmark...wouldn't you probe if you had to choose which person to invest in? let's throw out the "give them a task" because that means they are already hired. what would be your criteria for selecting a candidate if you are paying them "big money"? 

page 1 2 3
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground