Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

IS CANADIAN SEN CRUZ A LEGAL US CITIZEN?

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
randyjet 8
wayward1 2
SoupIsGoodFood 5
SleightOfHand 3
Perfection 1
zapper007 1
Warren Peace 1
Are we great again yet 2
OhBrother 1
Emperor of Kingwood 2
Ogre13 5
Gigolo Bloodline 1
Not KU 1
jacobson 1
Sweet Cherub 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

A person on another blog asked WHY is it taking so long for Cruz to repudiate his Canadian citizenship? It normally takes only a day and is simple and cheap, yet he claims that even as a Harvard Law grad the process is too complicated for him to do it quickly. That is not true since it is simple and takes only one day to do it.

The more likely explanation is that he did NOT file or apply for his US citizenship which ALL foreign born persons who wish to claim US citizenship must file. It is NOT automatic and he may simply be waiting for the papers to clear before he cancels his Canadian citizenship. If he cancels his Canadian citizenship before he gets his US papers, he will be literally stateless. 

zapper007 --- 12 years ago -

Absolutely NEVER!!! 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Why is this even an issue? He didn't say when he was going to do it. 

whatchamacallit --- 12 years ago -

lol... 

Not KU --- 12 years ago -

If Ted Cruz were a viable candidate I would say no. But because he is the best chance the dems have, eh who cares. Save that piece of bacon for later. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

The New Birthers............ gotta laugh at you guys. 

SleightOfHand --- 12 years ago -

0undefined 

Sweet Cherub --- 12 years ago -

lolololol SleightOfHand!!! 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

hahahahaha 

Are we great again yet --- 12 years ago -

If Ted Cruz were a viable candidate


He's not.
Next issue? 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

The left must be so scared of him that's why they are attempting to destroy him. 

Sweet Cherub --- 12 years ago -

How many times do you think Hillary wishes she could take those words back? lololol 

SleightOfHand --- 12 years ago -

"How many times do you think Hillary wishes she could take those words back? lololol"

Unethical people don't let that bother them 

Are we great again yet --- 12 years ago -

Chunky, He won't get the nod because the Pubs are scared of him, besides, the GOP is not going to make the same mistake as '08 this time a nominate a Senator, especially a fringe one.
But I sure do hope so. I really, really want him to get nominated. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Well, according to the standards established buy the Obama birthers, it doesn't matter because Cruz can't run for President anyway. 

Gigolo Bloodline --- 12 years ago -

The New Birthers............ gotta laugh at you guys.

Trust me on this one. You are the one being laughed at. 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

Ogre13 Glad to see you back. The only reason I ask this question is to bring up a serious question on US citizens not being born in the US and having dual citizenship. It used to be that only persons actually born in the US could claim to be natural born citizens, but court decisions expanded that definition. It also used to be that if you served in some other countries military, you would actually lose your US citizenship. That is why the US volunteers in the RAF during WWII refused to take the oath to King George VI, so that they could keep their US citizenship. Now there is almost no possible way you can lose US citizenship for a person born in the US.

As for Cruz, he has basically lied on two counts. One he has either refused or has a problem with his US citizenship so that he has so far not done what he said he would do. Then he lied about the process and how to get rid of Canadian citizenship. It is easy to do in less than one day.

That brings up the question as to Federal officials having split loyalty to the US. Should this be allowed for them, and how about ordinary US citizens? Should US citizens get to vote twice in foreign and US elections? My personal position is that we need a Constitutional amendment to ban dual citizenship for ALL US citizens, and that to enforce this, we should also only allow natural born to apply to persons born on US soil or installations such as military bases or embassies. 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

Ogre13 Glad to see you back. The only reason I ask this question is to bring up a serious question on US citizens not being born in the US and having dual citizenship. It used to be that only persons actually born in the US could claim to be natural born citizens, but court decisions expanded that definition. It also used to be that if you served in some other countries military, you would actually lose your US citizenship. That is why the US volunteers in the RAF during WWII refused to take the oath to King George VI, so that they could keep their US citizenship. Now there is almost no possible way you can lose US citizenship for a person born in the US.

As for Cruz, he has basically lied on two counts. One he has either refused or has a problem with his US citizenship so that he has so far not done what he said he would do. Then he lied about the process and how to get rid of Canadian citizenship. It is easy to do in less than one day.

That brings up the question as to Federal officials having split loyalty to the US. Should this be allowed for them, and how about ordinary US citizens? Should US citizens get to vote twice in foreign and US elections? My personal position is that we need a Constitutional amendment to ban dual citizenship for ALL US citizens, and that to enforce this, we should also only allow natural born to apply to persons born on US soil or installations such as military bases or embassies. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Lead the charge, randy.

The New Birthers!!!! 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Trust me on this one. You are the one being laughed at.

Not a chance, Bloodloss.

YOU'RE the ones being laughed at. 

wayward1 --- 12 years ago -

YOU'RE the ones being laughed at.?

You're both right I'm afraid. 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

I read some of the things Cruz said about his being a natural born US citizen. He assumed that he was an American. The FACT is that a person born overseas to an American in order to be a US citizen MUST take affirmative action to establish that claim. There is a form that MUST be completed in order to be officially a US citizen. Just saying your mother was a US citizen does NOT cut it legally. Then I wonder if his mother was in fact born in the US. So there are some really interesting questions about Cruz. If he did not fill out the US form claiming his citizenship, he has a BIG problem. Then his mother is of Irish extraction, and she may in fact have been born in Ireland in which case she may well be an illegal. In the Valley, there were a number of midwives who sold certificate of birth that were false saying a person was born in the US when in fact they were born in Mexico. That caused problems for lots of people who were legitimately US citizens since ALL birth certificates that the crooked midwives issued were VOID. So this long delay should raise some questions for some investigators to look into. 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

I also hope that some lawyer will force Cruz to submit PROOF of his citizenship according to the new Texas law requiring proof of US citizenship and challenge his US passport. Just what do you think the registrar of county voters would do when he brings his Canadian birth certificate when he submits that as proof? At the very least, he will have to submit his mothers birth certificate as well as the form claiming his US citizenship. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

natural born US citizen

Is a term of art and has NO legal weight.

I really don't feel well enough to debate the whole bloody thing today, but basing ANYTHING on the term "natural born citizen" - which is a phrase found SOLELY within the Constitution, which does NOT define it - without further clarification is bad legal theory.

The following is cribbed from; "Qualifications for President and the ?Natural Born? Citizenship Eligibility Requirement."

www.fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R42097.pdf

"The weight of legal and historical authority indicates that the term "natural born" citizen would mean a person who is entitled to U.S. citizenship "by birth" or "at birth", either by being born "in" the United States and under its jurisdiction, even those born to foreign parents; by being born abroad to U.S. citizen-parents; or by being born in other situations meeting legal requirements for U.S. citizenship "at birth". Such term, however, would not include a person who was not a U.S. citizen by birth or at birth, and who was thus born an "alien" required to go through the legal process of "naturalization" to become a U.S. citizen."

There are probably 407 SCOTUS cases that say the same bloody thing.

Arguing that someone is NOT qualified to be president because they weren't' born within the borders... shows a distinct ignorance of our laws and what an American Citizen is.

But of course, ignorance has never stopped idiots from arguing from their point of ignorance. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Sorry about the link above, not going to fix it.

proof of US citizenship

Here's the thing, "Natural born" (for lack of a better term) CITIZENSHIP is not GRANTED to someone who is born with it. They are simply BORN WITH IT. Like the color of their eyes, or hair, or skin. In this specific example, if Cruz can show he had ONE U.S. Citizen parent, then he is a U.S. Citizen it doesn't matter if he was born in Canada, or under the sea, or on Mars.

You don't' have to claim it, you shouldn't have to file for it. You simply have it.

In fact, I can't think of ANY nation in which "Natural born" citizenship has to be earned (Ala Starship Troopers-esque society). There may be one out there, but I've never heard of it.

Naturalization, on the other hand, is a whole other process wherein citizenship is conferred on a person. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

BTW... why would Cruz have to "repudiate" his dual citizenship w/ Canada? There is no requirement to do so. 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

Ogre13 I agree with most of what you said with this exception

In fact, I can't think of ANY nation in which "Natural born" citizenship has to be earned

Mexico comes to mind. In fact the Mexican Constitution had to be changed so that Fox could run for President. It used to be that not only did you have to have been actually born in Mexico, but BOTH parents had to have been born there. Fox' mother was born in Spain.

My question is how Cruz got his right to vote. Can you imagine him going to the clerk and presenting his Canadian birth certificate and demanding to be registered as a voter? From what I know of Texas law at the time, I would think that for him to register he would have to present not only his birth certificate, but his mothers as well as the form requesting his US citizenship. If he does not have all of those, I would think that he could not be legally registered. I DO know that an American mother or the person MUST fill out the forms registering the birth as a US citizen. If that has not been done, it would be improper for the registrar to register that person.

My suspicion is that there is something funny going on with Cruz not requesting cancellation of his Canadian citizenship. It would take at most an hour if the lines are too long at the embassy in DC, and if he made an appointment it could be done is about five minutes. I know that legally speaking he does not have to do that. 

wayward1 --- 12 years ago -

Cruz is living the dream. Every Canadian child dreams of being able to grow up one day and single handedly shutting down the U.S. government. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

In fact, I can't think of ANY nation in which "Natural born" citizenship has to be earned

Mexico comes to mind.


I'm not sure that's exactly what I meant by "earning" citizenship.

They didn't make Fox EARN it, they just changed the rules. 

OhBrother --- 12 years ago -

No, he's not an American. He's the Canadian son of immigrants to North America. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

This is stupid. Cruz is a US citizen. His mother registered his birth with the US consulate. Obtaining a US passport requires evidence of US citizenship (made possible because his mother registered his birth with the US consulate). He obtained this passport in 1986.

Renouncing Canadian citizenship is a process that can take up to eight months (Source). I know it's probably shocking that it is not as simple as filling out a form as randyjet claims, but the truth is any legal matter takes time. 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

. His mother registered his birth with the US consulate.

Thank you for that bit of info that was not provided by any news media or Cruz himself. I said that all he had to do was to got to the embassy or consulate and fill out the forms which would take a few minutes. I did not see any reports either from Cruz stating that he HAD filed the forms. Maybe you could show where Cruz has said he has already filed the forms and is simply waiting for the Canadians to process them. 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

By the way,Cruz only has one more month until eight months has passed. Then you have the problem that a HARVARD Law grad did not know he was a dual citizen! THAT alone doesn't speak well for him or his ability as a lawyer. Now that means he is stupid, or incompetent, or simply a liar. I will let you take your pick. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

I did not see any reports either from Cruz stating that he HAD filed the forms.

Then you dont know how to do research or read, which is it? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

By the way,Cruz only has one more month until eight months has passed. Then you have the problem that a HARVARD Law grad did not know he was a dual citizen! THAT alone doesn't speak well for him or his ability as a lawyer. Now that means he is stupid, or incompetent, or simply a liar. I will let you take your pick.?

Can someone please translate the above into some sort of coherent rational comment? 

SleightOfHand --- 12 years ago -

0 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Randy is channelling mark. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground