Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

MyRA what do you think of forced purchasing of government bonds?

who's talking here?

KWPlanner 2
SoupIsGoodFood 1
Perfection 2
Warren Peace 6
JohnLynch 2
Not KU 1
Snake Plissken 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

link title

While this program is for those without IRAs currently, it does have the same framework as the last proposed transfer of 401/403 money in to government bonds.

Seems another pathway to getting the 401/403 monies is in the works and this one has a chance of happening. 

Not KU --- 12 years ago -

During the SOTU PBO said they were Gov. insured savings. That kicks 401k's can IMO. Its not dependent on being at an employer for some silly length of time before one can contribute to it.

I dont know that much about it. 

Snake Plissken --- 12 years ago -

Tax deductible IRA's and tax free Roth IRA's are already available with no fees. A 22 year old could contribute $5,000 a year and retire at 65 with $1,300,000.

And yes that includes bull and bear markets.

Unlike Social Security, this is money they can pass on to their heirs. You want to end poverty, this is the way to do it. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

This is what we've been waiting for. I see no reason why everyone should not get on board with this.

Republicans have been pushing for an alternative to social security that creates interest bearing accounts for individuals for decades. But they've been historically terrible at selling good ideas and allowed Democrats to tear it down.

Now the lead Democrat is finally favoring it? Run with it. Get it done. This is the baby step we need into having that grow into what it needs to grow into - a model indistinguishable from the Federal Thrift Savings Plan. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

I hope Republicans don't view this as something they need to try to get credit for and drag this thing out to add on various other attributes.

Get it done the quickest, easiest way possible. Just replicate the website already in place for federal employees that does the exact same thing that this proposes. Keep it simple using only the G-fund at the inception so people dependent only on social security can adapt to the concept of rates on return. In time they will demand investment alternatives. We will get the private investment accounts that this country has been needing. This is what social security should have been.

There has been no single proposed legislation in my lifetime that I favor more than this one. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

Why is that Warren Peace?

What do you think of the original proposal that would take your 401/403 monies and convert them in to this automatically? Are you just as much behind that?

I am interested in why you think this is such a good idea and needed. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

what good is it if you are barely getting by and don't have any money to participate? 

KWPlanner --- 12 years ago -

I'm still researching this as much as possible, but so far I really do not see this as being a great idea.

What I've read so far:

1. Funds can be taken out tax-free for any reason. This makes it more of a slush fund than a savings vehicle for retirement.

2. The only investment option available is in the gov't bond, which pays between 1-1.5%. Sure, they guarantee you will never lose value but that is in monetary terms. With inflation averaging 2.5-3% annually you're actually losing money.

3. Once the account reaches $15k it is required to be rolled out into a Roth IRA. Then what? You're going to have low-income households who have no concept of investing (if they did, they'd be saving and investing right now rather than being forced to save in this program) and making them responsible for handling the funds going forward.

I'm still doing as much reading into this as I can, but I really doubt I will come across anything that will make me think 'Hey, this is a great idea'. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

Why is that Warren Peace?

What do you think of the original proposal that would take your 401/403 monies and convert them in to this automatically? Are you just as much behind that?


Where are you getting this Perfection?

Why are you suggesting a discussion on an original proposal that does not appear to be part of the current proposal?

The Whitehouse Fact Sheet states the opposite – that contributors will be able to roll it into a private sector retirement account at any time. 

Snake Plissken --- 12 years ago -

What's stopping Congress from borrowing against this money, like they do with Social Security? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

^^^^ that. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

There has been no single proposed legislation in my lifetime that I favor more than this one.

i'll go with kwplanner's assessment 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

I'm surprised at your initial take on this KWPlanner. Though you chose your words carefully to avoid being opposed, your take strikes me as completely contrary to what a financial planner should be thinking for a population of people not currently engaged in saving for their future.

This is a government plan that actually INCENTIVIZES savings. It is targeted to the notoriously un savvy lower income earners widely known to do nothing for their own future savings, relying on future taxpayer money in the form of various entitlement payments that incentivize sloth and poor planning (or no planning).

I have a lot of respect for what you do, but I'm going to challenge you on much of your reasoning.

1. Funds can be taken out tax-free for any reason. This makes it more of a slush fund than a savings vehicle for retirement.

I have seen this worded with the pretext "as with a Roth" before it. I haven't seen details, but if it's modeled on a Roth, doesn't it seem likely that it would follow the same limited circumstances that investors currently have to withdraw from a Roth tax free? Even in the event they allow more freedom to withdraw tax free than a Roth (I'll need a link to believe it), it's THEIR money, is it not?


2. The only investment option available is in the gov't bond, which pays between 1-1.5%. Sure, they guarantee you will never lose value but that is in monetary terms. With inflation averaging 2.5-3% annually you're actually losing money.

It's proposed to be the only option right now. It appears to be set up to force a transfer to higher rates of return and higher risk once the amount reaches the $15k threshold or after 30 years. This is being modeled after the Federal Thrift Savings Plan which does offer a limited number of other options.

Over the past 10 years, there have been only two years (2012 and 2013) in which the G-fund has earned less than 2% interest. There have also been two years where it outperformed the TSP's S&P equivalent fund. During the best year of this G-fund over the past 10, the interest rate approached 5%. During the worst year for the stock market when many investors were losing large chunks of their portfolio, this G-fund was still earning 3.75% interest. I personally am grateful that I had moved 100% of my retirement funds to this one prior to the crash. I earned money while others were losing.

The G-fund appears to have outpaced inflation (link to historical inflation rates) in 2003 (the earliest date the TSP website provides), 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2009, 2010, and in 2013. It matched inflation in 2008. It was only outpaced by inflation in 2011 and 2012.

Investors who put their money in funds that mimicked the S&P 500 (I'm using the federal C-fund for comparison) saw their returns outpaced by inflation in 2008 and in 2011.

So you claimed that it would result in investors losing money due to being outpaced by inflation. Yet the truth is since 2003, it was outpaced by inflation in only two years. This is the same number of years that the S&P 500 fund was also outpaced by inflation.


3. Once the account reaches $15k it is required to be rolled out into a Roth IRA. Then what? You're going to have low-income households who have no concept of investing (if they did, they'd be saving and investing right now rather than being forced to save in this program) and making them responsible for handling the funds going forward.

Then what? The same thing that happens with every person who saves their own money until it reaches a sum of $15k - we use our experience gained over a lifetime of saving to either go it alone or involve financial planners. Being invested in our future is an investment in our education. We will have a new generation of investors now tasked with planning for their future who otherwise may not have ever been.

If this plan grows like it is reasonable to expect, it could easily have additional investment funds added as alternatives. Since Democrats have historically taught their base to fear Wall Street, the rules could also change to enable people to keep money in that fund.

Having low income earners achieving a day when they have $15k saved is a nice problem to have. By historical standards, it would be unprecedented. 

KWPlanner --- 12 years ago -

I have a lot of respect for what you do, but I'm going to challenge you on much of your reasoning.

Challenge away...lol! I welcome opposing views, unlike many others on here.

I have no doubt my opposing the MyRA (at least with the info I've seen so far) seems counter-intuitive to what it is I do.

Believe me, I am all for encouraging saving for retirement, but this program doesn't place enough restrictions to make it a true 'savings' plan.

One of the articles I read was set up as in a FAQ format, and one of the questions/points was "A MyRA will help me get started. I just don't have the discipline to keep my hands off the money without those IRA withdrawal penalties." The first response to this was "Then you're going to have a hard time building a MyRA balance." And that's probably my biggest complaint with this plan. If you want to force people to save - fine. But at least make it just as difficult to tap into the funds as traditional IRAs and Roths. According to preliminary details offered up by the White House, "contributions can be withdrawn tax-free at any time." And that takes me back to the first point I made in my earlier post, that this account is nothing more than a slush fund. It's been my experience that those who do not save are not saving because they have no concept of budgeting and planning for the future. Giving someone the ability to 'save for retirement' but giving them unlimited, tax/penalty-free access to the funds at any time seems backwards to me.

I'm sure I haven't touched on everything in your reply, but I'll be happy to expand if needed - just trying to watch the market and type a reply at the same time. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

Right. You're doing what you are good at - recommending investments for people with varying thresholds for risk. I agree that there are better choices for people committed to saving. But that's not a reason to oppose this as a government policy if the reason is to transform minds and habits into more responsible practices than what is currently taking place.

This plan targets a group of people whose status quo is to not save for their retirement. It's a group of people that can be nudged into learning how to save. Of course they'll withdraw money every now and then as the availability of their own money will be tempting. They'll need to experience that. America will be no worse off than we are now with this outcome.

They also have the option to opt out of this. Many will choose that option. America will be no worse off than we are now with this outcome.

But many will succeed in using this to save money. Many will benefit from this baby step into saving and investment without the financial risk of massive losses that the rest of us face in riskier investments with higher returns. America will be better off with this outcome.

It's easy to prefer other investment choices. That shouldn't be the reason to oppose this. In my opinion, being for or against this policy should be based on whether or not this is a good government policy as an alternative to the status quo.

There is no way Democrats would approve this plan if it were promoted by a Republican President. They would say that it was a step toward "privatizing social security" (and they would be right). Republicans would be saying that it helps provide long term financial security for taxpayer money by making retirement less of a burden on future taxpayers (and they would be right).

The only Republicans who will be opposing this are the ones committed to political hackery. Even the worst case scenario of this plan leads to some lower income earners being less of a burden on future taxpayers. The best case scenario is that more of them will be less of a future burden. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

What's stopping Congress from borrowing against this money, like they do with Social Security?

My understanding of short term Treasury securities are that they serve as a form of collateral on government debt.

As to the likely consequences of increasing the demand on short term Treasury securities, I'll leave that commentary to someone far smarter than I am....

....paging JTcitrus.. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground