Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

May she rest in peace

who's talking here?

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees 6
smartypants 2
Polly Ester 4
Perfection 3
AngieKaye 31
RiteWingKing 2
zapper007 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 3
JohnLynch 32
RedMulch 4
sweetscreaminmonkey 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 27
In AbsentiaW 3
Clovis 2
Dorothy Parker 24
Joe Blow 1
gunsnroses 1
SineadORebellion 2
LitlJay 1
atthebeach 3
TONISFRIEND 2
Nurse Ratched 2
JAMS 8
witchywoman 6
GeorgiaPeach 1
Ogre13 3
MissPris 4
Snake Plissken 3
schaghticoke 2
mutton 6
You can call me Michelle 21
KPHSSenior2014 5
Sweet Cherub 4
JustPeachy27 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

GeorgiaPeach --- 12 years ago -

A judge on Friday ordered a Texas hospital to remove life support for a pregnant, brain-dead woman whose family had argued that she would not want to be kept in that condition.

Judge R. H. Wallace Jr. issued the ruling in the case of Marlise Munoz. John Peter Smith Hospital in Fort Worth has been keeping Munoz on life support against her family's wishes. The judge gave the hospital until 5 p.m. CST Monday to remove life support.

Earlier this week, Erick Munoz's attorneys said that the fetus, now believed to be at about 22 weeks' gestation, is "distinctly abnormal." They attorneys said they based that statement on medical records they received from the hospital. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

sad day when a child dies...that judge will have to answer to God... 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

only 2 more weeks! Hope they left the baby monitor on so they could hear its last heart beat. HOpe that gives the father night terror for the rest of his life.

My husband said there would of been no way he could of done that, even if the child was to have abnormalities. 

You can call me Michelle --- 12 years ago -

What a tragedy 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

this will be over by Monday. There was not going to be a good ending here, I believe this was the right one even though it was the hardest one. 

atthebeach --- 12 years ago -

I am confused...she was without oxygen for about an hour...at least that is what they think. How could she be alive to begin with? I know she is brain dead but she was still alive enough to put on life support? 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

she was pregnant and in texas they have to keep life support for the baby unless a judge orders differently.

In our thoughts it all boils down to this father didn't want to raise a 2nd child, thinking since his wife didn't want life support for herself that meant she didn't want life support for the baby. NO MOM would do that!

If they had just waited 2 more weeks that baby could of been birthed. I have read several stories where moms die, baby stays on life support and survives! 

atthebeach --- 12 years ago -

So basically they took a dead person and put them on life support? 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

So basically they took a dead person and put them on life support? 


Yes because she still had a living life inside her womb, still had a heartbeat. 

KPHSSenior2014 --- 12 years ago -

They could not even determine gender !!!. This fetus is distinctively abnormal.. With Hydrocephuls (sp).

It is very sad.. It had no chance outside the womb. A lot of babies born to this are blind,deaf, have severe mental disabilities. 

gunsnroses --- 12 years ago -

The judge and husband made the right decision for the woman and the child. 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

They could not even determine gender !!!. This fetus is distinctively abnormal.. With Hydrocephuls (sp).



Per their attorney, no one ever heard from HER or the babies Doctors. You really trust an attorney??? 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

atthebeach --- 5 min ago - quote - hide comments

So basically they took a dead person and put them on life support?



Yes, and no AngieKaye that wasn't WHY she was originally put on life support.

The news story stated her husband found her and he started life support thinking he could save HER life - not knowing she was already dead at the time.

When it was determined she was indeed dead, he wanted (according to her verbal wishes) life support stopped.

However because her heart was beating and she was pregnant the hospital felt they had to continue it.

The court decision today is that it is brain death that determines if the law applies, not that her blood is flowing artificially.

She is dead, the baby is also dead and this is the right move. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -


Per their attorney, no one ever heard from HER or the babies Doctors. You really trust an attorney???



The hospital did not dispute the condition of the baby AngieKaye if it were alive and healthy they would have said that.

They did not dispute she was brain dead either.

The hospital wanted an out as well, they just needed the legal protection of the court ordering it. 

JAMS --- 12 years ago -

Absolutely the right move.

The hospital was wrong in this situation, and now hopefully her family can begin to grieve her death and allow her body to be treated with dignity. 

KPHSSenior2014 --- 12 years ago -

She was 14wks when all of this happened. They wanted to wait at least until she was 24 weeks to see if the fetus was viable.

No one knows how long she was deprived of oxygen, or the fetus. 

atthebeach --- 12 years ago -

I just don't understand how her heart was still beating if she had been without oxygen for an hour. Isn't that usually when people come in and a person feels cold to the touch and that is that? I just didn't think it was possible 

schaghticoke --- 12 years ago -

she was pregnant and in texas they have to keep life support for the baby unless a judge orders differently.

That isn't the way the law was written. The law says they can't deny life saving measures to a pregnant woman. It wasn't created with the intention of using a brain dead woman's body as an incubator. 

Sweet Cherub --- 12 years ago -

It wasn't created with the intention of using a brain dead woman's body as an incubator


O.K. For the sake of argument, lets say that is what they are doing. If she is 'DEAD' then her spirit is no longer here anyway. That being the case, what is the harm to the mother (who is already gone anyway) to use her body to keep HER OWN CHILD alive? A child she clearly wanted. That is what mothers bodies do, isn't it. We keep our babies alive, healthy, well nourished? Is this an awful tragedy, yes, of course. No one is denying that. But why make it 2 lives lost when it only has to be 1? If the father does not want this child because it may be born with special needs, then he can always put it up for adoption. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

So basically they took a dead person and put them on life support? 

nope...the BABY was on life support

It wasn't created with the intention of using a brain dead woman's body as an incubator. 

yea...like she was going to be using it for something else...

and it was the intent of the law to keep the baby alive


btw...this thread title of "May she rest in peace" is absolute nonsense

keeping the baby alive has NOTHING to do with the soul/spirit of the woman 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

If the father does not want this child because it may be born with special needs, then he can always put it up for adoption. 

oh...but that may cost the people "money"...can't have that...

but we can have lazy people on welfare all of their adult lives... 

schaghticoke --- 12 years ago -

and it was the intent of the law to keep the baby alive

The lawmakers who passed the law have even said it wasn't written to be used this way. It's so a hospital can't DENY life saving measures to a LIVING pregnant woman. It wasn't written to keep a DEAD woman on life support against her wishes. 

zapper007 --- 12 years ago -

but we can have lazy people on welfare all of their adult lives...

And KU posters repeating their version of gospel - as they understand it...

JL - is there any topic for which you are not an EXPERT??? 

Polly Ester --- 12 years ago -

That being the case, what is the harm to the mother (who is already gone anyway) to use her body to keep HER OWN CHILD alive? A child she clearly wanted. That is what mothers bodies do, isn't it. We keep our babies alive, healthy, well nourished?

In this case, the baby is not healthy. The baby most likely suffered brain death with her and is also being kept alive on the machine. I think most mother's would want their baby to have the same right that they have to not be kept alive artificially. 

TONISFRIEND --- 12 years ago -

Our Lord is waiting with open arms for them both. They will be fine. And we need to pray for her grieving family. 

Polly Ester --- 12 years ago -

Hope they left the baby monitor on so they could hear its last heart beat. HOpe that gives the father night terror for the rest of his life.


What an awful thing to wish upon this family. You have no idea how much they anguished and how much they have suffered. They have had to be scrutinized and judged throughout this whole awful ordeal. I can only wish them peace and I hope that they can now mourn their loss of in privacy. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

The lawmakers who passed the law have even said it wasn't written to be used this way.

source please...

the purpose of the law was to keep treating a mother SO THAT THE BABY WOULDN'T DIE

"The statute in question is contained right in the part of the Texas Code that permits people to create Living Wills, or as they are called in some states, Advance Medical Directives and is fairly short and straightforward, saying simply that “A person may not withdraw or withhold life-sustaining treatment under this subchapter from a pregnant patient.” There does not appear that there is any way under Texas law that a person drafting a Living Will can void this provision of the law. Additionally, it doesn’t appear that the law makes any distrinction regardng the condition of the patient, meaning that someone such as Mrs. Munoz, who is effectively dead for all intents and purposes, and there is also no distinction made between someone who is, say 8 1/2 months pregnant and someone who, like Munoz was when she was first taken to the hospital, is only 3 1/2 months pregnant, which is far outside any reasonable range of viability, and her current 5th month of pregnancy is, at the very least, at teh very outer edges of fetal viability. Indeed, under this law, it would appear that under this law, a woman who is a mere few weeks pregnant and reports to the Emergency Room in a condition that eventually evolves into brain death would be forcibly kept alive for the next 8-9 months regardless of what her wishes might be as expressed in an otherwise legal document, and despite the wishes of her closes family members." 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

In this case, the baby is not healthy.

that is their supposition...there have been many babies that were improperly diagnosed by doctors...as proven by them being born completely healthy


Our Lord is waiting with open arms for them both.

IF the woman was born again...she's already been there for weeks 

TONISFRIEND --- 12 years ago -

Did you read that the fetus was significantly deformed? 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 12 years ago -

My friend had a child with the same issues as this baby he is 7 and done more than Drs have thought..I'm upset at this decision..:( 

JAMS --- 12 years ago -

Angie, go sit in the corner.

Your wishes of more anguish upon the family is truly disgusting. You should be ashamed of yourself!!! 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Did you read that the fetus was significantly deformed?

so?...doctors aren't always right...AND a person's life isn't valued by whether they are deformed or not...every person has some kind of deformity... 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

You should be ashamed of yourself!!! 

you should be ashamed of yourself for being accepting of killing babies... 

JAMS --- 12 years ago -

JL, you are the biggest deformity of 'em all. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

JL, you are the biggest deformity of 'em all. 

maybe so...but at least i don't want unborn children to be murdered 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Hope they left the baby monitor on so they could hear its last heart beat. HOpe that gives the father night terror for the rest of his life.

Wow... nice and scummy of you. 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

Praise the court system! 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

The hospital was wrong in this situation

I don't think the hospital was wrong in this situation. I think the law was wrong in THIS situation (in others it may not be). And the hospital followed the law, which I've said elsewhere is overly broad. 

witchywoman --- 12 years ago -

The law needs to be changed. Obviously. Stupid laws made by stupid people.

Keep your religion out of my life. 

Clovis --- 12 years ago -

Keep your religion out of my life.

Without a doubt.

Shame on the State of Texas for over-riding a family's personal decision and causing additional, unimaginable agony for a family already suffering.

Wishing peace and comfort for the family. 

page 1 2 3 4 5 6
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground