Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Anyone knowledgable about mountain bikes? Specifically about frames.

who's talking here?

movedagain 1
Jpgirl 3
Cajun Gris Gris 4
AlphabetSoup 2
RW19 1
a2645039uu 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

AlphabetSoup --- 12 years ago -

I'm looking to get a new bike and have always had a men's frame. I recently discovered a women's frame fits me better with the shorter reach but I really, really just don't like the look of the traditional women's/step through frame with the dropped crossbar. Are there any (reasonably) priced women's mountain bikes with the diamond frame or even men's that have a smaller frame or shorter reach? 

movedagain --- 12 years ago -

Try REI, I got one there and it is nontraditional as far as most bike shops and I like it so much better. I have a smaller frame because I am tiny. They also will give your money back if you hate it or don't like it, no questions asked. 

Jpgirl --- 12 years ago -

You could talk to a bike dealer and see if they could order you a smaller men's bike. Most store carry just a few sizes because they have to pay for the stock when the receive shipment not when they sell the bike. Plus most shops are small and space limited.

Having said that- don't throw away the idea of a woman's frame. Talk to the shops- there maybe a diamond frame in a woman's bike. I have long legs and a long torso and ride the same frame size as my husband. BUT 3 years ago I wanted to upgrade to an all carbon road bike. Mike, the owner of the old bike shop Better Bikes ( dang I miss him!!) suggested I'd be happier with a women's fit. I had my doubts but ordered a Specialized Ruby. He was totally spot on- it fits me like a glove- the reach is much better and the chronic muscle strain in my trapezius disappeared. The frame is a traditional diamond shape. And best of all I improved my speed - the configuration of the slightly shorter crank combined with the carbon, meant more power to the pedals= increase in speed.
So look around at the shops- ask to look at the catalogs or go online and see if there's a diamond frame in a woman's fit. Have fun- I have not really delved into mountain biking- I have a need for speed without having to worry about roots, trees and ravines ;) 

Cajun Gris Gris --- 12 years ago -

K2 and Trek both make quality bikes is several versions depending on your planned usage that have higher cross members on the womens bikes compared to others you'd find in Wal-Mart, Target, and other high volume movers. Sports Authority used to carry a variation of mens & womens K2 bikes which are quality and reasonably priced. Check out their styles online. Trek goes up a little to the higher end, and from there you will probably want to shop online or go to a specialized bike shop if you want super light frames, carbon rims, front/back disc brakes, etc. 

a2645039uu --- 12 years ago -

"reasonably priced" is such an abstract description, it can not not be answered. Some people think that means a bike less than$200. Others can find a reasonable priced bike for $2,000.

What is your specific price point? What are you going to use the bike for?

When you say "woman's frame," are you referring to the traditional woman's frame with step-through design (inspired by the era of women wearing dresses)? Or are you talking about what some bike companies call a Women's Specific Design in which the difference is not so much in the frame as it is in the length of the crank arms and stem, the depth of the handlebars, the reach of the brakes and the saddle design, among other things.

Unlike another poster here (and on the other site) he never fails to turn her answers into what a spectacular athlete she is, I'd like to know your specific wants and needs before I could give you an informative answer. 

Jpgirl --- 12 years ago -

Guilty of being Spectacular- never Sharing my personal experiences- yes.

I apologize if my responses rile you. 

Cajun Gris Gris --- 12 years ago -

I thought the original question was pretty basic...She's looking for a particular style/design of a mountain bike that isn't rediculously priced.

$2,000 isn't reasonably priced unless you come across a $5,000 bike for only $2,000.

"Resonably priced" would fall between $250-$500, which is the norm for most bikes that aren't a POS and meet all of the basic requirements one would want in a bike. 

RW19 --- 12 years ago -

"Resonably priced" would fall between $250-$500, which is the norm for most bikes that aren't a POS and meet all of the basic requirements one would want in a bike.

This is how I read the OP too. 

a2645039uu --- 12 years ago -


I thought the original question was pretty basic...She's looking for a particular style/design of a mountain bike that isn't ridiculously priced.

$2,000 isn't reasonably priced unless you come across a $5,000 bike for only $2,000.

"Resonably priced" would fall between $250-$500, which is the norm for most bikes that aren't a POS and meet all of the basic requirements one would want in a bike


Your assertion is just silly. Unless you can read minds to know what the OP wanted to spend.

Some people would see a $250-500 bike as exhorbitantly priced. Others might indeed see it as "reasonable priced." Many people would never consider a bike that costs lest than $1,000 Thus, "reasonably priced" means different things to different people. The only way to know for sure is to determine a particular individual's price point. Regardless of what YOUR opinion or MY of what reasonably priced is.

Personally, a $250-$500 bike to me sellingis a total piece of junk barely worthy of child's play. 

Cajun Gris Gris --- 12 years ago -

Yes...I do read minds!

So, would my assertion that exhorbitantly correctly spelled is exorbitantly, or would that be silly as well?

Listen, the lady seemed to asking a pretty simple question, and it's probably just a figment of my imagination, but regardless of topic, there's always someone on KU trying to commandeer a thread with rhetorical BS comments in response to people who actually offer up comments relative to the subject.

A $250-$500 bike to a Big Baller like you might be Child's Play (Love that movie BTW!), but to someone else it may fit their needs easily and isn't a total POS as I mentioned previously. I didn't read the OP claim to be training for the X-Games with $5K burning a hole in her pocket. She's looking for a decent women's bike that doesn't have a low cross member frame. Yes, opposite of the era of women wearing dresses and peddling off to the seamstress shops in 1932... 

Jpgirl --- 12 years ago -

You go Gris Gris!! 

a2645039uu --- 12 years ago -


Yes...I do read minds!

So, would my assertion that exhorbitantly correctly spelled is exorbitantly, or would that be silly as well?

Listen, the lady seemed to asking a pretty simple question, and it's probably just a figment of my imagination, but regardless of topic, there's always someone on KU trying to commandeer a thread with rhetorical BS comments in response to people who actually offer up comments relative to the subject.

A $250-$500 bike to a Big Baller like you might be Child's Play (Love that movie BTW!), but to someone else it may fit their needs easily and isn't a total POS as I mentioned previously. I didn't read the OP claim to be trainng for the X-Games with $5K burning a hole in her pocket. She's looking for a decent women's bike that doesn't have a low cross member frame. Yes, opposite of the era of women wearing dresses and peddling off to the seamstress shops in 1932... 



Still avoiding the fact that you don't know how "reasonably priced" is defined to the original poster? You are only pointing out how "reasonably priced" is defined to you.

Ironically, while you were busy pointing out my spelling error, you incorrectly put a coma in place of a period. And in another sentence, you failed to use a coma after a subordinate clause. 

AlphabetSoup --- 12 years ago -

Yes 250-500 for price and it is the step through frame that I don't like. 

Cajun Gris Gris --- 12 years ago -

Is that crickets I hear?

,,,...,,,...,,,...,,,...,,,...,,, 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground