Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Benghazi Investigation

who's talking here?

smartypants 18
Donkey Hodie 1
SoupIsGoodFood 1
Blaze 7
AngieKaye 41
RiteWingKing 7
Agent of Change 2
Hiro Protagonist 2
AwesomeTattooedDragon 12
JohnLynch 4
Emperor of Kingwood 1
witchywoman 1
GeorgiaPeach 1
a889324uu 4
Snake Plissken 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

An in-depth New York Times investigation published Saturday sheds new light on questions surrounding the September 11, 2012, attack on the U.S. consulate in Benghazi, Libya, that left four Americans dead, including U.S. ambassador Chris Stevens. Questions surrounding the attack have become a major political flashpoint in Washington, but the report reveals a truth much murkier than either the Obama administration or its critics in the GOP-led Congress has grasped upon.

Here are five major revelations from the report:

Al Qaeda was not involved in the assault. It has become an article of faith for some in the GOP that the Benghazi attack was a highly orchestrated terrorist attack led by the same group that carried out the 9/11 attacks in the U.S. “It was very clear to the individuals on the ground that this was an Al Qaeda-led event,” said Michigan Republican Mike Rogers, chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, in an interview on Fox News in November. But according to the Times report, there is no evidence to support this assertion.
Anger at the “Innocence of Muslims” video motivated the initial assault and fueled the anger that powered the attack. After the film appeared online dubbed into Arabic in September 2012, media in Cairo played a major role in stoking the rage that led to an assault on the American embassy in Benghazi. Witnesses on the ground at the attack recount numerous ways in which leaders of the assault used the video to stoke the rage of militiamen.
The spontaneous response to the video stoked another attack that was already in the works, planned by smaller militia not affiliated with Al Qaeda. Evidence suggests that hardline elements within the complex web of Islamist militias operating in Benghazi, including an uneducated loner and contrarian named Ahmed Abu Khattala, had been planning an attack, though it’s unclear when they had intended to strike. The U.S. government has sought to have Khattala apprehended in order to press charges, but authorities and powerful Islamist elements in Libya have closed ranks around the hardliner.
American officials were overly reliant on moderate Islamist elements for protection. As the assault turned full fledged, officials called on the leaders of militias that had been publicly friendly to the U.S. to come to their aid. But when the time came, almost none turned up to rescue Americans trapped inside the compound. “Whatever happened, they were other Libyans,” said one Islamist leader who eventually did enter the compound after resisting at first.
Inside the compound, attackers looted and plundered wildly. Witnesses describe men taking out suits on hangers, televisions and found food. One man reportedly poured what appeared to be Hershey’s chocolate syrup into his mouth.


Read more: Benghazi: Al Qaeda Played No Role in the Attack, New York Times Report Says | TIME.com http://world.time.com/2013/12/28/5-takeaways-from-the-new-york-times-benghazi-investigation/#ixzz2otnsXfOl 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

1. Al Qaeda was not involved in the assault.

2. Anger at the “Innocence of Muslims” video motivated the initial assault and fueled the anger that powered the attack.

3. The spontaneous response to the video stoked another attack that was already in the works, planned by smaller militia not affiliated with Al Qaeda.


4. American officials were overly reliant on moderate Islamist elements for protection.

5. Inside the compound, attackers looted and plundered wildly. 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

its all bs all networks are calling the NYtimes liars 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

A top congressional Republican is saying a new report that concludes Al Qaeda did not carry out the 2012 attack on the U.S diplomatic compound in Benghazi, Libya, is “misleading.”

The new report published Saturday in the New York Times concludes that there was no evidence that Al Qaeda or other international terrorist groups had any role in the assault that killed four Americans on September 11, 2012, and that it appeared that the attack was fueled in large part by anger at an American-made anti-Islamic video, as the Obama administration first claimed.

New York Rep. Peter King, member and former chairman of the House’s Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence, told Fox News the argument that the most overtly anti-Western militia, Ansar al-Shariah – not Al Qaeda – led the attack is an academic argument over semantics, considering Ansar al-Shariah is widely believed to be an affiliate terror group of Al Qaeda.

“It’s misleading,” King said. “It’s a distinction without a difference.”

The claims by the New York Times also conflicts with other evidence, including the testimony of Greg Hicks, the deputy of Ambassador Christopher Stevens who was killed in the attack. Hicks described the video as "a non-event in Libya" at that time, and consequently not a significant trigger for the attack

It would also contradict a separate report by a leading social media firm that found that the first reference to the anti-Islam film that was initially blamed for sparking the attack was not detected on social media until a day later. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

all networks or Fox? this isn't a snarky response, it's an honest question- 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

My Take:

The United States took sides in a civil war. One side liked us and the other side didn't. So a local group planned an attack and events triggered the timing of the attack.

The country was in chaos and still is.

I think the GOP overstated that the Democrats were trying to hide that an Al Qaeda attack had occurred. This would refute the Obama claim that he was winning the war against Al Qaeda.

The British closed their consulate. Why didn't we close this meeting house?

If the Ambassador who died knew the security concerns why did he go to the location? He put himself and others at risk.

In the big scheme this as a small event. I feel bad about the ones that lost their lives. But Libya was freed with with very little cost to the USA and our allies. 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

all networks or Fox? this isn't a snarky response, it's an honest question- 


Well to answer this would take some real digging, as I just went to CNN.com and there is NOTHING not one thing on their front page which their should be. So you tell me, who tells us what we need to know? The ones that cover it up and hide it? Or the ones that wont let it die. 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

The 2012 terrorist attack in Benghazi, Libya was an "Al Qaeda-led event" according to multiple, on the record, interviews with the head of the House intelligence committee who receives regular classified briefings and has access to the raw intelligence to make independent assessments.

"I will tell you this, by witness testimony and a year and a half of interviewing everyone that was on the ground by the way, either by an FBI investigator or the committee: It was very clear to the individuals on the ground that this was an Al Qaeda-led event. And they had pretty fairly descriptive events early on that lead those folks on the ground, doing the fighting, to the conclusion that this was a pre-planned, organized terrorist event," Rep. Mike Rogers, R-Mich. told Fox News in a November interview.

"Not a video, that whole part was debunked time and time again," Rogers added of the attack which killed Ambassador Chris Stevens, Foreign Service officer Sean Smith and former Navy Seals Tyrone Woods and Glen Doherty, "which just leads to questions of why the administration hung with that narrative for so long when all the folks who participated on the ground saw something different."

Asked in November what might explain the initial narrative that an anti-Islam film triggered the attack, Rogers did not answer directly but said all evidence points to the State Department, whose leadership skirted the security requirements for the Benghazi mission. "We think we can fairly sense what was going on here and I will tell you, the answers, I think, are going to lie within the State Department and the decision-making in the State Department," he said. "Lots of questions to be answered there."

In the same interview, Rogers also suggested there were attempts to connect between the assailants and the Al Qaeda senior leadership in Pakistan. "I can tell you we know the participants of the event were clearly Al Qaeda affiliates, had strong interest and desire to communicate with Al Qaeda core and others, in the process -- we believe before and after the event."

While there was no immediate response from the White House, State Department, National Security Council or Rogers to a New York Times investigation that "turned up no evidence that Al Qaeda or other international terrorist groups had any role in the assault," the Republican congressman who leads the House intelligence committee has consistently maintained, in on the record interviews, that the attack was premeditated terrorism and not linked to the anti-Islam film initially blamed by the Obama White House.

One day after the assault, on September 12, 2012, Rogers was among the first on Capitol Hill to describe the strike as a pre-planned attack. "I have no doubt it was a coordinated, military style commando-type raid that had both direct fire and indirect fire, military movements involved in it. This was a well-planned, well targeted event. No doubt about it."

Separately, an intelligence source on the ground in Libya told Fox News on September 17, 2012, one day after Susan Rice's controversial claims on the Sunday talk shows that linked the attack to the video, that there was no demonstration outside the U.S. Consulate in Benghazi prior to the attack -- challenging the Obama administration's claims that the assault grew out of a "spontaneous" protest against the film.

"There was no protest and the attacks were not spontaneous," the source said, adding the attack "was planned and had nothing to do with the movie."

The source said the assault came with no warning at about 9:35 p.m. local time, and included fire from more than two locations. The assault included RPG's and mortar fire, the source said, and consisted of two waves.

In subsequent on the record interviews, as more has been learned about the attack, Rogers laid out a timeline which further supported the initial assessment of pre-meditated terrorism. "I believe that they had an operational phase that lasted at least a couple of weeks, maybe even longer," Rogers told Fox in an October 2013 interview. "Then an initiation phase that lasted a couple or three days prior to the event itself."

"It is accurate that of the group being targeted by the bureau (FBI) at this point, there’s strong Al Qaeda ties," Rogers said. "You can still be considered to have strong ties because you are in the ring of operations of Al Qaeda core. ... There are individuals that certainly fit that definition."

Separately, Fox News was first to report, based on sources familiar with the investigation who were not authorized to discuss the case with the media, that at least two of the key suspects in the Benghazi terror attack were at one point working with Al Qaeda senior leadership. Fox News was told that one suspect was believed to be a courier for the network, and the other a bodyguard in Afghanistan prior to the 2001 terror attacks.

The direct historic ties to Al Qaeda senior leadership appear to undercut early characterizations by the Obama administration that the attackers in Benghazi were isolated "extremists" with no organizational structure or affiliation. After the attack, Faraj al Chalabi -- believed to be a former bodyguard for the network -- traveled to Pakistan, where he was detained, returned to Libya and eventually released before the FBI was granted access.

A former Guantanamo detainee, Sufian bin Qumu, who is suspected of training some of the operatives who took part in the assault, was in Benghazi on September 11, 2012, according to a knowledgeable source. Fox News was told last fall that the intelligence community was trying to determine whether he played any role directing the attack and whether he was physically on or near the consulate grounds.

While the New York Times investigation puts significant weight behind the video explanation, an independent analysis of social media traffic in Benghazi found that the first reference to the anti-Islam film was not detected until a day after the assault. The independent review of more than 4,000 postings was conducted by a leading social media monitoring firm in December 2012.

"From the data we have, it’s hard for us to reach the conclusion that the consulate attack was motivated by the movie. Nothing in the immediate picture – surrounding the attack in Libya -- suggests that,” Jeff Chapman, chief executive with Agincourt Solutions told Fox News three months after the assault.

Chapman said his analysts reviewed postings in Libya, including those from Benghazi, over a three-day period beginning on September 11. After identifying a geographic area and isolating a time frame, analysts "vacuumed" up the social media postings, which were then analyzed and translated.

"We have seen no traffic in Benghazi – in the immediate lead up to the attack - related to the anti-Islam film," Chapman said. "There is a single source reporting on the evening of 9/11 that roads leading to the U.S. consulate in Benghazi were blocked. We also believe we have identified at least one individual who may have been involved - based on our analysis - that he posted a picture of himself attacking the consulate with an RPG."

The first reference to the anti-Islam film, initially blamed by the Obama administration for provoking the violent attack in Benghazi, appears to be a retweet of a Russia Today story that was not posted until Sept. 12 at 9:12 a.m. local time. The translation reads, "U.S. ambassador killed in Libya during his his country's consulate in Benghazi - Russia today http://t.co/SvAV0o7T response to the film abuser."

While the New York Times investigation found "Benghazi was not infiltrated by Al Qaeda, but nonetheless contained grave local threats to American interests" a State Department classified cable directly conflicts with the claim. A review of an August 2012 classified cable, by Fox News, shows Al Qaeda was active in Benghazi and the fact was known to the CIA and the State department on the ground.

The U.S. Mission in Benghazi convened an "emergency meeting" less than a month before the assault that concluded Al Qaeda had training camps in Benghazi and the consulate could not defend against a "coordinated attack."

The authenticity of the classified cable, addressed to the office of then Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, has never been challenged. And while then Defense Secretary Leon Panettta, and the chairman of the joint chiefs, Martin Dempsey told lawmakers during congressional hearings on Benghazi that they were briefed on the cable, Mrs. Clinton claimed it was not brought to her attention.

The cable marked "SECRET" summarized an August 15, 2012 emergency meeting convened by the U.S. Mission in Benghazi. It states that the State Department’s senior security officer, also known as the RSO, did not believe the consulate could be protected.

"RSO (Regional Security Officer) expressed concerns with the ability to defend Post in the event of a coordinated attack due to limited manpower, security measures, weapons capabilities, host nation support, and the overall size of the compound," the cable said.

According to a review of the cable, the Emergency Action Committee was also briefed "on the location of approximately ten Islamist militias and AQ training camps within Benghazi … these groups ran the spectrum from Islamist militias, such as the QRF Brigade and Ansar al-Sharia, to 'Takfirist thugs.'" Each U.S. mission has a so-called Emergency Action Committee that is responsible for security measures and emergency planning.

In addition to describing the security situation in Benghazi as "trending negatively," the cable said explicitly that the mission would ask for more help. "In light of the uncertain security environment, US Mission Benghazi will submit specific requests to US Embassy Tripoli for additional physical security upgrades and staffing needs by separate cover." The details in the cable seemed to foreshadow the deadly September 11 attack on the U.S. compound.

While the administration’s public statements have suggested that the attack came without warning, the August 16 cable undercuts those claims. It was a direct warning to the State Department that the Benghazi consulate was vulnerable to attack, that it could not be defended and that the presence of anti-U.S. militias and Al Qaeda was well-known to the U.S. intelligence community.

The New York Times investigation also makes passing reference to the second wave of the attack on the CIA base, which included mortar fire, as "improvised that night." The second wave of the assault killed former Navy Seals Tyrone Woods and Glen Doherty who were defending the CIA annex from its roof top.

CIA personnel who testified on Capitol Hill in early December provided first hand accounts of the attack's premeditation, according to the Republican lawmaker who is leading the subcommittee investigation.

Rep. Lynn Westmoreland, R-Ga., told Fox News in an on the record interview, after the closed, classified session that all of the witnesses (eight total witnesses have now testified) were on the same page about the nature of the mortar attack.

"These were trained people and ... it was an attack. It wasn't over any type of film or propaganda," Westmoreland emphasized, referring to the administration's initial claims that an anti-Islam film triggered protests that led to the attack. "We don't know why the administration would have ever thought any differently," Westmoreland said. "Other than that them and the State Department were trying to make sure that they were covered because of the unpreparedness they were in."

The witnesses also testified that the mortar fire was accurate, professional and likely the work of a trained mortar team which they believed included a spotter. Sources familiar with the testimony said the first mortar was about 25 meters short of the target, the second was closer and the next three were direct hits.

This is consistent with previous testimony that five mortars were fired in quick succession;previous witnesses testified those mortars were fired in under a minute. The New York Times investigation describes "people lingering in a nearby pasture, stirring fears that they were plotting coordinates for launching a mortar attack."

When the CIA personnel were asked for their reaction to the administration's initial explanation that an anti-Islam video and a demonstration gone awry were to blame for the attack, Fox News is told they were seething with anger because everything on the ground -- from their perspective -- showed it was a premeditated attack.

Some counterterrorism analysts concur with the assessment, describing the mortars used to strike the CIA annex in the second wave of the attack as potentially "smoking gun" evidence -- as mortars require skill and training to fire, and typically must be pre-positioned during daylight hours to ensure accuracy. If the mortar attack in the early morning hours of September 12th was spontaneous, the plates would have been set without a direct line of sight to the target because of the night sky; a scenario described as unlikely by military sources who have worked with mortars.

The opposing analysis is that the mortars were successfully set, and the assailants did not bring significant equipment with them to suggest pre-planning. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

CNN is my go to for info- it depends on whether the NY Times story is true- they aren't known for being a liberal newspaper- 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

If the Ambassador who died knew the security concerns why did he go to the location? He put himself and others at risk.


You tell me? Billary sent him there also knowing he was gay. That country murders gays. Story tells he was raped and tortured for hours before death. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

Hillary was close friends with him- she would never have sent him to be killed! did Fox say she did? 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

CNN is my go to for info-


Then you can't compare if you only rely on one source. If you watch more than one and start seeing others response. Its like playing "grapevine game" you cant always go with one source you have to listen to all to get the whole picture. 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

this is off CNN after some digging.

Rep. Darrell Issa, chairman of the House oversight committee, has been a leading voice in the Congressional Republican-led charge against the administration over the Benghazi attack, especially over the initial statements.

"The American people were effectively lied to for a period of about a month," he said in May on "Meet the Press." "This was a terrorist attack from the get-go. It was never about a video."

Asked Sunday if he was wrong about the video, Issa said the public was still "effectively lied to." He pointed to Kirkpatrick's remarks that the administration's characterization of the attack as a spontaneous protest triggered by the video was still inaccurate.

"The statements made by Ambassador Susan Rice were not true then and they are not true now," he told reporters Sunday morning after appearing on "Meet the Press.
 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

Al Qaeda-led event (used in the broad sense. Really calling it a terrorist event)

Issa on meet the press basically uses Al Qaeda/terrorism as a synonym.

That is misleading. 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

"It was never about a video." That not what time reports.

Also Rice stated this is the best information at this time. 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

Hillary was close friends with him- she would never have sent him to be killed! did Fox say she did? 


No the facts did. As I said he was gay, she sent him to a country that doesn't accept nor tolerate gays. 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

"It was never about a video." That not what time reports.


Ok read Russian news or other countries news and see what they are saying about us? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I read it in it's entirety, and it said it was a combination of many factors- the only people emphatic in their beliefs that it was an entire lie were pubs- you can't possibly believe that Hillary set this up to get her very good friend, the Ambassador, killed! 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

her very good friend


And how do you know he was her "friend"? Because she said so? Did Chris state this? Do we have proof? Have you seen him in Christmas card pictures? NO the only thing that linked them was the fact she was his boss and he was a democrat. 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

As I said he was gay, she sent him to a country that doesn't accept nor tolerate gays.

Hillary must really hate gays. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

it was well known that they were friends for a long time- I wish you'd question fox to the extent you question any democrat- 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

Hillary must really hate gays. 


Then she hates herself. 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

Russian news

Russia has a free press. Oh.. They just let them out of the Gulag for the Olympics. 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

it was well known that they were friends for a long time- I wish you'd question fox to the extent you question any democrat- 


I do NOT rely on ONE source of news. I read all. I am not saying Fox said anything you did. But that said.. fox has become the #1 now in news. Looks like many on the "left" are going "right" 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

this is getting in to the realm of ridiculous- 

Agent of Change --- 12 years ago -

Hillary is gay??? Who knew..... 

a889324uu --- 12 years ago -

This thread is gay. And stupid.

But let's consider the source. 

Snake Plissken --- 12 years ago -

The real question is why does the Nyt feel it necessary to defend Obama? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I don't think they were defending anyone, just reporting what they determined to be a news story- 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

Hillary is gay??? Who knew...


You dont follow politics too much do ya? Guess you didnt' know she was the president of the lesbian group in college? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

source please- 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

oh and this just in and NO I didn't get it off Fox news! :/

has the possibility of impeachment scared the DNC??

DNC sends email defending Obama from impeachment possibility

The Democratic National Committee (DNC) sent out a paranoid email Saturday evening urging supporters to vote for Democrats so that Republicans can’t impeach President Obama.

The email, subject line “Impeachment,” was sent to Obama for America supporters, imploring them to contribute to the DNC’s 2014 efforts. “What do these people all have in common?,” the email asked, featuring quotes from Republican Sen. James Inhofe of Oklahoma, Rep. Michele Bachmann of Minnesota, Rep. Kerry Bentivolio of Michigan, and Rep. Blake Farenthold of Texas discussing the possibility of impeaching Obama for one of his numerous instances of presidential misconduct.

The DNC email discussed the “I-Word” and said that “Republicans are actually excited about the idea.”

“Show these Republicans that they are way, way off-base, and give President Obama a Congress that has his back,” according to the DNC email, noting that Democrats need to win 17 GOP House seats to reclaim a majority.

The DNC, which recently expanded its political tactics to include boycotting independent news outlets, previously supported the last president to be impeached: Bill Clinton.

Obama’s staff changed key talking points on the 2012 Benghazi terrorist attack; his Internal Revenue Service targeted conservative groups during the 2012 election cycle; and Obama personally lied to the American people when he told them that they could keep their existing doctors and health insurance plans under Obamacare.

Obama’s expansion of executive branch authority is “setting the stage for something very dangerous in the future” according to Republican Rep. Justin Amash.



Read more: http://dailycaller.com/2013/12/28/dnc-sends-email-defending-obama-from-impeachment-possibility/#ixzz2ouIzJJ4w 

Snake Plissken --- 12 years ago -

source please-


Hillary went to Wellesley. 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

For TD 

a889324uu --- 12 years ago -

DTD, Angie has no legitimate source to provide.

Ridiculous. 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

and google Hillary Lesbian and you will come up with LOTS of sources yourself. 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

DTD, Angie has no legitimate source to provide.

Ridiculous. 



think again. I can type in google search just as you can. I dont rely on KU for my news. I also dont rely on others to tell me wht is happening. I love my country so therefore I keep up with the ones that are trying to destroy her! 

a889324uu --- 12 years ago -

LMAO @ American Family Association.

Your source is a listed hate group.
Since its on the Internet though, it must be true. 

a889324uu --- 12 years ago -

Who is trying to destroy your country?

Lesbians? 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground