Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Good Poor, Bad Poor

who's talking here?

SoupIsGoodFood 25
SleightOfHand 1
RiteWingKing 12
Laurabeth 2
Hiro Protagonist 2
voice of reason 3
JohnLynch 1
I_won't_tell 6
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
Clovis 7
Dorothy Parker 8
WatchOut 2
Winning 1
sheddy 6
JAMS 2
Emperor of Kingwood 6
witchywoman 2
Gigolo Bloodline 1
schaghticoke 1
forevermt 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Clovis --- 12 years ago -

"...As the year ends, this argument is playing out in two of the most meanspirited actions left on the table by the least-productive Congress in modern history. The House, refuge of the shrunken-heart caucus, has passed a measure to eliminate food aid for four million Americans, starting next year. Many who would remain on the old food stamp program may have to pass a drug test to get their groceries. At the same time, Congress has let unemployment benefits expire for 1.3 million people, beginning just a few days after Christmas.

These actions have nothing to do with bringing federal spending into line, and everything to do with a view that poor people are morally inferior. Here is a sample of this line of thought:

"The explosion of food stamps in this country is not just a fiscal issue for me," said Representative Steve Southerland, Republican from Florida, chief crusader for cutting assistance to the poor. "This is a defining moral issue of our time."

It would be a disservice to further extend unemployment assistance to those who have been out of work for some time, said Senator Rand Paul, Republican of Kentucky. It encourages them to sit at home and do nothing.

No doubt, poor people drink beer, watch too much television and have bad morals. But so do rich people. If you drug-tested members of Congress as a condition of their getting federal paychecks, you would have most likely caught Representative Trey Radel, Republican of Florida, who recently pleaded guilty to possession of cocaine. Would it be Grinch-like of me to point out that this same congressman voted for the bill that would force many hungry people to pee in a cup and pass a drug test before getting food? Should I also mention that the median net worth for new members of the current Congress is exactly $1 million more than that of the typical American household, and that that may influence their view?

For the record, the baseline benefit for those getting help under the old food stamp program works out to $1.40 a meal. And the average check for those on emergency unemployment is $300 a week. If you cut them off cold, the argument goes, these desperate folks would soon find a job and put real food on the table. They are poor because they are weak.

I met a wheat farmer not long ago in Montana whose family operation was getting nearly $300,000 a year in federal subsidies. With his crop in, this wealthy farmer was looking forward to spending a month in Hawaii. No one suggested that he pass a drug test to continue receiving his sizable handout, or that he be cut off cold, and encouraged to grow something that taxpayers wouldn't have to subsidize.

One person deserves the handout, the other does not. But these distinctions are colored by your circumstances and where you stand depends on where you sit.

When a million Irish died during the Great Famine of the 1850s, many in the English aristocracy said the peasants deserved to starve because their families were too big and indolent. The British baronet overseeing food relief felt that the famine was God's judgment, and an excellent way to get rid of surplus population. His argument on relief was the same one used by Rand Paul.

'The only way to prevent the people from becoming habitually dependent on government is to bring the operation to a close," Sir Charles Trevelyan said about the relief plan at a time when thousands of Irish a day were dropping dead from hunger...

...And in that, he echoed my mother at Christmas. Luck is the residue of design, as the saying has it. But the most careful lives can be derailed - by cancer, a huge medical bill, a freak slap of weather, a massive failure of the potato crop. Virtue cannot prevent a 'bad hand' from being dealt. And making the poor out to be lazy, or dependent, or stupid, does not make them less poor. It only makes the person saying such a thing feel superior."

full article:
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/20/opinion/egan-good-poor-bad-poor.html?_r=2&adxnnl=1&adxnnlx=1388084591-YosYdJksmmwq237qa1br7g 

Gigolo Bloodline --- 12 years ago -

It's poor hating the poor in the case of the KU crowd.
They all "home office" if they work at all. LOL
No executive or manager or anyone making serious money does that. Just folks struggling and seething with anger at "those" people getting a buck forty per meal.

Love it. 

sheddy --- 12 years ago -

For everyone who truly needs help there are people abusing the system. How do you figure out who is being honest? I think the solution would be to let them have so many years to work themselves into independence. If the time is up and they've done nothing to improve their lot in life, CUT them off. 

JAMS --- 12 years ago -

What about those that are physically or mentally incapable of "improving their lot in life?"

What about the elderly or children? What about veterans?

Are you suggesting to just cut everyone off, based on a timeline you deem acceptable? 

sheddy --- 12 years ago -

If you'll retread my post I was talking about abusers. There are people who need or have earned their assistance. There are too many who abuse the system because it is so easy. 

SleightOfHand --- 12 years ago -

wow, what a moron to compare people living off unemployment for over 99 weeks to a famine in the 1850s 

Clovis --- 12 years ago -

wow, what a moron to compare people living off unemployment for over 99 weeks to a famine in the 1850s

It's comparing the masochistic and hateful attitude toward poor people. Basically, let them die.

Same AynRandian attitude that we have today, promoted by the extreme right. Gotta be hatin' on poor folks because "they made bad decisions." 

JAMS --- 12 years ago -

sheddy, what criteria would you use to define abuser?
How do you determine that? 

I_won't_tell --- 12 years ago -

I work to pay my way
and you work to pay your way.

Why do some folks consider
not wanting to pay for others
is hating anyone? 

Clovis --- 12 years ago -

I work to pay my way
and you work to pay your way.


This attitude is the problem.

Some of you just don't understand that people are different. We all are born different, we all grow up different, have different experiences, different opportunities, etc.

We also have different tragedies, illnesses and set-backs.

Good for you that you can take care of yourself, and in a perfect world, everyone would be able to, but this world and human life are not perfect, this "I can do it and so can everyone else" is a simplistic way to right off folks who need help. That meme doesn't work in real life. To childishly write off poor folks who are struggling, like taking away their $1.40 a day food stamps, is hateful and a sick way to feel superior over others.

I'm glad the Pope has been talking about this. 

forevermt --- 12 years ago -

I work to pay my way
and you work to pay your way.


Awwww, the Rand Paul way. 

Clovis --- 12 years ago -

Yup. Think only about yourself. She gave her followers permission to be selfish.

Too bad she didn't understand that we are all connected and dependent upon one another. Just a childish version of life. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Food stamp use among military families is at about $100 million a year.

This past week. Obama gave the military a measly 1% pay raise. This was about half of what they have been receiving (1.8%) annually.

What does this say about Obama and his disdain for the troops? Chances are, food aid to military families will increase.

Why couldn't he give them the 1.8% they had been receiving before? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Under Obama, food aid/stamp use has SKYROCKETED.

He is truly the FOOD STAMP PRESIDENT. 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

This past week. Obama gave the military a measly 1% pay raise. This was about half of what they have been receiving (1.8%) annually.

Hmmm. I thought the House controls the purse strings. Who controls the house? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Hmmm. I thought the House controls the purse strings. Who controls the house?

You crack me up. Obama doesn't need approval from anyone.

It was an executive order.

Obama reduces troop pay increase 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

I just go back to a report I saw on South Africa. The 10% minority owns most of the wealth in the country. So the 90% majority live in tin shacks. The 10% minority has walls and fences. Training sessions for protecting "their" property.

Do you really want to live this way?

I would rather see a human being be given the opportunity to succeed. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Cue the blame game in.......3......2.....1 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

I would rather see a human being be given the opportunity to succeed.

So would I. This isn't South Africa, though. Everyone has the opportunity to succeed here. Problem is...... some don't put forth the effort. They expect it to be handed to them. 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

It was an executive order.

Your right. I thought we need to reduce the deficit. 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

Everyone has the opportunity to succeed here.

Really.

One in five American children is now living in poverty, giving the United States the highest child poverty rate of any developed nation except for Romania. 

I_won't_tell --- 12 years ago -

Clovis - the problem is - them not doing what is required to take care of themselves.

I guess it is much easier for them to let others do the work/make the sacrifices/make the investment/.....

I could have made choices so that I could not take of myself/my family.
My parents could have made choices so that they could not take of our family.
Their parents could have made choices so that they could not take of their family.

I didn't and thankfully they didn't.

Governments can't make things fair.
Government intervention is unfair.

Some will find something to be "fair" or acceptable
only as long as it is unfair against the other guy and not them.

Taxing "GROUP B" more than "GROUP A" is unfair.
Giving "GROUP A" what the government took from "GROUP B" is unfair.
Taxing "everyone" at x% would be fair.
I think liberals don't want things to be fair.

Some of the variables that make a difference between surviving and thriving can include:
intellect/work ethic/investment/sacrifice/chance/decisions or choices

You are right - we are not all the same.

Some make great decisions
Some make poor choices
Some make sacrifices
Some squander opportunities
Some make investments
Some work hard
Some are lazy
Some work smarter
Some are smarter
Some are faster
Some are slower
Some are taller
some are shorter
Some are luckier
. . . . .

Some things are controllable and some are not within our control.
I was lucky enough to be born in the U.S to 2 great supporting parents who are now fantastic grand parents.

I should not be MADE to pay for others. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

One in five American children is now living in poverty, giving the United States the highest child poverty rate of any developed nation except for Romania.

It's amazing what 5 years of an Obama presidency will do. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Some will find something to be "fair" or acceptable
only as long as it is unfair against the other guy and not them.


This is how liberals live.

It's all okey-dokey as long as it's not their ox getting gored. 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

It's amazing what 5 years of an Obama presidency will do.

Can you say credit default swap. 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

Governments can't make things fair.
Government intervention is unfair.



So you must believe that capitalism fairly distributes wealth throughout our society. 

witchywoman --- 12 years ago -

Cue the blame game in.......3......2.....1



You mean like this:

Soup for Santa --- 52 min ago - quote - hide comments
Food stamp use among military families is at about $100 million a year.

This past week. Obama gave the military a measly 1% pay raise. This was about half of what they have been receiving (1.8%) annually.

What does this say about Obama and his disdain for the troops? Chances are, food aid to military families will increase.

Why couldn't he give them the 1.8% they had been receiving before?


Soup for Santa --- 50 min ago - quote - hide comments
Under Obama, food aid/stamp use has SKYROCKETED.

He is truly the FOOD STAMP PRESIDENT.


Soup for Santa --- 45 min ago - quote - hide comments
Hmmm. I thought the House controls the purse strings. Who controls the house?

You crack me up. Obama doesn't need approval from anyone.

It was an executive order.

Obama reduces troop pay increase



Soup for Santa --- 13 min ago - quote - hide comments
One in five American children is now living in poverty, giving the United States the highest child poverty rate of any developed nation except for Romania.

It's amazing what 5 years of an Obama presidency will do.


Soup for Santa --- 12 min ago - quote - hide comments
Some will find something to be "fair" or acceptable
only as long as it is unfair against the other guy and not them.

This is how liberals live.

It's all okey-dokey as long as it's not their ox getting gored.




All blame, no solution. 

I_won't_tell --- 12 years ago -

"So you must believe that capitalism fairly distributes wealth throughout our society."

Nope - the WAY TOO BIG government is in the way!

BTW: Fairly is a great concept.

Great contribution deserves great compensation.

Zero contribution deserves zero compensation. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Can you say credit default swap.

Can you say community reinvestment act? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

All blame, no solution.

All whine......... no cheese. 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

Can you say community reinvestment act?

So that act forced Bear Sterns and Lehman Brothers to give loans to low life poor people and that caused them to go bankrupt? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Exactly. The govt forced them to make loans to people they normally wouldn't. Barney said everything was fine with Fannie and Freddy. Was he lying? 

forevermt --- 12 years ago -

This past week. Obama gave the military a measly 1% pay raise. This was about half of what they have been receiving (1.8%) annually.



This week the Paul Ryan budget just cut military retiree benefits. Should we be blaming that on Obama too? 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

Exactly. The govt forced them to make loans to people they normally wouldn't.

No...Incorrect.

The CRA only deals with depository institutions. Lehman and Sterns were not depository institutions. They were investment banks. They did not have to comply nor did they.

Actually I have had comply with this act in my career. You know what. I actually have read it. 

I_won't_tell --- 12 years ago -

0

No business that made bad decisions
should have been bailed out.


Strong get stronger

Survival of the fittest

Natural selection 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

The stupid keep voting Democrat. 

sheddy --- 12 years ago -

People at the bottom make choices that keep them there. I have said this many times, I can't count all the first generation friends my daughter has. Parents came here without much and in a generation their children are doctors, lawyers, engineers, etc. these kids aren't smarter, but they worked harder. I honestly believe that in America anything is possible and anyone here can achieve the American dream with hard work. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

I find the "natural selection" attitude to be really disgusting.

I don't want to live in a 3rd world nation with poor people dying from starvation and disease. I don't understand the anger and animosity toward poor people. Especially when the complaining is being done by people who live in an affluent community.

I don't understand resenting someone less fortunate than myself. I don't begrudge people food and shelter....especially people with innocent children. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Oh the drama, Dorothy!

No one here "hates" the poor.

How do you help the poor? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

 I don't begrudge people food and shelter....especially people with innocent children. 

How many do you or any of us have living in our homes? 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground