Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

who's talking here?

Mabel 4
*Annie* 1
ladybeachbum 1
MiaBella Farm 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
In AbsentiaW 1
sheddy 1
Ender 1
witchywoman 1
You can call me Michelle 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Mabel --- 12 years ago -

So my MIL bought a really nice piano from my Mother about a year before I lost my Mom. Roll ahead about 2 years and my MIL became ill and needed to move in with one of her children. She only has one daughter and the daughter is the only one of her kids that lives close enough for my MIL to continue going to the church she has been attending for well over 30 years. So when it came time for her to move in with my SIL, my MIL decided to go ahead and give all her children one very nice item. She give the piano to one of the DIL's because she was the only one who can play it. My DH and I received a really nice grandfather clock. I wanted the piano but understood why she give it to my SIL and we LOVE the clock she give to us.

So tonight I read on FB that my SIL sold the piano. She did however sale it to my niece on my side of the family. My Mothers granddaughter. I'm not sure how I am suppose to feel about it all. First and for most I cant believe she would sale something her MIL had given to her, and than not to offer it to one of the other children in my DH's family first.
Yes I am grateful it is still in my family. But how do you start selling stuff your MIL wanted you to have and there is nothing more for that SD & SIL to get, so they now have nothing but memories. I know memories are the most important thing, I guess I am just more sentimental about things like this.

How would you feel about it? Am I just feeling the loss of my Mother more with the Holidays upon us and thats why it bothers me so much? 

witchywoman --- 12 years ago -

I think you wanted her to see if you wanted to buy it first.

It was hers to sell though....unfortunately....although it would've been nice for her to give you first right of refusal. 

You can call me Michelle --- 12 years ago -

I'm the same way with my Mom's things. She has also passed away and I can really relate to your post. People just don't understand. They are probably completely unaware that what they have done is hurting you. You could tell them of course, if you are willing to buy the piano. If I had the money and were you I probably would try to buy it for the sentimental aspects of it. You could always learn to play a simple tune. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

Yep I totally get it and you have a right to be hurt. I don't think you should try to buy it now that your niece has it but I would let her know that if she ever decides to get rid of it to PLEASE let you know because you would want it because it means a lot to you. The SIL is an arse. Not because she sold the piano her MIL gave her but because she didn't ask you about it first knowing it was your mothers. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

I think you have the right to be angry. We had a similar situation with one of our family heirlooms, but instead of being sold we had to watch it get destroyed by one of my trashy siblings..

I feel your pain, but I was kind of in the same boat: Once it was given to someone else, It is hard to have any real influence over it..

Sorry for your loss. Do not be shy about letting them know how you feel, they need to know what they did was not right. It made me feel better letting my sister know what she had done. 

MiaBella Farm --- 12 years ago -

Maybe you should offer to buy it from the family member that now has it, or at least have a sit down chat with her about the history of the piano and tell her that if she ever plans on getting rid of it, to let you know first.

Open and honest communication works sometimes. At least she will know how you feel about it. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

I wouldn't say too much to your niece about it. Its not her fault and you don't want to make her her weird about having it. 

*Annie* --- 12 years ago -

I don't think you should try to buy it now that your niece has it but I would let her know that if she ever decides to get rid of it to PLEASE let you know because you would want it because it means a lot to you.


That is exactly my thought. 

Mabel --- 12 years ago -

I think you wanted her to see if you wanted to buy it first.

It was hers to sell though....unfortunately....although it would've been nice for her to give you first right of refusal. 


I think you miss understand. My MIL bought it, give it to the SIL and the SIL give it ways. 

In AbsentiaW --- 12 years ago -

My parens both agreed that we shouldn't worry about any physical belongings that would be passed on to us.

As my mother so wisely said, "Every thing we own and cherish will eventually end up with someone else. We just have to enjoy and appreciate it while are still on this earth!"

Ever been to an estate sale? Fun but at the same time sad to see other's pride possessions go to someone else.

Don't let a material item cause stress and problems within your family. 

ladybeachbum --- 12 years ago -

In almost every family there is something like this. My sister took a antique clock my Dad and I had bought at an auction because her husband wanted it. I didn't say anthing except for how it was obtained but silently steamed. My sister is far more precious to me than any clock but watching her kids break it was hard. I did know that I had other things, but I really would have liked having that clock. This has been many many years ago and I still cherish my sister in my life more than I would seeing the clock on my mantel.
I would just let the niece know if she ever decides she doesn't want it, you would like to have it. I may even do the same and tell my sister if anything happens to her, I would like the clock for a few years before passing it back to one of her boys. 

Mabel --- 12 years ago -

Problem solved. My SIL that is my MIL's only daughter also seen the post on FB. My MIL was very upset and called my niece ask told her she had given it to her DIL because the SIL had ask for it. Come to find find out the SIL give it to my sister and in turn my sister has it at her DD house because my sister had no place to put it. After my SIL seen the post on FB and made my MIL aware of what had happened. My MIL was upset about the whole deal and called MY sister and ask if she could have it back. My sister ask her if she was going to keep it or give it to someone else. My MIL will keep it, she didn't really give it away but the SIL had ask her for it. My MIL bought it because she wanted to learn how to play it. So it will go to where my MIL now lives and maybe she will be able to learn how to play it. 

sheddy --- 12 years ago -

To be honest, your mother sold the piano. I am sure that the other side of the family figures if any of you wanted it in the first place, you would have bought it from your mother. I can't believe someone would get so upset over someone getting rid of something that they evidently didn't want two years ago. 

Mabel --- 12 years ago -

Mu mother in law bought it from my own Mother, so she could learn to play it. My own mother passed away two years ago this past June. My sister inlaw on my husbands side ask my MIL for it. MY MIL became ill and couldnt learn to play it, so she give it to my SIL when my MIL was forced to move into the house with her only Daughter. My MIL give each of her children one really nice item. Like I already said my DH and I got a grandfather clock. The oldest brother and his wife got the piano because that is what they had ask for. Now almost a year down the road, my MIL is back to her old self and can do whatever you would like to do. I just felt like the son & DIL should have asked my MIL if she would like to have the piano back before giving it to anyone. I dont care that my sister or my niece had it. I just could not believe someone could give the only thing that they have from a loved one. I also understand my MIL give it to the SIL, just felt she should have asked my MIL if she would like to have it back. Guess I am just more sentimental about things than most. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground