Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Warning Re: Plan B

who's talking here?

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees 1
Polly Ester 3
SleightOfHand 1
Agent of Change 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 19
JohnLynch 19
tinman 5
It is I WhyWhyWhy 16
Dorothy Parker 2
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
FabFive 4
a672999uu 8
Ender 19
JAMS 4
Emperor of Kingwood 3
Biggun 14
You can call me Michelle 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Agent of Change --- 12 years ago -

Plan B, the popular brand of emergency contraception that is now available to all U.S. women over the counter, may not work as well for heavier women. As Mother Jones reports, a European company that manufactures an identical morning after pill has added a warning label to its product noting that it begins losing its effectiveness for women over 165 pounds, and may be totally ineffective for women over 176 pounds.

The European drug, Norlevo, uses a compound called levonorgestrel to prevent pregnancy up to 48 hours after sexual intercourse. That’s the same ingredient in Plan B One-Step, which is currently the only morning after pill that can be purchased by women of all ages without a prescription. Norlevo’s packaging is being updated to reflect the potential weight limits, but it’s unclear whether the company that manufactures Plan B One-Step will make a similar update to its own warning labels.

HRA Pharma, the company that makes Norlevo, decided to update the drug’s packaging after a 2011 study suggested that levonorgestrel-based emergency contraception is less effective for women with a higher Body Mass Index (BMI). HRA Pharma reviewed the clinical data and requested permission to make the change from European pharmaceutical regulators. The request was approved earlier this month. 

SleightOfHand --- 12 years ago -

Simple fix, wrap it 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

If that wrap breaks....better have a back-up plan. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

yep- maybe those women should take 2- 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

I know absolutely NOTHING about the science behind this stuff, but isn't there some kind of dosage ratio depending on weight? Do hormones work like that?

I dunno, seems like 165lbs is a pretty specific cut off point. Would 2 doses work up to 330lbs? (I am pretty sure it is not a linear relationship, i am just throwing an example out there) 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

that sounds logical to me- 

You can call me Michelle --- 12 years ago -

Yikes 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

Would 2 doses work up to 330lbs?


I think thats its own birth control. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -


I think thats its own birth control. 


I typed out and deleted 3 different jokes saying that basically said the same thing lol

you gotta be careful with the banhammer these days 

FabFive --- 12 years ago -

Here I was thinking abstinence works at any weight. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

yep- maybe those women should take 2- 

they shouldn't be taking them at all 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

Again, I am pretty clueless about the specifics of these things...

they shouldn't be taking them at all 

What is the major difference between these pills and regular contraceptives? Is the "morning after" title misleading?

Can women take this pill well into a pregnancy?

I am genuinely ignorant about these things, so please take my questions at face value

When I didn't want babies, condoms were a simple effective solution lol 

You can call me Michelle --- 12 years ago -

Ender the Plan B is supposed to make it unlikely for a fertilized egg to implant on the uterine wall. If taken after implantation, it is not supposed to have any affect on the pregnancy. Plan B can cause an abortion when taken after fertilization and prior to implantation. 

Biggun --- 12 years ago -

Yes, Michelle is right. People need to know this is abortion.

This is not a contraceptive, which prevent conception (fertilization).

This product prevents a fertilized egg from implantation.

People who take this product do so in an attempt to abort an unwanted pregnancy.

It is simply chemical abortion. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

A lot of drugs can cause an abortion if taken improperly. This drug is supposed to be used the morning after only. It is used to prevent a pregnancy not to end one. 

JAMS --- 12 years ago -

Abstinence works, unless of course you're a rape victim. Or you were using protection but the condom broke.

But rape victims can't get pregnant, so...

Or is it that rape babies are a gift from god?

So much crap spews from the anti-choice group, it's hard to keep it all straight.

You'll never stop abortions. Ever. The government will never stop them. Ever. Chemical or otherwise.

So move on and feign outrage over something that really matters, like the homeless family with an infant who live off Texas St close to Dynamo Stadium.
Oh, that's right. That's THEIR problem. Should have made better choices, right? 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

OK, gotcha.

I figured it was something like that..

Now my next question is this: Since this terminates a pregnancy on a cellular level, isn't this a far better solution than someone waiting until the fetus has to be mechanically removed?

I do not understand the pushback on plan b itself (I'm not getting into how its distributed, just the product itself). This seems like the most humane solution for all involved in cases where a pregnancy needs to be avoided. (rape, incest, health problems, age, ect..)

I believe these first few weeks are when most women have miscarriages anyways. If a 1st trimester miscarriage is not the woman's body murdering a fetus, then why is this morning after pill considered that way by some? 

Biggun --- 12 years ago -

A lot of drugs can cause an abortion if taken improperly. This drug is supposed to be used the morning after only. It is used to prevent a pregnancy not to end one. 

Improperly is the key word. That means a bad choice has been made by a person. It is not the intent of the drug or the manufacturer to abort a pregnancy in that situation.

This drug is different and is wrong and never should have been made. Its only purpose is to destroy life. When it is being used with the intent of stopping or preventing a fertilized egg from implanting, it is being used with the intent of destroying or ending life. 

Biggun --- 12 years ago -

But rape victims can't get pregnant, so...

Or is it that rape babies are a gift from god? 


Victims of rape can and do get pregnant. Why would you say otherwise? What relevance does that have with this thread? This thread is not about rape victims.

All babies are a gift from God, no matter the circumstances. 

tinman --- 12 years ago -

I'm going to jump in here. Not with an opinion, but a warning.

I think this subject merits a vigorous debate. My stance on the subject is not needed.

But, the very first time I read on here that a thread contributor called another thread contributor a name or made a derogatory reference, I will ice.

Not edit, ice.

Keep it civil, keep it vigorous, and keep it on topic. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

When it is being used with the intent of stopping or preventing a fertilized egg from implanting, it is being used with the intent of destroying or ending life. 


If a kid eggs a house is he ending a life? Seriously you need to find something to fill up your time with. Maybe you should go down to CPS and adopt a bunch of abused and neglected children that were born to people they shouldn't have. Life is short, make a difference rather than just bleating. 

Biggun --- 12 years ago -

Now my next question is this: Since this terminates a pregnancy on a cellular level, isn't this a far better solution than someone waiting until the fetus has to be mechanically removed?

There is no "better solution" for terminating a pregnancy. Once pregnancy (conception) has occurred, it should be allowed to run its full, natural course.

Good choices in diet and lifestyle should be made to help the pregancy proceed smoothly and with as much good health as possible for both mother and child.

I do not understand the pushback on plan b itself (I'm not getting into how its distributed, just the product itself). This seems like the most humane solution for all involved in cases where a pregnancy needs to be avoided. (rape, incest, health problems, age, ect..)

There is no good reason ever to abort or kill an innocent life.

I believe these first few weeks are when most women have miscarriages anyways. If a 1st trimester miscarriage is not the woman's body murdering a fetus, then why is this morning after pill considered that way by some?

I would ask you to reconsider your use of the word "murdering" here.

I don't want you to do actually do this but only think about going up to a woman who has suffered a miscarriage and then ask her about her body murdering her child. Think about what reaction you would get from any woman to that question.

Do you really believe a mother has murdered her child when she has a miscarriage? I guarantee that my MIL and my sister would have some choice words for you.

Again, intent is everything here. The only intended use of this product is to stop implantation of a fertilized egg, which results in termination of life. 

FabFive --- 12 years ago -

My friend adopted a child that was conceived out of rape and she is a beautiful precious child. My friend was unable to have children of her own and was thrilled to be given the choice to love a child. She's now almost 11 and thriving. The child should not have a death sentence for no wrongdoing of their own.

Tinman I love your post. And I hope that you keep your word. 

FabFive --- 12 years ago -

As a person who has had multiple miscarriages, I can assure you the grief is very real and you blame yourself for every little thing you did. I can't imagine how a person who intentionally kills their child must feel. The grief and guilt must be overwhelming. It is so sad. 

Polly Ester --- 12 years ago -

My friend adopted a child that was conceived out of rape and she is a beautiful precious child.

did the adoption agency tell the parents that the child was the result of a rape? do they plan to tell the child one day? It seems like that could be a very difficult issue for a child to deal with. there are already issues dealing with adoption and then to think you were conceived in an act of violence seems like it could be a very hard thing to accept.

but I think it is a very brave woman that could carry a pregnancy that was the result of a rape and I would hope she would have a lot of support. For a married woman that was raped, perhaps with children of her own, I just can't imagine having to carry a child that was not your husbands and explain to your children that you were not keeping the baby. I dont know if I would be that strong. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

My friend adopted a child that was conceived out of rape


My would the adoption agency even release that information? No child should have to learn that. EVER 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

I would ask you to reconsider your use of the word "murdering" here.

I don't want you to do actually do this but only think about going up to a woman who has suffered a miscarriage and then ask her about her body murdering her child. Think about what reaction you would get from any woman to that question.


My wife had a miscarriage earlier this year. I am well aware of the grief that comes along with it.

All babies are a gift from God, no matter the circumstances.

If this is how you feel personally, more power to you. Making it a political agenda to force that line of thinking on others is no different than the Taliban forcing their women to wear burqua's, regardless of what they want.

Abortion is clearly an all or nothing issue for some people, but that is a problem when we live in a modern society that demands compromise from both sides.

If history has shown us anything it is that extremism begets more extremism:

Zero tolerance abortion policy gave rise to "pro-choice" groups that are just as unwilling to accept what seem like sensible rules regulating abortions.

The biggest victim resulting from this inability to compromise is our country itself. Our future at stake and we are STILL choosing candidates based (mostly) on their stance on issues that rely on personal beliefs rather than what is best for our nation.

I say it is time to realize that a nation of 313 million Americans are not going to share the same level of religious belief and start focusing on issues that we can actually fix.

I can tell you right now that I agree more with Republicans on many important issues, but if someone puts a candidate in front of me that tells me that my wife and I would have to raise a baby resulting from her rape I will NOT support them.

It is time to grow up, compromise, and move on from these issues. You could lock everyone who has posted in this thread in a room for 100 years and we would never change each others convictions. It is all about the middle ground...

Maybe we can discuss them when we fix the bigger issues. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

All babies are a gift from God, no matter the circumstances.

If this is how you feel personally, more power to you. Making it a political agenda to force that line of thinking on others is no different than the Taliban forcing their women to wear burqua's, regardless of what they want.

I say it is time to realize that a nation of 313 million Americans are not going to share the same level of religious belief and start focusing on issues that we can actually fix.

I can tell you right now that I agree more with Republicans on many important issues, but if someone puts a candidate in front of me that tells me that my wife and I would have to raise a baby resulting from her rape I will NOT support them.




^^^THIS 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

My friend adopted a child that was conceived out of rape


My would the adoption agency even release that information? No child should have to learn that. EVER




Absolutely right. Why would anyone do that? No parent with a brain would reveal that info. I know some people who didn't even know they were adopted til their Adoptive parents passed on. 

Polly Ester --- 12 years ago -

I can tell you right now that I agree more with Republicans on many important issues, but if someone puts a candidate in front of me that tells me that my wife and I would have to raise a baby resulting from her rape I will NOT support them.


I have a friend that was raped. she was vocal in her opposition to abortion. she is very conservative. but when offered the plan b in the hospital she took it. she never doubted her choice at that point and her husband was very supportive of her. I dont think you ever know for sure how you will deal with a hypothetical situation until you are actually facing it. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

No parent with a brain would reveal that info

I know you are talking about adoption, but what happens if the woman cant bring herself to give up the child since she has carried it to term? (This happened to a cousin of mine, not a rape case, just a teen pregnancy) What happens if the Rapist was a different ethnicity than the mother and father? There would be no way to keep that from them (or anyone else) for long..

Would some people be ok with that? Maybe, but they can decide to do that without taking the choice away from other people.

(Before anyone makes racist allegations, i only brought up ethnicity to illustrate the point that there is not 'always' a way to keep that information a secret) 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

I have a friend that was raped. she was vocal in her opposition to abortion. she is very conservative.



Being conservative doesn't mean you mindlessly follow any and all issues that are considered the conservative "platform" or you can't join the club. Only mindless idiots think that way. Humans can make their own choices in life and still choose the party that most fits their ideals. Its getting easier and easier to know who NOT to vote for. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

Would some people be ok with that? Maybe, but they can decide to do that without taking the choice away from other people.



I think in those situations its up to the parent to decide what they tell their child. I just can't imagine living with the knowledge of who your father was or having on of my children have to face that. 

Polly Ester --- 12 years ago -

Being conservative doesn't mean you mindlessly follow any and all issues that are considered the conservative "platform" or you can't join the club. Only mindless idiots think that way.

that was my point. she supports a conservative doctrine but when faced with a real life dilemma she had a different view. much like people who are strongly opposed to gay marriage who change their stance when faced with their own gay child wanting the right to marry. I just think until actually facing some of these events, a person can say for sure how they would choose to deal with it. the important word is "choose". 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

I have a friend that was raped. she was vocal in her opposition to abortion. she is very conservative. but when offered the plan b in the hospital she took it.

I am sorry about your friend. I couldn't imagine how my wife and I would handle a situation like that..

Anyone put in that situation should have the option to do whatever they feel is best. Dealing with rape (especially in a marriage) is a lifelong healing process, anything else thrown into the mix does not help..

Could you imagine a love one being raped and not having the option of plan b, then passing away from pregnancy/childbirth complications?

That is absolutely insane. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

If a kid eggs a house is he ending a life?

ridiculous comment

I believe these first few weeks are when most women have miscarriages anyways.

a miscarriage isn't murder 

FabFive --- 12 years ago -

My friend's adopted daughter does not know the circumstances of her conception and never will. No one in their family even knows. I just happen to know because it is my best friend. The daughter is mixed race and her parents are one of those races. She and my daughter were best friends for a long time until we moved. They ha e no intention of disclosing it and the agency doesn't even know as far as I know. The bio mom was not married and has another child that has a dad in prison for drugs and being a pedophile. That child is in her care. Another one of her children died from SIDS and another one had been removed from her care by authorities. Those are the four I know of, there may be more by now. 

tinman --- 12 years ago -

If a kid eggs a house is he ending a life?

ridiculous comment



Ok....here we go. While this doesn't rise to the level of an ice offense, it is certainly worthy to note.

JL, you are one of the ones who complain the loudest about folks ganging up on you. This thread, while controversial in nature, has been very civil and, to be quite honest, educational.

For you to say anyone's take on it is ridiculous only causes the very behavior your are trying to stop.

You are smart. Find another way to let the person you disagree with know that you vehemently disagree with their take.

To call their take ridiculous is to call them ridiculous.

Thanks 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

a miscarriage isn't murder

You are right, I concede to that point. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

that was my point. she supports a conservative doctrine but when faced with a real life dilemma she had a different view. much like people who are strongly opposed to gay marriage who change their stance when faced with their own gay child wanting the right to marry. I just think until actually facing some of these events, a person can say for sure how they would choose to deal with it. the important word is "choose". 


I agree with you but I don't think all people have to face something like the above to know that those are personal decisions and do not make a person any less conservative than someone who is a religious fanatic holding to ever whim ever thought of by the party line. 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground