Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Using Attractive Women To Sell The Army?

who's talking here?

zapper007 1
Warren Peace 6
It is I WhyWhyWhy 6
Dorothy Parker 2
SagaciousSighFiGurl 22
Semper 3
OL AG 89 2
JAMS 1
Emperor of Kingwood 4
DVaz 1
The Day I Tried to Live 2
Snake Plissken 1
The Master 23
Pure Elegance 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

By The Associated Press
Pentagon officials said Friday that an Army colonel who wrote an internal email suggesting photos of attractive women should be avoided in promotional materials has stepped down from her duties involving a gender study.

Army spokesman George Wright said Gen. Robert Cone, commander of the Army’s Training and Doctrine Command at Fort Eustis, Va., agreed to step aside from leading a gender integration study “in order to protect the integrity of the ongoing work.”

The content of the email was first reported by Politico this week. In the email, Arnhart stated that “average-looking women” should be used in Army materials used to attract women for combat roles, Politico reported.

In addition, Wright said that Col. Christian Kubik, a public affairs officer also with the Army’s Training and Doctrine Command, was suspended for his involvement in the email pending an investigation.

According to the email chain obtained by Politico, Kubik forwarded Arnhart’s email to other public affairs officers, cautioning the use of photos “that glamourize women” would undermine the Army’s gender integration efforts.

Wright confirmed that the email existed but didn’t provide copies to The Associated Press. Messages seeking comment from Arnhart, who worked at the Training and Doctrine Command’s analysis center at Fort Leavenworth, and Kubik about the staff changes weren’t immediately returned.

Earlier Friday, Kubik said in a statement that Arnhart’s comments were internal, “nothing more” and didn’t reflect official Army policy.

“The intent was to help ensure that images depict professional female soldiers as they are,” he said. “And to ensure that they are recognized on their hard-earned achievements as members of the professional arms.”

Theresa Vail, a Kansas Army National Guard soldier who is also the reigning Miss Kansas, was critical of the email, saying Arnhart’s comments reflected entrenched stereotypes that attractive women aren’t competent enough to serve in combat or other military roles.

“It’s the sad truth. It’s the unfortunate reality,” Vail said Friday. “From what I’ve been getting, women are outraged.”

The military is trying to figure out how to implement policy changes to move women into battlefront jobs, including infantry, armor and elite commando positions. Updated physical and mental standards that are equal for men and women are being devised for thousands of combat jobs. The military has until Jan. 1, 2016, to open as many jobs as possible to women and explain why if they decide to keep some closed.

Vail, 23, enlisted in the Army when she was 17 and was told she “too pretty join the military,” she said.

“I’ve always been stereotyped. I pray that more women will stand up to this and take a stand,” Vail said. “It’s not going to just take me. It’s going to take an army of women.”





Well that's interesting! 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

It's hilarious what gets reported as news. Anyone who advertises prefers to use attractive people that's just the way it is. 

DVaz --- 12 years ago -

With the gay-ban lifted soon it will be male models! 

Snake Plissken --- 12 years ago -

Born pretty is a god given advantage. Just like born intelligent or athletic. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

I see both sides .

There IS a clear stereotype that good looking women are dumb. And yet the army ain't beauty school. Showing glamorous women as military examples is pretty much a lie. There's nothing glamorous about the job, especially with the changes they want to make now.

I think it's ridiculous to be fired over that email or forced out. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

Would using ugly women in advertising get more women to enlist?

What a weird situation....lol. 

The Master --- 12 years ago -

There IS a clear stereotype that good looking women are dumb.

What kind of people do you hang out with, neanderthals?

I don't know anyone who thinks hot women are inherently dumb. Yes, hot women sometimes DO use their looks to get what they want or get others to do stuff for them (they act dumb or incompetent on purpose).

But that's on them.

I have never looked at a hot woman and assumed she was dumb because of her looks. I really doubt anyone with an IQ over room temp does that.

So this "stereotype" you speak of may only be among morons (or maybe people of an older generation). 

The Day I Tried to Live --- 12 years ago -

Military women aren't hot and most are as use as an old catchers mitt. When I was enlisted I stayed away from them. 

The Day I Tried to Live --- 12 years ago -

Up is down in this situation. The more attractive a military woman is the hotter she is not because the more used she probably is. 

The Master --- 12 years ago -

Top 10 sexiest female scientists  

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

Its not really women they want to attract. Its males age 18 to 26. Anyone care to hedge a guess what they like to see? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

Master, in answer to your rejection that there is no stereotyping attractive women, you asked WHO thinks that?

She does:

"Theresa Vail, a Kansas Army National Guard soldier who is also the reigning Miss Kansas, was critical of the email, saying Arnhart’s comments reflected entrenched stereotypes that attractive women aren’t competent enough to serve in combat or other military." 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

Kudos to the sexy female scientist. Too bad lots of people aren't aware there ARE some. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

The Army, and basically all the services dont really care about attracting women recruits and officers. They have to in order to satisfy Congress. 

The Master --- 12 years ago -

She does:

"Theresa Vail, a Kansas Army National Guard soldier who is also the reigning Miss Kansas, was critical of the email, saying Arnhart’s comments reflected entrenched stereotypes that attractive women aren’t competent enough to serve in combat or other military."


Just because she is stereotyping others doesn't mean that the majority (or even a large minority) does that.

I'm a guy. I know lots of guys. I have never heard anyone say anything like this: "she's hot so she must be dumb or incompetent". Not even remotely. Nor have I seen anyone act on such a view. It's ridiculous. Dream come true for most guys is intelligent AND hot.

So should I believe the view (stereotype view at that) or what I have seen and heard myself?

The lady quoted has a chip on her shoulder and is stereotyping others. 

The Master --- 12 years ago -

But yes, I have seen women in general discriminated against in the workplace. The main reason is concern over getting pregnant and leaving during a project or putting kids before the job.

But that's very different than discrimination for reasons that are absurd (like attractiveness). If anything, attractive women (and men) benefit from it. I see an attractive women dressed business causal I assume intelligence and competence.

Attractive women who dress and act like "girls gone wild" (in the workplace) will be assumed to be dumb, but not because of how they look. But because of their inappropriate attire and actions. Guys would be viewed the same way under the same circumstances. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

Attractive women who dress and act like "girls gone wild" will be assumed to be dumb, 

Thats because we know why those girls do that. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

She does:

"Theresa Vail, a Kansas Army National Guard soldier who is also the reigning Miss Kansas, was critical of the email, saying Arnhart’s comments reflected entrenched stereotypes that attractive women aren’t competent enough to serve in combat or other military."

Just because she is stereotyping others doesn't mean that the majority (or even a large minority) does that.

I'm a guy. I know lots of guys. I have never heard anyone say anything like this: "she's hot so she must be dumb or incompetent". Not even remotely. Nor have I seen anyone act on such a view. It's ridiculous. Dream come true for most guys is intelligent AND hot.

So should I believe the view (stereotype view at that) or what I have seen and heard myself?

The lady quoted has a chip on her shoulder and is stereotyping others.






You asked who thought that. The article states that was part of the issue and why.

Just bc you don't think that way doesn't mean it isn't a valid stereotype that exists.

Ever heard of dumb blonde jokes or bimbo jokes? What about all the females portrayed as dumb blondes in films?? How did that get started, that blondes are dumb?? And just happened to be the ideal in female beauty for eons?

Also, you are a man, meaning you were never a target, so maybe that affects ones understanding? 

The Master --- 12 years ago -

Ever heard of dumb blonde jokes or bimbo jokes? What about all the females portrayed as dumb blondes in films?? How did that get started, that blondes are dumb?? And just happened to be the ideal in female beauty for eons?

You do know of course that all of those silly jokes came about many decades ago. The world has moved forward. We aren't in the 50's anymore.

Among the older set there may indeed be a stereotype, but they are retired or retiring soon. Non issue for the most part.


As for the media, the media is in a world all of it's own, one that does not reflect reality. Note all the "stupid husband" commercials on TV? I ignore the media when it comes to my understanding of the world.

I repeat, I have NEVER heard ANYONE say that a woman was incompetent or dumb because she was attractive. I find this stereotype so laughable that I'm wasting precious Saturday minutes discussing it.

The real "stereotype" is women who ACT dumb or incompetent to get what they want, manipulate or to get others to do their work for them. That I've seen countless times. Usually done by women who are far from dumb. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

Well, all I can say is the Miss Kansas in the above article is 23 years old. Wonder where she got that idea? Lol 

The Master --- 12 years ago -

Well, all I can say is the Miss Kansas in the above article is 23 years old. Wonder where she got that idea? Lol

Perhaps she isn't as successful in the national guard as she thinks she should be and is looking for an excuse?

Perhaps she buys into the stories from her mother, who lived in a different time?

But of course all I can speak to with complete confidence are from my personal experiences (and logic). 

The Master --- 12 years ago -

Let's put this to the test.

Any guys here actually think attractive women are dumb or incompetent, just because they are attractive?

I'm sure a few jokers will say so, but let's be real. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

Intelligence, a pretty smile and nice butt are very attractive. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

Well, all I can say is the Miss Kansas in the above article is 23 years old. Wonder where she got that idea? Lol

Perhaps she isn't as successful in the national guard as she thinks she should be and is looking for an excuse?

Perhaps she buys into the stories from her mother, who lived in a different time?

But of course all I can speak to with complete confidence are from my personal experiences (and logic).



Oh come on. You said it isn't real and I pointed out that a BEAUTY contestant and a military member expressed that she thought so. Then you said it was just old retired people, and I pointed out she was 23. Now you're making excuses by totally guessing about her opinion and take on it and trying to discredit her. Her opinion is from her personal experiences and logic too. Just like yours!

You don't know her and her experiences. If she experienced it-then she DID. And so have many others.

It's not the end of the world. 

The Master --- 12 years ago -

Attractive women aren't the ones being discriminated against.

Attractive people of both genders have a great advantage in the world when it comes to getting a "leg up".

I don't know what experiences you've had in the corp world or military, but I have had much. I have never ever heard of "attractive = dumb". Ever.

I have heard fat = lazy, women take more time off comments, and even some racially prejudicial statements. But discrimination against the attractive? NEVER.

Oh, but to have that problem of being so attractive one is thought dumb. I'd love it. :) 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

The most interesting thing about the way this article is written is the way it downplays the gender of the Colonel who wrote the internal memo and stepped down.

Her full name is never even used above. From the very first mention of her identity through the last, the reader is only seeing her referred to as Colonel and Arnhart. At no point in the article are we told that the person who stepped down is Lynette Arnhart. It almost appears as if an editor left that out since journalists normally introduce subjects to us first, before reverting to referencing them by surname.

This is a story about gender stereotypes yet the person embracing them that was asked to step down is a woman. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

Stereotypes exist among the ignorant.

Hot women are stupid
Blondes have more fun
Redheads are wild in bed
Redheads are hot tempered
Fat=lazy
small hands little uh hem

and on and on and on 

The Master --- 12 years ago -

Redheads are hot tempered

That one IS true.

Redheads are wild in bed

I suspect this one is as well. But I need to verify it for myself. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

Redheads are hot tempered

That one IS true.

Redheads are wild in bed

I suspect this one is as well. 



Maybe the after years of being accused of being hot tempered they become that way… 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

No, it's because hot women are CrAzY


Hot crazy scale! 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

No, it's because hot women are CrAzY


Hot crazy scale! 




Why you hating on attractive women today Sigh? 

OL AG 89 --- 12 years ago -

I put 21 years in the military. I served in units with and without females on the roles. I served alongside some of the most talented men and women in the world.
I have mixed emotions about women serving in a "frontline" combat position, call me old fashioned, but if we have enough able-bodied men able to perform that role, why also endanger the lives of the primary care takers of our children.

AND NO I'M NOT SAYING BAREFOOT AND PREGNANT!

Go ahead and call me names, but it's MY opinion. I was raised to be the "protector", not a prejudice, just was the " way of the world". 

The Master --- 12 years ago -

But old ag, irrespective of your views on women in the military, have you ever thought to yourself "she's attractive so she's probably dumb or incompetent?" 

The Master --- 12 years ago -

[i]Maybe the after years of being accused of being hot tempered they become that way… [/i]

No. But it's ok, they make up for it in bed. 

OL AG 89 --- 12 years ago -

NO. I apparently don't possess that "first glance" gene. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

Well, this from a mans blog...seems he assumes the most attractive women are Dumb And implies it's a 'man thing' to think so!

And he's not old either! It seems THERE IS this belief out there.

Why good looking women are dumb 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

have you ever thought to yourself "she's attractive so she's probably dumb or incompetent?" 

I admit to thinking something slightly different than this. When I see women that are employed as models, I think they are probably not as intelligent as other women who are in fields that depend on their intelligence. Pursuing a career in such a vain, and superficial field requires being vain and superficial. So it's not quite the same as thinking hot=dumb (I have never thought this and never met anyone who thinks like this). 

The Master --- 12 years ago -

And? His view is that hot women don't HAVE to WORK as hard to be educated.

"There is no external motivation for the hotties to sit down and cram vocabulary or maths formulas or read 2,000 pages every semester. This lack of motivation of course leads to a lack of intellectual activities which keeps/makes these girls dumb."

But that's not the same thing as intelligence. I've met uneducated people whose logical thinking skills would knock your socks off.

It's not the attractiveness that would lead one to view a hot woman as dumb, it would be her actions.

Yes, a few people may feel otherwise, but they are irrelevant in the scheme of things.

The point you (and the article) made is that it is a widespread view. And it isn't.

If it was widespread I'm sure I'd have witnessed it at some point and I haven't. So I must either be a liar or ignorant?

There are people out there that think all kinds of stupid crap. Doesn't mean that there are that many of them or that they have any influence or power. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -


There are people out there that think all kinds of stupid crap. Doesn't mean that there are that many of them. 




^^ this 

The Master --- 12 years ago -

and never met anyone who thinks like this

Yep. Same here. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground