Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

jtcitrus forgot one..Top Five Westerns

who's talking here?

Lillabeth 1
Warren Peace 4
jtcitrus 4
AwesomeTattooedDragon 4
tinman 5
Aah Grasshoppa 1
TinktheSprite 1
LitlJay 1
sheddy 1
NitANee 1
java 1
FabFive 4
Edgar Po Wong 1
JAMS 2
mutton 1
ARealPeach 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

tinman --- 13 years ago -

And don't no one argue with me about this list. I happen to be an expert on the Western.



The Outlaw Josey Wales
High Plains Drifter
The Good, The Bad and the Ugly
True Grit (Coen Brothers Version)
Tombstone

More Lee Van Cleef and less John Wayne makes for a great Western. 

Lillabeth --- 13 years ago -

More Lee Van Cleef and less John Wayne makes for a great Western.

What? You're crazy! John Wayne is the best. Ugh, and I hate Clint Eastwood.
Except Grand Torino & Million Dollar Baby. Hubby, loves him some Clint and every darn time one of his "Westerns" comes on, I'm subjected to his laughable stares and bad acting. 

sheddy --- 13 years ago -

Well, at least you just have to watch every Clint movie, I have to watch every John Wayne and Clint Eastwood movie my husband passes while channel surfing. 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

I am cracking up. I thought that Mrs. Tinman was the only woman in the bubble subjected to forced "Clint Eastwood" marathons.

My lovely bride knows which movie these quotes belong to and she's not proud about it either.

"I have not yet begun to defile myself"

"Buzzard's got to eat...same as the worms"

"Somebody left the door open and the wrong dogs came home"

"A saucy line will not get you far with me"

"You see, in this world there's two kinds of people, my friend: Those with loaded guns and those who dig. You dig." 

LitlJay --- 13 years ago -

I can and will argue with that list, although it is partly right:

Tombstone
Open Range
True Grit
The Shootist
Waterhole #3

(honorable mention to the comically PC 90's Maverick remake) 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

The Shootist



Ok...OK....I'll have to admit. When the Shootist and The Undefeated come on, I watch them every single time.

Now...it's only a coincidence that the only Rock Hudson movie I'll profess to liking is The Undefeated.

Rock Hudson, Roman Gariel, Marion Morrison... 

ARealPeach --- 13 years ago -

Anything with Clint in it 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Tombstone. End of story. 

Aah Grasshoppa --- 13 years ago -

Tinman that's my top 5 too. Same list. 

mutton --- 13 years ago -

Any of the old Clint Eastwood westerns.... 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

Young Guns!!!!! 

TinktheSprite --- 13 years ago -

Maverick 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

hands down- the Lonesome Dove miniseries- as good as the book- loved it- Robert Duvall is terrific in any one of his movies- 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Do any of you guys watch Longmire? It's a series on A&E. Takes place in Wyoming or Montana. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

Love it!!! I'm a big western fan- 

NitANee --- 13 years ago -

Butch Cassidy & The Sundance Kid
True Grit (Coen Brothers)
Shane
Tombstone
The Unforgiven
3:10 to Yuma
Dances with Wolves

LOL Couldn't stop at just 5 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Longmire is one of our fav shows. I know it's not exactly a Western.... 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

I think of it as a western- a modern western- 

java --- 13 years ago -

DH loves: Tombstone
Jeremiah Johnson
The Good, The Bad and The Ugly
Wyatt Earp
I am not a Westerns fan. 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

I like Longmire. And Hell On Wheels. That's awesome! 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

The Good, The Bad and the Ugly
Unforgiven
True Grit (Coen Brothers)
The Assassination of Jesse James by The Coward Robert Ford (watched it last night)
The Proposition

Honorable Mention for being different than the traditional western:
Blazing Saddles
Django Unchained 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

My favorite western show:
Firefly

Movie:
probably tombstone.
I'm not really a fan of westerns...
it was really a Jackie Chan movie, but I really liked Shanghai Noon.

and I didn't forget top five westerns... KU told me to cool it with my posts. Then my wife told me to go to bed.

fwiw, I was going to quit with "top five John Cusack movies. (see what I did there?)

;) 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

Hondo and sons of Katie elder always come to mind for me as well. 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

fwiw, I was going to quit with "top five John Cusack movies.

That list begins and ends with Grosse Pointe Blank 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

That list begins and ends with Grosse Pointe Blank

1408 was good too.

Hot Tub time machine was highly underrated.
;) 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

Warren Peace (Mod) --- 8 hours ago - quote - hide comments

fwiw, I was going to quit with "top five John Cusack movies.

That list begins and ends with Grosse Pointe Blank




I didn't see that movie for the first time until about a year ago. What an under rated flick. I was never a Minnie Driver fan, but she freaking captured my imagination with her quirky character.

I have been a huge Cusack fan since "Class" in the early 80's. The fact that I had to watch a brat pack movie with Andrew McCarthy and Rob Lowe in it only makes the pleasure of discovering Cusack worth the pain of the other two.

My favorite Cusack movie is, by far and away, "Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil".

That one might also be one of the truly under rated efforts by Clint Eastwood as a director.

On a personal note....I find Unforgiven to be the most cliche, over directed, underacted piece of trash western that Clint not only directed, but starred in.

The fact that he hadn't won an Oscar yet only helped the hype machine and, don't under estimate the fact that he announced it would be his last western.

I stand here as a complete devotee of the genre and will tell you that I would not put this flick in the top 20 of my list of greatest Westerns. That means I would have to find some movies that starred Marion and Gary Cooper in order to pay homage to the rest of the wanna be's.

That being said, Gene Hackman is one Hell of a cowboy. 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

I had a long drive from Kingwood to Laredo this morning tinman. Having plenty time to let my thoughts drift with many miles passing without seeing another vehicle or another human while admiring the desolate scenery along the way (cactus, dust, and roadside memorials of highway deaths) got me thinking of the era of the western.

A great western is about capturing the era. It must portray the struggle of maintaining civility on an expansive and unruly frontier where uncivil behavior quite easily goes unpunished without vengeance being a significant motivation. For me, a great film must have a psychological appeal. I need more than just pretty faces, clever dialogue, and cool action scenes.

That is exactly why Unforgiven is a far better flick than Tombstone. What you described above is a far more fitting description of Tombstone.

Take another look at this cliche' ridden piece.

 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

I still can barely get past the first 10 minutes. Take a look at the opening scene where we see the clichéd stand-off where we know a gunfight is about to ensue yet no other bystanders have even an inkling that the bad guys (as the ominous music leads us to believe) are on the verge of gunning down some innocents during the most clichéd innocent moment of them all [gasp] a wedding day. We see a line of gunfighters not even budging as every one of the human obstacles (sombrero wearing Mexicans serving in the Star Trek red shirt role) to their ultimate target is gunned down so we can have a moment or two of tension building dialogue where the villain introduces himself to us by actually saying to the crowd, “They call me Curly Bill Brocius.” This sets up the finishing move on the final victim just before the delivery of …(who did not see this coming)…a clichéd one liner. We then see other well armed bystanders who survived the gunfight, yet no longer sense neither danger nor an obligation for justice tending to the hysterical bride by restraining her for some reason after her man is gunned down. We then see the clichéd scenes of a skilled gunfighter shooting the hat off of someone followed by the clichéd twirling of the guns as they are reholstered. Did you happen to notice that the scene of this shootout is the exact same location as featured in the previously released Western comedy The Three Amigos? Does it get more schlocky than that?

Take a look early in this video of the moment we meet the well moisturized face of Hollywood pretty boy Kurt Russell. He steps off a train and pauses (with no other passengers choosing the same exit) so we can take in his magnificent beauty as he squints and takes in the scenery. He is immediately recognized of course by characters that promptly introduce themselves to us. Russell’s well lotioned and carefully groomed portrayal of Wyatt Earp immediately announces to us that he has done his “duty” and is retired now…alluding to his gunfighter past. His impeccably dressed buddies (and equally well moisturized and well groomed) enter the scene among the heroic background music as they engage in the introductory buddy slaps so we know they have shared fond memories. Not a single one has so much as a speck of dust on them as dust circulates in the air around them. That is textbook overly glamorized Hollywood over-production. It is unwatchable. But I know it remains popular.

Go to the 11 minute mark where we then meet Val Kilmer. Yet another well moisturized pretty boy with well groomed facial hair makes his introduction. His first scene is more like a Western version of a Derek Zoolander photoshoot. But he’s in the gambler role. Of course he’s skillfully twirling a coin among his fingers. We then get the clichéd stand-off as one player rises for a dramatic confrontation as the hero character delivers cool banter while remaining seated just before the obligatory quick draw followed by yet another twirl of the revolvers.

I’m sure I could keep going. But there’s no way Tombstone is either a better film nor a better Western than Unforgiven. It just strains credulity to view both films and conclude that Unforgiven is more cliched than Tombstone. 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

I’m sure I could keep going. But there’s no way Tombstone is either a better film nor a better Western than Unforgiven. It just strains credulity to view both films and conclude that Unforgiven is more cliched than Tombstone.


I get what you are saying, and there is a ton of validity in you thoughts.

But for me, the bottom line on cliche is the overall effect of the movie as it relates to other Westerns. This is where we part company.

The entire Western Genre is a cliche. But, the individual performances in a Western are what make the movie for me.

Kurt Russell, Sam Elliott, Dana Delany are horrible actors, and especially horrible in Tombstone.

Val Kilmer...makes that movie and makes it to the point that it is memorable and makes me want to see it again and again. That's what puts it in my top five.

Unforgiven is a cliche built upon a cliche with a cliche as a side dish. There was one semi riveting performance and that was Gene Hackman's. Other than that, you have a broken down gun fighter who is trying to be a good father and the only way he can do this is to stop drinking. Along comes his old side kick and a blind midget and you have a plot.

The ending of the movie was completely predictable and the fact that it occurred during a thunderstorm, with requisite thunder in all the right moments, lightning timed just perfectly to illuminate the sneer to me, just takes the movie in a direction that could have been done by any one at any time.

I expected more from Clint for his last Western. Again, there is no bigger fan of the Western, and of Clint Eastwood. It's just this particular Western didn't even get in the zip code of the hype it generated.

I was looking for Josey Wales or any of the "Man With No Name" reprisals. I got none of that in "Unforgiven".

Now, having said that, I love this topic and the different takes it has generated. I think how a person sees a movie says so much about them. I also love that a good debate can be drummed up over movies amongst movie lovers and the passion always shows itself.

Same with music. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Val Kilmer does definitely make that movie. 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

That is exactly why Unforgiven is a far better flick than Tombstone. What you described above is a far more fitting description of Tombstone.


this is where I wind up arguing with myself: The notion of a "Great Movie" vs the notion of a "favorite movie".
- On the one hand, to what extent can we objectively define "great"?
- On the other hand, how much weight should popular preferences be given?

Tombstone is cliched. no doubt. But it's GLORIOUSLY cliched, and a fan favorite. doesn't that warrant it some consideration for a top-X nod?

Val Kilmer does definitely make that movie.

True. 

Edgar Po Wong --- 13 years ago -

Can't believe nobody has mentioned:

0 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

Oh, yes! Hell on Wheels! another current show, too! terrific! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground