Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The Tea Party's Pyrrhic Victory

who's talking here?

SoupIsGoodFood 5
RiteWingKing 3
Warren Peace 3
jtcitrus 6
JohnLynch 1
Let Logic Prevail 1
Clovis 1
WatchOut 2
Gigolo Bloodline 1
a889324uu 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

RiteWingKing --- 13 years ago -

0undefined 

RiteWingKing --- 13 years ago -

Interesting Opinion Article 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

I'm just surprised that Obama and his minions haven't taken all the credit. 

RiteWingKing --- 13 years ago -

Fiscal policy is probably subtracting 1.5 percentage points from the economy’s growth rate in 2013, taking into account this year’s spending cuts and higher taxes, estimates Zandi of Moody’s Analytics. The Federal Reserve can’t offset the harm by cutting interest rates because the federal funds rate is already at zero. So the economy is expected to grow only about 1.5 percent this year, barely above stall speed. “At stall speed,” Zandi says, “job growth is no longer sufficient to forestall an increase in unemployment. As soon as unemployment ticks higher, you’re in recession. You’re in a vicious cycle down.” He says the U.S. economy should avoid that fate—unless Congress stumbles into a default at some point. “The minute Treasury doesn’t pay someone, we’ve opened Pandora’s box.”


This probably hurt economic growth/employment 

Let Logic Prevail --- 13 years ago -

You're wasting your time. No one here is interested in facts. 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

just for the record:

Discretionary spending hit a 53 year low at 5% of GDP in Q1-2000 and then climbed to peak at 7.1% in Q2 and Q3 of 2010: before the 2010 mid-term elections. It has since fallen steadily to a post-recession low of 6.2% in Q2-2010.

Discretionary spending as a percent of GDP trended down from a peak of 13.6% of GDP in Q3-1952, the highest level of spending on record (as a percent of GDP)

Fiscal policy is probably subtracting 1.5 percentage points from the economy’s growth rate in 2013, taking into account this year’s spending cuts and higher taxes, estimates Zandi of Moody’s Analytics.

And government shutdowns take on average 0.1 %-points off quarterly GDP growth per week of shutdown (this will take an expected 0.25%-points off of Q4 GDP accounting). According to Blue Chip Economics 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

Forgive me for not being a fan of Mark Zandi of Moody Analytics. He's the same Mark Zandi that promoted the 2009 stimulus spending as something that would create 1.9 million jobs at a cost of a mere quarter million per job.

The Obama supporting registered Democrat's rosy Keynesian predictions were famously showcased in a chart used by the administration to sell the public on the need for spending more money we didn't have (and still don't):

0

The actual, real life results were much more in line with what opponents were saying would happen:

0

It can be said that the government's contribution to GDP is limited to spending only and does not add value to production in the way that private sector spending does. The shutdown merely delayed payments. But the monetary obligations were not shut down. The money was still spent even though workers were not pushing the papers of government.

I'm not saying Zandi is right or wrong. I'm saying his analysis presumes much...and the last time his analysis was waved in front of the nation for a political victory was not exactly his finest moment. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

The sheeple can't swallow this truth.

Any facts not supportive to Obama and his agenda are automatically deemed racist. 

Gigolo Bloodline --- 13 years ago -

The tide is turning....LMAO 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

Did your meeting let out early tonight, tommyboy? 

Clovis --- 13 years ago -

Congratulations to the teahadists faction of the Republican party for wasting $24 billion dollars for NOTHING. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

Congratulations to the teahadists faction of the Republican party for wasting $24 billion dollars for NOTHING.

where do the libs come up with those worthless numbers?...where was any money wasted?

the truth is...money was probably SAVED because Congress couldn't spend more of our money 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

Maybe some of you economic geniuses can educate me why I should be concerned about a temporary hit to the GDP when the entire drop is due to a reduction in deficit spending?

Shouldn’t we be more concerned with whether or not that money ever needed to be spent in the first place? If all we care about is inflating our GDP on the backs of additional deficit spending, then why not just spend another gazillion and raise the debt ceiling to infinity while we’re at it?

I suppose it was ok when one political party legislated into the economy an increase in the cost of labor that came at the expense of job creation AND productivity. THAT drop in GDP and unemployment was just fine, right? It was fine why? How sure are you that the actual outcome was worth the actual cost?

Was it just fine when the 2009 Stimulus bill committed over $830 billion dollars in additional spending that we lacked the funds to pay for (and still don’t have)? One of that bill’s highlights includes “investing” $7 million per household simply to extend internet access to an area in Montana that was not even under-served, among countless other reckless spending commitments.

Our labor participation rate is now down to its lowest point since August of 1978. Good times. The blame lies at the feet of politicians who believe they have the requisite knowledge to know better than the collective number of participants in our economy with varying areas of specialized knowledge (that politicians lack), who make decisions for themselves every day. We should be trying to empower those who bear the consequences of their own decisions (you and I), rather than continuing to empower politicians motivated by their own political ideology to spend more of the money they take from our economy for their own political victories. They tend not to suffer the consequences of their terrible spending decisions. Instead, we keep voting them more money to spend recklessly and believe them when they blame external villains when their spending decisions have the opposite real life consequences from what they told us.

Our economy has lost trillions due to the policies of our Washington bureaucrats in both parties. But it’s incredible that we would have anyone who is not a hardcore, committed political hack grousing about the temporary quarterly “loss” of $24 billion in non-essential spending (a reduction in spending from a government that runs a $75 billion dollars DEFICIT PER MONTH) without asking a more obvious question - “How can we make that permanent?”

Isn’t the better question how much we lose when the government is not in shutdown? 

a889324uu --- 13 years ago -

John, the S&P index is where us libs come up with "worthless numbers." 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

the entire drop is due to a reduction in deficit spending?

The sequester, loss of benefits and inflation are responsible for the spending drop in real dollar terms. But the revenue side ticked up too. after the GDP revisions, tax reciepts as a percent of GDP last year were near 16.5% of GDP by the fourth Quarter (The mean is 17.5% with a standard deviation of 1.2 percentage points). The first half of this year, and Q4 of last year saw tax revenues shoot up in absolute and %-of-GDP terms (Q2-2013 Federal tax receipts are now 19% of GDP). Both of those have worked together to bring down the deficit spending.

The temporary hit to GDP caused by the Shutdown (the money will still be paid) wouldn't be that bad for the country IF they had resolved anything. But they didn't. They just tabled the decisions for another few months. The state of perpetual uncertainty in fiscal and regulatory markets has a very real cost in foregone economic activity.

Shouldn’t we be more concerned with whether or not that money ever needed to be spent in the first place?

Seriously. Or some estimate on the rate of return on that expense? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

Congratulations to the teahadists faction of the Republican party for wasting $24 billion dollars for NOTHING

This is BEYOND rich.

A liberal complaining about wasted govt money.

Awesomeness!!!! 

WatchOut --- 13 years ago -

Congratulations to the teahadists faction of the Republican party for wasting $24 billion dollars for NOTHING.  

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

LOL............. AGAIN!!!

Are you guys for realz? 

WatchOut --- 13 years ago -

Congratulations to the teahadists faction of the Republican party for wasting $24 billion dollars for NOTHING.  

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

Our labor participation rate is now down to its lowest point since August of 1978.

Most of that is due to demographic factors. As a nation we're getting older, but the distribution is also widening at the young end.

both groups are more likely to detach from the labor force.

I'll see if I can find my source for that, I don't think he's published it yet.

They tend not to suffer the consequences of their terrible spending decisions.

neither do we, that's part of the problem.

Isn’t the better question how much we lose when the government is not in shutdown?

Yes and no. It is A better question, but I think it leaves people too much lee-way in interpreting the course of action.

The fact is that none of the "revenue enhancements", "government inefficiencies/redundancies", "Spending Cuts" that are potentially on the table are anything more than stall tactics. (which only works if the Boomers die out ahead of schedule)

Any budget deal that fails to address the domineering problem of inexorable growth in the real cost of our transfer payment programs (mainly medicare and social security) is nothing more than another example of the unwillingness of politicians to make tough decisions. 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

0

testing 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

Most of that is due to demographic factors. As a nation we're getting older, but the distribution is also widening at the young end.

both groups are more likely to detach from the labor force.


I am curious about the data behind this claim. It seems you’re suggesting that over 50% of that reduction in labor force participation rate has to do with persons aging out of the workforce and some other demographic reason that younger workers would now be working less. But the last time I glanced, I read that aging baby boomers only explains a quarter of the drop. If that's still accurate, that leaves the other 25% or more to be due to the demographics of the younger workers.

In my opinion, the cause of younger workers not participating in the workforce is not a demographic explanation, but an economic explanation. Starter jobs are not being created at the same rate. It tends to be younger persons who work starter jobs. The other explanation is that the higher cost of labor for starter jobs requires a more skilled worker to be worth the increase in total compensation now mandated by law.

Data sourced from the Census Bureau that I've reviewed indicates that baby boomers are not retiring on time - they are doing the opposite by working longer than prior generations did. The older generations who have been removed out of the labor force are no longer content being out of work at the same rate as in the past - they are now looking to be employed again at an increased rate and are competing for those scarce jobs.

Here's a chart that reflects a portion of the above observation and compares labor force representation rates by age group from 2007 compared to 2012:

0

Notice that from 2007 to 2012, we do not see an increase in the percentage of persons over age 55 who are not in the labor force. That's the opposite of what I would expect to see if it is true that most of the drop in labor participation rate is explained by workers aging out of the labor force. We should have seen an INCREASE in persons over the age of 55 not in the labor force. But persons over the age of 55 now (2012) make up a larger portion of the labor force than they did in 2007.

The largest labor force reduction came from persons aged 16-24 (those more likely to be in the market for starter jobs). So we are losing an investment in our future by having an increase in the number of persons in this age group not working. I recall reading articles that predicted this exact thing as mandated healthcare was to be provided by those who create starter jobs along with the increase in mandated minimum wages (and jobs indexed to minimum wage rates) for starter jobs. The chart also shows that younger workers are not in the labor force due to schooling at an increase of 4.5%, which is still disproportionately lower than their reduction on labor participation (-7.1%).

The above chart seems to indicate that the only group to gain in labor force representation came from persons over the age of 55 (which includes baby boomers). So as a share of labor force representation, the older generation has taken a larger portion of the share of jobs. I see this as the opposite of what you are claiming (half the losses in labor force participation is explained by demographics).

There's no one else on KU whose opinion on economics I respect more than yours, JT. So what am I missing? 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

It seems you’re suggesting that over 50% of that reduction in labor force participation rate has to do with persons aging out of the workforce and some other demographic reason that younger workers would now be working less.

I was wrong. the estimate is Half, not more than half of the fall is explained by demographics. See below...


the cause of younger workers not participating in the workforce is not a demographic explanation, but an economic explanation.

Well it's kinda both. Because they're young their opportunity cost of education is lower, they're more likely to detach due having children (a rising trend relative to the recent past) etc etc.




we do not see an increase in the percentage of persons over age 55 who are not in the labor force. That's the opposite of what I would expect to see if it is true that most of the drop in labor participation rate is explained by workers aging out of the labor force.

The percentage of (55+ y.o. people) who identified as "Not in LF" in the Current population survey did not fall from 2007 to 2012[this is what is reported in the chart], but the number of people in the 55+ category increased relative to the rest of the labor force by a large enough margin to bring down the total participation rate.

Using Household data, you can fix each age-groups' share of the population at 2007 levels. If you then carry that forward to 2012 and aggregate each age-category's 2012 unemployment statistics according to 2007's population shares you find that fully half of the fall in the labor force participation disappears. Thus, half of the fall in the LF-participation rate is attributable to a change in demographics.

To be fair, a different number may arise for CPS data vs household data.


I recall reading articles that predicted this exact thing as mandated healthcare was to be provided by those who create starter jobs along with the increase in mandated minimum wages (and jobs indexed to minimum wage rates) for starter jobs.


The young (disproportionately minorities too unfortunately) are ALWAYS the first to be dis-employed by a forced increase in the cost of employing the very low skilled If the new wage/benefit level is above the mkt equilibrium.

The above chart seems to indicate that the only group to gain in labor force representation came from persons over the age of 55...
...So what am I missing?


If the population shares were constant yes that would be true, but the population shares shifted. This table doesn't contain the information needed to calculate between-group changes in shares, it only contains within-group ratios. 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

There's no one else on KU whose opinion on economics I respect more than yours, JT

Well thank you sir! And there is no one on KU whose comments about everything else I respect more than yours. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground